Check your work: Audit a fictional group decision for rights, access, dissent and ownership

Staged checking material

Answer key

1. A passes budget, time, step-free route and quiet break, but photographs after the event are not live remote participation. Mark REVISE or relabel the access claim.
2. B fails budget, step-free access, live remote access and full facilitation. Mark EXCLUDE unless the fictional venue and delivery are redesigned; preserve Jon's hands-on preference.
3. C passes budget, time, step-free, live remote and quiet-break requirements, but the last 15 minutes have no moderator. Mark CONDITIONALLY ELIGIBLE pending a named owner.
4. D is a valid no-decision/fallback. It protects against pretending unknowns are resolved and has an information owner and review point.
5. A full record credits Mira, Jon and Sam, preserves Jon's preference and the reasons A/B need revision or exclusion, and selects C only conditionally with D as fallback.

Scoring rule

Award 2 points each for naming affected roles, declaring rights, preserving hard constraints, preserving provenance, marking unknowns, testing every option, recording dissent and writing a reversible decision with owner/review/fallback: 16 points total. Passing requires at least 14 and no rights override. A well-reasoned no-decision can receive full credit. This scores a fictional audit, not live cooperation.

Authority boundary: Titan teaches a complete Power-specific research method because operational capability practice is not currently justified.