{ "schema_version": "TITAN-INTERNAL-EVOLUTION-PUBLIC-v1.0", "publication_id": "TITAN-INTERNAL-EVOLUTION-PUBLIC-LENS-v1.0", "created": "2026-08-10", "status": "PUBLIC_SAFE_PROJECTION", "headline": "Titan can research, explain and build bounded low-risk guidance internally while reserving stronger claims for the checks they actually require.", "interpretation": "The five public labels are non-exclusive projections of orthogonal authority dimensions. Counts overlap and must never be summed.", "state_display_labels": { "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE": "Internal evidence complete", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY": "Public explainer ready", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY": "Non-prescriptive guide frame ready", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED": "External confirmation required", "INDEPENDENTLY_VALIDATED": "Independently validated" }, "state_definitions": { "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE": "Titan completed and machine-validated a bounded internal evidence dossier. This says nothing about external independence, universal efficacy or promotion.", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY": "A supportable claim, explicit limitations, measurement boundary and prohibited wording may be published as explanation. It authorises no training protocol, treatment, diagnosis or promotion.", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY": "Public display name: Non-prescriptive guide frame ready. A bounded informational guide frame may use only the source safe-content scope. It excludes a training programme, dosage, escalation, clinical use, dangerous exposure and claims of guaranteed benefit.", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED": "An external specialist, affected-person, cultural/community authority or other independent check is a hard prerequisite before the declared higher-authority use.", "INDEPENDENTLY_VALIDATED": "Exact independent evidence or review has been completed, bound and audited for the declared claim and configuration. No power currently holds this label." }, "authority_scope_definition": "NONE_BY_THIS_ARTIFACT means this package performs no manuscript integration, site-source integration or deployment itself; it does not prohibit or deny a separately executed and separately validated integration or deployment action.", "evidence_axis_normalization": { "rule_id": "SOURCE_DECLARED_ROLE_IDENTITY-v1.0", "source_field": "family evidence_register[].evidence_roles", "transform": "TRIMMED_UPPER_SNAKE_CASE_IDENTITY", "question_axis_union": false, "role_map": { "AAC": "AAC", "ABANDONMENT": "ABANDONMENT", "ACCESS": "ACCESS", "ACCESSIBILITY": "ACCESSIBILITY", "ACCOUNTABILITY": "ACCOUNTABILITY", "ACCURACY_DECOUPLING": "ACCURACY_DECOUPLING", "ACTIVE_BASELINE": "ACTIVE_BASELINE", "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION": "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION", "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR": "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "ACTIVE_CONTROL": "ACTIVE_CONTROL", "ADVERSE_RESPONSE": "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS": "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "AFFORDABILITY": "AFFORDABILITY", "AGE_BOUNDARY": "AGE_BOUNDARY", "AGE_CONFIGURATION": "AGE_CONFIGURATION", "AI_CONFIGURATION": "AI_CONFIGURATION", "AI_GOVERNANCE": "AI_GOVERNANCE", "AI_ONLY_BASELINE": "AI_ONLY_BASELINE", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION": "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "ASSISTED_CONFIGURATION": "ASSISTED_CONFIGURATION", "ASSISTED_PERCEPTION": "ASSISTED_PERCEPTION", "ASSISTIVE_SUPPORT": "ASSISTIVE_SUPPORT", "ATTRIBUTION": "ATTRIBUTION", "ATTRITION": "ATTRITION", "AUTHORSHIP": "AUTHORSHIP", "AUTOMATION_BIAS": "AUTOMATION_BIAS", "BEHAVIORAL_INTENTION": "BEHAVIORAL_INTENTION", "BEHAVIOURAL_EFFECT": "BEHAVIOURAL_EFFECT", "BELIEF_UPDATE": "BELIEF_UPDATE", "BETTER_STANDALONE_BASELINE": "BETTER_STANDALONE_BASELINE", "BIAS": "BIAS", "BIAS_TRANSFER": "BIAS_TRANSFER", "BIOHYBRID_INTERFACE": "BIOHYBRID_INTERFACE", "BIOLOGICAL_LIMIT": "BIOLOGICAL_LIMIT", "BIOMARKER_BOUNDARY": "BIOMARKER_BOUNDARY", "BOUNDARY": "BOUNDARY", "BRAIN_COMPUTER_COMMUNICATION": "BRAIN_COMPUTER_COMMUNICATION", "BRAIN_CONTROLLED_PROSTHESIS": "BRAIN_CONTROLLED_PROSTHESIS", "CANE_COMPARATOR": "CANE_COMPARATOR", "CAREGIVER_SUPPORT": "CAREGIVER_SUPPORT", "CARE_PARTNER_SUPPORT": "CARE_PARTNER_SUPPORT", "CEILING_EFFECT": "CEILING_EFFECT", "CHANGE_OVER_TIME": "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY": "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "CLINICAL_GATE": "CLINICAL_GATE", "COERCION": "COERCION", "COERCION_BOUNDARY": "COERCION_BOUNDARY", "COGNITIVE_LOAD": "COGNITIVE_LOAD", "COGNITIVE_OFFLOADING": "COGNITIVE_OFFLOADING", "COLLECTIVE_DIVERSITY_COST": "COLLECTIVE_DIVERSITY_COST", "COLLISION_COMPARATOR": "COLLISION_COMPARATOR", "COMMUNICATION": "COMMUNICATION", "COMPARATOR": "COMPARATOR", "COMPLEMENTARITY": "COMPLEMENTARITY", "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY": "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY", "COMPREHENSION_CHECK": "COMPREHENSION_CHECK", "CONFIGURATION": "CONFIGURATION", "CONFIGURATION_DEPENDENCE": "CONFIGURATION_DEPENDENCE", "CONFIGURATION_INTERACTION": "CONFIGURATION_INTERACTION", "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE": "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "CONSENT": "CONSENT", "CONSTRUCT_HYPOTHESIS": "CONSTRUCT_HYPOTHESIS", "CONSTRUCT_VALIDITY": "CONSTRUCT_VALIDITY", "CONTENT_PROVENANCE": "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "CONTEXT_EFFECT": "CONTEXT_EFFECT", "CONTEXT_SPECIFICITY": "CONTEXT_SPECIFICITY", "CONTRADICTION": "CONTRADICTION", "CONTRADICTORY_CONFIGURATION": "CONTRADICTORY_CONFIGURATION", "CONTROLLED_CORRIDOR": "CONTROLLED_CORRIDOR", "COPYRIGHT": "COPYRIGHT", "CORRECTED_RECORD": "CORRECTED_RECORD", "CREATIVE_OUTPUT": "CREATIVE_OUTPUT", "CROSSMODAL_TRANSFER": "CROSSMODAL_TRANSFER", "CROSS_CULTURAL": "CROSS_CULTURAL", "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY": "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_CONTEXT": "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE": "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "CULTURAL_VALIDATION": "CULTURAL_VALIDATION", "CULTURAL_VARIABILITY": "CULTURAL_VARIABILITY", "CYBERSECURITY": "CYBERSECURITY", "DATA_LIFECYCLE": "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "DELEGATION": "DELEGATION", "DESKILLING_RISK": "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_COMPARISON": "DEVICE_COMPARISON", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT": "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "DEVICE_ON_OFF": "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "DEVICE_SPECIFIC": "DEVICE_SPECIFIC", "DISCLOSURE": "DISCLOSURE", "DISCONTINUATION": "DISCONTINUATION", "DOSE_INTERACTION": "DOSE_INTERACTION", "DRIFT": "DRIFT", "DURATION": "DURATION", "EMBODIMENT": "EMBODIMENT", "EMERGENT_COORDINATION": "EMERGENT_COORDINATION", "ENVIRONMENTAL_CONTROL": "ENVIRONMENTAL_CONTROL", "EQUITY": "EQUITY", "EQUITY_INTERACTION": "EQUITY_INTERACTION", "ERROR_DETECTION": "ERROR_DETECTION", "EXISTENCE": "EXISTENCE", "EXPERIENCE_ASSOCIATION": "EXPERIENCE_ASSOCIATION", "EXPERIENCE_INTERACTION": "EXPERIENCE_INTERACTION", "EXPERT_CONFIGURATION": "EXPERT_CONFIGURATION", "EXPLANATION_EFFECT": "EXPLANATION_EFFECT", "EXPLANATION_NULL": "EXPLANATION_NULL", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION": "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "FAIL_SAFE": "FAIL_SAFE", "FALLBACK": "FALLBACK", "FALSE_OPERATION": "FALSE_OPERATION", "FATIGUE_PROFILE": "FATIGUE_PROFILE", "FIELD_ASSOCIATION": "FIELD_ASSOCIATION", "FIELD_USE": "FIELD_USE", "FINE_MOTOR_TELEOPERATION": "FINE_MOTOR_TELEOPERATION", "FUNCTIONAL_INDEPENDENCE": "FUNCTIONAL_INDEPENDENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_TASK": "FUNCTIONAL_TASK", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE": "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "GOVERNANCE": "GOVERNANCE", "GROUP_EXISTENCE": "GROUP_EXISTENCE", "HAPTIC_GUIDANCE": "HAPTIC_GUIDANCE", "HEARING_SAFETY": "HEARING_SAFETY", "HETEROGENEITY": "HETEROGENEITY", "HIGH_IMPACT_BOUNDARY": "HIGH_IMPACT_BOUNDARY", "HIGH_STAKES_BOUNDARY": "HIGH_STAKES_BOUNDARY", "HIGH_STAKES_GOVERNANCE": "HIGH_STAKES_GOVERNANCE", "HOME_USE": "HOME_USE", "HUMAN_AI_CONFIGURATION": "HUMAN_AI_CONFIGURATION", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR": "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "IMMEDIATE_TRANSFER": "IMMEDIATE_TRANSFER", "IMPLANT_RISK": "IMPLANT_RISK", "IMPLEMENTATION": "IMPLEMENTATION", "INCORRECT_ADVICE": "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "INDIVIDUAL_VARIATION": "INDIVIDUAL_VARIATION", "INEQUALITY": "INEQUALITY", "INFORMATION_HARM": "INFORMATION_HARM", "INTERFACE_CONFIGURATION": "INTERFACE_CONFIGURATION", "INTERFERENCE": "INTERFERENCE", "ITEM_EFFECT": "ITEM_EFFECT", "LANGUAGE_ACCESS_LIMIT": "LANGUAGE_ACCESS_LIMIT", "LEARNING": "LEARNING", "LEGITIMACY": "LEGITIMACY", "LIFECYCLE": "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING": "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM": "LONG_TERM", "LONG_TERM_RISK": "LONG_TERM_RISK", "MEASUREMENT": "MEASUREMENT", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY": "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY", "MECHANISM": "MECHANISM", "MECHANISM_DECOMPOSITION": "MECHANISM_DECOMPOSITION", "MEMORY_CONTENT_VS_LOCATION": "MEMORY_CONTENT_VS_LOCATION", "MENTAL_INTEGRITY": "MENTAL_INTEGRITY", "METABOLIC_MEASUREMENT": "METABOLIC_MEASUREMENT", "MISUSE": "MISUSE", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE": "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "MODEL_DRIFT": "MODEL_DRIFT", "MULTIMODAL_ACCESS": "MULTIMODAL_ACCESS", "NARROW_TASK": "NARROW_TASK", "NEAR_TRANSFER": "NEAR_TRANSFER", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY": "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY", "NEGATIVE_FINDING": "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "NEURAL_SENSORY_FEEDBACK": "NEURAL_SENSORY_FEEDBACK", "NEUROFEEDBACK": "NEUROFEEDBACK", "NEURORIGHTS": "NEURORIGHTS", "NONCAUSAL": "NONCAUSAL", "NULL_BETWEEN_GROUP": "NULL_BETWEEN_GROUP", "NULL_COMPARATOR": "NULL_COMPARATOR", "NULL_CONDITIONS": "NULL_CONDITIONS", "NULL_FINDING": "NULL_FINDING", "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING": "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING", "NULL_REAL_WORLD_TRANSFER": "NULL_REAL_WORLD_TRANSFER", "NULL_SECONDARY_OUTCOMES": "NULL_SECONDARY_OUTCOMES", "NULL_TRANSFER": "NULL_TRANSFER", "OBJECTIVE_VS_JUDGED_OUTCOME": "OBJECTIVE_VS_JUDGED_OUTCOME", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY": "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK": "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "ORDER_EFFECT": "ORDER_EFFECT", "OVERRELIANCE": "OVERRELIANCE", "OVERRELIANCE_REDUCTION": "OVERRELIANCE_REDUCTION", "OWNERSHIP": "OWNERSHIP", "PARTICIPATION": "PARTICIPATION", "PEOPLE_HARM": "PEOPLE_HARM", "PERCEPTION_VS_PERFORMANCE": "PERCEPTION_VS_PERFORMANCE", "PHYSIOLOGICAL_SYNCHRONY": "PHYSIOLOGICAL_SYNCHRONY", "PILOT": "PILOT", "PLACEBO_BOUNDARY": "PLACEBO_BOUNDARY", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY": "POPULATION_BOUNDARY", "PREDICTION": "PREDICTION", "PRIVACY": "PRIVACY", "PROCESS_MECHANISM": "PROCESS_MECHANISM", "PROCESS_PROXY": "PROCESS_PROXY", "PROSTHETIC_CONTROL": "PROSTHETIC_CONTROL", "REACQUISITION": "REACQUISITION", "RECONSOLIDATION_HYPOTHESIS": "RECONSOLIDATION_HYPOTHESIS", "RECOVERY": "RECOVERY", "REGULATED_DEVICE": "REGULATED_DEVICE", "REGULATORY_BOUNDARY": "REGULATORY_BOUNDARY", "REHABILITATION": "REHABILITATION", "RELIABILITY": "RELIABILITY", "REPLICATION": "REPLICATION", "RESILIENCE": "RESILIENCE", "RESPONDER_VARIATION": "RESPONDER_VARIATION", "RESPONSIBILITY": "RESPONSIBILITY", "RESTRICTED": "RESTRICTED", "RETENTION": "RETENTION", "RETENTION_GAP": "RETENTION_GAP", "ROBOTIC_AUGMENTATION": "ROBOTIC_AUGMENTATION", "SAFEGUARDING": "SAFEGUARDING", "SAFETY": "SAFETY", "SAFETY_BOUNDARY": "SAFETY_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY": "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "SELF_EFFICACY": "SELF_EFFICACY", "SELF_REGULATION": "SELF_REGULATION", "SELF_REPORT_BOUNDARY": "SELF_REPORT_BOUNDARY", "SENSORY_SUBSTITUTION": "SENSORY_SUBSTITUTION", "SEQUENCING": "SEQUENCING", "SERIOUS_ADVERSE_EVENT": "SERIOUS_ADVERSE_EVENT", "SERVICE_SYSTEM": "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "SHAM_CONTROL": "SHAM_CONTROL", "SHARED_AUTONOMY": "SHARED_AUTONOMY", "SIGNAL_SELF_REGULATION": "SIGNAL_SELF_REGULATION", "SIGN_LANGUAGE": "SIGN_LANGUAGE", "SIMULATION": "SIMULATION", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT": "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT", "SLOWER_PERFORMANCE": "SLOWER_PERFORMANCE", "SMALL_SAMPLE": "SMALL_SAMPLE", "SOCIAL_CONFIGURATION": "SOCIAL_CONFIGURATION", "SPEAK_UP": "SPEAK_UP", "SPECIALIST_CONFIGURATION": "SPECIALIST_CONFIGURATION", "SPECIFICITY": "SPECIFICITY", "SUBGROUP": "SUBGROUP", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION": "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION", "SYSTEM_MODEL": "SYSTEM_MODEL", "TASK_SPECIFICITY": "TASK_SPECIFICITY", "TEAM_LEARNING": "TEAM_LEARNING", "TELEOPERATION": "TELEOPERATION", "TELEPRESENCE": "TELEPRESENCE", "TRADEOFF": "TRADEOFF", "TRAINABILITY": "TRAINABILITY", "TRAINED_TASK_IMPROVEMENT": "TRAINED_TASK_IMPROVEMENT", "TRANSFER": "TRANSFER", "TRANSFER_BOUNDARY": "TRANSFER_BOUNDARY", "TRANSFER_SPECIFICITY": "TRANSFER_SPECIFICITY", "UNCERTAINTY": "UNCERTAINTY", "USER_INVOLVEMENT": "USER_INVOLVEMENT", "USER_OVERRIDE": "USER_OVERRIDE", "VALIDITY": "VALIDITY", "VERIFICATION": "VERIFICATION", "VERIFICATION_BURDEN": "VERIFICATION_BURDEN", "VOCAL_SAFETY": "VOCAL_SAFETY", "WALKING_INDEPENDENCE": "WALKING_INDEPENDENCE", "WEARABLE": "WEARABLE", "WEARABLE_NAVIGATION": "WEARABLE_NAVIGATION" }, "role_map_sha256": "90489912e6976f7426e62012b0864cdc6572ded410008746b3efdfdd4234602b" }, "citation_role_contract": { "primary_empirical_support_role": "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT requires PRIMARY_RESEARCH, a bound supports_power_ids relationship and at least one non-limiting source-declared evidence role.", "official_normative_system_support_role": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT is confined to the six declared normative or system-governance powers. It supports only their bounded non-efficacy proposition and is never empirical efficacy evidence.", "official_normative_system_support_power_ids": [ "PWR-230", "PWR-235", "PWR-236", "PWR-237", "PWR-240", "PWR-246" ], "limiting_role": "LIMITING_CONTRARY requires a bound limiting_power_ids relationship plus a source-declared role matching (LIMITING|NULL|NEGATIVE|CONTRADICT|BOUNDARY|RISK|ADVERSE|ATTRITION|BIAS|INTERFERENCE|SLOWER|ERROR|ABANDONMENT|INEQUALITY|COERCION|PRIVACY|MISUSE|HARM|BURDEN|DRIFT|OVERRELIANCE|DESKILLING|CEILING|NONCAUSAL|SMALL_SAMPLE|UNCERTAINTY|TRADEOFF).", "official_boundary_role": "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT is used when an official source supplies measurement, safety, access, governance, normative or other boundary context outside the six declared normative/system support powers. It is not empirical efficacy support.", "official_empirical_support_allowed": false, "question_axis_union": false }, "counts": { "powers": 256, "canonical_public_citations": 492, "source_alias_rows": 520, "state_labels_non_exclusive": { "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE": 256, "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY": 256, "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY": 22, "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED": 216, "INDEPENDENTLY_VALIDATED": 0 }, "closure": { "exception_tasks": 181, "exception_internal_closed": 49, "exception_held_external": 132, "high_risk_dossiers": 46, "high_risk_configuration_matched": 43, "high_risk_search_exhausted": 3, "high_risk_held_external": 46, "external_reviews_completed": 0, "promotions": 0, "public_stepwise_training_protocols": 0, "research_authority_deployments_in_controlling_closure_snapshot": 0 } }, "completion_boundary": "Internal research is complete for this evidence snapshot. External reviews completed remain zero; no record is independently validated, promoted, converted into a stepwise protocol or written into canonical/operational authority. This public-safe projection may be served by a separate presentation or deployment action; this artifact itself performs no deployment and grants no additional research authority.", "source_register": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0001", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/archinte.166.17.1822", "title": "The Care Transitions Intervention: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Eric A. Coleman; Carla Parry; Sandra Chalmers; Sung-joon Min", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/410933", "doi": "10.1001/archinte.166.17.1822", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S012", "F30-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23", "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S012", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "The Care Transitions Intervention: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Eric A. Coleman; Carla Parry; Sandra Chalmers; Sung-joon Min", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/410933", "doi": "10.1001/archinte.166.17.1822", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1ad7a81190253a3d9cd7e2162a3e94321d63369e2788b34058b7acf1c66e308a" }, { "source_id": "F30-S009", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "The care transitions intervention: results of a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Eric A. Coleman; Carla Parry; Sandra Chalmers; Sung-Joon Min", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17000937/", "doi": "10.1001/archinte.166.17.1822", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "19f7ea910c6e78978111be21d0533461d7c808a89aeb11014ee1703732540abb" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "aea248e6fd8967fab91ec857724aa4ebd767b58dfc8a35b1205c7eef24fd1b7d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0002", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/archotol.129.8.819", "title": "Recovery of dynamic visual acuity in unilateral vestibular hypofunction", "authors": "Susan J Herdman; Michael C Schubert; Vallabh E Das; Ronald J Tusa", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12925338/", "doi": "10.1001/archotol.129.8.819", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S003", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Recovery of dynamic visual acuity in unilateral vestibular hypofunction", "authors": "Susan J Herdman; Michael C Schubert; Vallabh E Das; Ronald J Tusa", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12925338/", "doi": "10.1001/archotol.129.8.819", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "03ea9297da830cb808f4e236cb1b71a757431c5e3e44bc4563355beccf23248b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3dfa6e893c9c114e317df192eb8aa799dad9f72757343030263db8f676fff9ac" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0003", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jama.1990.03440220053029", "title": "High-intensity strength training in nonagenarians. Effects on skeletal muscle", "authors": "Maria A. Fiatarone; Evelyn C. Marks; Nancy D. Ryan; C. N. Meredith; Lewis A. Lipsitz; William J. Evans", "year": 1990, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2342214/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.1990.03440220053029", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S001", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "High-intensity strength training in nonagenarians. Effects on skeletal muscle", "authors": "Maria A. Fiatarone; Evelyn C. Marks; Nancy D. Ryan; C. N. Meredith; Lewis A. Lipsitz; William J. Evans", "year": 1990, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2342214/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.1990.03440220053029", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "41db8d8c6b887b51295a4400c963aad1a36cd9f3e9adc8dd2b7b8584b18a98af" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a4747b80ea283cd73cfa51c5386be9ad08c877fdf9a1387b59e051a7d9f1bd73" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0004", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jama.2016.2323", "title": "Effect of Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction vs Cognitive Behavioral Therapy or Usual Care on Back Pain and Functional Limitations in Adults With Chronic Low Back Pain", "authors": "Daniel C Cherkin; Karen J Sherman; Benjamin H Balderson; Andrea J Cook; Melissa L Anderson; Rene J Hawkes; Kelly E Hansen; Judith A Turner", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27002445/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.2016.2323", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S005", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Effect of Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction vs Cognitive Behavioral Therapy or Usual Care on Back Pain and Functional Limitations in Adults With Chronic Low Back Pain", "authors": "Daniel C Cherkin; Karen J Sherman; Benjamin H Balderson; Andrea J Cook; Melissa L Anderson; Rene J Hawkes; Kelly E Hansen; Judith A Turner", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27002445/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.2016.2323", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "46cf6150b44a85d5c4539ce784018c61686945d6a2039a4290fc65dff5a4c639" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a697f04f13641435f96ba0f960eb0bc25249f0fbb9de3c75b36d69a6fa48b7e8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0005", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jama.2020.0059", "title": "Effect of Incisional Negative Pressure Wound Therapy vs Standard Wound Dressing on Deep Surgical Site Infection After Surgery for Lower Limb Fractures Associated With Major Trauma: The WHIST Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "Matthew L Costa; Juul Achten; Ruth Knight; Julie Bruce; Susan J Dutton; Jason Madan; Melina Dritsaki; Nick Parsons; Miguel Fernandez; Richard Grant; Jagdeep Nanchahal; WHIST Trial Collaborators", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32044942/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.2020.0059", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S009", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Effect of Incisional Negative Pressure Wound Therapy vs Standard Wound Dressing on Deep Surgical Site Infection After Surgery for Lower Limb Fractures Associated With Major Trauma: The WHIST Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "Matthew L Costa; Juul Achten; Ruth Knight; Julie Bruce; Susan J Dutton; Jason Madan; Melina Dritsaki; Nick Parsons; Miguel Fernandez; Richard Grant; Jagdeep Nanchahal; WHIST Trial Collaborators", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32044942/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.2020.0059", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c4955c146155bcd2fbd153d178f0529a59a91aee32ee9d0a2e7c2b877a727456" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6b0d8dc5a9193090bfc9681da98cfc1754f1b683692bc06dc2b17ae742f3f4a8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0006", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jama.296.17.2095", "title": "Effect of constraint-induced movement therapy on upper extremity function 3 to 9 months after stroke: the EXCITE randomized clinical trial", "authors": "Steven L Wolf; Carolee J Winstein; J Philip Miller; Edward Taub; Gitendra Uswatte; David Morris; Carol Giuliani; Kathye E Light; Deborah Nichols-Larsen; EXCITE Investigators", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17077374/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.296.17.2095", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S001", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Effect of constraint-induced movement therapy on upper extremity function 3 to 9 months after stroke: the EXCITE randomized clinical trial", "authors": "Steven L Wolf; Carolee J Winstein; J Philip Miller; Edward Taub; Gitendra Uswatte; David Morris; Carol Giuliani; Kathye E Light; Deborah Nichols-Larsen; EXCITE Investigators", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17077374/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.296.17.2095", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d255d2a1f41167e6ad2da579b3b5207f66d471a5434840ba9d141fde0e22885c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2f8f4e03ec3bd472154d297829a8e1f42c3b23644b34b0dbe681c5303e54e9ef" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0007", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jama.296.23.2805", "title": "Long-term Effects of Cognitive Training on Everyday Functional Outcomes in Older Adults", "authors": "Sherry L. Willis; Sharon L. Tennstedt; Michael Marsiske; Karlene Ball; Jeffrey Elias; Kathy Mann Koepke; John N. Morris; George W. Rebok; Frederick W. Unverzagt; Anne M. Stoddard; Elizabeth Wright; ACTIVE Study Group", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17179457/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.296.23.2805", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S002", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Long-term Effects of Cognitive Training on Everyday Functional Outcomes in Older Adults", "authors": "Sherry L. Willis; Sharon L. Tennstedt; Michael Marsiske; Karlene Ball; Jeffrey Elias; Kathy Mann Koepke; John N. Morris; George W. Rebok; Frederick W. Unverzagt; Anne M. Stoddard; Elizabeth Wright; ACTIVE Study Group", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17179457/", "doi": "10.1001/jama.296.23.2805", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2446905aefc4405eced84c2eba5be343c80ad5fb8498574d092dcc0d22495b6f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f0b7c4a97891c6440c1a843479b62e3cfbcf1c18b0224e63cec4403cccf2d593" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0008", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.6026", "title": "Effect of a Biobehavioral Environmental Approach on Disability Among Low-Income Older Adults: A Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "Sarah L Szanton; Qian-Li Xue; Bruce Leff; Jack Guralnik; Jennifer L Wolff; Elizabeth K Tanner; Cynthia Boyd; Roland J Thorpe Jr; David Bishai; Laura N Gitlin", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30615024/", "doi": "10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.6026", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S012", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Effect of a Biobehavioral Environmental Approach on Disability Among Low-Income Older Adults: A Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "Sarah L Szanton; Qian-Li Xue; Bruce Leff; Jack Guralnik; Jennifer L Wolff; Elizabeth K Tanner; Cynthia Boyd; Roland J Thorpe Jr; David Bishai; Laura N Gitlin", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30615024/", "doi": "10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.6026", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EQUITY", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "739110b2318f3597fa24cb4ae7f67e8eb91c02082351535b784d874c8227af3a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e860a95cdaec8adc07f3b1ca715d93a811dc636806958f713260c5694d5c86fc" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0009", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.8422", "title": "Effect of Treadmill Perturbation-Based Balance Training on Fall Rates in Community-Dwelling Older Adults: A Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "Jens Eg Nørgaard; Stig Andersen; Jesper Ryg; Andrew James Thomas Stevenson; Jane Andreasen; Anderson Souza Oliveira; Mathias Brix Danielsen; Martin Gronbech Jorgensen", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2803960", "doi": "10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.8422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S008", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Effect of Treadmill Perturbation-Based Balance Training on Fall Rates in Community-Dwelling Older Adults: A Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "Jens Eg Nørgaard; Stig Andersen; Jesper Ryg; Andrew James Thomas Stevenson; Jane Andreasen; Anderson Souza Oliveira; Mathias Brix Danielsen; Martin Gronbech Jorgensen", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2803960", "doi": "10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.8422", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7a66f543645cbce01e03da4dc64be0184b463317594956ac9ea4ed43d26b33a1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1eead04efa6b6abb51ef524f2078f801259eb98c2514f571a008ebe65baf99e8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0010", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/bdm.2334", "title": "Automated calibration training for forecasters", "authors": "Eric R. Stone; Jason Luu; Cory K. Costello; Annie H. Somerville", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/bdm.2334", "doi": "10.1002/bdm.2334", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S001", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Automated calibration training for forecasters", "authors": "Eric R. Stone; Jason Luu; Cory K. Costello; Annie H. Somerville", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/bdm.2334", "doi": "10.1002/bdm.2334", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b7b8c039357dbc7f9ab198fe83becc884b4d98559e38f65d4200c31c94c8ef8c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "de46a507fb0845d39dd0b6ce650ae9ca95b3bf54a0bdc75f74f14a0643a6b4a2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0011", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/ejsp.3177", "title": "Enhancing Intellectual Humility About Political Topics: An Intervention Tournament Including Five Conceptual Replications", "authors": "Larissa Knöchelmann; Adina Janßen; Julia Dörbaum; Daniel W. Heck; J. Christopher Cohrs", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.3177", "doi": "10.1002/ejsp.3177", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S014", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Enhancing Intellectual Humility About Political Topics: An Intervention Tournament Including Five Conceptual Replications", "authors": "Larissa Knöchelmann; Adina Janßen; Julia Dörbaum; Daniel W. Heck; J. Christopher Cohrs", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.3177", "doi": "10.1002/ejsp.3177", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "REPLICATION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "632fcab66b9822d78190ad4b770aaeb0ef72930f4cb9bbbb79db50eb23ef5f0d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2dfe15c27692c256189ac792aec0a72021d1c35ca3c86b64f9079edaea81645a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0012", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/ejsp.674", "title": "How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world", "authors": "Phillippa Lally; Cornelia H. M. van Jaarsveld; Henry W. W. Potts; Jane Wardle", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.674", "doi": "10.1002/ejsp.674", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S003", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world", "authors": "Phillippa Lally; Cornelia H. M. van Jaarsveld; Henry W. W. Potts; Jane Wardle", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.674", "doi": "10.1002/ejsp.674", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c6f2c2022764cba9f93bd670fa3ffcf740f927d8a2d5aeca152791eb826959fa" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d4cf33b0c34cf3ca13ed8c34f872587cd6ece630ae053b5e4cf83e4c7bf7a389" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0013", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/ffo2.199", "title": "Calibration Feedback With the Practical Scoring Rule Does Not Improve Calibration of Confidence", "authors": "Matthew Martin; David R. Mandel", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/ffo2.199", "doi": "10.1002/ffo2.199", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S002", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Calibration Feedback With the Practical Scoring Rule Does Not Improve Calibration of Confidence", "authors": "Matthew Martin; David R. Mandel", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/ffo2.199", "doi": "10.1002/ffo2.199", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "REPLICATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "07b79ecab4360e073f1a503dee3ce2929a2784acdd861eaa033ae786c65eae14" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "aecd4065864ea63a926634b33bfff22c8830047a5147eed090315dd8a71a5cac" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0014", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/hipo.20233", "title": "London taxi drivers and bus drivers: a structural MRI and neuropsychological analysis", "authors": "Eleanor A Maguire; Katherine Woollett; Hugo J Spiers", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17024677/", "doi": "10.1002/hipo.20233", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S008", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "London taxi drivers and bus drivers: a structural MRI and neuropsychological analysis", "authors": "Eleanor A Maguire; Katherine Woollett; Hugo J Spiers", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17024677/", "doi": "10.1002/hipo.20233", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fb32505a6c2fbdb125adad581b651faf7effec7ca38031e31e8fe0a6d260837a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d4c31f251fe2cb38e880f2d2ba6102c14fc9cddc9c740323cf7666d853022a86" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0015", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/jbmr.3284", "title": "High-Intensity Resistance and Impact Training Improves Bone Mineral Density and Physical Function in Postmenopausal Women With Osteopenia and Osteoporosis: The LIFTMOR Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Steven L Watson; Benjamin K Weeks; Lisa J Weis; Amy T Harding; Sean A Horan; Belinda R Beck", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28975661/", "doi": "10.1002/jbmr.3284", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S003", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "High-Intensity Resistance and Impact Training Improves Bone Mineral Density and Physical Function in Postmenopausal Women With Osteopenia and Osteoporosis: The LIFTMOR Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Steven L Watson; Benjamin K Weeks; Lisa J Weis; Amy T Harding; Sean A Horan; Belinda R Beck", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28975661/", "doi": "10.1002/jbmr.3284", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0df374459b31b13d08180163e26379c3299928b7d1456a652df382208b02e0dc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e37d65a8188bbd6807d3965ab5a85a37d1fb6e4f001ec48d29b21abc1a63416a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0016", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/job.413", "title": "Making it safe: the effects of leader inclusiveness and professional status on psychological safety and improvement efforts in health care teams", "authors": "Ingrid M. Nembhard; Amy C. Edmondson", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/job.413", "doi": "10.1002/job.413", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S004", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Making it safe: the effects of leader inclusiveness and professional status on psychological safety and improvement efforts in health care teams", "authors": "Ingrid M. Nembhard; Amy C. Edmondson", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/job.413", "doi": "10.1002/job.413", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "PROCESS_PROXY", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4c1ae45c34d0648e86d1f4979197060cf84d6d6f52d9dddb8429780e4aa44a47" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "13ff5496b4d45881544c2c0ab78b60d072b3d8abb895401b00a9eb661764bcfe" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0017", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/lary.24340", "title": "Olfactory training is helpful in postinfectious olfactory loss: a randomized, controlled, multicenter study", "authors": "M. Damm; L. K. Pikart; H. Reimann; S. Burkert; Ö. Göktas; B. Haxel; S. Frey; I. Charalampakis; A. Beule; B. Renner; T. Hummel; K.-B. Hüttenbrink", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23929687/", "doi": "10.1002/lary.24340", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S014", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Olfactory training is helpful in postinfectious olfactory loss: a randomized, controlled, multicenter study", "authors": "M. Damm; L. K. Pikart; H. Reimann; S. Burkert; Ö. Göktas; B. Haxel; S. Frey; I. Charalampakis; A. Beule; B. Renner; T. Hummel; K.-B. Hüttenbrink", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23929687/", "doi": "10.1002/lary.24340", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f67bafd52e1a73c0d788a0bdafbfde79b70815445b97a5936296c73c94aa09c7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4c7854a7ca970c32d682c3ce0c84ee021570e7100a27cfbcb3c2f9490fcbc3ca" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0018", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1002/wjs.12074", "title": "Dyadic practice for the acquisition of laparoscopic skills (DALS)-A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "A M A Ritchie; N Chaudhry; S J A Robinson; M Pacilli; R M Nataraja", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38686749/", "doi": "10.1002/wjs.12074", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S012", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Dyadic practice for the acquisition of laparoscopic skills (DALS)-A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "A M A Ritchie; N Chaudhry; S J A Robinson; M Pacilli; R M Nataraja", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38686749/", "doi": "10.1002/wjs.12074", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2e3c8c031322627d7731f92ad3454c54908185ee395d566f83ec0304b63539ff" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6b067067a6e443d98b3eae9ddaa7c2a4ee095bcfe38e3b47ab10b7c5f04bd6fd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0019", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1006/obhd.2000.2888", "title": "Idea Generation in Groups: A Basis for Creativity in Organizations", "authors": "Paul B. Paulus; Huei-Chuan Yang", "year": 2000, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0749597800928887", "doi": "10.1006/obhd.2000.2888", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S015", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Idea Generation in Groups: A Basis for Creativity in Organizations", "authors": "Paul B. Paulus; Huei-Chuan Yang", "year": 2000, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0749597800928887", "doi": "10.1006/obhd.2000.2888", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "07aa7eff8ebc814ad04313e0d8879ffd15cfbed613e276b742e0924d7a71af8b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ce7e603aaa8425d338427018300837d79b2ca0d790ff024d5320e1957228b352" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0020", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/bf00637386", "title": "Specificity of joint angle in isometric training", "authors": "T A Kitai; D G Sale", "year": 1989, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2737195/", "doi": "10.1007/BF00637386", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S004", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Specificity of joint angle in isometric training", "authors": "T A Kitai; D G Sale", "year": 1989, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2737195/", "doi": "10.1007/BF00637386", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3e620b6684dc77ae6d18b41291eff01d6235f14c05f78b93208e586c2ff3a440" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5281a4d3455ba052688f5d05365b28b8a034a13b3e87cf7fb6976cc87ced3b05" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0021", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/bf00845268", "title": "Behavioral treatment of Raynaud's phenomenon in scleroderma", "authors": "Robert R Freedman; P Ianni; P Wenig", "year": 1984, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6520866/", "doi": "10.1007/BF00845268", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S010", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Behavioral treatment of Raynaud's phenomenon in scleroderma", "authors": "Robert R Freedman; P Ianni; P Wenig", "year": 1984, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6520866/", "doi": "10.1007/BF00845268", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "279f4e8d46448842cc6dfe2f18db85220761858e9644e36d888977cf9562b36b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1a2e05ee76106e38f6ae1e5163944fa95147479c37dfeec707adb5976d393d82" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0022", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/bf02156842", "title": "Dark adaptation with interposed white adapting fields", "authors": "C D Bernholz; L Spillmann; V DaForno", "year": 1982, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7173631/", "doi": "10.1007/BF02156842", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S013", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Dark adaptation with interposed white adapting fields", "authors": "C D Bernholz; L Spillmann; V DaForno", "year": 1982, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7173631/", "doi": "10.1007/BF02156842", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0ba7df1b7e60e1eb8817cdc0e2eadad180829eb37b6fca5d3f4d925d868e41d5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d8f50dc0b276e4a417a0f7d57b99aa532aa145b4164b6a241a23e36cdf5c5cca" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0023", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00213-018-5140-0", "title": "Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover study of the effects of repeated-dose caffeine on neurobehavioral performance during 48 h of total sleep deprivation", "authors": "Devon A Hansen; Sridhar Ramakrishnan; Brieann C Satterfield; Nancy J Wesensten; Matthew E Layton; Jaques Reifman; Hans P A Van Dongen", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30539266/", "doi": "10.1007/s00213-018-5140-0", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S006", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover study of the effects of repeated-dose caffeine on neurobehavioral performance during 48 h of total sleep deprivation", "authors": "Devon A Hansen; Sridhar Ramakrishnan; Brieann C Satterfield; Nancy J Wesensten; Matthew E Layton; Jaques Reifman; Hans P A Van Dongen", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30539266/", "doi": "10.1007/s00213-018-5140-0", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0c8f6f6e66bd921e0f90fecf9e6d7de3d26a09c4f5b0486be154db8343484f6f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "52777f0c56da1a19ff0ffd401adf19526102222d1a2d68b4c3a9d7fe18e3174b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0024", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00221-004-2085-9", "title": "The effects of practice and delay on motor skill learning and retention", "authors": "Tal Savion-Lemieux; Virginia B. Penhune", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15551084/", "doi": "10.1007/s00221-004-2085-9", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S004", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "The effects of practice and delay on motor skill learning and retention", "authors": "Tal Savion-Lemieux; Virginia B. Penhune", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15551084/", "doi": "10.1007/s00221-004-2085-9", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "619b804077def0d7ffe483c298646182242a4a7920e73360c0d6ef4ea5d139ee" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ca7cfe21776c6ac1414847422bfad703ec1d31f2a29490782caefb62302feeb1" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0025", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00221-021-06230-5", "title": "No effect of 10-week training in click-based echolocation on auditory localization in people who are blind", "authors": "L. Thaler; L. J. Norman", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s00221-021-06230-5", "doi": "10.1007/s00221-021-06230-5", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S004", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "No effect of 10-week training in click-based echolocation on auditory localization in people who are blind", "authors": "L. Thaler; L. J. Norman", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s00221-021-06230-5", "doi": "10.1007/s00221-021-06230-5", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0b838ac6cdf40b339ad181abe166e63eae963a6046dd1f6a27966d019e18dcc9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3239e6630ea322a92ac080bb032455acfa60740fa5f6165d851b4d085fdcef5f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0026", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00221-025-07180-y", "title": "Compression may be a general tendency of auditory distance judgments: evidence from distance estimates using a novel echolocation skill", "authors": "A. J. Kolarik; S. Evans; E. McCarthy; B. C. J. Moore", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s00221-025-07180-y", "doi": "10.1007/s00221-025-07180-y", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S018" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S018", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Compression may be a general tendency of auditory distance judgments: evidence from distance estimates using a novel echolocation skill", "authors": "A. J. Kolarik; S. Evans; E. McCarthy; B. C. J. Moore", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s00221-025-07180-y", "doi": "10.1007/s00221-025-07180-y", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BIAS", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "50cf1a3be13f3869ecb4f7d4f7196f83225ccf914f4403fdd29296fe6e1f21e5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "065c47ed151c06d8627de2cd12ebbe1fd3e8779ac956cb9f413e440823ad9c3b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0027", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00406-019-00997-z", "title": "A randomized controlled trial of training of affect recognition in schizophrenia shows lasting effects for theory of mind", "authors": "Anja Vaskinn; André Løvgren; Maj K. Egeland; Frida K. Feyer; Tiril Østefjells; Ole A. Andreassen; Ingrid Melle; Kjetil Sundet", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30826974/", "doi": "10.1007/s00406-019-00997-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S003", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "A randomized controlled trial of training of affect recognition in schizophrenia shows lasting effects for theory of mind", "authors": "Anja Vaskinn; André Løvgren; Maj K. Egeland; Frida K. Feyer; Tiril Østefjells; Ole A. Andreassen; Ingrid Melle; Kjetil Sundet", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30826974/", "doi": "10.1007/s00406-019-00997-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "92e18d5b77accd60da1cc91cbb3563802222f9ed4a83b12785eaa59f065f068b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "90e2033532cfb33b2f00ea0bc9f94758b0826d39a31054adabe3f36cd2807bb0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0028", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00421-002-0681-6", "title": "Muscular adaptations in response to three different resistance-training regimens: specificity of repetition maximum training zones", "authors": "Gerson E. R. Campos; Thomas J. Luecke; Heather K. Wendeln; Kumika Toma; Fredrick C. Hagerman; Thomas F. Murray; Kerry E. Ragg; Nicholas A. Ratamess; William J. Kraemer; Robert S. Staron", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12436270/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-002-0681-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S003", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Muscular adaptations in response to three different resistance-training regimens: specificity of repetition maximum training zones", "authors": "Gerson E. R. Campos; Thomas J. Luecke; Heather K. Wendeln; Kumika Toma; Fredrick C. Hagerman; Thomas F. Murray; Kerry E. Ragg; Nicholas A. Ratamess; William J. Kraemer; Robert S. Staron", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12436270/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-002-0681-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "319aa2ed6b57abbe9d3d7c84c4136f27fdd30e54e7de3aa5c5d66d74a635551c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f5c22f8dd9d4fcdcea4b1ed8fbf2a72a4967a118005ae481ae2bf9f68182333f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0029", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00421-010-1687-0", "title": "Performance and physiological responses to repeated-sprint exercise: a novel multiple-set approach", "authors": "Fabio R. Serpiello; Michael J. McKenna; Nigel K. Stepto; David J. Bishop; Robert J. Aughey", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20957389/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-010-1687-0", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S009", "F03-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02", "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S009", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Performance and physiological responses to repeated-sprint exercise: a novel multiple-set approach", "authors": "Fabio R. Serpiello; Michael J. McKenna; Nigel K. Stepto; David J. Bishop; Robert J. Aughey", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20957389/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-010-1687-0", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e0092fa9cb20413b0562872667dd416f652d968e7424bbac78b2dd6fbefc082e" }, { "source_id": "F03-S007", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Performance and physiological responses to repeated-sprint exercise: a novel multiple-set approach", "authors": "Fabio R. Serpiello; Michael J. McKenna; Nigel K. Stepto; David J. Bishop; Robert J. Aughey", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20957389/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-010-1687-0", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FATIGUE_PROFILE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5a1c621e7cc0b8061969c70eba2f2ac70167a671340baf7a969b65cb17f6e5b5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7620e353ce8a01265a0d378b37db2e8ed115f47b6f79f0c4b381b6dee3231ef9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0030", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00421-011-1974-4", "title": "Reproducibility of pacing strategy during simulated 20-km cycling time trials in well-trained cyclists", "authors": "Kevin Thomas; Mark R. Stone; Kevin G. Thompson; Alan St Clair Gibson; Les Ansley", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21533808/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-011-1974-4", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S010", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Reproducibility of pacing strategy during simulated 20-km cycling time trials in well-trained cyclists", "authors": "Kevin Thomas; Mark R. Stone; Kevin G. Thompson; Alan St Clair Gibson; Les Ansley", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21533808/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-011-1974-4", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f67642e304f34b1cebd7d8d7595cf572973173614b421e8963aa1040542fe406" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d6ac1594599cb999fd15e03df406d439c5733f40f7ceb3bd53d988145717d174" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0031", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00421-019-04153-2", "title": "Can older adults’ balance and mobility improve with visual attention training?", "authors": "M M Althomali; L A Vallis; S J Leat", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31055677/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-019-04153-2", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S004", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Can older adults’ balance and mobility improve with visual attention training?", "authors": "M M Althomali; L A Vallis; S J Leat", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31055677/", "doi": "10.1007/s00421-019-04153-2", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2b50a874f1248ab8005c474f54fddaef42c5741b12401acac2ccbbe9818ca514" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a163d700667f6f57146b0dbccfe961758ca605010e10adc11f7591a687f818d8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0032", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s004210050416", "title": "Temperature dependence of habituation of the initial responses to cold-water immersion", "authors": "M J Tipton; F S Golden; C Higenbottam; I B Mekjavic; C M Eglin", "year": 1998, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9721005/", "doi": "10.1007/s004210050416", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S005", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Temperature dependence of habituation of the initial responses to cold-water immersion", "authors": "M J Tipton; F S Golden; C Higenbottam; I B Mekjavic; C M Eglin", "year": 1998, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9721005/", "doi": "10.1007/s004210050416", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2bcef1d77158cc5b863114c396647857c8ea114c956bf9cb7f01fdc38e0b289d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e6836b88515cd41449d0befbb5c3d69f9afd3b4df5fb5d654dce2080ee01ed7b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0033", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s00464-024-10688-z", "title": "Variable practice is superior to self-directed training for laparoscopic simulator training: a randomized trial", "authors": "A Vamadevan; L Konge; F Bjerrum", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38321334/", "doi": "10.1007/s00464-024-10688-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S001", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Variable practice is superior to self-directed training for laparoscopic simulator training: a randomized trial", "authors": "A Vamadevan; L Konge; F Bjerrum", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38321334/", "doi": "10.1007/s00464-024-10688-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "741c1dc65e3a8e9fd8de1301d434cd9cfe5c3941bdf73bb9f23c3dc8fcd0919b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8e468e3fd1afbdbc42bd07a64de6875d5ae6dafac50b3a39143654b82319443a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0034", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s10162-011-0266-3", "title": "Pitch discrimination learning: specificity for pitch and harmonic resolvability, and electrophysiological correlates", "authors": "S. Carcagno; C. J. Plack", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21484466/", "doi": "10.1007/s10162-011-0266-3", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S006", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Pitch discrimination learning: specificity for pitch and harmonic resolvability, and electrophysiological correlates", "authors": "S. Carcagno; C. J. Plack", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21484466/", "doi": "10.1007/s10162-011-0266-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5821699f19504fd02de35fb0c6ef9d134601ba741fed08348f2759753f47a860" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "68d383f68cfd9023323ac80b9d1764c7178e1134a4adb48d862b892d57c69e70" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0035", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s10286-014-0255-9", "title": "Time sequence of autonomic changes induced by daily slow-breathing sessions", "authors": "Pietro Amedeo Modesti; Antonella Ferrari; Cristina Bazzini; Maria Boddi", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25345681/", "doi": "10.1007/s10286-014-0255-9", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S003", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Time sequence of autonomic changes induced by daily slow-breathing sessions", "authors": "Pietro Amedeo Modesti; Antonella Ferrari; Cristina Bazzini; Maria Boddi", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25345681/", "doi": "10.1007/s10286-014-0255-9", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bfd44750b6e7a037ca874efd2ea35b7f122757b8b22872fd5076dd642f313114" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d07c70fce45e825be1ab6c09d7bdc0724989234fffa65acad0041d4e230515fa" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0036", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s10484-015-9293-x", "title": "Physical activity, mindfulness meditation, or heart rate variability biofeedback for stress reduction: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Judith Esi van der Zwan; Wieke de Vente; Anja C Huizink; Susan M Bögels; Esther I de Bruin", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26111942/", "doi": "10.1007/s10484-015-9293-x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S012", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Physical activity, mindfulness meditation, or heart rate variability biofeedback for stress reduction: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Judith Esi van der Zwan; Wieke de Vente; Anja C Huizink; Susan M Bögels; Esther I de Bruin", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26111942/", "doi": "10.1007/s10484-015-9293-x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "332d4ca2a8ea11ffb51502e8163ab026c4f20d21c46386e7089445d4f1cae490" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1b5deaddcd90c1c20d09787788a5020736223e8ada2bc84ed0bb8f5a80d1cc5b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0037", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s10661-024-12419-2", "title": "Citizen scientists' engagement in flood risk-related data collection: a case study in Bui River Basin, Vietnam", "authors": "Huan N. Tran; Martine Rutten; Rajaram Prajapati; Ha T. Tran; Sudeep Duwal; Dung T. Nguyen; Jeffrey C. Davids; Konrad Miegel", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10874335/", "doi": "10.1007/s10661-024-12419-2", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S002", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Citizen scientists' engagement in flood risk-related data collection: a case study in Bui River Basin, Vietnam", "authors": "Huan N. Tran; Martine Rutten; Rajaram Prajapati; Ha T. Tran; Sudeep Duwal; Dung T. Nguyen; Jeffrey C. Davids; Konrad Miegel", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10874335/", "doi": "10.1007/s10661-024-12419-2", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8628a1c292bccdeccbb60055ddc152574095ac6edc9e967ab4dbeda6f42bd415" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "77475bdcf796b71634491736df4a4ec970c53118cfd6fd9a8242b85c04c9c413" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0038", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s10802-018-0499-2", "title": "Can Self-Persuasion Reduce Hostile Attribution Bias in Young Children?", "authors": "Anouk van Dijk; Sander Thomaes; Astrid M. G. Poorthuis; Bram Orobio de Castro", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30511144/", "doi": "10.1007/s10802-018-0499-2", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S008", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Can Self-Persuasion Reduce Hostile Attribution Bias in Young Children?", "authors": "Anouk van Dijk; Sander Thomaes; Astrid M. G. Poorthuis; Bram Orobio de Castro", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30511144/", "doi": "10.1007/s10802-018-0499-2", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "NEAR_TRANSFER", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "25929e97d853539dd23a0f5bb04ba3470eb8ec37d1af3104cbe1574960a6fc99" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "895b1dd35cd763833958e19ae260bcfef49d894321f0dbe8430c8d12ab922fec" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0039", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s11548-016-1425-0", "title": "Shared control of a medical robot with haptic guidance", "authors": "Linfei Xiong; Chin Boon Chng; Chee Kong Chui; Peiwu Yu; Yao Li", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27314590/", "doi": "10.1007/s11548-016-1425-0", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S009", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Shared control of a medical robot with haptic guidance", "authors": "Linfei Xiong; Chin Boon Chng; Chee Kong Chui; Peiwu Yu; Yao Li", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27314590/", "doi": "10.1007/s11548-016-1425-0", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FINE_MOTOR_TELEOPERATION", "HAPTIC_GUIDANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIMULATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "085c3f9ada453228610ccf20eeb4fcc3db52a17bae87391b069fae7c257da88a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9496853715fb431f8b0bf3cad1770ab5f54768214e2e6d0cae4675f4303f75f4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0040", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s11606-012-2063-z", "title": "Empathy Training for Resident Physicians: A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Neuroscience-Informed Curriculum", "authors": "Helen Riess; John M. Kelley; Robert W. Bailey; Emily J. Dunn; Margot Phillips", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22549298/", "doi": "10.1007/s11606-012-2063-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S001", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Empathy Training for Resident Physicians: A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Neuroscience-Informed Curriculum", "authors": "Helen Riess; John M. Kelley; Robert W. Bailey; Emily J. Dunn; Margot Phillips", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22549298/", "doi": "10.1007/s11606-012-2063-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "81d3d8336c94aaef003ccd0f8879d045c16465fa4a9ff4be60de18982fe83b74" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e2d189d4ac49dee3480d48e0d7a68df39844d3e1cc3fa322caf32d3c51bbcdd8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0041", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s40617-023-00794-0", "title": "Using Behavioral Skills Training to Teach Functional Assessment Interviewing, Cultural Responsiveness, and Empathic and Compassionate Care to Students of Applied Behavior Analysis", "authors": "Ksenia S. Gatzunis; Mary Jane Weiss; Shahla Ala’i-Rosales; Tara A. Fahmie; Noor Y. Syed", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37363650/", "doi": "10.1007/s40617-023-00794-0", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S009", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Using Behavioral Skills Training to Teach Functional Assessment Interviewing, Cultural Responsiveness, and Empathic and Compassionate Care to Students of Applied Behavior Analysis", "authors": "Ksenia S. Gatzunis; Mary Jane Weiss; Shahla Ala’i-Rosales; Tara A. Fahmie; Noor Y. Syed", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37363650/", "doi": "10.1007/s40617-023-00794-0", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c3336e23f84cc89a57a33f3e63e21724909efde1a19155fa59d5428aacdc37df" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1e01caad5c6b755b05f1ee24a6e651dab6fef723ae821e2ce264bc447200059e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0042", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1007/s42978-021-00120-6", "title": "The Effects of High-Intensity Acute Exercise on Face-Name Memory in Healthy Young Adults", "authors": "Morgan Gilbert; Paul D. Loprinzi", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s42978-021-00120-6", "doi": "10.1007/s42978-021-00120-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S013", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "The Effects of High-Intensity Acute Exercise on Face-Name Memory in Healthy Young Adults", "authors": "Morgan Gilbert; Paul D. Loprinzi", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/s42978-021-00120-6", "doi": "10.1007/s42978-021-00120-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "94f9abea01bb1b26fe2cdb6beb62f221cd971f20e3701b0464e5525dfae0a2ef" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bfb9e5bbaeefe91bec297edaf8f56a563480a2d3145ccd423231bcc69443c64d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0043", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/0010-0285(83)90002-6", "title": "Schema induction and analogical transfer", "authors": "Mary L. Gick; Keith J. Holyoak", "year": 1983, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0285(83)90002-6", "doi": "10.1016/0010-0285(83)90002-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S003", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Schema induction and analogical transfer", "authors": "Mary L. Gick; Keith J. Holyoak", "year": 1983, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-0285(83)90002-6", "doi": "10.1016/0010-0285(83)90002-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_CONDITIONS", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "401529ed40ad0ebd6e281dd1bd3e3718c6051c3d3e1540ed494546ba2e66b360" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4fee6b945401a2a76ad7e8f912392a4af9dc56ef6ddc838a12e512f6cd19e2e2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0044", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/0010-0285(86)90002-2", "title": "Pragmatic versus syntactic approaches to training deductive reasoning", "authors": "Patricia W. Cheng; Keith J. Holyoak; Richard E. Nisbett; Lindsay M. Oliver", "year": 1986, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3742999/", "doi": "10.1016/0010-0285(86)90002-2", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S015", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Pragmatic versus syntactic approaches to training deductive reasoning", "authors": "Patricia W. Cheng; Keith J. Holyoak; Richard E. Nisbett; Lindsay M. Oliver", "year": 1986, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3742999/", "doi": "10.1016/0010-0285(86)90002-2", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTEXT_SPECIFICITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7f2442b7123cd85594262a578bbfe1fce9ede3914718ad011f0308414ca0b630" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c3dd00fefa5ed1fdc460bf002a89a8600149b0167c02e0124a9c20bd7a250e43" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0045", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/0168-8227(91)90127-y", "title": "The Thermocross: a simple tool for rapid assessment of thermal sensation thresholds", "authors": "C. Liniger; A. Albeanu; J. F. Moody; J. Richez; D. Bloise; J. P. Assal", "year": 1991, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1855438/", "doi": "10.1016/0168-8227(91)90127-Y", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S011", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "The Thermocross: a simple tool for rapid assessment of thermal sensation thresholds", "authors": "C. Liniger; A. Albeanu; J. F. Moody; J. Richez; D. Bloise; J. P. Assal", "year": 1991, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1855438/", "doi": "10.1016/0168-8227(91)90127-Y", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7090ab8683fe24b6cbb5aa0b91808b7fee634ad61b4853401b11f3996b0f9e52" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bea1286dee90dfa23204a2d020ef82a9fe70ec610c6037d7995d4f83ea642475" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0046", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.actpsy.2018.04.016", "title": "Effects of task repetition but no transfer of inhibitory control training in healthy adults", "authors": "Tabea Talanow; Ulrich Ettinger", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29772392/", "doi": "10.1016/j.actpsy.2018.04.016", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S007", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Effects of task repetition but no transfer of inhibitory control training in healthy adults", "authors": "Tabea Talanow; Ulrich Ettinger", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29772392/", "doi": "10.1016/j.actpsy.2018.04.016", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5a0c9b3dbe4da4c1328e7ae9ba0f9698e0ee8dbb383ac32764968e928d65291f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "105c4c652b6bb4523e172856a7a04b83a751f6e2444280602d170239b9201aab" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0047", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104678", "title": "Compassionate mind training for university students - A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C Andersson; S J Støre; H Säldebjer; M Gunnarsson; K L Bergsten; W Osika", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39701000/", "doi": "10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104678", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S016", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Compassionate mind training for university students - A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C Andersson; S J Støre; H Säldebjer; M Gunnarsson; K L Bergsten; W Osika", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39701000/", "doi": "10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104678", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e7fce54f731f251ad1376ca7a3335bb83c22f8a029f284bc3ae16d9dabb8e925" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "94e11f6638454f522c8fd906c06d972563bd06f8a6b33ca5a4158a43bcdec65d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0048", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.amjsurg.2020.02.002", "title": "Training with cognitive load improves performance under similar conditions in a real surgical task", "authors": "G Sankaranarayanan; C A Odlozil; K O Wells; S G Leeds; S Chauhan; J W Fleshman; D B Jones; S De", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32107012/", "doi": "10.1016/j.amjsurg.2020.02.002", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S004", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Training with cognitive load improves performance under similar conditions in a real surgical task", "authors": "G Sankaranarayanan; C A Odlozil; K O Wells; S G Leeds; S Chauhan; J W Fleshman; D B Jones; S De", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32107012/", "doi": "10.1016/j.amjsurg.2020.02.002", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "46fa206aed2df52da0a4e3e62efdaf98f24aca774868bccfd27d19f308a53193" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1c371a909c66339c933b01f90d9a3658e80ad3bdf213a476cb1e79d1d9bb4fb8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0049", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.anbehav.2007.05.010", "title": "Consensus decision making in human crowds", "authors": "John R. G. Dyer; Christos C. Ioannou; Lesley J. Morrell; Darren P. Croft; Iain D. Couzin; Dean A. Waters; Jens Krause", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://research-information.bris.ac.uk/en/publications/consensus-decision-making-in-human-crowds/", "doi": "10.1016/j.anbehav.2007.05.010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S010", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Consensus decision making in human crowds", "authors": "John R. G. Dyer; Christos C. Ioannou; Lesley J. Morrell; Darren P. Croft; Iain D. Couzin; Dean A. Waters; Jens Krause", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://research-information.bris.ac.uk/en/publications/consensus-decision-making-in-human-crowds/", "doi": "10.1016/j.anbehav.2007.05.010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EMERGENT_COORDINATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0ab8252a19f7f5c6629eede291fa64898a63df23f28c1860e90aac6c5b782836" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e7579cb50060ee2e341591ea64195ce487153f1e1cd7d6a0ce8f273a539968c5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0050", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.apergo.2025.104469", "title": "Effects of 24-weeks in-field use of a back-supporting exoskeleton on biomechanics, work intensity and musculoskeletal discomfort", "authors": "L. Schrøder Jakobsen; A. Samani; K. Desbrosses; M. de Zee; B. Steinhilber; P. Madeleine", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39904204", "doi": "10.1016/j.apergo.2025.104469", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S004", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Effects of 24-weeks in-field use of a back-supporting exoskeleton on biomechanics, work intensity and musculoskeletal discomfort", "authors": "L. Schrøder Jakobsen; A. Samani; K. Desbrosses; M. de Zee; B. Steinhilber; P. Madeleine", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39904204", "doi": "10.1016/j.apergo.2025.104469", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DISCONTINUATION", "FIELD_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "ROBOTIC_AUGMENTATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6cb938ce7adf9cbf5539aa150baef27972be863125156ce30083c8f0b8613706" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d9b1b80350376dbab9b7e116143270d6723c1162553c115087736546f57be26b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0051", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.apergo.2026.104733", "title": "Soldier load carriage: Does the type of pack matter?", "authors": "Robin Orr; Jacques Rousseau; Elisa F. D. Canetti; Ben Schram", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41548350/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apergo.2026.104733", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S009", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Soldier load carriage: Does the type of pack matter?", "authors": "Robin Orr; Jacques Rousseau; Elisa F. D. Canetti; Ben Schram", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41548350/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apergo.2026.104733", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "89d71aef07deea0f1227c39eb7f11aded2f3cb56e889e5265ad6b095f3f48dcc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9ac5b8d7ac788e8ea3b9822d6b37c4ebd9231948cf5d16d9d89a6d8b224fe467" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0052", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2007.06.010", "title": "Sensory retraining of the lower limb after acute stroke: a randomized controlled pilot trial", "authors": "Elizabeth A Lynch; Susan L Hillier; Kathy Stiller; Rachel R Campanella; Penny H Fisher", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17826453/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apmr.2007.06.010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S003", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Sensory retraining of the lower limb after acute stroke: a randomized controlled pilot trial", "authors": "Elizabeth A Lynch; Susan L Hillier; Kathy Stiller; Rachel R Campanella; Penny H Fisher", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17826453/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apmr.2007.06.010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6434e21be27acf8eddb570d152d652e24c1b2475a1871c2529389e8c095c8834" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2012c7e44df35596ed6f8b78c3ef989f314d014bb81725e61ff088fe8fc99cb3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0053", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2014.10.018", "title": "Improving motor control in walking: a randomized clinical trial in older adults with subclinical walking difficulty", "authors": "Jennifer S Brach; Kristin Lowry; Subashan Perera; Victoria Hornyak; David Wert; Stephanie A Studenski; Jessie M VanSwearingen", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25448244/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apmr.2014.10.018", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S010", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Improving motor control in walking: a randomized clinical trial in older adults with subclinical walking difficulty", "authors": "Jennifer S Brach; Kristin Lowry; Subashan Perera; Victoria Hornyak; David Wert; Stephanie A Studenski; Jessie M VanSwearingen", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25448244/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apmr.2014.10.018", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "076097a157d590fb51d1ee447a22f07f2e4ddaaf17cf1da5b3c0e4b43a408418" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9d57d1047b54240d8874739e3e9450998ad241527d330be3678991e3638313ee" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0054", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.apmr.2025.07.005", "title": "Virtual Reality in Training of Sustained Attention, Processing Speed, and Working Memory After Traumatic Brain Injury: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Truls Johansen; Martin Matre; Marianne Løvstad; Alexander Olsen; Anne Lund; Anne Catrine Trægde Martinsen; Frank Becker; Cathrine Brunborg; Albert Rizzo; Jacoba M Spikman; Dawn Neumann; Jennie Ponsford; Sveinung Tornås", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40714041/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apmr.2025.07.005", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S002", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Virtual Reality in Training of Sustained Attention, Processing Speed, and Working Memory After Traumatic Brain Injury: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Truls Johansen; Martin Matre; Marianne Løvstad; Alexander Olsen; Anne Lund; Anne Catrine Trægde Martinsen; Frank Becker; Cathrine Brunborg; Albert Rizzo; Jacoba M Spikman; Dawn Neumann; Jennie Ponsford; Sveinung Tornås", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40714041/", "doi": "10.1016/j.apmr.2025.07.005", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "11a201e81496eff4b30a27cc52a5f15880d63fbfb974dc03eaadc6ee43978c87" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3fffffaaebb6a22e4d688ee825484f56d0879685a7457dea19586dce5f461d5b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0055", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.archger.2024.105405", "title": "The Social and Cognitive Online Training (SCOT) project: A digital randomized controlled trial to promote socio-cognitive well-being in older adults", "authors": "Giulia Funghi; Claudia Meli; Arianna Cavagna; Lisa Bisoffi; Francesca Zappini; Costanza Papagno; Alessandra Dodich", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38531149/", "doi": "10.1016/j.archger.2024.105405", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S005", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "The Social and Cognitive Online Training (SCOT) project: A digital randomized controlled trial to promote socio-cognitive well-being in older adults", "authors": "Giulia Funghi; Claudia Meli; Arianna Cavagna; Lisa Bisoffi; Francesca Zappini; Costanza Papagno; Alessandra Dodich", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38531149/", "doi": "10.1016/j.archger.2024.105405", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACTIVE_CONTROL", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5c5a0faf329794c4b209a7313ad29c66da6de13a9ff31320efd881d06404d963" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3ff784f166e64466c430b38149021e8cd0f8e196092c611a39f296474ca37a40" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0056", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.bandc.2008.08.032", "title": "Changes in brain activation induced by the training of hypothesis generation skills: an fMRI study", "authors": "Kwon YJ; Lee JK; Shin DH; Jeong JS", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18848743", "doi": "10.1016/j.bandc.2008.08.032", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S005", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Changes in brain activation induced by the training of hypothesis generation skills: an fMRI study", "authors": "Kwon YJ; Lee JK; Shin DH; Jeong JS", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18848743", "doi": "10.1016/j.bandc.2008.08.032", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b7545f909cbca2a007067083d6d9bc501d9db32234167d1455b6704ab03c8991" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "365d69ebb19804f427cbaacebe6948680e9fb0673e973123f30c61a6c457ed16" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0057", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.biopsycho.2014.12.010", "title": "Effects of heartbeat feedback on beliefs about heart rate and heartbeat counting: a cautionary tale about interoceptive awareness", "authors": "C. Ring; J. Brener; K. Knapp; J. Mailloux", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25553874/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2014.12.010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S021" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S021", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Effects of heartbeat feedback on beliefs about heart rate and heartbeat counting: a cautionary tale about interoceptive awareness", "authors": "C. Ring; J. Brener; K. Knapp; J. Mailloux", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25553874/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2014.12.010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f96710bc352d2681930ec2590cb22e2d5933e2794a3594d7c81edac887eac951" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e8d77da11b5ae68399dc9ae4970f10a1ac1e57fe682aac1472398ffcc3d733ce" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0058", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.biopsycho.2018.09.004", "title": "The heartbeat counting task largely involves non-interoceptive processes: Evidence from both the original and an adapted counting task", "authors": "O. Desmedt; O. Luminet; O. Corneille", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30218689/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2018.09.004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S020" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S020", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "The heartbeat counting task largely involves non-interoceptive processes: Evidence from both the original and an adapted counting task", "authors": "O. Desmedt; O. Luminet; O. Corneille", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30218689/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2018.09.004", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c1494af63c5caec9c05a45ba05750d82912ebe0831548e2104149e021e94424d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a02ce2108c2c25271356e29e0fbf1cacfb325d57a88e8f766288257adec2e259" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0059", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.biopsycho.2025.109172", "title": "Post-learning stress after a heartbeat perception training facilitates interoceptive accuracy in the heartbeat counting task, but not in the heartbeat discrimination task", "authors": "R. Müller; C. Vögele; I. Van Diest; A. Schulz", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41314278/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2025.109172", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S023" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S023", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Post-learning stress after a heartbeat perception training facilitates interoceptive accuracy in the heartbeat counting task, but not in the heartbeat discrimination task", "authors": "R. Müller; C. Vögele; I. Van Diest; A. Schulz", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41314278/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2025.109172", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b6519b2b3b1862fca7952089d6355e0694347d768c55b966392edd02d094e22b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a579d95d7451cacaacfbdf45e6dfb54105b3cca5d317c1e618a7431ec6ffdd67" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0060", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.biopsycho.2026.109315", "title": "More than ears: Neural synchrony underlies the facilitating effects of active listening on reappraisal over acceptance during interpersonal emotion regulation", "authors": "Wang Linzi; Zhu Tongtong; Wang Yicheng; Jin Luyao; Dai Yuanfu; Ning Hao; Yanmei Wang", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42288208/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2026.109315", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S010", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "More than ears: Neural synchrony underlies the facilitating effects of active listening on reappraisal over acceptance during interpersonal emotion regulation", "authors": "Wang Linzi; Zhu Tongtong; Wang Yicheng; Jin Luyao; Dai Yuanfu; Ning Hao; Yanmei Wang", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42288208/", "doi": "10.1016/j.biopsycho.2026.109315", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a8e0f4b4d46ccce6d46e9890ee8899a5b3885b5ea5e479102ffd2cdba25d3aef" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6df0b131f7ad76f04492366817522d998c7ad1e900931a98ac9efa6ed9b9cc83" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0061", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.bonr.2016.04.004", "title": "Effects of low-dose ibuprofen supplementation and resistance training on bone and muscle in postmenopausal women: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Whitney R D Duff; Saija A Kontulainen; Darren G Candow; Julianne J Gordon; Riley S Mason; Regina Taylor-Gjevre; Bindu Nair; Michael Szafron; Adam D G Baxter-Jones; Gordon A Zello; Philip D Chilibeck", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28326351/", "doi": "10.1016/j.bonr.2016.04.004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S004", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Effects of low-dose ibuprofen supplementation and resistance training on bone and muscle in postmenopausal women: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Whitney R D Duff; Saija A Kontulainen; Darren G Candow; Julianne J Gordon; Riley S Mason; Regina Taylor-Gjevre; Bindu Nair; Michael Szafron; Adam D G Baxter-Jones; Gordon A Zello; Philip D Chilibeck", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28326351/", "doi": "10.1016/j.bonr.2016.04.004", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "34c02f67a14392483e12bc70d0275ddc081a45a8740adcff1ccbf7141dcd8193" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5d3cf01c6df0dff18a8aabfa154438abf5d86f86454e47cd0730f2bb7f3a66a6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0062", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.brat.2014.05.005", "title": "Dialectical behavior therapy skills for transdiagnostic emotion dysregulation: a pilot randomized controlled trial", "authors": "A D Neacsiu; J W Eberle; R Kramer; T Wiesmann; M M Linehan", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24974307/", "doi": "10.1016/j.brat.2014.05.005", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S008", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Dialectical behavior therapy skills for transdiagnostic emotion dysregulation: a pilot randomized controlled trial", "authors": "A D Neacsiu; J W Eberle; R Kramer; T Wiesmann; M M Linehan", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24974307/", "doi": "10.1016/j.brat.2014.05.005", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "465cd899e5e4830a7c02d743a03f228de3c8beb5aca9fd436a7281b0f6d8048b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "da5de77ce14889f1febed9592426034d56759fc0aa13045e174e62ce28d14c02" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0063", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.brat.2026.104979", "title": "Impact of a brief HRV-biofeedback intervention on emotion regulation following a real-life stressful event: A randomized controlled study", "authors": "J Depoorter; K Hoorelbeke; T Guillaumée; M Cortet; M Lilot; G Rode; R De Raedt; S Schlatter", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41702143/", "doi": "10.1016/j.brat.2026.104979", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S018" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S018", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Impact of a brief HRV-biofeedback intervention on emotion regulation following a real-life stressful event: A randomized controlled study", "authors": "J Depoorter; K Hoorelbeke; T Guillaumée; M Cortet; M Lilot; G Rode; R De Raedt; S Schlatter", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41702143/", "doi": "10.1016/j.brat.2026.104979", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a6205836365945f39d653c4e148d481f88ba2d42a21987d8ffdd210ca4893e87" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "eea13bfa0b91cbe18e51e448730bba1365381515c48e31748c22a0d307e53c78" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0064", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cnp.2018.06.004", "title": "Method-of-limits; Cold and warm perception thresholds at proximal and distal body regions", "authors": "V. Heldestad Lilliesköld; E. Nordh", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30215024/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cnp.2018.06.004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S008", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Method-of-limits; Cold and warm perception thresholds at proximal and distal body regions", "authors": "V. Heldestad Lilliesköld; E. Nordh", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30215024/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cnp.2018.06.004", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "eb9225045360a5e69d86868f0de160c2a0b99b1042e578876818c453b511a1cf" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7670d2681233b02d2dc0a8bb9e9a8aaead2c9847b1b1042af0d1c49028428abb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0065", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cognition.2019.06.010", "title": "Vision and proprioception make equal contributions to path integration in a novel homing task", "authors": "Elizabeth R Chrastil; Grace L Nicora; Andrew Huang", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31228680/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cognition.2019.06.010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S006", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Vision and proprioception make equal contributions to path integration in a novel homing task", "authors": "Elizabeth R Chrastil; Grace L Nicora; Andrew Huang", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31228680/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cognition.2019.06.010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "df9acbc995959c16f5062c17c00f61c5b86c63a15d698b184c93b43373191834" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9c19c1c27198d5a17e596b6637d4247813bb8ce2804fbb0b312b76f1b734fb12" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0066", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cortex.2020.04.017", "title": "No persistent attenuation of fear memories in humans: A registered replication of the reactivation-extinction effect", "authors": "Anastasia Chalkia; Natalie Schroyens; Lu Leng; Niels Vanhasbroeck; Ann-Kathrin Zenses; Lukas Van Oudenhove; Tom Beckers", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32580869/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cortex.2020.04.017", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S013", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "No persistent attenuation of fear memories in humans: A registered replication of the reactivation-extinction effect", "authors": "Anastasia Chalkia; Natalie Schroyens; Lu Leng; Niels Vanhasbroeck; Ann-Kathrin Zenses; Lukas Van Oudenhove; Tom Beckers", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32580869/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cortex.2020.04.017", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "REPLICATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d2182f23982bb936e18c1ee744615c3e50d7821e8e8dff1645c426bfad65c203" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a14eafd26b43e3312fc40b3527df28acd2234608f179095b3c2de3d3763f581d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0067", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.csbj.2023.07.033", "title": "Continuous shared control of a mobile robot with brain–computer interface and autonomous navigation for daily assistance", "authors": "Baoguo Xu; Deping Liu; Muhui Xue; Minmin Miao; Cong Hu; Aiguo Song", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://spj.science.org/doi/10.1016/j.csbj.2023.07.033", "doi": "10.1016/j.csbj.2023.07.033", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S006", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Continuous shared control of a mobile robot with brain–computer interface and autonomous navigation for daily assistance", "authors": "Baoguo Xu; Deping Liu; Muhui Xue; Minmin Miao; Cong Hu; Aiguo Song", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://spj.science.org/doi/10.1016/j.csbj.2023.07.033", "doi": "10.1016/j.csbj.2023.07.033", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTROLLED_CORRIDOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "SHARED_AUTONOMY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9b25433721039d3fe844528cf5268c8f8551b2e9206822cb11f0b54880958b89" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bd7f10bbe2263c285bb42d1c083db936fe40b4abca45babc63fc33c043d84c83" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0068", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cub.2006.05.048", "title": "Sound facilitates visual learning", "authors": "A. R. Seitz; R. Kim; L. Shams", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16860741/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2006.05.048", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S027" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S027", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Sound facilitates visual learning", "authors": "A. R. Seitz; R. Kim; L. Shams", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16860741/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2006.05.048", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CROSSMODAL_TRANSFER", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e26dfac7bad37819a53e24f7cdc8ca5941cd224bf47763fe8d3cc03699ecfce3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b8c2ee627e94717bd37d7781a773c662d4f1829860de1e8fbb4caec885ebdc89" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0069", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cub.2009.05.009", "title": "Tool-use induces morphological updating of the body schema", "authors": "Lucilla Cardinali; Francesca Frassinetti; Claudio Brozzoli; Christian Urquizar; Alice C Roy; Alessandro Farnè", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19549491/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2009.05.009", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S011", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Tool-use induces morphological updating of the body schema", "authors": "Lucilla Cardinali; Francesca Frassinetti; Claudio Brozzoli; Christian Urquizar; Alice C Roy; Alessandro Farnè", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19549491/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2009.05.009", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b1c65fa1edb963fdf2767a8de150285d52eaa4c7876a63b9ffc696d6b5d97d93" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "46066a3de51147105cf1d44c5c4480eccaa9a22c943e03d31571d60af3b01607" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0070", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cub.2011.11.018", "title": "Acquiring “the Knowledge” of London’s layout drives structural brain changes", "authors": "Katherine Woollett; Eleanor A Maguire", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22169537/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2011.11.018", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S007", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Acquiring “the Knowledge” of London’s layout drives structural brain changes", "authors": "Katherine Woollett; Eleanor A Maguire", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22169537/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2011.11.018", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c90667c3c24ba57b77f5365a933ce15c27bb8a96763f0c420ee85496e9ceedd5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "24b46d712b64edc7abea303c5ffc3f28c96208433c195ffcbd806999f738c665" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0071", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cub.2015.08.016", "title": "Humans Can Continuously Optimize Energetic Cost during Walking", "authors": "Jessica C Selinger; Shawn M O'Connor; Jeremy D Wong; J Maxwell Donelan", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26365256/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2015.08.016", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S009", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Humans Can Continuously Optimize Energetic Cost during Walking", "authors": "Jessica C Selinger; Shawn M O'Connor; Jeremy D Wong; J Maxwell Donelan", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26365256/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2015.08.016", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4934a3ed7df312ad165b7b160c200bc72c60f6072b02286047a320473f341be2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7ed96b6de7b1388d551670c595c412e415f61e196f4e78da2d04ac07f98be529" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0072", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.cub.2021.01.026", "title": "Real-time dialogue between experimenters and dreamers during REM sleep", "authors": "Karen R Konkoly; Kristoffer Appel; Emma Chabani; Anastasia Mangiaruga; Jarrod Gott; Remington Mallett; Bruce Caughran; Sarah Witkowski; Nathan W Whitmore; Christopher Y Mazurek; Jonathan B Berent; Frederik D Weber; Başak Türker; Smaranda Leu-Semenescu; Jean-Baptiste Maranci; Gordon Pipa; Isabelle Arnulf; Delphine Oudiette; Martin Dresler; Ken A Paller", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33607035/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2021.01.026", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S009", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Real-time dialogue between experimenters and dreamers during REM sleep", "authors": "Karen R Konkoly; Kristoffer Appel; Emma Chabani; Anastasia Mangiaruga; Jarrod Gott; Remington Mallett; Bruce Caughran; Sarah Witkowski; Nathan W Whitmore; Christopher Y Mazurek; Jonathan B Berent; Frederik D Weber; Başak Türker; Smaranda Leu-Semenescu; Jean-Baptiste Maranci; Gordon Pipa; Isabelle Arnulf; Delphine Oudiette; Martin Dresler; Ken A Paller", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33607035/", "doi": "10.1016/j.cub.2021.01.026", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d5b7407d1bf75c7d719a142dc9a21d4554897c8a851093052b49b40c9861d94a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ee217ae179e10f6efc4b6873ed3f546e08474518880a97ff71948f86cd4adc3b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0073", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.exger.2020.110860", "title": "The effect of resistance training, detraining and retraining on muscle strength and power, myofibre size, satellite cells and myonuclei in older men", "authors": "Sara Blocquiaux; Tatiane Gorski; Evelien Van Roie; Monique Ramaekers; Ruud Van Thienen; Henri Nielens; Christophe Delecluse; Katrien De Bock; Martine Thomis", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32017951/", "doi": "10.1016/j.exger.2020.110860", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S016", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "The effect of resistance training, detraining and retraining on muscle strength and power, myofibre size, satellite cells and myonuclei in older men", "authors": "Sara Blocquiaux; Tatiane Gorski; Evelien Van Roie; Monique Ramaekers; Ruud Van Thienen; Henri Nielens; Christophe Delecluse; Katrien De Bock; Martine Thomis", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32017951/", "doi": "10.1016/j.exger.2020.110860", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a6b19e6a047da972b74e3b6c71e5339207cdfefa144eefbbbd63ff1b5dbc4cf1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ca2468b182d937012cd5c1b3e4d7df5a96002124fec1f17e74d33d9891de1a09" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0074", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.hansur.2020.11.007", "title": "Can maximal handgrip strength and endurance be improved by an 8-week specialized strength training program in older women? A randomized controlled study", "authors": "V. Gerodimos; K. Karatrantou; K. Kakardaki; P. Ioakimidis", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33340721/", "doi": "10.1016/j.hansur.2020.11.007", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S006", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Can maximal handgrip strength and endurance be improved by an 8-week specialized strength training program in older women? A randomized controlled study", "authors": "V. Gerodimos; K. Karatrantou; K. Kakardaki; P. Ioakimidis", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33340721/", "doi": "10.1016/j.hansur.2020.11.007", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1891dd512cf827553aba263d6711996065ce12c602d27fb5f5ad6324e5c70787" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "abf167ab17a0824cc0f049da3b8ba75c5d30b426d89bec5fe9b1af25ba38d9f3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0075", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.heares.2026.109554", "title": "Vestibular habituation is associated with distinct autonomic signatures and greater reduction in visually induced motion sickness: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Qikun Zhang; Xinyang Chen; Chuanxia Cao; Yaqi Zhang; Jing Zhao; Linyao Shi; Shengguang Yan; Zhanguo Jin", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41643532/", "doi": "10.1016/j.heares.2026.109554", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S015", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Vestibular habituation is associated with distinct autonomic signatures and greater reduction in visually induced motion sickness: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Qikun Zhang; Xinyang Chen; Chuanxia Cao; Yaqi Zhang; Jing Zhao; Linyao Shi; Shengguang Yan; Zhanguo Jin", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41643532/", "doi": "10.1016/j.heares.2026.109554", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6fc2718616e7a20d0f957ec1746fb9d15dc1828c843b9df59c4f2f3e966b18c5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f190a820c86b924c3a400542f39e0908deaef0211fa1aafa74ed454e80049861" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0076", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2015.05.001", "title": "Reducing conflict and containment rates on acute psychiatric wards: The Safewards cluster randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Len Bowers; Karen James; Alan Quirk; Alan Simpson; SUGAR; Duncan Stewart; John Hodsoll", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26166187/", "doi": "10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2015.05.001", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S015", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Reducing conflict and containment rates on acute psychiatric wards: The Safewards cluster randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Len Bowers; Karen James; Alan Quirk; Alan Simpson; SUGAR; Duncan Stewart; John Hodsoll", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26166187/", "doi": "10.1016/j.ijnurstu.2015.05.001", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "beb736b8b7bbb933bf8916a6ea44b9ceda39dfc49b3ebc525184861fdd4dd25e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "44aacf008658964f8ee90f88c3e64824ac45cf15934b1f88b82ccdaed8a99a54" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0077", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2019.03.014", "title": "Training gains and transfer effects after mnemonic strategy training in mild cognitive impairment: A fMRI study", "authors": "Sharon S. Simon; Benjamin M. Hampstead; Mariana P. Nucci; Fábio L. S. Duran; Luciana M. Fonseca; Maria da Graça M. Martin; Renata Ávila; Fábio H. G. Porto; Sônia M. D. Brucki; Camila B. Martins; Lyssandra S. Tascone; Edson Amaro; Geraldo F. Busatto; Cássio M. C. Bottino", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30936043/", "doi": "10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2019.03.014", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S012", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Training gains and transfer effects after mnemonic strategy training in mild cognitive impairment: A fMRI study", "authors": "Sharon S. Simon; Benjamin M. Hampstead; Mariana P. Nucci; Fábio L. S. Duran; Luciana M. Fonseca; Maria da Graça M. Martin; Renata Ávila; Fábio H. G. Porto; Sônia M. D. Brucki; Camila B. Martins; Lyssandra S. Tascone; Edson Amaro; Geraldo F. Busatto; Cássio M. C. Bottino", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30936043/", "doi": "10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2019.03.014", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "06f9725064092e2ec6c21d16818801232c287b09f87a436f51801e450f3daa48" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d41d7990fbefa8cf99cb2fdca8040db5b8bd211aa1112efe3fcdcdb7ce5adfb9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0078", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2021.08.001", "title": "Direct voluntary control of pupil constriction and dilation: Exploratory evidence from pupillometry, optometry, skin conductance, perception, and functional MRI", "authors": "Lisa V Eberhardt; Georg Grön; Martin Ulrich; Anke Huckauf; Christoph Strauch", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34391820/", "doi": "10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2021.08.001", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S005", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Direct voluntary control of pupil constriction and dilation: Exploratory evidence from pupillometry, optometry, skin conductance, perception, and functional MRI", "authors": "Lisa V Eberhardt; Georg Grön; Martin Ulrich; Anke Huckauf; Christoph Strauch", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34391820/", "doi": "10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2021.08.001", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d761a2932aa5f834b0b0297ec52d0154c3d2889f11cc14a87a8f9134f88dde05" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8d3617061c011c78161693904a1e55e589b259974021d90095f8c42ba754d7c8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0079", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.intell.2016.11.004", "title": "Smart groups of smart people: Evidence for IQ as the origin of collective intelligence in the performance of human groups", "authors": "Timothy Bates; Shivani Gupta", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.research.ed.ac.uk/en/publications/smart-groups-of-smart-people-evidence-for-iq-as-the-origin-of-col/", "doi": "10.1016/j.intell.2016.11.004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S009", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Smart groups of smart people: Evidence for IQ as the origin of collective intelligence in the performance of human groups", "authors": "Timothy Bates; Shivani Gupta", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.research.ed.ac.uk/en/publications/smart-groups-of-smart-people-evidence-for-iq-as-the-origin-of-col/", "doi": "10.1016/j.intell.2016.11.004", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c5930c19be78cc8e47dc250c0d847f1ca51f8ee0bcc2f2358472ff4f6dba2011" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ec24c412104ad67ee4a2979992ee5090d98caebe45ee526b6ec051a86b8ac517" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0080", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jacc.2006.06.059", "title": "Effectiveness of physical counterpressure maneuvers in preventing vasovagal syncope: the Physical Counterpressure Manoeuvres Trial (PC-Trial)", "authors": "Nynke van Dijk; Fabio Quartieri; Jean-Jaques Blanc; Roberto Garcia-Civera; Michele Brignole; Angel Moya; Wouter Wieling; PC-Trial Investigators", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17045903/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jacc.2006.06.059", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S011", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Effectiveness of physical counterpressure maneuvers in preventing vasovagal syncope: the Physical Counterpressure Manoeuvres Trial (PC-Trial)", "authors": "Nynke van Dijk; Fabio Quartieri; Jean-Jaques Blanc; Roberto Garcia-Civera; Michele Brignole; Angel Moya; Wouter Wieling; PC-Trial Investigators", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17045903/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jacc.2006.06.059", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BOUNDARY", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "77f115e89d35635cafe73e5789372457e1a2cc363f43fa41b6be52baffe47540" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fcffc7c598b6223cb169393434500b1cef3b77bd51d06c823dff13aa60d758d6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0081", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jad.2020.07.015", "title": "Goal management training as a cognitive remediation intervention in depression: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Bjørn Ivar Hagen; Bjørn Lau; Jutta Joormann; Milada C Småstuen; Nils Inge Landrø; Jan Stubberud", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32734919/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jad.2020.07.015", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S014", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Goal management training as a cognitive remediation intervention in depression: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Bjørn Ivar Hagen; Bjørn Lau; Jutta Joormann; Milada C Småstuen; Nils Inge Landrø; Jan Stubberud", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32734919/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jad.2020.07.015", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4afef65a4ca0e9e694c710e93c9bd03193e0dd2fc25839c2c5d08b0d0443148d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "dd62fab0a5d3261acbe6d4fff550155d80bcca26a6adc21f2a661e41e230a78e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0082", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jagp.2013.12.175", "title": "A Multidimensional Home-Based Care Coordination Intervention for Elders with Memory Disorders: The Maximizing Independence at Home (MIND) Pilot Randomized Trial", "authors": "Quincy M. Samus; Deirdre Johnston; Betty S. Black; Edward Hess; Christopher Lyman; Amrita Vavilikolanu; Jane Pollutra; Jeannie-Marie Leoutsakos; Laura N. Gitlin; Peter V. Rabins; Constantine G. Lyketsos", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24502822/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jagp.2013.12.175", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S006", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "A Multidimensional Home-Based Care Coordination Intervention for Elders with Memory Disorders: The Maximizing Independence at Home (MIND) Pilot Randomized Trial", "authors": "Quincy M. Samus; Deirdre Johnston; Betty S. Black; Edward Hess; Christopher Lyman; Amrita Vavilikolanu; Jane Pollutra; Jeannie-Marie Leoutsakos; Laura N. Gitlin; Peter V. Rabins; Constantine G. Lyketsos", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24502822/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jagp.2013.12.175", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "77add009f9837625355e840d509ca7d4c0ea0b25f5d4099af50f2ffbd7e47554" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4c8aaf7aa6a250233e9f23ef3cd1f2446a4f71cbaa2e3ec76474dbff7a88baaa" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0083", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2014.07.933", "title": "Influence of surgeon behavior on trainee willingness to speak up: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Marco J. Barzallo Salazar; Howard Minkoff; Jyothshna Bayya; Brian Gillett; Helen Onoriode; Jeremy Weedon; Lisa Altshuler; Nelli Fisher", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25256368/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2014.07.933", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S017", "F31-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24", "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S017", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Influence of surgeon behavior on trainee willingness to speak up: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Marco J. Barzallo Salazar; Howard Minkoff; Jyothshna Bayya; Brian Gillett; Helen Onoriode; Jeremy Weedon; Lisa Altshuler; Nelli Fisher", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25256368/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2014.07.933", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPEAK_UP", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "358fa9186ce28a068ff38a225fc6875dda08a0bf38c34f5956edd901d4efc7cf" }, { "source_id": "F31-S004", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Influence of surgeon behavior on trainee willingness to speak up: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Marco J. Barzallo Salazar; Howard Minkoff; Jyothshna Bayya; Brian Gillett; Helen Onoriode; Jeremy Weedon; Lisa Altshuler; Nelli Fisher", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25256368/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2014.07.933", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3307fc48585f49c5e2c199a708a8698cf477fa1b41273c8c48f8e6bcaffbefd9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bd59cb5d06505516b91d66e76dbc16ae90bae900ccda0648cea445e7d6d6fc05" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0084", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jbiomech.2010.08.014", "title": "Plasticity of human Achilles tendon mechanical and morphological properties in response to cyclic strain", "authors": "Adamantios Arampatzis; Andreas Peper; Stefanie Bierbaum; Kirsten Albracht", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20863501/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jbiomech.2010.08.014", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S002", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Plasticity of human Achilles tendon mechanical and morphological properties in response to cyclic strain", "authors": "Adamantios Arampatzis; Andreas Peper; Stefanie Bierbaum; Kirsten Albracht", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20863501/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jbiomech.2010.08.014", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d383a29f3cdca6d503515215f08ca1949763e2f8d5851c5d00ae5abc2e9dbea0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c00194b0793d73a39f74395613ad31ba2df16bc3c41810732056a3d23a3dd341" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0085", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jbmt.2019.02.016", "title": "Traditional physical therapy exercises combined with sensorimotor training: The effects on clinical outcomes for chronic neck pain in a double-blind, randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Maryam Saadat; Reza Salehi; Hossein Negahban; Mohammad Jafar Shaterzadeh; Mohammad Mehravar; Masumeh Hessam", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31733780/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jbmt.2019.02.016", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S001", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Traditional physical therapy exercises combined with sensorimotor training: The effects on clinical outcomes for chronic neck pain in a double-blind, randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Maryam Saadat; Reza Salehi; Hossein Negahban; Mohammad Jafar Shaterzadeh; Mohammad Mehravar; Masumeh Hessam", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31733780/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jbmt.2019.02.016", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "03fde6817d5214a79d4f35debc32c43d3c0f3475b0570394b93c50bfc3eeec6c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "330efaf409e0405c8caf565aa1c62cba167092e168d0ec725371b1f6c8000ef0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0086", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jht.2016.12.001", "title": "Effectiveness of a fine motor skills rehabilitation program on upper limb disability, manual dexterity, pinch strength, range of fingers motion, performance in activities of daily living, functional independency, and general self-efficacy in hand osteoarthritis: A randomized clinical trial", "authors": "J M Pérez-Mármol; M C García-Ríos; M A Ortega-Valdivieso; E E Cano-Deltell; M I Peralta-Ramírez; K Ickmans; M E Aguilar-Ferrándiz", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28502698/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jht.2016.12.001", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S008", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Effectiveness of a fine motor skills rehabilitation program on upper limb disability, manual dexterity, pinch strength, range of fingers motion, performance in activities of daily living, functional independency, and general self-efficacy in hand osteoarthritis: A randomized clinical trial", "authors": "J M Pérez-Mármol; M C García-Ríos; M A Ortega-Valdivieso; E E Cano-Deltell; M I Peralta-Ramírez; K Ickmans; M E Aguilar-Ferrándiz", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28502698/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jht.2016.12.001", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d932c5b5bf09359f85f1440bbd158b3bd2bb802b2c18734242a83f89e6c948c9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6f2c3b9d826b3fde4913e3c74b8503ed257e7ea342c7a3a21158fa972d3dc057" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0087", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jht.2023.10.010", "title": "Effect of Kinesio taping on wrist proprioception in healthy subjects: A randomized clinical trial", "authors": "Lorenzo A Justo-Cousiño; Iria Da Cuña-Carrera; Alejandra Alonso-Calvete; Yoana González-González", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38307737/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jht.2023.10.010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S002", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Effect of Kinesio taping on wrist proprioception in healthy subjects: A randomized clinical trial", "authors": "Lorenzo A Justo-Cousiño; Iria Da Cuña-Carrera; Alejandra Alonso-Calvete; Yoana González-González", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38307737/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jht.2023.10.010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c13700e169dd443c1ad2f273eddf8a15703e9eba4f30f5344a3fc0aebfb41974" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d7882d2821301e43d702903c2b4339ba75b3135f350484d092013b3a829c3594" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0088", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jpain.2018.09.013", "title": "Operant Learning Versus Energy Conservation Activity Pacing Treatments in a Sample of Patients With Fibromyalgia Syndrome: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Mélanie Racine; Mark P Jensen; Manfred Harth; Patricia Morley-Forster; Warren R Nielson", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30326271/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jpain.2018.09.013", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S006", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Operant Learning Versus Energy Conservation Activity Pacing Treatments in a Sample of Patients With Fibromyalgia Syndrome: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Mélanie Racine; Mark P Jensen; Manfred Harth; Patricia Morley-Forster; Warren R Nielson", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30326271/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jpain.2018.09.013", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1e446bd0ab3bebf0d9559b23efbdf566c7a0320fcfaece38b702811d4e78a6a3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "53e70b250da1db91a54ea779d15341e68b4524778b1b7c868c5074f426e49d2b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0089", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2016.09.005", "title": "Dignity Therapy and Life Review for Palliative Care Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Dean Vuksanovic; Heather J. Green; Murray Dyck; Shirley A. Morrissey", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27810568/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2016.09.005", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S008", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Dignity Therapy and Life Review for Palliative Care Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Dean Vuksanovic; Heather J. Green; Murray Dyck; Shirley A. Morrissey", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27810568/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jpainsymman.2016.09.005", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fe760360f516d1d5a476089984079f88de322dbf1f92ca91ea6fc3388cba85ad" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "df6e0651c4e4cc6493527af9415345136b664553b351bd889285dece67ecf59d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0090", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2025.105380", "title": "The value of group purchasing: Evidence from the U.S. hospital industry", "authors": "Haizhen Lin; Yanhao Wang", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047272725000787", "doi": "10.1016/j.jpubeco.2025.105380", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S005", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "The value of group purchasing: Evidence from the U.S. hospital industry", "authors": "Haizhen Lin; Yanhao Wang", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047272725000787", "doi": "10.1016/j.jpubeco.2025.105380", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "dccc90218285f38b06d9d49d0756a4e1e3f88f58a85062a01b70bc149de4154b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "99ffea89b7d8e31872a7f1d8008cd2f725f34acd435db8c9c7707f720721daaa" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0091", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jtherbio.2021.103174", "title": "Age comparison of changes in local warm and cold sensitivity due to whole body cooling", "authors": "N. A. Coull; S. G. Hodder; G. Havenith", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35180960/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jtherbio.2021.103174", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S010", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Age comparison of changes in local warm and cold sensitivity due to whole body cooling", "authors": "N. A. Coull; S. G. Hodder; G. Havenith", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35180960/", "doi": "10.1016/j.jtherbio.2021.103174", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTEXT_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7ce19af8591899c223c45d556c6d1b9f750d63cc8410967f11576b0a28c3cd7b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4cffc040dfb0c11be34707a5b51fd8556f8e24cfe151eaa2ee6ca1836814deba" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0092", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.jvoice.2022.10.012", "title": "Vocal Function Exercises With and Without Maximally Sustained Phonation: A Randomized Controlled Trial of Individuals With Normal Voice", "authors": "Bane M; Morton M; Angadi V; Andreatta R; Stemple J", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36379827", "doi": "10.1016/j.jvoice.2022.10.012", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S003", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Vocal Function Exercises With and Without Maximally Sustained Phonation: A Randomized Controlled Trial of Individuals With Normal Voice", "authors": "Bane M; Morton M; Angadi V; Andreatta R; Stemple J", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36379827", "doi": "10.1016/j.jvoice.2022.10.012", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_BETWEEN_GROUP", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ba9e186d7716b89aa5edd6163bef2537907b3765435a3f201c75f094068ac9f1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "239595ec16d03f9ffbc85123e03d6948a9b8d3fd2d5b44a57169369fb998b940" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0093", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.nepr.2024.104063", "title": "The effect of problem-solving and decision-making education on problem-solving and decision-making skills of nurse managers: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Berra Yilmaz Kusakli; Betül Sönmez", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39038405/", "doi": "10.1016/j.nepr.2024.104063", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S009", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "The effect of problem-solving and decision-making education on problem-solving and decision-making skills of nurse managers: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Berra Yilmaz Kusakli; Betül Sönmez", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39038405/", "doi": "10.1016/j.nepr.2024.104063", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "710cff8e728aafdc433c37cadedbe19e14c8b00cf79796865b036aaba666d074" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "28c7310754195892347d46f0506d61e87c6c5683ecfac1710d8ab969c67064eb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0094", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2017.02.003", "title": "Mnemonic Training Reshapes Brain Networks to Support Superior Memory", "authors": "Martin Dresler; William R. Shirer; Boris N. Konrad; Nils C. J. Müller; Isabella C. Wagner; Guillén Fernández; Michael Czisch; Michael D. Greicius", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28279356/", "doi": "10.1016/j.neuron.2017.02.003", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S009", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Mnemonic Training Reshapes Brain Networks to Support Superior Memory", "authors": "Martin Dresler; William R. Shirer; Boris N. Konrad; Nils C. J. Müller; Isabella C. Wagner; Guillén Fernández; Michael Czisch; Michael D. Greicius", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28279356/", "doi": "10.1016/j.neuron.2017.02.003", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "512fffaab172b86c148bd16de7983156ac0cdaed1c1fa669f8d364c95efa0677" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c3fc891e46081b467fe9472b876536562180a230b2228dd1543ea9562c3565b7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0095", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2022.108309", "title": "Perceptual training narrows the temporal binding window of audiovisual integration in both younger and older adults", "authors": "D. P. McGovern; S. Burns; R. J. Hirst; F. N. Newell", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35752266/", "doi": "10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2022.108309", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S025" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S025", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Perceptual training narrows the temporal binding window of audiovisual integration in both younger and older adults", "authors": "D. P. McGovern; S. Burns; R. J. Hirst; F. N. Newell", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35752266/", "doi": "10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2022.108309", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AGE_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4dc21b7ca2511ea535ca134a88e1e0ebbf447020fc11e34439e3a2f19756b8a9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1206398eb2933a3deed775e51559228088c753dbdbe8a4556c1f6cba2c1ef177" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0096", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.pain.2007.10.021", "title": "Tactile discrimination, but not tactile stimulation alone, reduces chronic limb pain", "authors": "G. L. Moseley; N. M. Zalucki; K. Wiech", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18054437/", "doi": "10.1016/j.pain.2007.10.021", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S003", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Tactile discrimination, but not tactile stimulation alone, reduces chronic limb pain", "authors": "G. L. Moseley; N. M. Zalucki; K. Wiech", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18054437/", "doi": "10.1016/j.pain.2007.10.021", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f08bcb0979fd21a3bfbc9d1b5ab9426b254d2201b9e5d9be074506ede84c6d45" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c44fad96ed32362740751b021f3dbd5438d6b992b8f6ba864f36cf43336116c0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0097", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.pec.2016.11.008", "title": "Breaking bad news to patients with cancer: A randomized control trial of a brief communication skills training module incorporating the stories and preferences of actual patients", "authors": "Gorniewicz J; Floyd M; Krishnan K; Bishop TW; Tudiver F; Lang F", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27876220", "doi": "10.1016/j.pec.2016.11.008", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S006", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Breaking bad news to patients with cancer: A randomized control trial of a brief communication skills training module incorporating the stories and preferences of actual patients", "authors": "Gorniewicz J; Floyd M; Krishnan K; Bishop TW; Tudiver F; Lang F", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27876220", "doi": "10.1016/j.pec.2016.11.008", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_REAL_WORLD_TRANSFER", "SIMULATION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6116d80e791283d3187ced509b7122337e0b7cb04e20a33ccce298d3da1e7225" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "077f1194e710abade0a82598c8416b3d5b2cf02e4002055ecd5bf040bd5adc2d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0098", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2017.02.026", "title": "Habituation of the cold shock response is inhibited by repeated anxiety: Implications for safety behaviour on accidental cold water immersions", "authors": "M J Barwood; J Corbett; M Tipton; C Wagstaff; H Massey", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28242468/", "doi": "10.1016/j.physbeh.2017.02.026", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S006", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Habituation of the cold shock response is inhibited by repeated anxiety: Implications for safety behaviour on accidental cold water immersions", "authors": "M J Barwood; J Corbett; M Tipton; C Wagstaff; H Massey", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28242468/", "doi": "10.1016/j.physbeh.2017.02.026", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "06b693aaa67198f97367133b5e50e94b042be9436432307c504e53dfac99fa63" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "127890f8167715d9197d6577dca53c7e009b20c5e2d2ddb5e5b416522e55d11a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0099", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.pnpbp.2019.109851", "title": "Caffeine-dependent changes of sleep-wake regulation: Evidence for adaptation after repeated intake", "authors": "Janine Weibel; Yu-Shiuan Lin; Hans-Peter Landolt; Corrado Garbazza; Vitaliy Kolodyazhniy; Joshua Kistler; Sophia Rehm; Katharina Rentsch; Stefan Borgwardt; Christian Cajochen; Carolin Franziska Reichert", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31866308/", "doi": "10.1016/j.pnpbp.2019.109851", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S011", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Caffeine-dependent changes of sleep-wake regulation: Evidence for adaptation after repeated intake", "authors": "Janine Weibel; Yu-Shiuan Lin; Hans-Peter Landolt; Corrado Garbazza; Vitaliy Kolodyazhniy; Joshua Kistler; Sophia Rehm; Katharina Rentsch; Stefan Borgwardt; Christian Cajochen; Carolin Franziska Reichert", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31866308/", "doi": "10.1016/j.pnpbp.2019.109851", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "INDIVIDUAL_VARIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "401e92c9df5f420025c0c52be51407cbf0967429076eef45979ad2b40e450218" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "208ff3a0995e3637e3b138cccd267c4b1744ddff948b14395eb5923332f877dd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0100", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2018.04.018", "title": "The introduction of a rapid response system in acute hospitals: A pragmatic stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Filip Haegdorens; Peter Van Bogaert; Ella Roelant; Koen De Meester; Marie Misselyn; Kristien Wouters; Koenraad G. Monsieurs", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29679694/", "doi": "10.1016/j.resuscitation.2018.04.018", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S013", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "The introduction of a rapid response system in acute hospitals: A pragmatic stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Filip Haegdorens; Peter Van Bogaert; Ella Roelant; Koen De Meester; Marie Misselyn; Kristien Wouters; Koenraad G. Monsieurs", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29679694/", "doi": "10.1016/j.resuscitation.2018.04.018", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ac7b6ccf8db091e6afa2c3a53d380c9de58bbd6352fe190bbe4698049440a5ff" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8373ee0cf6474ce651e55ebf79a0e4912cc4883a1f7e65ef0d95b20de3bac6dd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0101", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.resuscitation.2019.06.010", "title": "A randomized education trial of spaced versus massed instruction to improve acquisition and retention of paediatric resuscitation skills in emergency medical service providers", "authors": "Catherine Patocka; Adam Cheng; Matthew Sibbald; Jonathan P. Duff; Anita Lai; Patricia Lee-Nobbee; Helen Levin; Terry Varshney; Bryan Weber; Farhan Bhanji", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31212041/", "doi": "10.1016/j.resuscitation.2019.06.010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S007", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "A randomized education trial of spaced versus massed instruction to improve acquisition and retention of paediatric resuscitation skills in emergency medical service providers", "authors": "Catherine Patocka; Adam Cheng; Matthew Sibbald; Jonathan P. Duff; Anita Lai; Patricia Lee-Nobbee; Helen Levin; Terry Varshney; Bryan Weber; Farhan Bhanji", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31212041/", "doi": "10.1016/j.resuscitation.2019.06.010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a03f35527e56a3fdae2b2b14c73e3dc53825b0117cecf620876b2aba363d7e1d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0b1e0048b9834eaec314a925283c9f82578f7b6008492e5fd4412899c6a273d4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0102", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.visres.2005.07.031", "title": "Perceptual learning improves contrast sensitivity and visual acuity in adults with anisometropic amblyopia", "authors": "Y. Zhou; C. Huang; P. Xu; L. Tao; Z. Qiu; X. Li; Z.-L. Lu", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16153674/", "doi": "10.1016/j.visres.2005.07.031", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S002", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Perceptual learning improves contrast sensitivity and visual acuity in adults with anisometropic amblyopia", "authors": "Y. Zhou; C. Huang; P. Xu; L. Tao; Z. Qiu; X. Li; Z.-L. Lu", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16153674/", "doi": "10.1016/j.visres.2005.07.031", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "dde552b1520d19ca729ba2304d204101488a8d9a955dc8aae9994f6c944e193a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8dbdf872a21a1e3f8f10a8908cf91e7b4e94939837e9063d9c3f80244463320f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0103", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/j.visres.2013.10.011", "title": "Perceptual learning of motion direction discrimination transfers to an opposite direction with TPE training", "authors": "J.-Y. Zhang; Y.-X. Yang", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24184566/", "doi": "10.1016/j.visres.2013.10.011", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S008", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Perceptual learning of motion direction discrimination transfers to an opposite direction with TPE training", "authors": "J.-Y. Zhang; Y.-X. Yang", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24184566/", "doi": "10.1016/j.visres.2013.10.011", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e6b6a0544c7ef3de8c992bca6ff318864a9277c4385f35ce755cba8297731fbd" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "267a522ff364231b45ffa9a89fb3812eabcb43f87cec973455c17ee07e668fb2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0104", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/s0042-6989(99)00092-9", "title": "Aging and dark adaptation", "authors": "G. R. Jackson; C. Owsley; G. McGwin", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10748929/", "doi": "10.1016/S0042-6989(99)00092-9", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S011", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Aging and dark adaptation", "authors": "G. R. Jackson; C. Owsley; G. McGwin", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10748929/", "doi": "10.1016/S0042-6989(99)00092-9", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6160c60cfc42e927cb70cf0da49546be0b40ade192d72c64f1aa6d4cf8f83541" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ffaa392f9bbcec5fc7f7ce38ff1004fa92b7b20885aa5f69eeae60f87ae79a46" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0105", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(05)66733-5", "title": "Introduction of the medical emergency team (MET) system: a cluster-randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Ken Hillman; Jack Chen; Michelle Cretikos; Rinaldo Bellomo; Daniel Brown; Gordon Doig; Simon Finfer; Arthas Flabouris; MERIT Study Investigators", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15964445/", "doi": "10.1016/S0140-6736(05)66733-5", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S001", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Introduction of the medical emergency team (MET) system: a cluster-randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Ken Hillman; Jack Chen; Michelle Cretikos; Rinaldo Bellomo; Daniel Brown; Gordon Doig; Simon Finfer; Arthas Flabouris; MERIT Study Investigators", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15964445/", "doi": "10.1016/S0140-6736(05)66733-5", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f2bb6d2c492f5135feec3a36db38255c032246ca1fa9d5e83e81c408a2a292c0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "32b320a7cbe5503d3767638b38c08266b3813557bd59889c0059562b4a717530" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0106", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(15)60690-0", "title": "Efficacy and safety of very early mobilisation within 24 h of stroke onset (AVERT): a randomised controlled trial", "authors": "AVERT Trial Collaboration group", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25892679/", "doi": "10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60690-0", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S002", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Efficacy and safety of very early mobilisation within 24 h of stroke onset (AVERT): a randomised controlled trial", "authors": "AVERT Trial Collaboration group", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25892679/", "doi": "10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60690-0", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fb0ec82da8a16db4c2311d6377929ef20069d3e1238432180c6ef2151cf3d49d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bde001e8e8000d9ecfd8a025b76dcba20a5ab93a22ce1092dcae7088ea318e59" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0107", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(17)30067-3", "title": "Intensive speech and language therapy in patients with chronic aphasia after stroke: a randomised, open-label, blinded-endpoint, controlled trial in a health-care setting", "authors": "Caterina Breitenstein; Tanja Grewe; Agnes Flöel; Wolfram Ziegler; Luise Springer; Peter Martus; Walter Huber; Klaus Willmes; E Bernd Ringelstein; Karl Georg Haeusler; Stefanie Abel; Ralf Glindemann; Frank Domahs; Frank Regenbrecht; Klaus-Jürgen Schlenck; Marion Thomas; Hellmuth Obrig; Ernst de Langen; Roman Rocker; Franziska Wigbers; Christina Rühmkorf; Indra Hempen; Jonathan List; Annette Baumgaertner; FCET2EC study group", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28256356/", "doi": "10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30067-3", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S007", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Intensive speech and language therapy in patients with chronic aphasia after stroke: a randomised, open-label, blinded-endpoint, controlled trial in a health-care setting", "authors": "Caterina Breitenstein; Tanja Grewe; Agnes Flöel; Wolfram Ziegler; Luise Springer; Peter Martus; Walter Huber; Klaus Willmes; E Bernd Ringelstein; Karl Georg Haeusler; Stefanie Abel; Ralf Glindemann; Frank Domahs; Frank Regenbrecht; Klaus-Jürgen Schlenck; Marion Thomas; Hellmuth Obrig; Ernst de Langen; Roman Rocker; Franziska Wigbers; Christina Rühmkorf; Indra Hempen; Jonathan List; Annette Baumgaertner; FCET2EC study group", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28256356/", "doi": "10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30067-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5a3b220e07ecb228be15cd0291d1b977940fbf9a35a3a6febda6ec4482651034" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4f6f7b1e7cb4691cf8d5419e490c2e2d33f9eea80f4511dca676f1ff5590679a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0108", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/s0926-6410(03)00202-7", "title": "Perceptual learning modulates sensory evoked response during vowel segregation", "authors": "K. S. Reinke; Y. He; C. Wang; C. Alain", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14561463/", "doi": "10.1016/S0926-6410(03)00202-7", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S011", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Perceptual learning modulates sensory evoked response during vowel segregation", "authors": "K. S. Reinke; Y. He; C. Wang; C. Alain", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14561463/", "doi": "10.1016/S0926-6410(03)00202-7", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9f0ed0d7e1d71b2f6ac852d7b461ea1ce10c9ce2bd9676260fb9b71322ff2f48" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "10a9e51119a0de6291883825bb0e276c64b8a37f1c8f6923a5253d7e35a5549f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0109", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1016/s1470-2045(11)70153-x", "title": "Effect of dignity therapy on distress and end-of-life experience in terminally ill patients: a randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Harvey Max Chochinov; Linda J. Kristjanson; William Breitbart; Susan McClement; Thomas F. Hack; Tom Hassard; Mike Harlos", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21741309/", "doi": "10.1016/S1470-2045(11)70153-X", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S012", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Effect of dignity therapy on distress and end-of-life experience in terminally ill patients: a randomised controlled trial", "authors": "Harvey Max Chochinov; Linda J. Kristjanson; William Breitbart; Susan McClement; Thomas F. Hack; Tom Hassard; Mike Harlos", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21741309/", "doi": "10.1016/S1470-2045(11)70153-X", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "246569c2a9e2aa21c50a4dafe7aa83cc6abaa1b264ae0da52ab888bc8d084ed5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b932fbe5b8667d3b56d651e3fab2c3d36179c7d9a0c4c23613580975c51aae30" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0110", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1017/dmp.2019.78", "title": "Does Preparedness Matter? The Influence of Household Preparedness on Disaster Outcomes During Superstorm Sandy", "authors": "L A Clay; J B Goetschius; M A Papas; J Trainor; N Martins; J M Kendra", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31452492/", "doi": "10.1017/dmp.2019.78", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S017", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Does Preparedness Matter? The Influence of Household Preparedness on Disaster Outcomes During Superstorm Sandy", "authors": "L A Clay; J B Goetschius; M A Papas; J Trainor; N Martins; J M Kendra", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31452492/", "doi": "10.1017/dmp.2019.78", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "de94b285e129f668799078cdf742bc48199bb0aa785f321f9aa451d7cc5be714" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b92a05b6e115f23f042d8a3f1cd4258a057478bf3be9104978e9368c77f47888" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0111", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1017/s1352465823000206", "title": "Feasibility and initial impact of single-session internet-delivered acceptance vs change skills for emotions for stress- and trauma-related problems: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C L McLean; A K Ruork; M K Ramaiya; A E Fruzzetti", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37288653/", "doi": "10.1017/S1352465823000206", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S010", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Feasibility and initial impact of single-session internet-delivered acceptance vs change skills for emotions for stress- and trauma-related problems: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C L McLean; A K Ruork; M K Ramaiya; A E Fruzzetti", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37288653/", "doi": "10.1017/S1352465823000206", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "809d3d4e5a020005990d72b0582581244dcc40c13a213247e0a7d5ee5b7422c2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "daa707bb97dcfce10117e0ee9a2cd4bb59a727632b21f939ef28511ba8bc9310" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0112", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1017/s1355617715001344", "title": "Rehabilitation of Executive Functions in Patients with Chronic Acquired Brain Injury with Goal Management Training, External Cuing, and Emotional Regulation: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Sveinung Tornås; Marianne Løvstad; Anne-Kristin Solbakk; Jonathan Evans; Tor Endestad; Per Kristian Hol; Anne-Kristine Schanke; Jan Stubberud", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26812574/", "doi": "10.1017/S1355617715001344", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S008", "F13-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08", "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S008", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Rehabilitation of Executive Functions in Patients with Chronic Acquired Brain Injury with Goal Management Training, External Cuing, and Emotional Regulation: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Sveinung Tornås; Marianne Løvstad; Anne-Kristin Solbakk; Jonathan Evans; Tor Endestad; Per Kristian Hol; Anne-Kristine Schanke; Jan Stubberud", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26812574/", "doi": "10.1017/S1355617715001344", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0c3b5af0d9a0ab796e0e018a13406b17779328baa6cce32ed2d4f53c2b4cc071" }, { "source_id": "F13-S013", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Rehabilitation of Executive Functions in Patients with Chronic Acquired Brain Injury with Goal Management Training, External Cuing, and Emotional Regulation: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Sveinung Tornås; Marianne Løvstad; Anne-Kristin Solbakk; Jonathan Evans; Tor Endestad; Per Kristian Hol; Anne-Kristine Schanke; Jan Stubberud", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26812574/", "doi": "10.1017/S1355617715001344", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9ebfc963d787e014e3e60ec368be7340d567f2381bc53b0884ef9472608ef914" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4aefb6983612a774e62b1a962272f6f2733c8ac2a072eadad948892d073f621d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0113", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0021-9010.85.6.971", "title": "Performance implications of leader briefings and team-interaction training for team adaptation to novel environments", "authors": "Michelle A. Marks; Stephen J. Zaccaro; John E. Mathieu", "year": 2000, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11125660/", "doi": "10.1037/0021-9010.85.6.971", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S001", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Performance implications of leader briefings and team-interaction training for team adaptation to novel environments", "authors": "Michelle A. Marks; Stephen J. Zaccaro; John E. Mathieu", "year": 2000, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11125660/", "doi": "10.1037/0021-9010.85.6.971", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8a2952def69e308fb4ca170f22e7b8de2acc7cb4f66cf3439d3e599722a7cd63" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3faa9ee36ebbc0f2f47fe1ccb3dd7d086cfcd1c6d2099421cd9775c2c5623cd1" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0114", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0021-9010.90.5.857", "title": "After-event reviews: drawing lessons from successful and failed experience", "authors": "Shmuel Ellis; Inbar Davidi", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16162059/", "doi": "10.1037/0021-9010.90.5.857", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S016", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "After-event reviews: drawing lessons from successful and failed experience", "authors": "Shmuel Ellis; Inbar Davidi", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16162059/", "doi": "10.1037/0021-9010.90.5.857", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e95c9ed75a7eb129baff153a8fdb2d4bdf19e6d32d0ef68b963c7257da4ca72f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a57261f1c9214c4db538d3c891dafe24e43f3f756e7f49c4ccfccdbf78dc5ce3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0115", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0022-3514.48.6.1467", "title": "Pooling of unshared information in group decision making: Biased information sampling during discussion", "authors": "Garold Stasser; William Titus", "year": 1985, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.48.6.1467", "doi": "10.1037/0022-3514.48.6.1467", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S003", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Pooling of unshared information in group decision making: Biased information sampling during discussion", "authors": "Garold Stasser; William Titus", "year": 1985, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.48.6.1467", "doi": "10.1037/0022-3514.48.6.1467", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a49ea34c49e6d913bfbc57aa25a3d35da42215e64c96762cd7eeb47ebf65e759" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "55b0c0f93ea5d390b3c8fc1a1c1af821840c455cb7420c7badb9cf5213293998" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0116", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0022-3514.53.3.497", "title": "Productivity loss in brainstorming groups: Toward the solution of a riddle", "authors": "Michael Diehl; Wolfgang Stroebe", "year": 1987, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.53.3.497", "doi": "10.1037/0022-3514.53.3.497", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S014", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Productivity loss in brainstorming groups: Toward the solution of a riddle", "authors": "Michael Diehl; Wolfgang Stroebe", "year": 1987, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.53.3.497", "doi": "10.1037/0022-3514.53.3.497", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY", "PROCESS_MECHANISM" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2fa9da2304186eda260164db9b71637ba6c70b9d9c02925ca2c49b6b08761a29" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d921b88b61d82db7ebcf3e612dfe645084733dcd72a36f85d19f25122afce99a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0117", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0022-3514.93.3.478", "title": "Culture and self-concept stability: consistency across and within contexts among Asian Americans and European Americans", "authors": "Tammy English; Serena Chen", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17723061/", "doi": "10.1037/0022-3514.93.3.478", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S014", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Culture and self-concept stability: consistency across and within contexts among Asian Americans and European Americans", "authors": "Tammy English; Serena Chen", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17723061/", "doi": "10.1037/0022-3514.93.3.478", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6d399419c7c3220c82736cbd42f1a90ceb50fb3f721ff9e31ed9e2e299efb70c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0608695dfc422b1c223833487a54f30f1059b6bb42e9d1c3f4012223092346b9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0118", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0278-7393.33.4.704", "title": "Expanding retrieval practice promotes short-term retention, but equally spaced retrieval enhances long-term retention", "authors": "Jeffrey D. Karpicke; Henry L. Roediger", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17576148/", "doi": "10.1037/0278-7393.33.4.704", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S002", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Expanding retrieval practice promotes short-term retention, but equally spaced retrieval enhances long-term retention", "authors": "Jeffrey D. Karpicke; Henry L. Roediger", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17576148/", "doi": "10.1037/0278-7393.33.4.704", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bfe3d21d0fd99033424ae5ccb5525eba2d4ba60ce028b7e2bcc0ad3d5f1c2555" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "743ea209b49502cbe79664a242ce89492e7d04fd9ad74a0dd65c972c6f6bd3e2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0119", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0278-7393.34.4.834", "title": "Sleep does not enhance motor sequence learning", "authors": "Timothy C. Rickard; Denise J. Cai; Cory A. Rieth; Jason Jones; M. Colin Ard", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18605872/", "doi": "10.1037/0278-7393.34.4.834", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S005", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Sleep does not enhance motor sequence learning", "authors": "Timothy C. Rickard; Denise J. Cai; Cory A. Rieth; Jason Jones; M. Colin Ard", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18605872/", "doi": "10.1037/0278-7393.34.4.834", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3ba8769bd1f9252b0f92dddd9c5da9ca676ef66adc8f8243a936f1691ac0cef2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d1f3525070ac4d906fdcd92aa2b3052825e9f82caec817f14a6633d1928d3514" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0120", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/0882-7974.20.4.695", "title": "Training effects on dual-task performance: are there age-related differences in plasticity of attentional control?", "authors": "Louis Bherer; Arthur F Kramer; Matthew S Peterson; Stanley Colcombe; Kirk Erickson; Ensar Becic", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16420143/", "doi": "10.1037/0882-7974.20.4.695", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S005", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Training effects on dual-task performance: are there age-related differences in plasticity of attentional control?", "authors": "Louis Bherer; Arthur F Kramer; Matthew S Peterson; Stanley Colcombe; Kirk Erickson; Ensar Becic", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16420143/", "doi": "10.1037/0882-7974.20.4.695", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7c9407b086e4f401f51bdc0c7694ace4b567cfbe4a6cd576cc5fcd926e728c4e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "025e3bd1f459381af4b323a7c789fd6aa31a1e69654947d3421e53036cd761ae" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0121", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/a0016634", "title": "Effects of assertiveness training and expressive writing on acculturative stress in international students: A randomized trial", "authors": "Shedeh Tavakoli; Mark A. Lumley; Alaa M. Hijazi; Olga M. Slavin-Spenny; George P. Parris", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20357910/", "doi": "10.1037/a0016634", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S004", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Effects of assertiveness training and expressive writing on acculturative stress in international students: A randomized trial", "authors": "Shedeh Tavakoli; Mark A. Lumley; Alaa M. Hijazi; Olga M. Slavin-Spenny; George P. Parris", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20357910/", "doi": "10.1037/a0016634", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f58bf98e16b5b1dfdc44e9fc850de3d57c70c00e3672893ac66e0c67bac85e6f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "820a060bf259561d8eac7f5ed04d1b0f489ad19f0993eef4db1c78795d26b1ca" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0122", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/a0018132", "title": "Marital status and satisfaction five years following a randomized clinical trial comparing traditional versus integrative behavioral couple therapy", "authors": "Andrew Christensen; David C. Atkins; Brian Baucom; Jean Yi", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20350033/", "doi": "10.1037/a0018132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S014", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Marital status and satisfaction five years following a randomized clinical trial comparing traditional versus integrative behavioral couple therapy", "authors": "Andrew Christensen; David C. Atkins; Brian Baucom; Jean Yi", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20350033/", "doi": "10.1037/a0018132", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESTRICTED", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "126009429cd66dec44ffa83f9762ac73499213783b04e3f3d9a038e24be2328c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9582d0fb7e2a2ffb284cb1e19f64561fcd8bce02d58c103634ae7c5ab7551c9b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0123", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/a0029082", "title": "No evidence of intelligence improvement after working memory training: a randomized, placebo-controlled study", "authors": "Thomas S Redick; Zach Shipstead; Tyler L Harrison; Kenny L Hicks; David E Fried; David Z Hambrick; Michael J Kane; Randall W Engle", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22708717/", "doi": "10.1037/a0029082", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S011", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "No evidence of intelligence improvement after working memory training: a randomized, placebo-controlled study", "authors": "Thomas S Redick; Zach Shipstead; Tyler L Harrison; Kenny L Hicks; David E Fried; David Z Hambrick; Michael J Kane; Randall W Engle", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22708717/", "doi": "10.1037/a0029082", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d075555ed3a541a729617c2951080936b12817cd9b71cf23ed65eb5bc00f0802" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d5e164af05492b4311479e11c22b9b9244421f4b43251fb888122c0680f011ed" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0124", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/a0033881", "title": "Changes over swim lessons in parents’ perceptions of children’s supervision needs in drowning risk situations: “His swimming has improved so now he can keep himself safe”", "authors": "B A Morrongiello; M Sandomierski; J R Spence", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23977872/", "doi": "10.1037/a0033881", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S012", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Changes over swim lessons in parents’ perceptions of children’s supervision needs in drowning risk situations: “His swimming has improved so now he can keep himself safe”", "authors": "B A Morrongiello; M Sandomierski; J R Spence", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23977872/", "doi": "10.1037/a0033881", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8833ec4b375f6d28b79d9ce371bcfd94150368198c21240a4619cb3bedcc10e8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c2821ec36bc3338b39ea6ac01f9ae3236e10a728c7921ff6630a5a5621f71e54" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0125", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/a0036165", "title": "No evidence for true training and transfer effects after inhibitory control training in young healthy adults", "authors": "Stefan Enge; Alexander Behnke; Monika Fleischhauer; Laura Küttler; Matthias Kliegel; Alexander Strobel", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24707778/", "doi": "10.1037/a0036165", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S008", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "No evidence for true training and transfer effects after inhibitory control training in young healthy adults", "authors": "Stefan Enge; Alexander Behnke; Monika Fleischhauer; Laura Küttler; Matthias Kliegel; Alexander Strobel", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24707778/", "doi": "10.1037/a0036165", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "568b1f4cdcd4b740e00c748188b1d7488d00cfef81431bf1be675a1032c11ab2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a99e5072e2ffb86894832044d866de0fcc06cd299c2724b2317bc41215f43438" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0126", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/emo0001328", "title": "Emotion regulation training for adolescents with major depression: Results from a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C Zsigo; L Feldmann; F Oort; C Piechaczek; J Bartling; M Schulte-Rüther; C Wachinger; G Schulte-Körne; E Greimel", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38060020/", "doi": "10.1037/emo0001328", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S005", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Emotion regulation training for adolescents with major depression: Results from a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C Zsigo; L Feldmann; F Oort; C Piechaczek; J Bartling; M Schulte-Rüther; C Wachinger; G Schulte-Körne; E Greimel", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38060020/", "doi": "10.1037/emo0001328", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "495b943db17b742265af6576033fc11d9005ff32380108b3e8bee2b480b52bc5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b9e70a328c98bc9586dba1ede6e9b7146ed4c957689211c44bde646c9f4cbc9e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0127", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/xap0000040", "title": "The psychology of intelligence analysis: Drivers of prediction accuracy in world politics", "authors": "Barbara Mellers; Eric Stone; Pavel Atanasov; Nick Rohrbaugh; S. Emlen Metz; Lyle Ungar; Michael M. Bishop; Michael Horowitz; Ed Merkle; Philip Tetlock", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25581088/", "doi": "10.1037/xap0000040", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S005", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "The psychology of intelligence analysis: Drivers of prediction accuracy in world politics", "authors": "Barbara Mellers; Eric Stone; Pavel Atanasov; Nick Rohrbaugh; S. Emlen Metz; Lyle Ungar; Michael M. Bishop; Michael Horowitz; Ed Merkle; Philip Tetlock", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25581088/", "doi": "10.1037/xap0000040", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e000009a64d26b12845874fc996497c3347502d134245b2196862f686420bf39" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "97a263652701d73be33df99232e955861280bd2b3bce391de8a5904e37cf768c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0128", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/xhp0000697", "title": "The flexible action system: Click-based echolocation may replace certain visual functionality for adaptive walking", "authors": "L. Thaler; X. Zhang; M. Antoniou; D. C. Kish; D. Cowie", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/xhp0000697", "doi": "10.1037/xhp0000697", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S017", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "The flexible action system: Click-based echolocation may replace certain visual functionality for adaptive walking", "authors": "L. Thaler; X. Zhang; M. Antoniou; D. C. Kish; D. Cowie", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1037/xhp0000697", "doi": "10.1037/xhp0000697", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1d9db1607f761e737501abbf37b7b2ad723b30384a216cb269ce0aa6a7eb9a1d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "97cffdb87384bfd0bd7da986c5bb74f234766b37acb6406116958c18b1dae501" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0129", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1037/xlm0001630", "title": "Offloading reduces prospective memory learning", "authors": "C Fellers; B C Storm", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42241083/", "doi": "10.1037/xlm0001630", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S007", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Offloading reduces prospective memory learning", "authors": "C Fellers; B C Storm", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42241083/", "doi": "10.1037/xlm0001630", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b2cbd2170fc2544af438f329f63f946bc245387b3c4355245fcc8e7dbf64f107" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d984013b32725c595e3b8efc51ee0138502f9446f8a764e70fa3dc0ee089b583" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0130", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/435439a", "title": "Cognitive psychology: rare items often missed in visual searches", "authors": "J. M. Wolfe; T. S. Horowitz; N. M. Kenner", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15917795/", "doi": "10.1038/435439a", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S007", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Cognitive psychology: rare items often missed in visual searches", "authors": "J. M. Wolfe; T. S. Horowitz; N. M. Kenner", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15917795/", "doi": "10.1038/435439a", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7381d395fdc4b0ad2b3a2883bc556bdf0212748a4dc0b71852ad6f0cf1469618" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "60d78b3b21a4116211d66a772504700219ec1bb577e5c295eb4dba0e7376cbdd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0131", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/nature08637", "title": "Preventing the return of fear in humans using reconsolidation update mechanisms", "authors": "Daniela Schiller; Marie-H. Monfils; Candace M. Raio; David C. Johnson; Joseph E. LeDoux; Elizabeth A. Phelps", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20010606/", "doi": "10.1038/nature08637", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S012", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Preventing the return of fear in humans using reconsolidation update mechanisms", "authors": "Daniela Schiller; Marie-H. Monfils; Candace M. Raio; David C. Johnson; Joseph E. LeDoux; Elizabeth A. Phelps", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20010606/", "doi": "10.1038/nature08637", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RECONSOLIDATION_HYPOTHESIS" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "945b5d3579781a1829cd7eeb9fc0adfafa41d7872886664e0b37e10ec23fdf7c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3f65112833cefc702d18151fb61bb1882b2c0e7df5eb5936f8eb8633d250838a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/nature09042", "title": "Putting brain training to the test", "authors": "Adrian M Owen; Adam Hampshire; Jessica A Grahn; Robert Stenton; Said Dajani; Alistair S Burns; Robert J Howard; Clive G Ballard", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20407435/", "doi": "10.1038/nature09042", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016", "F15-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13", "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S016", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Putting brain training to the test", "authors": "Adrian M Owen; Adam Hampshire; Jessica A Grahn; Robert Stenton; Said Dajani; Alistair S Burns; Robert J Howard; Clive G Ballard", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20407435/", "doi": "10.1038/nature09042", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9265cda5aa072f9cfe09ecd0fbf891d56a3415fcab06e6da12fc73cbe4e3d9f6" }, { "source_id": "F15-S016", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Putting brain training to the test", "authors": "Adrian M. Owen; Adam Hampshire; Jessica A. Grahn; Robert Stenton; Said Dajani; Alistair S. Burns; Robert J. Howard; Clive G. Ballard", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20407435/", "doi": "10.1038/nature09042", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINED_TASK_IMPROVEMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "872de3e7a0bb8641ed8b57674a8d60425b3bfc08aaa9606f7e0a20327263f933" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f04fb30e1f00c8f8bc8046669e34850767b4ce4f94e99ac6272b5e064f7c8330" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0133", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/nature11076", "title": "Reach and grasp by people with tetraplegia using a neurally controlled robotic arm", "authors": "Leigh R. Hochberg; Daniel Bacher; Beata Jarosiewicz; Nicolas Y. Masse; John D. Simeral; Joern Vogel; Sami Haddadin; Jie Liu; Sydney S. Cash; Patrick van der Smagt; John P. Donoghue", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/nature11076", "doi": "10.1038/nature11076", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S002", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Reach and grasp by people with tetraplegia using a neurally controlled robotic arm", "authors": "Leigh R. Hochberg; Daniel Bacher; Beata Jarosiewicz; Nicolas Y. Masse; John D. Simeral; Joern Vogel; Sami Haddadin; Jie Liu; Sydney S. Cash; Patrick van der Smagt; John P. Donoghue", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/nature11076", "doi": "10.1038/nature11076", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BRAIN_CONTROLLED_PROSTHESIS", "FUNCTIONAL_TASK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "652812033caa48f55d32f4a9cd840851095f0e4f7c94e509f4fc4f0236f8e7e0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7342f25c30915cac2e57855a9100dd214385adb5aafeb45fefd0de747dda35d2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0134", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41467-022-30073-5", "title": "Accuracy prompts are a replicable and generalizable approach for reducing the spread of misinformation", "authors": "Gordon Pennycook; David G. Rand", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30073-5", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-022-30073-5", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S005", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Accuracy prompts are a replicable and generalizable approach for reducing the spread of misinformation", "authors": "Gordon Pennycook; David G. Rand", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30073-5", "doi": "10.1038/s41467-022-30073-5", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BEHAVIORAL_INTENTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "REPLICATION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c9495d316790fa4c98d619f96efd99211d8076f884a9033149c038105d75e69e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bac3cfbadeffc084fb131157ea46873ebd8389e52514ab4f81b3dc2ff94e5031" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0135", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41558-023-01863-6", "title": "Community forest governance and synergies among carbon, biodiversity and livelihoods", "authors": "Harry W. Fischer; Ashwini Chhatre; Apurva Duddu; Nabin Pradhan; Arun Agrawal", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-023-01863-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41558-023-01863-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S008", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Community forest governance and synergies among carbon, biodiversity and livelihoods", "authors": "Harry W. Fischer; Ashwini Chhatre; Apurva Duddu; Nabin Pradhan; Arun Agrawal", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-023-01863-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41558-023-01863-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bbaf828a4919a64e2586723c6e80ac5c12f1315381759acfac578e7c12cd16a4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7b2797daf655bf443377724d36378f3c0cf11db82ff15d9e39fd99c6e36152ec" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0136", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41562-023-01729-z", "title": "Self-regulating arousal via pupil-based biofeedback", "authors": "Sarah Nadine Meissner; Marc Bächinger; Sanne Kikkert; Jenny Imhof; Silvia Missura; Manuel Carro Dominguez; Nicole Wenderoth", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37904022/", "doi": "10.1038/s41562-023-01729-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S004", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Self-regulating arousal via pupil-based biofeedback", "authors": "Sarah Nadine Meissner; Marc Bächinger; Sanne Kikkert; Jenny Imhof; Silvia Missura; Manuel Carro Dominguez; Nicole Wenderoth", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37904022/", "doi": "10.1038/s41562-023-01729-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "78195fd79d26ad097d7e51e014b2b6f6ac72c7d9db653efa5c77890dac5112f6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "43898485bec1ef90656d1ab6fc549f2485a8cbabc2a9edf3bc7b7175b3c80de7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0137", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41586-023-06377-x", "title": "A high-performance speech neuroprosthesis", "authors": "Francis R. Willett; Erin M. Kunz; Chaofei Fan; Donald T. Avansino; Guy H. Wilson; Eun Young Choi; Foram Kamdar; Matthew F. Glasser; Leigh R. Hochberg; Shaul Druckmann; Krishna V. Shenoy; Jaimie M. Henderson", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06377-x", "doi": "10.1038/s41586-023-06377-x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S001", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "A high-performance speech neuroprosthesis", "authors": "Francis R. Willett; Erin M. Kunz; Chaofei Fan; Donald T. Avansino; Guy H. Wilson; Eun Young Choi; Foram Kamdar; Matthew F. Glasser; Leigh R. Hochberg; Shaul Druckmann; Krishna V. Shenoy; Jaimie M. Henderson", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06377-x", "doi": "10.1038/s41586-023-06377-x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BRAIN_COMPUTER_COMMUNICATION", "DRIFT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "17aab7d53fa27b0baf13e168512b7eaf33fdb71638c75b8668871a20d6091b0f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "19525eaa2a1de7101deeb40e58663e790bd8d1f21c279c20fa352c1c7a163298" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0138", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41591-026-04414-6", "title": "Long-term independent use of an intracortical brain–computer interface for speech and cursor control", "authors": "Nicholas S. Card; Tyler Singer-Clark; Hamza Peracha; Carrina Iacobacci; Xianda Hou; Maitreyee Wairagkar; Zachery Fogg; Elena C. Offenberg; Leigh R. Hochberg; Sergey D. Stavisky; David M. Brandman", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-026-04414-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41591-026-04414-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S007", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Long-term independent use of an intracortical brain–computer interface for speech and cursor control", "authors": "Nicholas S. Card; Tyler Singer-Clark; Hamza Peracha; Carrina Iacobacci; Xianda Hou; Maitreyee Wairagkar; Zachery Fogg; Elena C. Offenberg; Leigh R. Hochberg; Sergey D. Stavisky; David M. Brandman", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-026-04414-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41591-026-04414-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CARE_PARTNER_SUPPORT", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0d0bf30be8cd2697f0a2cc436ec6466ad65e5a950ba9ff62ecb95d2454788427" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b6c68407a469a9293401e43c5a7c38719c3d1f9d45fe16d0eed60d2f20668e32" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0139", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-018-26929-w", "title": "Reward-enhanced encoding improves relearning of forgotten associations", "authors": "Ewa A. Miendlarzewska; Sara Ciucci; Carlo V. Cannistraci; Daphne Bavelier; Sophie Schwartz", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29867116/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-018-26929-w", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S011", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Reward-enhanced encoding improves relearning of forgotten associations", "authors": "Ewa A. Miendlarzewska; Sara Ciucci; Carlo V. Cannistraci; Daphne Bavelier; Sophie Schwartz", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29867116/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-018-26929-w", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "REACQUISITION", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9d6b1444668ee2c2f91888ec15c18c1217da3073889c3d905b8fb8d51cd1d98d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d383d2a6dde8fab72abe55baba253ae666171fc3760375af8bec8ce05028a573" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0140", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-018-26952-x", "title": "Home Use of a Neural-connected Sensory Prosthesis Provides the Functional and Psychosocial Experience of Having a Hand Again", "authors": "Emily L Graczyk; Linda Resnik; Matthew A Schiefer; Melissa S Schmitt; Dustin J Tyler", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29959334/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-018-26952-x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S009", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Home Use of a Neural-connected Sensory Prosthesis Provides the Functional and Psychosocial Experience of Having a Hand Again", "authors": "Emily L Graczyk; Linda Resnik; Matthew A Schiefer; Melissa S Schmitt; Dustin J Tyler", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29959334/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-018-26952-x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EMBODIMENT", "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "50f5b73efcf68f716f1997df0a4869815ad3d79ce348de8fdf150ecdb597a5ef" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cb92b91008f707f76d9e2c4d43d4387d791245a6346aca7066782dfb1fe815b9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0141", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-018-31169-z", "title": "Fluoxetine does not enhance the effect of perceptual learning on visual function in adults with amblyopia", "authors": "H. J. Huttunen; J. M. Palva; L. Lindberg; S. Palva; V. Saarela; E. Karvonen; M.-L. Latvala; J. Liinamaa; S. Booms; E. Castrén; H. Uusitalo", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30150750/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-018-31169-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S004", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Fluoxetine does not enhance the effect of perceptual learning on visual function in adults with amblyopia", "authors": "H. J. Huttunen; J. M. Palva; L. Lindberg; S. Palva; V. Saarela; E. Karvonen; M.-L. Latvala; J. Liinamaa; S. Booms; E. Castrén; H. Uusitalo", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30150750/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-018-31169-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8fa001faca198ed30b456ef61562140e42669c64bb173f22526a122c86620ec0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "16f5c8a4b0a314cbf60d796987d3a95dbf110707b7cf24b8bcc377293fabef42" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0142", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-019-44267-3", "title": "Interactions between egocentric and allocentric spatial coding of sounds revealed by a multisensory learning paradigm", "authors": "G. Rabini; E. Altobelli; F. Pavani", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31133688/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-019-44267-3", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S003", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Interactions between egocentric and allocentric spatial coding of sounds revealed by a multisensory learning paradigm", "authors": "G. Rabini; E. Altobelli; F. Pavani", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31133688/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-019-44267-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b710294ed43ad95ae67f80b12c9b996e41b74d3ec1fb6acc343e217947310f39" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "80fb52a65df8f85fc53f16b195ebbcf008cc337bc20945e3c071474153ac8bec" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0143", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-020-65670-1", "title": "Physiological and Behavioral Synchrony Predict Group Cohesion and Performance", "authors": "Ilanit Gordon; Avi Gilboa; Shai Cohen; Nir Milstein; Nir Haimovich; Shay Pinhasi; Shahar Siegman", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32439861/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-020-65670-1", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S014", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Physiological and Behavioral Synchrony Predict Group Cohesion and Performance", "authors": "Ilanit Gordon; Avi Gilboa; Shai Cohen; Nir Milstein; Nir Haimovich; Shay Pinhasi; Shahar Siegman", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32439861/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-020-65670-1", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "GROUP_EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PHYSIOLOGICAL_SYNCHRONY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "603539f1c38c8477e231dfe4c82b46329ab9ff5298a127a346f749174b013d5e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "07f4d4795909d5a789f3ed235c7904099d37d7322c21d5f015941b6b55b7b592" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0144", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-020-71894-y", "title": "Aging and haptic shape discrimination: the effects of variations in size", "authors": "J. F. Norman; J. M. Dukes; T. N. Palmore", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32895441/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-020-71894-y", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S005", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Aging and haptic shape discrimination: the effects of variations in size", "authors": "J. F. Norman; J. M. Dukes; T. N. Palmore", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32895441/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-020-71894-y", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bcf870398aa60e8122faec8cb2535b71ac0d73347417f5f6942c7c412cd1b74e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "75f6b5d2ab324713b297ea7278edb0734bac5b37c6660dbc3bec2db97a10c921" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0145", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-022-11518-9", "title": "Delegation to artificial agents fosters prosocial behaviors in the collective risk dilemma", "authors": "Elias Fernández Domingos; Inês Terrucha; Rémi Suchon; Jelena Grujić; Juan C. Burguillo; Francisco C. Santos; Tom Lenaerts", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-11518-9", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-022-11518-9", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S010", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Delegation to artificial agents fosters prosocial behaviors in the collective risk dilemma", "authors": "Elias Fernández Domingos; Inês Terrucha; Rémi Suchon; Jelena Grujić; Juan C. Burguillo; Francisco C. Santos; Tom Lenaerts", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-11518-9", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-022-11518-9", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DELEGATION", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "INEQUALITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESPONSIBILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "982349aa569216b668e954a77c53db8d9c3c0df42fce84cad89cf5909992b9e8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "316dde9c60cc84ba88c84ca45617ec236fb56b2ae53449f2a59dea05fe61105a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0146", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-022-15858-4", "title": "Cognitive map formation through tactile map navigation in visually impaired and sighted persons", "authors": "Lianne Ottink; Boudewijn van Raalte; Christian F Doeller; Thea M Van der Geest; Richard J A Van Wezel", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35798929/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-022-15858-4", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S014", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Cognitive map formation through tactile map navigation in visually impaired and sighted persons", "authors": "Lianne Ottink; Boudewijn van Raalte; Christian F Doeller; Thea M Van der Geest; Richard J A Van Wezel", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35798929/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-022-15858-4", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cd47a6ed358ad4ec82fdb1d1af3c6f41a4af7dd26ecb8d3588ffceca7d4a4e43" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7c751c83ec89533dce77d004da949655f13a6e7f036cc7857746ae192c5ddc24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0147", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-022-18255-z", "title": "Improving taste sensitivity in healthy adults using taste recall training: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Y. Otsubo; M. Miyagi; H. Sekiya; O. Kano; S. Ebihara", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35974039/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-022-18255-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S018" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S018", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Improving taste sensitivity in healthy adults using taste recall training: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Y. Otsubo; M. Miyagi; H. Sekiya; O. Kano; S. Ebihara", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35974039/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-022-18255-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1efcb35ed1511b88981e00b8bb9a867be01fe6bf7490d309b93e159efd911aee" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cc84b186f4ee9347eaf968f56a4e7a463bb1e5013cc1e698aa49677d9fd5a24e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0148", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-023-42384-8", "title": "Humans inherit artificial intelligence biases", "authors": "Lucía Vicente; Helena Matute", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37789032/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-023-42384-8", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S009", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Humans inherit artificial intelligence biases", "authors": "Lucía Vicente; Helena Matute", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37789032/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-023-42384-8", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BIAS_TRANSFER", "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "832133ffda2a3c27698ad1145a7d0c25e2e5064519adef66791b56be4ec4259d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d9e5c22e704c697c519781972b82fe57249f3d92719156cbcd52fe7b2d94695e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0149", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-024-60220-5", "title": "Explainability does not mitigate the negative impact of incorrect AI advice in a personnel selection task", "authors": "Julia Cecil; Eva Lermer; Matthias F. C. Hudecek; Jan Sauer; Susanne Gaube", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38679619/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-024-60220-5", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S007", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Explainability does not mitigate the negative impact of incorrect AI advice in a personnel selection task", "authors": "Julia Cecil; Eva Lermer; Matthias F. C. Hudecek; Jan Sauer; Susanne Gaube", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38679619/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-024-60220-5", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXPLANATION_NULL", "HIGH_IMPACT_BOUNDARY", "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "61a1ec88d5c7a441f487db6e2f2a9131191a90f460e07f8445d53db350b42361" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0369578c666745cc52ddd73a3ab0eb7b75baa71aaf5881665cf98583d2e821c6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0150", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-024-82501-9", "title": "Explainable AI improves task performance in human-AI collaboration", "authors": "Julian Senoner; Simon Schallmoser; Bernhard Kratzwald; Stefan Feuerriegel; Torbjørn Netland", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39730794/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-024-82501-9", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S012", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Explainable AI improves task performance in human-AI collaboration", "authors": "Julian Senoner; Simon Schallmoser; Bernhard Kratzwald; Stefan Feuerriegel; Torbjørn Netland", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39730794/", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-024-82501-9", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ASSISTED_PERCEPTION", "EXPERT_CONFIGURATION", "EXPLANATION_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b5f397f186e2930836c14510cb56c60364594af7046fedcb69d578966e22213f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3106d7ce2d10127a00a558a3a71a34b094a70a44973effca2eafb7f2d887f88b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0151", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-025-28134-y", "title": "Introducing the fusion innovation test as a new paradigm for studying realworld creative problem solving", "authors": "Wu CT; Kern FB; Su YS; Street M; Chao ZC", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41436751", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-025-28134-y", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S008", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Introducing the fusion innovation test as a new paradigm for studying realworld creative problem solving", "authors": "Wu CT; Kern FB; Su YS; Street M; Chao ZC", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41436751", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-025-28134-y", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONSTRUCT_VALIDITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d6f9d1aa5c2543520a19aa14a5effaec901338f674d55ba99641ec9f812118f9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "abf2c25d9f2471eb10432bd965df7a00a714cff91491cd2a83985cff8ddff54b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0152", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6", "title": "AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting", "authors": "Greg Kestin; Kelly Miller; Anna Klales; Timothy Milbourne; Gregorio Ponti", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S005", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting", "authors": "Greg Kestin; Kelly Miller; Anna Klales; Timothy Milbourne; Gregorio Ponti", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-025-97652-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACTIVE_BASELINE", "CONFIGURATION_DEPENDENCE", "LEARNING", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a16101cf62f2312941427312adfbcee793346866cde98fe3c7fc696a61c754f3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c0f948cd4f5dcf44de0b7cb2eb6a8a93619332020d62be35f97ea8b56a2f6570" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0153", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-026-37578-9", "title": "Efficacy of electronic travel aids for the blind and visually impaired during wayfinding", "authors": "C. E. Pittet; E. Villar Ortega; M. Fabien; M. T. Wallace; M. Gori; M. M. Murray", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-37578-9", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-026-37578-9", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S021" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S021", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Efficacy of electronic travel aids for the blind and visually impaired during wayfinding", "authors": "C. E. Pittet; E. Villar Ortega; M. Fabien; M. T. Wallace; M. Gori; M. M. Murray", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-37578-9", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-026-37578-9", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DEVICE_COMPARISON", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d4a59082177f297ce20e86449af0ea86892e86e0dfaffffffebedaf76b515294" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5890f4f2c66b36458592df8b48c80feb5c96c251273d03be4d04d251c5a033db" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0154", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s41598-026-42312-6", "title": "Relying on AI at work reduces self-efficacy, ownership, and meaning while active collaboration mitigates the effects", "authors": "Elena Hayoung Lee; Yidan Yin; Nan Jia; Cheryl J. Wakslak", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-42312-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-026-42312-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S011", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Relying on AI at work reduces self-efficacy, ownership, and meaning while active collaboration mitigates the effects", "authors": "Elena Hayoung Lee; Yidan Yin; Nan Jia; Cheryl J. Wakslak", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-42312-6", "doi": "10.1038/s41598-026-42312-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION", "DESKILLING_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP", "SELF_EFFICACY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "021a2ce38c4ac14787f39576fb23633a5ba3a254c8feb4d3f7d285b98acecc38" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5ba894a6e3d0b12db170c565a69726a93114320a5b487a0a2ef1f622f22cf801" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0155", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s42003-023-05522-6", "title": "Multisensory input modulates memory-guided spatial navigation in humans", "authors": "Deetje Iggena; Seung-Hyun Jeung; Pauline M Maier; Christoph J Ploner; Klaus Gramann; Carsten Finke", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37963986/", "doi": "10.1038/s42003-023-05522-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S013", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Multisensory input modulates memory-guided spatial navigation in humans", "authors": "Deetje Iggena; Seung-Hyun Jeung; Pauline M Maier; Christoph J Ploner; Klaus Gramann; Carsten Finke", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37963986/", "doi": "10.1038/s42003-023-05522-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9840e29245eb1816bd7f3823130078eb70e6b2dde01c9cb3bd56b56874b243f7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4dbdf2c241005875ac5469aebfdec704016fc4c08197c0aa2e8aac3ae9d88a6e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0156", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1038/s44271-025-00342-2", "title": "High-quality listening behaviors linked to social connection between strangers", "authors": "Taylor N. West; Sara Huston; Kylie R. Chandler; Jieni Zhou; Barbara L. Fredrickson", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41272285/", "doi": "10.1038/s44271-025-00342-2", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S001", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "High-quality listening behaviors linked to social connection between strangers", "authors": "Taylor N. West; Sara Huston; Kylie R. Chandler; Jieni Zhou; Barbara L. Fredrickson", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41272285/", "doi": "10.1038/s44271-025-00342-2", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d79cc27a00e6601577767f490d208b8952d7c8216db1bd659a8cfc4f8546c472" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "489f9b9d7a5b32c4446a9a6d0c491c38f2b28173d131c6d493b37416fb77296e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0157", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1044/2015_aja-14-0064", "title": "Comparison of Performance of Older Adults on Two Tests of Temporal Resolution", "authors": "R. Vaidyanath; A. Yathiraj", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25652341/", "doi": "10.1044/2015_AJA-14-0064", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S015", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Comparison of Performance of Older Adults on Two Tests of Temporal Resolution", "authors": "R. Vaidyanath; A. Yathiraj", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25652341/", "doi": "10.1044/2015_AJA-14-0064", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1b7f8145dee5fe29f68fc7a31edae2be19fb7a6973aabb51dcdb227eb72632d5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8b473fdc1b2e3814eb167d72672ea662e1619b7a7db74e28c1a65e204fc74db3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0158", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1056/nejm199406233302501", "title": "Exercise training and nutritional supplementation for physical frailty in very elderly people", "authors": "Maria A. Fiatarone; Evelyn F. O'Neill; Nancy Doyle Ryan; Karen M. Clements; Guido R. Solares; Miriam E. Nelson; Susan B. Roberts; Joseph J. Kehayias; Lewis A. Lipsitz; William J. Evans", "year": 1994, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199406233302501", "doi": "10.1056/NEJM199406233302501", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S009", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Exercise training and nutritional supplementation for physical frailty in very elderly people", "authors": "Maria A. Fiatarone; Evelyn F. O'Neill; Nancy Doyle Ryan; Karen M. Clements; Guido R. Solares; Miriam E. Nelson; Susan B. Roberts; Joseph J. Kehayias; Lewis A. Lipsitz; William J. Evans", "year": 1994, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199406233302501", "doi": "10.1056/NEJM199406233302501", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9180d29b6ac0001788bbb5048eeab9cc240cb84cd80273381f3ffe0849db67b4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4ad52409f90557618343cc1d9db6290963d00a637b47854615efb546513aba5b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0159", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1056/nejmoa1917537", "title": "Self-Contained Neuromusculoskeletal Arm Prostheses", "authors": "Max Ortiz-Catalan; Enzo Mastinu; Paolo Sassu; Oskar Aszmann; Rickard Brånemark", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1917537", "doi": "10.1056/NEJMoa1917537", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S006", "F27-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26", "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S006", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Self-Contained Neuromusculoskeletal Arm Prostheses", "authors": "Max Ortiz-Catalan; Enzo Mastinu; Paolo Sassu; Oskar Aszmann; Rickard Brånemark", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1917537", "doi": "10.1056/NEJMoa1917537", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CORRECTED_RECORD", "HOME_USE", "IMPLANT_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PROSTHETIC_CONTROL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "35525c08ae0f8e44075ce453e2f63da8fc74a5020cd20d82591b46443d7f9553" }, { "source_id": "F27-S008", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Self-Contained Neuromusculoskeletal Arm Prostheses", "authors": "Max Ortiz-Catalan; Enzo Mastinu; Paolo Sassu; Oskar Aszmann; Rickard Brånemark", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1917537", "doi": "10.1056/NEJMoa1917537", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BIOHYBRID_INTERFACE", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERIOUS_ADVERSE_EVENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "13bde9ae02c90bcc5a49bbfdb2a7e6f1c8be5dae9b19a977549eff7527afd129" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "709f86d89cfe6af6b9ceb28e386baae55b2ae96a1088f0d70f5c2cb87443854a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0160", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1068/p6399", "title": "Rubber hand illusions and size-weight illusions: self-representation modulates representation of external objects", "authors": "Patrick Haggard; Shyma Jundi", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20192129/", "doi": "10.1068/p6399", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S012", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Rubber hand illusions and size-weight illusions: self-representation modulates representation of external objects", "authors": "Patrick Haggard; Shyma Jundi", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20192129/", "doi": "10.1068/p6399", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f1c23385d5960ecbae83d4d41e42f092275f99a16840f62b91b295db6d06999f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "16a3e90eea371f0f818d4decc793ad6365b030baae3c34b1575290ff6621b6ff" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0161", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.0401200101", "title": "Improving vision in adult amblyopia by perceptual learning", "authors": "U. Polat; T. Ma-Naim; M. Belkin; D. Sagi", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15096608/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.0401200101", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S001", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Improving vision in adult amblyopia by perceptual learning", "authors": "U. Polat; T. Ma-Naim; M. Belkin; D. Sagi", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15096608/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.0401200101", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c54213ce12c8c8c6156b1a484f07f0a047a07a98031caac5ff7031ff3e522f96" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e63623ca751bcca30794452047f241e529b0811d5481cba32c5fb1c4190515ec" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0162", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.1016507108", "title": "How simple rules determine pedestrian behavior and crowd disasters", "authors": "Mehdi Moussaïd; Dirk Helbing; Guy Theraulaz", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21502518/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1016507108", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S011", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "How simple rules determine pedestrian behavior and crowd disasters", "authors": "Mehdi Moussaïd; Dirk Helbing; Guy Theraulaz", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21502518/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1016507108", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY_BOUNDARY", "SYSTEM_MODEL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8ab44c13392627ff0c93ada34eb127649331ae15ce104e35f99ee36abad65db8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "64ffcc15b937c6fc5db618a02ec73f3ea5b3367c76f155d7ef793c0f20d78ca2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0163", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.1105183108", "title": "Recovery of stereopsis through perceptual learning in human adults with abnormal binocular vision", "authors": "J. Ding; D. M. Levi", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21896742/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1105183108", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S010", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Recovery of stereopsis through perceptual learning in human adults with abnormal binocular vision", "authors": "J. Ding; D. M. Levi", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21896742/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1105183108", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3a70b267b91d5c34739859f1202ed97d78d292059468d820b1a5ab2820b25c8e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8fdca3e955cd0b20dbb4eb2b2efeaa3cfa93ed949ed770fb77bb5e52c13a1785" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0164", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.1200155109", "title": "Facial expressions of emotion are not culturally universal", "authors": "Rachael E. Jack; Oliver G. B. Garrod; Hui Yu; Roberto Caldara; Philippe G. Schyns", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22509011/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1200155109", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S015", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Facial expressions of emotion are not culturally universal", "authors": "Rachael E. Jack; Oliver G. B. Garrod; Hui Yu; Roberto Caldara; Philippe G. Schyns", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22509011/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1200155109", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3887b027ed02681aafd3f72ac3435bc0736fb8d790e87e848c6922471202a8b8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "48f70f05ea77645932be78684c149383695737657b310eb85912b6bba9e6f2fe" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0165", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.1322174111", "title": "Voluntary activation of the sympathetic nervous system and attenuation of the innate immune response in humans", "authors": "Matthijs Kox; Lucas T van Eijk; Jelle Zwaag; Joanne van den Wildenberg; Fred C G J Sweep; Johannes G van der Hoeven; Peter Pickkers", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24799686/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1322174111", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S001", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Voluntary activation of the sympathetic nervous system and attenuation of the innate immune response in humans", "authors": "Matthijs Kox; Lucas T van Eijk; Jelle Zwaag; Joanne van den Wildenberg; Fred C G J Sweep; Johannes G van der Hoeven; Peter Pickkers", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24799686/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1322174111", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d66b4ac691cb59b7f506e0b230c2cbc56d624e430c8b70afc4b2d37cb3d6f2f7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e312626105ae8d0d4ab912ab9bf085ac9e9871055c763a9f38527af9813179f4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0166", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.1913678117", "title": "The effects of communicating uncertainty on public trust in facts and numbers", "authors": "Anne Marthe van der Bles; Sander van der Linden; Alexandra L. J. Freeman; David J. Spiegelhalter", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1913678117", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1913678117", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S010", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "The effects of communicating uncertainty on public trust in facts and numbers", "authors": "Anne Marthe van der Bles; Sander van der Linden; Alexandra L. J. Freeman; David J. Spiegelhalter", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1913678117", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.1913678117", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMMUNICATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "766442c72f39f4ebb2ea01dc38081004ee480060b9bbe524f02a511d6e349b83" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cbec198576cae4cdbc7e8c3aecd2f2207ffa3285fc4dbf15bab7cde791977b46" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0167", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.2015172118", "title": "Can community monitoring save the commons? Evidence on forest use and displacement", "authors": "Sabrina Eisenbarth; Louis Graham; Anouk S. Rigterink", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8307456/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2015172118", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S004", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Can community monitoring save the commons? Evidence on forest use and displacement", "authors": "Sabrina Eisenbarth; Louis Graham; Anouk S. Rigterink", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8307456/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2015172118", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "10d8a962ed8c4bae4b263f2dc799ec3f976e1a0f8f6a81c5c5e49692fb7f6b5c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4394ea132a3570eb17b8e79d52998b42c26b8f838624f1e5bcd03d5d1f65397c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0168", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.2015367118", "title": "Adoption of community monitoring improves common pool resource management across contexts", "authors": "Tara Slough; Daniel Rubenson; Ro’ee Levy; Francisco Alpizar Rodriguez; María Bernedo del Carpio; Mark T. Buntaine; Darin Christensen; Alicia Cooperman; Sabrina Eisenbarth; Paul J. Ferraro; Louis Graham; Alexandra C. Hartman; Jacob Kopas; Sasha McLarty; Anouk S. Rigterink; Cyrus Samii; Brigitte Seim; Johannes Urpelainen; Bing Zhang", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34253604/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2015367118", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S003", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Adoption of community monitoring improves common pool resource management across contexts", "authors": "Tara Slough; Daniel Rubenson; Ro’ee Levy; Francisco Alpizar Rodriguez; María Bernedo del Carpio; Mark T. Buntaine; Darin Christensen; Alicia Cooperman; Sabrina Eisenbarth; Paul J. Ferraro; Louis Graham; Alexandra C. Hartman; Jacob Kopas; Sasha McLarty; Anouk S. Rigterink; Cyrus Samii; Brigitte Seim; Johannes Urpelainen; Bing Zhang", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34253604/", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2015367118", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4c66e1a46233d46a69d808ed129839f7fdfec0449453b1b658fb20d8030021ae" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b4a8904aa08b74c793c5a1af6291d07f27e0876097dc38f79bdc8faa2023b1c2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0169", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1073/pnas.2104235118", "title": "The global effectiveness of fact-checking: Evidence from simultaneous experiments in Argentina, Nigeria, South Africa, and the United Kingdom", "authors": "Ethan Porter; Thomas J. Wood", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2104235118", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2104235118", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S012", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "The global effectiveness of fact-checking: Evidence from simultaneous experiments in Argentina, Nigeria, South Africa, and the United Kingdom", "authors": "Ethan Porter; Thomas J. Wood", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2104235118", "doi": "10.1073/pnas.2104235118", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BELIEF_UPDATE", "CROSS_CULTURAL", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1615d5b6fccb2d1ad6f3f4c1df49ed2aca5b1bc1731669dc5376c0effac2530e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a77245cfb2f54e63d7044d613d59c3023d16e7028c87384b526fd2ddeee52d7f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0170", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/00140139.2023.2300954", "title": "How to walk to reduce footstep noise in multi-story residential buildings", "authors": "Woojin Yoon; Yujin Kwon; Jaehyun Yoon; Seobin Choi; Gwanseob Shin", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38186284/", "doi": "10.1080/00140139.2023.2300954", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S011", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "How to walk to reduce footstep noise in multi-story residential buildings", "authors": "Woojin Yoon; Yujin Kwon; Jaehyun Yoon; Seobin Choi; Gwanseob Shin", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38186284/", "doi": "10.1080/00140139.2023.2300954", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1fdbed2b1996be9954604c457e1d3ce327167a113212e2ed999bf4523d578274" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "339a8c84558b69dea136fc87e01a5668f428cadd42a9c88beb60eba852e460b0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0171", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/00393541.1987.11650560", "title": "Efficacy of Edwards' Cognitive Shift Approach to Art Education", "authors": "C A Chambliss; A J Hartl", "year": 1987, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/00393541.1987.11650560", "doi": "10.1080/00393541.1987.11650560", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S015", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Efficacy of Edwards' Cognitive Shift Approach to Art Education", "authors": "C A Chambliss; A J Hartl", "year": 1987, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/00393541.1987.11650560", "doi": "10.1080/00393541.1987.11650560", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "38199506abadc9bb37b0b710480a97a105452c78586d4ca5298b966967d41ef8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a1dc604f79bd77367af7c0157c24d372d28e8dcbf2c38fe223dbcc88d1d4ab9b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0172", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/026404102760000053", "title": "Effects of inspiratory muscle training on time-trial performance in trained cyclists", "authors": "Lee M. Romer; Alison K. McConnell; David A. Jones", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12166881/", "doi": "10.1080/026404102760000053", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S005", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Effects of inspiratory muscle training on time-trial performance in trained cyclists", "authors": "Lee M. Romer; Alison K. McConnell; David A. Jones", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12166881/", "doi": "10.1080/026404102760000053", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "04b666e00848e4501ea92b23ef8126e546f7a436e8d94a0f78a332960d33ba51" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fe1ae5b75387db9559f00e3a2cffe2ff50f4d25b91e0799b3b2022c2a69809b8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0173", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/02640410802287055", "title": "Effects of active and passive recovery on performance during repeated-sprint swimming", "authors": "Argyris G. Toubekis; Michael C. Peyrebrune; Henryk K. A. Lakomy; Mary E. Nevill", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18979341/", "doi": "10.1080/02640410802287055", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S014", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Effects of active and passive recovery on performance during repeated-sprint swimming", "authors": "Argyris G. Toubekis; Michael C. Peyrebrune; Henryk K. A. Lakomy; Mary E. Nevill", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18979341/", "doi": "10.1080/02640410802287055", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTORY_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "faf8252537ec68ecafc26e4b4934181a15dc425c7298e28776b5c63e4726e636" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ba97aa18fdeb684b145e8b395ed0b64b2e733b5efa3c4098f012073fd0485bb4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0174", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/02640414.2016.1227466", "title": "Running quietly reduces ground reaction force and vertical loading rate and alters foot strike technique", "authors": "Xuan Phan; Tiffany L Grisbrook; Kevin Wernli; Sarah M Stearne; Paul Davey; Leo Ng", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27594087/", "doi": "10.1080/02640414.2016.1227466", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S012", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Running quietly reduces ground reaction force and vertical loading rate and alters foot strike technique", "authors": "Xuan Phan; Tiffany L Grisbrook; Kevin Wernli; Sarah M Stearne; Paul Davey; Leo Ng", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27594087/", "doi": "10.1080/02640414.2016.1227466", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "61c5d2cca535a47c4ae80d9c46d1122346c5f62624a861963ca00c6c5d0246be" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "52d1d8ce5508d3719290e1026580dc97743b2d0e787f11ba4dfa42e61a90ae9c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0175", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/08824090903526638", "title": "Assessing Deception Detection Accuracy with Dichotomous Truth–Lie Judgments and Continuous Scaling: Are People Really More Accurate When Honesty Is Scaled?", "authors": "Timothy R. Levine; Allison S. Shaw; Hillary Shulman", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08824090903526638", "doi": "10.1080/08824090903526638", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S016", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Assessing Deception Detection Accuracy with Dichotomous Truth–Lie Judgments and Continuous Scaling: Are People Really More Accurate When Honesty Is Scaled?", "authors": "Timothy R. Levine; Allison S. Shaw; Hillary Shulman", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08824090903526638", "doi": "10.1080/08824090903526638", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "eec0c511dd57b5353e9189c6deda39668fa2ed40be25afaca545716d4d46ef88" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e06f921c506727fb04aaf8c6e8293cfc1024ca579492dfd7101633272e51314d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0176", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/08870446.2018.1456660", "title": "Effectiveness of a smartphone-based worry-reduction training for stress reduction: A randomized-controlled trial", "authors": "A Versluis; B Verkuil; P Spinhoven; J F Brosschot", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29609475/", "doi": "10.1080/08870446.2018.1456660", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S009", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Effectiveness of a smartphone-based worry-reduction training for stress reduction: A randomized-controlled trial", "authors": "A Versluis; B Verkuil; P Spinhoven; J F Brosschot", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29609475/", "doi": "10.1080/08870446.2018.1456660", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2c6e2de865bd11069b588b5c703fe420038dbe8880b1b233140bb5512bf50b29" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fdc32553a913cb97f5c53e5e78f07da4f8c9cd5074be13e902ac99c08c864d9d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0177", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/09602011.2016.1208617", "title": "Rehabilitation of visuospatial neglect by prism adaptation: effects of a mild treatment regime. A randomised controlled trial", "authors": "N. Vaes; G. Nys; C. Lafosse; L. Dereymaeker; K. Oostra; D. Hemelsoet; G. Vingerhoets", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27425388/", "doi": "10.1080/09602011.2016.1208617", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S014", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Rehabilitation of visuospatial neglect by prism adaptation: effects of a mild treatment regime. A randomised controlled trial", "authors": "N. Vaes; G. Nys; C. Lafosse; L. Dereymaeker; K. Oostra; D. Hemelsoet; G. Vingerhoets", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27425388/", "doi": "10.1080/09602011.2016.1208617", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a5ec54d2e677fdb0956bbb54d90db1aacfeb7c8246bedae54bab6f057b7d0f82" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e37f3fc3e57ebaf31ef877c288d4f183f64bd9d469d221b6a1271ffd2e07f438" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0178", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/09602011.2018.1447973", "title": "Evaluation of NeuroPage as a memory aid for people with multiple sclerosis: A randomised controlled trial", "authors": "R A Goodwin; N B Lincoln; R das Nair; A Bateman", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29557731/", "doi": "10.1080/09602011.2018.1447973", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S009", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Evaluation of NeuroPage as a memory aid for people with multiple sclerosis: A randomised controlled trial", "authors": "R A Goodwin; N B Lincoln; R das Nair; A Bateman", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29557731/", "doi": "10.1080/09602011.2018.1447973", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5294c9f77d96cca43c0bd7f0e926e70400f9bfc0cbf34ea071580984afa09bcf" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bb18df9183858332eace7f06d031a95268168e5ed03ca1f8e97ae9955492481e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0179", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/09658211.2023.2198263", "title": "Lost in the mall again: a preregistered replication and extension of Loftus & Pickrell (1995)", "authors": "Gillian Murphy; Caroline A. Dawson; Charlotte Huston; Lisa Ballantyne; Elizabeth Barrett; Conor S. Cowman; Christopher Fitzsimons; Julie Maher; Katie M. Ryan; Ciara M. Greene", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37312574/", "doi": "10.1080/09658211.2023.2198263", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S014", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Lost in the mall again: a preregistered replication and extension of Loftus & Pickrell (1995)", "authors": "Gillian Murphy; Caroline A. Dawson; Charlotte Huston; Lisa Ballantyne; Elizabeth Barrett; Conor S. Cowman; Christopher Fitzsimons; Julie Maher; Katie M. Ryan; Ciara M. Greene", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37312574/", "doi": "10.1080/09658211.2023.2198263", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "INFORMATION_HARM", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ee1af3f7db3a27607834ad4aee0309952ffb460f0e083a6a6e83edcf0f0b09b7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "77c8041549d1b4c4e644bbe98f0953204cc8e4807a4cb9eab405b92acaf48db8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0180", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/10447318.2025.2487861", "title": "Calibrating Reliance on Automated Advice: Transparency and Trust Calibration Feedback", "authors": "Monica Tatasciore; Shayne Loft", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/10447318.2025.2487861", "doi": "10.1080/10447318.2025.2487861", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S006", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Calibrating Reliance on Automated Advice: Transparency and Trust Calibration Feedback", "authors": "Monica Tatasciore; Shayne Loft", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/10447318.2025.2487861", "doi": "10.1080/10447318.2025.2487861", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "HUMAN_AI_CONFIGURATION", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cd536075254af4fd326ebcbf55373038657bde26099398aaebd162441c5d4cfc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "21e5e2e297f8bd7883d5c536c13e761c7356bea567b136b67eefef5c87fc7ca1" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0181", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/10615806.2021.1929934", "title": "The impact of emotion regulation therapy on emotion differentiation in psychologically distressed caregivers of cancer patients", "authors": "M B Mikkelsen; E Elkjær; D S Mennin; D M Fresco; R Zachariae; A Applebaum; M S O'Toole", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34047220/", "doi": "10.1080/10615806.2021.1929934", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S003", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "The impact of emotion regulation therapy on emotion differentiation in psychologically distressed caregivers of cancer patients", "authors": "M B Mikkelsen; E Elkjær; D S Mennin; D M Fresco; R Zachariae; A Applebaum; M S O'Toole", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34047220/", "doi": "10.1080/10615806.2021.1929934", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "44a2d2f417ddb63cd30c5feb62190095f5c2ee861cab2af225183239bdceec5c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b954baafdaac16725a8b5ace34396dd61e13027080f18925dd249d9822ac7ec6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0182", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/10904018.2013.813234", "title": "The Relative Effectiveness of Active Listening in Initial Interactions", "authors": "Harry Weger; Gina Castle Bell; Elizabeth M. Minei; Melissa C. Robinson", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10904018.2013.813234", "doi": "10.1080/10904018.2013.813234", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S011", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "The Relative Effectiveness of Active Listening in Initial Interactions", "authors": "Harry Weger; Gina Castle Bell; Elizabeth M. Minei; Melissa C. Robinson", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10904018.2013.813234", "doi": "10.1080/10904018.2013.813234", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "059cf595043aa6706604b2b9427ce519601710f1419f8e8005d8ac647886ec81" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "738bb0568176f1aa2aa48bcad10ffe84454fb4386f2bd0df7555c5c1704b263e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0183", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/13645706.2017.1319866", "title": "Lack of transfer of skills after virtual reality simulator training with haptic feedback", "authors": "C Våpenstad; E F Hofstad; L E Bø; E Kuhry; G Johnsen; R Mårvik; T Langø; T N Hernes", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28486087/", "doi": "10.1080/13645706.2017.1319866", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S002", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Lack of transfer of skills after virtual reality simulator training with haptic feedback", "authors": "C Våpenstad; E F Hofstad; L E Bø; E Kuhry; G Johnsen; R Mårvik; T Langø; T N Hernes", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28486087/", "doi": "10.1080/13645706.2017.1319866", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a4a2f986223f43bf29dce6dea76d659f0895c169fa5d96ffca51b0533b2f9314" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cfeed57510baef5041080502427c313d04bed89be4c505340ba9ff64ce354554" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0184", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/13825585.2023.2271531", "title": "Teaching older adults to use retrieval practice improves their self-regulated learning", "authors": "Robert Ariel; Addison Babineau; Sarah K. Tauber", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37847784/", "doi": "10.1080/13825585.2023.2271531", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S015", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Teaching older adults to use retrieval practice improves their self-regulated learning", "authors": "Robert Ariel; Addison Babineau; Sarah K. Tauber", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37847784/", "doi": "10.1080/13825585.2023.2271531", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SELF_REGULATION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6675fe80e2fce2364e2b30564e7f0b7a4f5cbcef5369159186ab32d9532d5692" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e9c8eea9664e3ff9ae07b5db67e7323e900731f3d3353c313c0a2ec1fe30688e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0185", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/13825585.2024.2414855", "title": "Enhancing creative divergent thinking in older adults with a semantic retrieval strategy", "authors": "Dubec L; Gerver CR; Dennis NA; Beaty RE", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39415729", "doi": "10.1080/13825585.2024.2414855", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S007", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Enhancing creative divergent thinking in older adults with a semantic retrieval strategy", "authors": "Dubec L; Gerver CR; Dennis NA; Beaty RE", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39415729", "doi": "10.1080/13825585.2024.2414855", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e801a3d776f9c412837a4bfed3758a4c99c7baeaf4358e1e2a98f64e141f1909" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "958c7eb8c0383140f5059feecefa453e3df12ce2aabf164b480c4f6ee09d34df" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0186", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/15534510.2012.658653", "title": "Synchrony and destructive obedience", "authors": "Scott Wiltermuth", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15534510.2012.658653", "doi": "10.1080/15534510.2012.658653", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S006", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Synchrony and destructive obedience", "authors": "Scott Wiltermuth", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15534510.2012.658653", "doi": "10.1080/15534510.2012.658653", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cdd1a59f9f406469a27c5f2cf6ca0d74231ad6231eb66bd594173a7cf109ea16" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "32d3bafb644fb95bda094b463828161fc967765bf8584b91befc556b5549d722" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0187", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/17439760902992456", "title": "Executive coaching enhances goal attainment, resilience and workplace well-being: a randomised controlled study", "authors": "Anthony M. Grant; Linley Curtayne; Geraldine Burton", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17439760902992456", "doi": "10.1080/17439760902992456", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S013", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Executive coaching enhances goal attainment, resilience and workplace well-being: a randomised controlled study", "authors": "Anthony M. Grant; Linley Curtayne; Geraldine Burton", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17439760902992456", "doi": "10.1080/17439760902992456", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "60d5ed7242f93e3356385e52dd9d6c40642b60a0fb0f789c0a2064b644bbd3b6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4f4d20b906e242f3d05f5a65de102fafaf822a81b78806073f735c157b1672e9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0188", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/17470218.2014.972420", "title": "How to train your Bayesian: A problem-representation transfer rather than a format-representation shift explains training effects", "authors": "Miroslav Sirota; Lenka Kostovičová; Frédéric Vallée-Tourangeau", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25283723/", "doi": "10.1080/17470218.2014.972420", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S003", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "How to train your Bayesian: A problem-representation transfer rather than a format-representation shift explains training effects", "authors": "Miroslav Sirota; Lenka Kostovičová; Frédéric Vallée-Tourangeau", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25283723/", "doi": "10.1080/17470218.2014.972420", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "164c517948ec85b1d81aef73bf3554436b5fd522a21927e88bc9f888543e6218" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f54913f0de2dae26911af2c8956eeb3f07ee4f7963304e91b2f44dce5f30d076" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0189", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/17483107.2026.2697427", "title": "How do environmental control systems affect mental health and psychological well-being? A pilot study", "authors": "Graham Henderson; Hannah Harris; Michael John Dolan; Ruaraidh Hill", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42400500/", "doi": "10.1080/17483107.2026.2697427", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S013", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "How do environmental control systems affect mental health and psychological well-being? A pilot study", "authors": "Graham Henderson; Hannah Harris; Michael John Dolan; Ruaraidh Hill", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42400500/", "doi": "10.1080/17483107.2026.2697427", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CAREGIVER_SUPPORT", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PILOT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ea8f1c8834c2b38f431c8f81fe2f7b5c2fe4b5e52fc84c6e96430d608cc68b89" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9ac68373c49f40bd87cd17fee7a4d6c0c38d00a62de9f6abd285408c5c739c2f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0190", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/17518423.2021.1903603", "title": "The Impact of Eye-gaze Controlled Computer on Communication and Functional Independence in Children and Young People with Complex Needs - A Multicenter Intervention Study", "authors": "Maria Borgestig; Isphana Al Khatib; Sandra Masayko; Helena Hemmingsson", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33872136/", "doi": "10.1080/17518423.2021.1903603", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S001", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "The Impact of Eye-gaze Controlled Computer on Communication and Functional Independence in Children and Young People with Complex Needs - A Multicenter Intervention Study", "authors": "Maria Borgestig; Isphana Al Khatib; Sandra Masayko; Helena Hemmingsson", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33872136/", "doi": "10.1080/17518423.2021.1903603", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AAC", "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "FUNCTIONAL_INDEPENDENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "08fe6dd4cb350877d3810b2098e8e34f848d701014191eb531933ad74ece866b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f7b7d74585916c027773d6021e55bd42980f637cfc9c785d5afad4d567e5b9f2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0191", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1080/23328940.2024.2383505", "title": "Time-course for onset and decay of physiological adaptations in endurance trained athletes undertaking prolonged heat acclimation training", "authors": "C Cubel; M Fischer; D Stampe; M B Klaris; T R Bruun; C Lundby; N B Nordsborg; L Nybo", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39583901/", "doi": "10.1080/23328940.2024.2383505", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S003", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Time-course for onset and decay of physiological adaptations in endurance trained athletes undertaking prolonged heat acclimation training", "authors": "C Cubel; M Fischer; D Stampe; M B Klaris; T R Bruun; C Lundby; N B Nordsborg; L Nybo", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39583901/", "doi": "10.1080/23328940.2024.2383505", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "68dd5c291c44ae9ddcb369cfa921857e375b7cd7e5bc2ec8f0b9c3ef81c50f4f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e0930e430e85a87a714f36c1d52052c7c4d38de7a5dd3b5c3fb4c53005640a91" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0192", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1086/716884", "title": "Values and Beliefs Underlying Mutual Aid: An Exploration of Collective Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic", "authors": "Danielle M. Littman; Madi Boyett; Kimberly Bender; Annie Zean Dunbar; Marisa Santarella; Trish Becker-Hafnor; Kate Saavedra; Tara Milligan", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/full/10.1086/716884", "doi": "10.1086/716884", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S001", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Values and Beliefs Underlying Mutual Aid: An Exploration of Collective Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic", "authors": "Danielle M. Littman; Madi Boyett; Kimberly Bender; Annie Zean Dunbar; Marisa Santarella; Trish Becker-Hafnor; Kate Saavedra; Tara Milligan", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/full/10.1086/716884", "doi": "10.1086/716884", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fe64a9b6ca91106105819b3a6e294121b8b67c8150cf9122648f4ec51529e378" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "22ec1a4aaf2c0f260d8bbe4b376f91aad1e1140bd3bba4fd2aab82fb16a7481f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0193", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1088/1741-2552/ab059b", "title": "Intraneural sensory feedback restores grip force control and motor coordination while using a prosthetic hand", "authors": "Francesco Clemente; Giacomo Valle; Marco Controzzi; Ivo Strauss; Francesco Iberite; Thomas Stieglitz; Giuseppe Granata; Paolo M. Rossini; Francesco M. Petrini; Silvestro Micera; Christian Cipriani", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30736030", "doi": "10.1088/1741-2552/ab059b", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S003", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Intraneural sensory feedback restores grip force control and motor coordination while using a prosthetic hand", "authors": "Francesco Clemente; Giacomo Valle; Marco Controzzi; Ivo Strauss; Francesco Iberite; Thomas Stieglitz; Giuseppe Granata; Paolo M. Rossini; Francesco M. Petrini; Silvestro Micera; Christian Cipriani", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30736030", "doi": "10.1088/1741-2552/ab059b", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEURAL_SENSORY_FEEDBACK", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2677b3d342935054be754d09b5aad0553f5e10540c6cdcfadf70a67430f5e939" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "252fe94e13d19204c04d62ddcd62ff3c1a6d77e52f182087fe79390e033f4c21" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0194", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1089/neu.2017.5230", "title": "Olfactory Training in Post-Traumatic Smell Impairment: Mild Improvement in Threshold Performances: Results from a Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "C. Langdon; E. Lehrer; J. Berenguer; S. Laxe; I. Alobid; L. Quintó; F. Mariño-Sánchez; M. Bernabeu; C. Marin; J. Mullol", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29790420/", "doi": "10.1089/neu.2017.5230", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S016", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Olfactory Training in Post-Traumatic Smell Impairment: Mild Improvement in Threshold Performances: Results from a Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "C. Langdon; E. Lehrer; J. Berenguer; S. Laxe; I. Alobid; L. Quintó; F. Mariño-Sánchez; M. Bernabeu; C. Marin; J. Mullol", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29790420/", "doi": "10.1089/neu.2017.5230", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a78dbc16f8446515714a60ba86ab39acb10d71e341cd68ae970bd3855a0a85c2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fed164eb37436d859ccac4dfca15724516110148d3c8550e3431d397ff7f7706" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0195", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/brain/awx011", "title": "Better than sham? A double-blind placebo-controlled neurofeedback study in primary insomnia", "authors": "Manuel Schabus; Hermann Griessenberger; Maria-Teresa Gnjezda; Dominik P. J. Heib; Malgorzata Wislowska; Kerstin Hoedlmoser", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28335000/", "doi": "10.1093/brain/awx011", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S010", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Better than sham? A double-blind placebo-controlled neurofeedback study in primary insomnia", "authors": "Manuel Schabus; Hermann Griessenberger; Maria-Teresa Gnjezda; Dominik P. J. Heib; Malgorzata Wislowska; Kerstin Hoedlmoser", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28335000/", "doi": "10.1093/brain/awx011", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEUROFEEDBACK", "PLACEBO_BOUNDARY", "SHAM_CONTROL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "230b1e562c9a17e162e30266b377d1009b805a0a70e7b4f992cb7eebf793c72d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "09e767bb43d68105642a0040f084243e70ed254253f86508221caacd12352d19" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0196", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/gerona/56.8.m518", "title": "Skilled finger movement exercise improves hand function", "authors": "Vinoth K. Ranganathan; Vlodek Siemionow; Vinod Sahgal; Jing Z. Liu; Guang H. Yue", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11487606/", "doi": "10.1093/gerona/56.8.M518", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S005", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Skilled finger movement exercise improves hand function", "authors": "Vinoth K. Ranganathan; Vlodek Siemionow; Vinod Sahgal; Jing Z. Liu; Guang H. Yue", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11487606/", "doi": "10.1093/gerona/56.8.M518", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6d6ac36b38d58b96e50c7abe5be6a19a89efd7833c7df2ebb1719b5b86961b7d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "06bc8ce1503eb39b0eac27cbe6ef35c80d8954a57f7daacca64870dc3955a650" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0197", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/gerona/60.6.777", "title": "Effects of maximal isometric and isokinetic resistance training on strength and functional mobility in older adults", "authors": "T. Brock Symons; Anthony A. Vandervoort; Charles L. Rice; Tom J. Overend; Greg D. Marsh", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15983182/", "doi": "10.1093/gerona/60.6.777", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S002", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Effects of maximal isometric and isokinetic resistance training on strength and functional mobility in older adults", "authors": "T. Brock Symons; Anthony A. Vandervoort; Charles L. Rice; Tom J. Overend; Greg D. Marsh", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15983182/", "doi": "10.1093/gerona/60.6.777", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "aa7e3b201d283a8d34834832d0c2d58c7cd7218b5af0d77bffc38496f9afca5b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4bcd78d7967be8768d67d81be615232c659750f9f48003bc8dd9a109c3d6120e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0198", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/gerona/glu087", "title": "Perturbation training can reduce community-dwelling older adults' annual fall risk: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Yi-Chung Pai; Tanvi Bhatt; Feng Yang; Edward Wang", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24966227/", "doi": "10.1093/gerona/glu087", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S007", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Perturbation training can reduce community-dwelling older adults' annual fall risk: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Yi-Chung Pai; Tanvi Bhatt; Feng Yang; Edward Wang", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24966227/", "doi": "10.1093/gerona/glu087", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1e268729c7a6a02d8d98931e6fe89ac8c0f279e9e8169e7e99f482e20c71eaae" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "56c44eb383681f8677ad95ab5ddac36a714be184a212aaec30660af62f1fd154" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0199", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/geronb/gbac021", "title": "Piano Training Enhances Executive Functions and Psychosocial Outcomes in Aging: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Bugos JA; Wang Y", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35134913", "doi": "10.1093/geronb/gbac021", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S005", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Piano Training Enhances Executive Functions and Psychosocial Outcomes in Aging: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Bugos JA; Wang Y", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35134913", "doi": "10.1093/geronb/gbac021", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1084aecd395c6f766b9f53bc9c47aa990da7a6696402ebf80624e282ec097630" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9d89e36e8f13fbd1d8b2061acd0c9d7e6e7e505e1e5a7b158341be1bb289df6d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0200", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/geronb/gbv105", "title": "Limited Benefits of Heterogeneous Dual-Task Training on Transfer Effects in Older Adults", "authors": "Maxime Lussier; Philippe Brouillard; Louis Bherer", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26603017/", "doi": "10.1093/geronb/gbv105", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S006", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Limited Benefits of Heterogeneous Dual-Task Training on Transfer Effects in Older Adults", "authors": "Maxime Lussier; Philippe Brouillard; Louis Bherer", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26603017/", "doi": "10.1093/geronb/gbv105", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7d48ece6e4881fe55a69022f10895304ba518f7070dc8b172c0e565a3f09f8e9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fb5fb36c5ac1680d015a19f6e9f405dfb4f33b4019caa05ea476c6b27dafcee8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0201", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/rheumatology/kem384", "title": "Low-intensity pulsed ultrasound for chronic patellar tendinopathy: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial", "authors": "Stuart J Warden; B R Metcalf; Z S Kiss; Jill L Cook; C R Purdam; Kim L Bennell; Kay M Crossley", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18270224/", "doi": "10.1093/rheumatology/kem384", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S008", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Low-intensity pulsed ultrasound for chronic patellar tendinopathy: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial", "authors": "Stuart J Warden; B R Metcalf; Z S Kiss; Jill L Cook; C R Purdam; Kim L Bennell; Kay M Crossley", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18270224/", "doi": "10.1093/rheumatology/kem384", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ba7b4d332bcf430dbc8a9e6ccc099429f1abc3447686f52884baf2e8410cf796" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cc513ffe50108f94d54c951bf2eb0f46700e595d42e338e4192241fbe4062f24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0202", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/scan/nss095", "title": "Compassion meditation enhances empathic accuracy and related neural activity", "authors": "Jennifer S. Mascaro; James K. Rilling; Lobsang Tenzin Negi; Charles L. Raison", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22956676/", "doi": "10.1093/scan/nss095", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S002", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Compassion meditation enhances empathic accuracy and related neural activity", "authors": "Jennifer S. Mascaro; James K. Rilling; Lobsang Tenzin Negi; Charles L. Raison", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22956676/", "doi": "10.1093/scan/nss095", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "121f52ef513f60847816037c3c7d184c2240e01de8279a92ff6cd8c9e740867f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5e1c165e01af0654a2fabd31f40346881c3466f0e71dc1a55ac2a6aa76d87cbb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0203", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/scan/nst060", "title": "Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training", "authors": "Olga M. Klimecki; Susanne Leiberg; Matthieu Ricard; Tania Singer", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23576808/", "doi": "10.1093/scan/nst060", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S014", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training", "authors": "Olga M. Klimecki; Susanne Leiberg; Matthieu Ricard; Tania Singer", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23576808/", "doi": "10.1093/scan/nst060", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "91ea6e908e675ba47e863ebd92f5b502c0a6b45ab96cff86873747aa40c5dc44" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5a125f0148d74412e101e4bbcf8580960b6742c7940a28ac712c5e4468ad16e8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0204", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/sleep/zsaa034", "title": "The effects of digital cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia on cognitive function: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Simon D Kyle; Madeleine E D Hurry; Richard Emsley; Antonia Marsden; Ximena Omlin; Amender Juss; Kai Spiegelhalder; Lampros Bisdounis; Annemarie I Luik; Colin A Espie; Claire E Sexton", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32128593/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsaa034", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S002", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "The effects of digital cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia on cognitive function: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Simon D Kyle; Madeleine E D Hurry; Richard Emsley; Antonia Marsden; Ximena Omlin; Amender Juss; Kai Spiegelhalder; Lampros Bisdounis; Annemarie I Luik; Colin A Espie; Claire E Sexton", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32128593/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsaa034", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "031006825086f441ab2d22b059eebe0628c274bebde3d5e347ff1407e79f2685" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "68366c75194d24dcab31b8b59b3c37fca0def306b0f38942786032201eeb289f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0205", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/sleep/zsaa291", "title": "Performance of seven consumer sleep-tracking devices compared with polysomnography", "authors": "Evan D Chinoy; Joseph A Cuellar; Kirbie E Huwa; Jason T Jameson; Catherine H Watson; Sara C Bessman; Dale A Hirsch; Adam D Cooper; Sean P A Drummond; Rachel R Markwald", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33378539/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsaa291", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S010", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Performance of seven consumer sleep-tracking devices compared with polysomnography", "authors": "Evan D Chinoy; Joseph A Cuellar; Kirbie E Huwa; Jason T Jameson; Catherine H Watson; Sara C Bessman; Dale A Hirsch; Adam D Cooper; Sean P A Drummond; Rachel R Markwald", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33378539/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsaa291", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c0d33c8b870c476538f9822419297f3897f1883d02c94091aa6358361c9a87d7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "08c2fefaf7793684efc6b4fdbdae033b3574eca142caabe268d41c119169d65c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0206", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/sleep/zsad025", "title": "Influence of mid-afternoon nap duration and sleep parameters on memory encoding, mood, processing speed, and vigilance", "authors": "Ruth L F Leong; TeYang Lau; Andrew R Dicom; Teck Boon Teo; Ju Lynn Ong; Michael W L Chee", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36775965/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsad025", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S004", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Influence of mid-afternoon nap duration and sleep parameters on memory encoding, mood, processing speed, and vigilance", "authors": "Ruth L F Leong; TeYang Lau; Andrew R Dicom; Teck Boon Teo; Ju Lynn Ong; Michael W L Chee", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36775965/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsad025", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2ba9766c9ac098c85fc928fe5a65b05e466ae372d6340b9a4cb396191eb87101" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "138e266061591a1cce98ba5b02e4effc1d01aa5172930545bafe59eb65453f1d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0207", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/sleep/zsz292", "title": "Robust stability of trait-like vulnerability or resilience to common types of sleep deprivation in a large sample of adults", "authors": "Erika M Yamazaki; Namni Goel", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31784748/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsz292", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S005", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Robust stability of trait-like vulnerability or resilience to common types of sleep deprivation in a large sample of adults", "authors": "Erika M Yamazaki; Namni Goel", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31784748/", "doi": "10.1093/sleep/zsz292", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "PREDICTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "49ac9532e7b81384872a5f0ab857331df011003034d00b14b952a1ffee708200" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "deab641cf5e61f85d6925ee6f694422010dd705e5611878f685cd1631628daa0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0208", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1093/texcom/tgac009", "title": "Benefit from retrieval practice is linked to temporal and frontal activity in healthy young and older humans", "authors": "Catherine-Noémie Alexandrina Guran; Lorena Deuker; Martin Göttlich; Nikolai Axmacher; Nico Bunzeck", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35372838/", "doi": "10.1093/texcom/tgac009", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S001", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Benefit from retrieval practice is linked to temporal and frontal activity in healthy young and older humans", "authors": "Catherine-Noémie Alexandrina Guran; Lorena Deuker; Martin Göttlich; Nikolai Axmacher; Nico Bunzeck", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35372838/", "doi": "10.1093/texcom/tgac009", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4a2a0e384c814e53666a5d74f89ba65f409daf71e6658cfecd650721fa6a374e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0d9aa97cea08cac6ea47ade76caa537d9d48cdfa84db73fb158feb4e952b024e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0209", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/00005768-199610000-00018", "title": "Effects of moderate-intensity endurance and high-intensity intermittent training on anaerobic capacity and VO2max", "authors": "Izumi Tabata; Kouji Nishimura; Motoki Kouzaki; Yuusuke Hirai; Futoshi Ogita; Motohiko Miyachi; Kaoru Yamamoto", "year": 1996, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8897392/", "doi": "10.1097/00005768-199610000-00018", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S004", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Effects of moderate-intensity endurance and high-intensity intermittent training on anaerobic capacity and VO2max", "authors": "Izumi Tabata; Kouji Nishimura; Motoki Kouzaki; Yuusuke Hirai; Futoshi Ogita; Motohiko Miyachi; Kaoru Yamamoto", "year": 1996, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8897392/", "doi": "10.1097/00005768-199610000-00018", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY_BOUNDARY", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bf03ad9d3931524a25f216561627bd313ec5c6758aa01cd9d506b7b508b6a9be" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "96f65daf1849174dae17b771c765be5caef2a73d36c4348ea84667ddd181dfeb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0210", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/00005768-200205000-00010", "title": "Inspiratory muscle fatigue in trained cyclists: effects of inspiratory muscle training", "authors": "Lee M. Romer; Alison K. McConnell; David A. Jones", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11984296/", "doi": "10.1097/00005768-200205000-00010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S006", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Inspiratory muscle fatigue in trained cyclists: effects of inspiratory muscle training", "authors": "Lee M. Romer; Alison K. McConnell; David A. Jones", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11984296/", "doi": "10.1097/00005768-200205000-00010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "90e0db5b1b403bacd077e91e58da0b2caa2355a9fa7fe3d7baf073f445672bbd" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ae1af6886a0e49580c6a9087822f8fa0dbd3e27ee63e70d0ac42957da8b7a3ab" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0211", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/01.psy.0000089200.81962.19", "title": "Heart rate variability biofeedback increases baroreflex gain and peak expiratory flow", "authors": "Paul M Lehrer; Evgeny Vaschillo; Bronya Vaschillo; Shou-En Lu; Dwain L Eckberg; Robert Edelberg; Weichung Joe Shih; Yong Lin; Tom A Kuusela; Kari U O Tahvanainen; Robert M Hamer", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14508023/", "doi": "10.1097/01.psy.0000089200.81962.19", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S002", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Heart rate variability biofeedback increases baroreflex gain and peak expiratory flow", "authors": "Paul M Lehrer; Evgeny Vaschillo; Bronya Vaschillo; Shou-En Lu; Dwain L Eckberg; Robert Edelberg; Weichung Joe Shih; Yong Lin; Tom A Kuusela; Kari U O Tahvanainen; Robert M Hamer", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14508023/", "doi": "10.1097/01.psy.0000089200.81962.19", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5c39bd73d7a040b9a71c442a879f41f129c148302c9086a38c2a20d0db4b23eb" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fe2ee1561848f6b6f3974f040e4a34b25dd6eddeee49039c0c03f1ef32de9428" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0212", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/ajp.0000000000000857", "title": "The Effects of a Pain Psychology and Neuroscience Self-Evaluation Internet Intervention: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "David J Kohns; Christopher P Urbanik; Michael E Geisser; Howard Schubiner; Mark A Lumley", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32520816/", "doi": "10.1097/AJP.0000000000000857", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S004", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "The Effects of a Pain Psychology and Neuroscience Self-Evaluation Internet Intervention: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "David J Kohns; Christopher P Urbanik; Michael E Geisser; Howard Schubiner; Mark A Lumley", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32520816/", "doi": "10.1097/AJP.0000000000000857", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0d3f72a9853ea59be2a01f6d9fdbfbcf6a62157e4de3abfab846acd2f3525fb9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "909a4703dd365b626ea9e4cd40d2758b7888265f5b33f8464bbc1bbf21dc8ad5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0213", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/aud.0000000000000020", "title": "Benefits of phoneme discrimination training in a randomized controlled trial of 50- to 74-year-olds with mild hearing loss", "authors": "M. A. Ferguson; H. Henshaw; D. P. Clark; D. R. Moore", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24752284/", "doi": "10.1097/AUD.0000000000000020", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S008", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Benefits of phoneme discrimination training in a randomized controlled trial of 50- to 74-year-olds with mild hearing loss", "authors": "M. A. Ferguson; H. Henshaw; D. P. Clark; D. R. Moore", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24752284/", "doi": "10.1097/AUD.0000000000000020", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8c275147486421e511ef0973ae64128c3109d7b5fdda5010fd5f29dd920763ec" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a499e6e6ff25ca3d151a0592061d282be968239f92e4a8368c7f9e325ae765e2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0214", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/aud.0000000000000688", "title": "Clinical Effectiveness of an At-Home Auditory Training Program: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "L. E. Humes; K. G. Skinner; D. L. Kinney; S. E. Rogers; A. K. Main; T. M. Quigley", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30575602/", "doi": "10.1097/AUD.0000000000000688", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S009", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Clinical Effectiveness of an At-Home Auditory Training Program: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "L. E. Humes; K. G. Skinner; D. L. Kinney; S. E. Rogers; A. K. Main; T. M. Quigley", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30575602/", "doi": "10.1097/AUD.0000000000000688", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "85df99a7b526b76e83f8c25461d43b8ad3803aed8c8b606a5656048fa2c0535d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c1db9874dadbe423851ccfc842f8cd89bd52dcf76688951d0601ebdc3f2daef9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0215", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/cce.0000000000000249", "title": "Development and Verification of a Digital Twin Patient Model to Predict Specific Treatment Response During the First 24 Hours of Sepsis", "authors": "A Lal; G Li; E Cubro; S Chalmers; H Li; V Herasevich; Y Dong; B W Pickering; O Kilickaya; O Gajic", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33225302/", "doi": "10.1097/CCE.0000000000000249", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S006", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Development and Verification of a Digital Twin Patient Model to Predict Specific Treatment Response During the First 24 Hours of Sepsis", "authors": "A Lal; G Li; E Cubro; S Chalmers; H Li; V Herasevich; Y Dong; B W Pickering; O Kilickaya; O Gajic", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33225302/", "doi": "10.1097/CCE.0000000000000249", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c35b0d409a47985fe5e17a159216fc0c3c9e3dbaf594272e47df9064ad40e201" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4f862ce84f23207d4f6a4fa152ad362711cc0f467600a80039263a268a9a29ed" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0216", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001095", "title": "Tempo-spatial discrimination is lower for noxious stimuli than for innocuous stimuli", "authors": "K. S. Frahm; C. D. Mørch; O. K. Andersen", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29112535/", "doi": "10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001095", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S012", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Tempo-spatial discrimination is lower for noxious stimuli than for innocuous stimuli", "authors": "K. S. Frahm; C. D. Mørch; O. K. Andersen", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29112535/", "doi": "10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001095", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "09a6b122b8044e84fdf748b14416cd44fa3cee1c01fd678616674b0c46e9e749" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6f7f39db029a93c36beb9aa2d82cbd659d1dd4859dfd0919985d10e72fda633b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0217", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/jom.0000000000000924", "title": "Effects of Brief Communication Skills Training for Workers Based on the Principles of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy", "authors": "Norio Sasaki; Hironori Somemura; Saki Nakamura; Megumi Yamamoto; Manabu Isojima; Issei Shinmei; Masaru Horikoshi; Katsutoshi Tanaka", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28045799/", "doi": "10.1097/JOM.0000000000000924", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S005", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Effects of Brief Communication Skills Training for Workers Based on the Principles of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy", "authors": "Norio Sasaki; Hironori Somemura; Saki Nakamura; Megumi Yamamoto; Manabu Isojima; Issei Shinmei; Masaru Horikoshi; Katsutoshi Tanaka", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28045799/", "doi": "10.1097/JOM.0000000000000924", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4abb82ba505e99782cc7af92aa0938b10bd1039b7ea30ba64df573a82ce741b6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2e407b870b304cb605a63397a23c339654bfacce6c9bcaf53f43f3511af68839" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0218", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/mrr.0000000000000506", "title": "The efficacy of robot-assisted training for patients with upper limb amputations who use myoelectric prostheses: a randomized controlled pilot study", "authors": "Tuğba Aydin; Fatma Nur Kesiktaş; Yusuf Doğan Akbulut; Mustafa Çorum; Kadriye Öneş; Taha Kizilkurt; Nazli Derya Buğdayci; Ilhan Karacan", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34775437/", "doi": "10.1097/MRR.0000000000000506", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S007", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "The efficacy of robot-assisted training for patients with upper limb amputations who use myoelectric prostheses: a randomized controlled pilot study", "authors": "Tuğba Aydin; Fatma Nur Kesiktaş; Yusuf Doğan Akbulut; Mustafa Çorum; Kadriye Öneş; Taha Kizilkurt; Nazli Derya Buğdayci; Ilhan Karacan", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34775437/", "doi": "10.1097/MRR.0000000000000506", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DEVICE_SPECIFIC", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "665fb6910ee417e3f0a860b23ed785a8b931f6e037187992507b1a504e7843e0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9aeb75561cbca08d946bc9b6a4788760e0f7bcf47941767c3be811a49d8c1176" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0219", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/npt.0000000000000382", "title": "Vestibular Rehabilitation for Peripheral Vestibular Hypofunction: An Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline (CPG+)", "authors": "American Physical Therapy Association; Academy of Neurologic Physical Therapy", "year": 2022, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.apta.org/patient-care/evidence-based-practice-resources/cpgs/vestibular-rehabilitation-for-peripheral-vestibular-hypofunction-an-evidence-based-clinical-practice-guideline-cpg", "doi": "10.1097/NPT.0000000000000382", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S004", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Vestibular Rehabilitation for Peripheral Vestibular Hypofunction: An Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline (CPG+)", "authors": "American Physical Therapy Association; Academy of Neurologic Physical Therapy", "year": 2022, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.apta.org/patient-care/evidence-based-practice-resources/cpgs/vestibular-rehabilitation-for-peripheral-vestibular-hypofunction-an-evidence-based-clinical-practice-guideline-cpg", "doi": "10.1097/NPT.0000000000000382", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4bdc287a89cfe47ff7c9cce095b7d35b10557fee861e2e0ad18ff785e3cad2ff" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "28fe507fd2f686d7c00c02520b031d91fbaf0ac5c7d1ef2d26a2c14bc8fba627" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0220", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/phh.0000000000000248", "title": "Systems Thinking in 49 Communities Related to Healthy Eating, Active Living, and Childhood Obesity", "authors": "Laura K. Brennan; Nasim S. Sabounchi; Allison L. Kemner; Peter Hovmand", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25828223/", "doi": "10.1097/PHH.0000000000000248", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S007", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Systems Thinking in 49 Communities Related to Healthy Eating, Active Living, and Childhood Obesity", "authors": "Laura K. Brennan; Nasim S. Sabounchi; Allison L. Kemner; Peter Hovmand", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25828223/", "doi": "10.1097/PHH.0000000000000248", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "IMPLEMENTATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e52406ab4fd4d96292d6ad6593c68fbc31535bdb66a7046983ccedbbf490583a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b1b22c11a126d7b0c2f26a8d1c2018f5d8b3c71bd765b659d260560eafc1a072" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0221", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1097/phm.0000000000001450", "title": "Concentric and Eccentric Resistance Training Comparison on Physical Function and Functional Pain Outcomes in Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Kevin R. Vincent; Heather K. Vincent", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32324615/", "doi": "10.1097/PHM.0000000000001450", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S007", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Concentric and Eccentric Resistance Training Comparison on Physical Function and Functional Pain Outcomes in Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Kevin R. Vincent; Heather K. Vincent", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32324615/", "doi": "10.1097/PHM.0000000000001450", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "06946f59159db64ebb0edd0a42fe47c922af72a76ac04033b2861da762c63ab1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "833d61adb357b49917f9d3954e02213b6eb9c413540d3b6d68507d3d44ff4f6a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0222", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1098/rsos.221097", "title": "Correcting COVID-19 vaccine misinformation in 10 countries", "authors": "Ethan Porter; Yamil Velez; Thomas J. Wood", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.221097", "doi": "10.1098/rsos.221097", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S013", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Correcting COVID-19 vaccine misinformation in 10 countries", "authors": "Ethan Porter; Yamil Velez; Thomas J. Wood", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.221097", "doi": "10.1098/rsos.221097", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BELIEF_UPDATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "307d11c1b199ea05900aef31871f1cbba1c4e69ae21eeba95db1dc3fb85eb236" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7a14346e351e85deb203ea018c95090bc7d6a2611068188bad88cdad1df5f9bf" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0223", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1098/rsos.230604", "title": "The effects of communicating uncertainty around statistics, on public trust", "authors": "John Kerr; Anne-Marthe van der Bles; Sarah Dryhurst; Claudia R. Schneider; Vivien Chopurian; Alexandra L. J. Freeman; Sander van der Linden", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.230604", "doi": "10.1098/rsos.230604", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S011", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "The effects of communicating uncertainty around statistics, on public trust", "authors": "John Kerr; Anne-Marthe van der Bles; Sarah Dryhurst; Claudia R. Schneider; Vivien Chopurian; Alexandra L. J. Freeman; Sander van der Linden", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.230604", "doi": "10.1098/rsos.230604", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMMUNICATION", "CROSS_CULTURAL", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9ada039bf68c9eac2e1f8c472e34f84f159d7b1a49ca3c526c49171a04c1e5dd" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "66ebe3dfd46f23eee77c9607f451864cdcdd419c4c4edece7d02b2f5c42fcf8c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0224", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1098/rsos.240175", "title": "The role of art knowledge training on aesthetic judgements and executive functions", "authors": "I Bara; E S Cross; R Ramsey", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40012756/", "doi": "10.1098/rsos.240175", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S006", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "The role of art knowledge training on aesthetic judgements and executive functions", "authors": "I Bara; E S Cross; R Ramsey", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40012756/", "doi": "10.1098/rsos.240175", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c565399eec95406d30ff64929c373ca54f41ddb053fb8e08056c6d426f2b46c5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1adca717d0938600c1081b40151e7f896a035a1040eaf2bb47faec9dd8407608" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0225", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1101/lm.55503", "title": "Temporal specificity of perceptual learning in an auditory discrimination task", "authors": "U. R. Karmarkar; D. V. Buonomano", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12663752/", "doi": "10.1101/lm.55503", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S013", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Temporal specificity of perceptual learning in an auditory discrimination task", "authors": "U. R. Karmarkar; D. V. Buonomano", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12663752/", "doi": "10.1101/lm.55503", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0e53b63edc22a23935e919591c19e20584a5e7091b891a26934af17a95588040" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a7cb2843e0e897f777750fc25013bfa3a18796bee09fdde0761870d2da5352b8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0226", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1109/icorr.2015.7281253", "title": "Assistive Robotic Manipulation through Shared Autonomy and a Body-Machine Interface", "authors": "Siddarth Jain; Ali Farshchiansadegh; Alexander Broad; Farnaz Abdollahi; Ferdinando Mussa-Ivaldi; Brenna D. Argall", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26855690", "doi": "10.1109/ICORR.2015.7281253", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S005", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Assistive Robotic Manipulation through Shared Autonomy and a Body-Machine Interface", "authors": "Siddarth Jain; Ali Farshchiansadegh; Alexander Broad; Farnaz Abdollahi; Ferdinando Mussa-Ivaldi; Brenna D. Argall", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26855690", "doi": "10.1109/ICORR.2015.7281253", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SHARED_AUTONOMY", "TELEOPERATION", "USER_OVERRIDE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2990987d4bbeeb0705d679058b2b46b51e75abc800639e6607303e919ba0e04e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "07721aa74a05e00e80d623a39426148221f4c6ba8e39daaff6b2c20c038e73a7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0227", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1109/tbme.2018.2834555", "title": "An EOG-Based Human-Machine Interface to Control a Smart Home Environment for Patients With Severe Spinal Cord Injuries", "authors": "Rui Zhang; Shenghong He; Xinghua Yang; Xiaoyun Wang; Kai Li; Qiyun Huang; Zhuliang Yu; Xichun Zhang; Dan Tang; Yuanqing Li", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29993413/", "doi": "10.1109/TBME.2018.2834555", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S012", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "An EOG-Based Human-Machine Interface to Control a Smart Home Environment for Patients With Severe Spinal Cord Injuries", "authors": "Rui Zhang; Shenghong He; Xinghua Yang; Xiaoyun Wang; Kai Li; Qiyun Huang; Zhuliang Yu; Xichun Zhang; Dan Tang; Yuanqing Li", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29993413/", "doi": "10.1109/TBME.2018.2834555", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ENVIRONMENTAL_CONTROL", "FALSE_OPERATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d0241d0d1b6416cfb43d7fb34f2fcad04b9b51412a227c0d86107175158042e7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f445af8a54558d334e44c3d029826cbe90432c669e8fbb2fa758c818c4c1de26" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0228", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1109/toh.2020.3009581", "title": "A Multisensory Approach to Present Phonemes as Language Through a Wearable Haptic Device", "authors": "N Dunkelberger; J L Sullivan; J Bradley; I Manickam; G Dasarathy; R Baraniuk; M K O'Malley", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32746381/", "doi": "10.1109/TOH.2020.3009581", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S004", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "A Multisensory Approach to Present Phonemes as Language Through a Wearable Haptic Device", "authors": "N Dunkelberger; J L Sullivan; J Bradley; I Manickam; G Dasarathy; R Baraniuk; M K O'Malley", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32746381/", "doi": "10.1109/TOH.2020.3009581", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1913f054f5fcd423f94180a57511281c070ee78eef3104910b61debde583f658" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bc057817c90f42d4f90a541e9e21493ce52743a82dd3ea7a93e31f3bc9ac8c24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0229", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/1467-8624.00081", "title": "All Other Things Being Equal: Acquisition and Transfer of the Control of Variables Strategy", "authors": "Zhe Chen; David Klahr", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://srcd.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1467-8624.00081", "doi": "10.1111/1467-8624.00081", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S017", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "All Other Things Being Equal: Acquisition and Transfer of the Control of Variables Strategy", "authors": "Zhe Chen; David Klahr", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://srcd.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1467-8624.00081", "doi": "10.1111/1467-8624.00081", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AGE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5b5be85a57812438fe944b67568a5b1f0e8bbfb33007f761397e7a7c6be0fdc8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c5f274536d20e07c800aadbc1c5c27b442ab92a0c20e09da496263a120e25567" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0230", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/1475-6765.12541", "title": "Public support for deliberative citizens' assemblies selected through sortition: evidence from 15 countries", "authors": "Jean-Benoit Pilet; Damien Bol; Davide Vittori; Emilien Paulis", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1475-6765.12541", "doi": "10.1111/1475-6765.12541", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S009", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Public support for deliberative citizens' assemblies selected through sortition: evidence from 15 countries", "authors": "Jean-Benoit Pilet; Damien Bol; Davide Vittori; Emilien Paulis", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1475-6765.12541", "doi": "10.1111/1475-6765.12541", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "16a22bcc37beaf0920e6e947c048322b38214d0fe073cf7a1a52bae2a35c71c5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d2d76888a60df24206e99f32948aa0fa5fff26013d669a1aa0d3f7ceb43a633d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0231", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/add.16325", "title": "Behavioural self-control training versus motivational enhancement therapy for individuals with alcohol use disorder with a goal of controlled drinking: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Stina Ingesson Hammarberg; Sara Wallhed Finn; Ingvar Rosendahl; Sven Andréasson; Nitya Jayaram-Lindström; Anders Hammarberg", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37658776/", "doi": "10.1111/add.16325", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S009", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Behavioural self-control training versus motivational enhancement therapy for individuals with alcohol use disorder with a goal of controlled drinking: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Stina Ingesson Hammarberg; Sara Wallhed Finn; Ingvar Rosendahl; Sven Andréasson; Nitya Jayaram-Lindström; Anders Hammarberg", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37658776/", "doi": "10.1111/add.16325", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b2cefd7e2f5eac47f3fc4c089c38730d78c13d58c442b06fd4c959257e22c1d9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fa8ad0fd01eb25e370097c1868f193a4925b5044699f5cc4af1f2ee0797da49d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0232", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/aphw.70184", "title": "Savor-Aging: The Art of Savoring Positive Emotions in Older Adulthood-A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "E Pancini; G Cremaschi; M Degani; E Cisotto; D Villani", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42400304/", "doi": "10.1111/aphw.70184", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S007", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Savor-Aging: The Art of Savoring Positive Emotions in Older Adulthood-A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "E Pancini; G Cremaschi; M Degani; E Cisotto; D Villani", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42400304/", "doi": "10.1111/aphw.70184", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "46e5ab8c0c9493e702f4fabc0d39a975ce08f8d087a9a303b131b373c60e16e9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "98a8103233a4f02f46a118b0ee9ebb1305e78277f546edd47d81992a3a2e00fa" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0233", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/bjc.12044", "title": "A randomized, controlled trial of Social Cognition and Interaction Training (SCIT) for outpatients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders", "authors": "David L. Roberts; Dennis R. Combs; Michael Willoughby; Jim Mintz; Clare Gibson; Betty Rupp; David L. Penn", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24417608/", "doi": "10.1111/bjc.12044", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S004", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "A randomized, controlled trial of Social Cognition and Interaction Training (SCIT) for outpatients with schizophrenia spectrum disorders", "authors": "David L. Roberts; Dennis R. Combs; Michael Willoughby; Jim Mintz; Clare Gibson; Betty Rupp; David L. Penn", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24417608/", "doi": "10.1111/bjc.12044", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "31cedf4b843b01c12055de12d8c58d258c1c98df8e3abe1870f668c6aa1ce307" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b1fab9ba6e222333de494ae013dbbfd9b75b314b200f350b2da80318c7fa5c26" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0234", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/bjep.12061", "title": "Enhancing divergent thinking in visual arts education: Effects of explicit instruction of meta-cognition", "authors": "van de Kamp MT; Admiraal W; van Drie J; Rijlaarsdam G", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25420777", "doi": "10.1111/bjep.12061", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S004", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Enhancing divergent thinking in visual arts education: Effects of explicit instruction of meta-cognition", "authors": "van de Kamp MT; Admiraal W; van Drie J; Rijlaarsdam G", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25420777", "doi": "10.1111/bjep.12061", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "OBJECTIVE_VS_JUDGED_OUTCOME", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9f2d067369b91ad01d23b066684468ee0f4d412093fdba03f117d284c4bf2bf6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c207feebb64618d9c399bdf9bf0d1051200645995a4b83477db40793fb416127" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0235", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/cogs.12442", "title": "Imitation, Inspiration, and Creation: Cognitive Process of Creative Drawing by Copying Others' Artworks", "authors": "T Okada; K Ishibashi", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.12442", "doi": "10.1111/cogs.12442", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S016", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Imitation, Inspiration, and Creation: Cognitive Process of Creative Drawing by Copying Others' Artworks", "authors": "T Okada; K Ishibashi", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/cogs.12442", "doi": "10.1111/cogs.12442", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f03bb3b6923929590e5547c2ed4cac75865b20707493d4b9cb5e026185a3cab4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "69f6869b1b7aa45d593b58f472d409436802f8377511d26de918031e8677ebe2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0236", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/dmcn.13330", "title": "Caregiver-directed home-based intensive bimanual training in young children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: a randomized trial", "authors": "C L Ferre; M Brandão; B Surana; A P Dew; N G Moreau; A M Gordon", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27864822/", "doi": "10.1111/dmcn.13330", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S010", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Caregiver-directed home-based intensive bimanual training in young children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: a randomized trial", "authors": "C L Ferre; M Brandão; B Surana; A P Dew; N G Moreau; A M Gordon", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27864822/", "doi": "10.1111/dmcn.13330", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8cdaf339df6499e4b21262c04f30d219b5f4e88a6eae7aff9a616c714b733db9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d89cbbde33fe3366215a83a899407765efad34c8e39a4f550098095f236cb488" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0237", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1467-7687.2009.00846.x", "title": "How useful is executive control training? Age differences in near and far transfer of task-switching training", "authors": "Julia Karbach; Jutta Kray", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19840052/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1467-7687.2009.00846.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S009", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "How useful is executive control training? Age differences in near and far transfer of task-switching training", "authors": "Julia Karbach; Jutta Kray", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19840052/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1467-7687.2009.00846.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "261aa50dc02e4026bd3b3a25397f00274e521c91a873b3995fb36367da707b63" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9a4b99bfd1c9b8daf4c1796b738dad69a1320b38cc6848eee31451b91c3b06bb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0238", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.02006.x", "title": "Rare Targets Are Rarely Missed in Correctable Search", "authors": "Mathias S. Fleck; Stephen R. Mitroff", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.02006.x", "doi": "10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.02006.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S009", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Rare Targets Are Rarely Missed in Correctable Search", "authors": "Mathias S. Fleck; Stephen R. Mitroff", "year": 2007, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.02006.x", "doi": "10.1111/j.1467-9280.2007.02006.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "INTERFACE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8b6b57057f4e63fe7c0ab84cce9aa00942f4532413cb284e56eaf17c6c2a05f8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "04b2790706800724430df5685f9641a00cc1b1414f48ea35d0686d9f8b851ba7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0239", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02253.x", "title": "Synchrony and Cooperation", "authors": "Scott S. Wiltermuth; Chip Heath", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19152536/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02253.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S005", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Synchrony and Cooperation", "authors": "Scott S. Wiltermuth; Chip Heath", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19152536/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1467-9280.2008.02253.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8f05325b6c4e2d17d2087c9a469e0c37560ec3a07a44f3e1f2eaffd29f20f929" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "eb78c86f41fa4d014a0ad03e8633f8e7423ef30703e319acde1ddb7587964072" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0240", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1469-8986.2005.00302.x", "title": "Context modulation of memory for fear extinction in humans", "authors": "M R Milad; S P Orr; R K Pitman; S L Rauch", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16008774/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1469-8986.2005.00302.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S013", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Context modulation of memory for fear extinction in humans", "authors": "M R Milad; S P Orr; R K Pitman; S L Rauch", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16008774/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1469-8986.2005.00302.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c75df0fabcf83925f4794e3ed120b629a9a152cc5355ada2ba49c9ce84975a43" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fb27ea64d23553b6024f04777513e9d26a9d44f6840cc94eeb803130a151f6b5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0241", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1469-8986.2008.00666.x", "title": "Interoceptive awareness in experienced meditators", "authors": "S. S. Khalsa; D. Rudrauf; A. R. Damasio; R. J. Davidson; A. Lutz; D. Tranel", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18503485/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1469-8986.2008.00666.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S022" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S022", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Interoceptive awareness in experienced meditators", "authors": "S. S. Khalsa; D. Rudrauf; A. R. Damasio; R. J. Davidson; A. Lutz; D. Tranel", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18503485/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1469-8986.2008.00666.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d36e164270019d96331b83f95e1997e41de7e6983fdb00d2b13c5f1a59bda567" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4f5d0e5b30c8120a8d4a42bca07625ff66955a8343911d8d6ce6939fedba153a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0242", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1532-5415.2006.00703.x", "title": "A randomized trial of a multicomponent home intervention to reduce functional difficulties in older adults", "authors": "Laura N Gitlin; Laraine Winter; Marie P Dennis; Mary Corcoran; Sandy Schinfeld; Walter W Hauck", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16696748/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1532-5415.2006.00703.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S011", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "A randomized trial of a multicomponent home intervention to reduce functional difficulties in older adults", "authors": "Laura N Gitlin; Laraine Winter; Marie P Dennis; Mary Corcoran; Sandy Schinfeld; Walter W Hauck", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16696748/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1532-5415.2006.00703.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e239f6880ec3ce7328180afd6e4f83ee6aaa56fd3ca7d2230bd2ae161d9b2c73" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "88b79ac89f88efcd6a14106e924b18500fbb9dcaaced82c8ac9e01391a0e68fd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0243", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/j.1600-0838.2009.00949.x", "title": "Corticosteroid injections, eccentric decline squat training and heavy slow resistance training in patellar tendinopathy", "authors": "Mads Kongsgaard; V Kovanen; Per Aagaard; Simon Doessing; P Hansen; A H Laursen; N C Kaldau; Michael Kjaer; S Peter Magnusson", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19793213/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1600-0838.2009.00949.x", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S007", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Corticosteroid injections, eccentric decline squat training and heavy slow resistance training in patellar tendinopathy", "authors": "Mads Kongsgaard; V Kovanen; Per Aagaard; Simon Doessing; P Hansen; A H Laursen; N C Kaldau; Michael Kjaer; S Peter Magnusson", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19793213/", "doi": "10.1111/j.1600-0838.2009.00949.x", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e58f33449ae08414a64d21797f64da5c00e97993f6ff53661fc3e5c1ee7d0a0d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6439bbfbe1fb70977e00492e9a60e91eeeae2e9e000e7b6bb984f50756e991b2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0244", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/jasp.12995", "title": "Can group-based strategies increase community resilience? Longitudinal predictors of sustained participation in Covid-19 mutual aid and community support groups", "authors": "Rotem Perach; Maria Fernandes-Jesus; Daniel Miranda; Guanlan Mao; Evangelos Ntontis; Chris Cocking; Michael McTague; Joanna Semlyen; John Drury", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jasp.12995", "doi": "10.1111/jasp.12995", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S017", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Can group-based strategies increase community resilience? Longitudinal predictors of sustained participation in Covid-19 mutual aid and community support groups", "authors": "Rotem Perach; Maria Fernandes-Jesus; Daniel Miranda; Guanlan Mao; Evangelos Ntontis; Chris Cocking; Michael McTague; Joanna Semlyen; John Drury", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/jasp.12995", "doi": "10.1111/jasp.12995", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "99885aff298e0418975797ff55658d95729a3439e4e3d60bbce7c674df5e471f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2f49aea40c6ad44a525f069b1dcaa5bcd21c1dd7710926167a785f2576b0f45c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0245", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/jgs.70116", "title": "CAPABLE for People After Hospitalization: A Randomized Trial", "authors": "Sarah L Szanton; David L Roth; Kathryn Bowles; Nicole Onorato; Laura N Gitlin; Bruce Leff", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40990312/", "doi": "10.1111/jgs.70116", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S013", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "CAPABLE for People After Hospitalization: A Randomized Trial", "authors": "Sarah L Szanton; David L Roth; Kathryn Bowles; Nicole Onorato; Laura N Gitlin; Bruce Leff", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40990312/", "doi": "10.1111/jgs.70116", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "SUBGROUP" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "92b3801792fb3b8eb86e4d75f153e53b1b06ab00e62e00f9b8a47b278a3b64e9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b3f61ad0d456851a9148fda2aa293ae8e93d516bbfdda50ff3fb5fcd93b9fd15" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0246", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/nyas.14857", "title": "Multimodal music training enhances executive functions in children: Results of a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Jennifer A. Bugos; Darlene DeMarie; Christina Stokes; Lindsay P. Power", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35899371/", "doi": "10.1111/nyas.14857", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S013", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Multimodal music training enhances executive functions in children: Results of a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Jennifer A. Bugos; Darlene DeMarie; Christina Stokes; Lindsay P. Power", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35899371/", "doi": "10.1111/nyas.14857", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5c2e0589b0519c8cf7dee152ebe302a8096dd4deb9cee7955c44ae1ee7309e5f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "67c5c8e22fa26fe00d6eaaa4e320e9616688abfa3bdf61167fb0eef78e7e53ae" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0247", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/opo.13395", "title": "Randomised trial of three treatments for amblyopia: Vision therapy and patching, perceptual learning and patching alone", "authors": "R. Hernández-Andrés; M. Á. Serrano; A. Alacreu-Crespo; M. J. Luque", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39396111/", "doi": "10.1111/opo.13395", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S017", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Randomised trial of three treatments for amblyopia: Vision therapy and patching, perceptual learning and patching alone", "authors": "R. Hernández-Andrés; M. Á. Serrano; A. Alacreu-Crespo; M. J. Luque", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39396111/", "doi": "10.1111/opo.13395", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "47ab2e7880a1f7cfb6ec2bc7817ca39db270af07c3ef1f937db898643f64ea8d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2ccdd7cd02dafe6f0c25590b90357d89dfd7282c1776befe68692734df37ce26" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0248", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/psyp.14385", "title": "Positive emotion up-regulation is resistant to working memory load: An electrocortical investigation of reappraisal and savoring", "authors": "Y Cheng; B R Peters; A MacNamara", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37424455/", "doi": "10.1111/psyp.14385", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S006", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Positive emotion up-regulation is resistant to working memory load: An electrocortical investigation of reappraisal and savoring", "authors": "Y Cheng; B R Peters; A MacNamara", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37424455/", "doi": "10.1111/psyp.14385", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "caca1d3c7280ac560fbbc3ccc9307ad267ab2703c17f4a1eee32200c9fc38587" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "aaf190b5f71183de04e40b03f2afb535b2b9f542f37ef7d85e8be36603d451e9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0249", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/psyp.14605", "title": "Individuals lack the ability to accurately detect emotional piloerection", "authors": "Jonathon McPhetres; Ailin Han; Halo H Gao; Nicole Kemp; Bhakti Khati; Cathy X Pu; Abbie Smith; Xinyu Shui", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38715216/", "doi": "10.1111/psyp.14605", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S008", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Individuals lack the ability to accurately detect emotional piloerection", "authors": "Jonathon McPhetres; Ailin Han; Halo H Gao; Nicole Kemp; Bhakti Khati; Cathy X Pu; Abbie Smith; Xinyu Shui", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38715216/", "doi": "10.1111/psyp.14605", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4e67886a6edb276a6be7b87bd8a84fb9bd39e1de9509ab877b29da68b2b53c10" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5a202181395468ae4f231a22d49db847a35c1abcfb224af9d30d1a9cad7b41eb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0250", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1111/psyp.14705", "title": "Using a virtual reality game to train biofeedback-based regulation under stress conditions", "authors": "Lucie Daniel-Watanabe; Benjamin Cook; Grace Leung; Marino Krstulović; Johanna Finnemann; Toby Woolley; Craig Powell; Paul Fletcher", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39385361/", "doi": "10.1111/psyp.14705", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S013", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Using a virtual reality game to train biofeedback-based regulation under stress conditions", "authors": "Lucie Daniel-Watanabe; Benjamin Cook; Grace Leung; Marino Krstulović; Johanna Finnemann; Toby Woolley; Craig Powell; Paul Fletcher", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39385361/", "doi": "10.1111/psyp.14705", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ee57980b95c3f0987a154fa5248959c346d540eabb539de741e3b538bc6d521d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9c1c79a33d2ac1742c1d17ecc913ddef09b828b9a55a887358bdb6098d34777d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0251", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1113/jp273395", "title": "Four-week cold acclimation in adult humans shifts uncoupling thermogenesis from skeletal muscles to brown adipose tissue", "authors": "D P Blondin; A Daoud; T Taylor; H C Tingelstad; V Bézaire; D Richard; A C Carpentier; A W Taylor; M E Harper; C Aguer; F Haman", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28025824/", "doi": "10.1113/JP273395", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S004", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Four-week cold acclimation in adult humans shifts uncoupling thermogenesis from skeletal muscles to brown adipose tissue", "authors": "D P Blondin; A Daoud; T Taylor; H C Tingelstad; V Bézaire; D Richard; A C Carpentier; A W Taylor; M E Harper; C Aguer; F Haman", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28025824/", "doi": "10.1113/JP273395", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "507f6b5fcbe3c881dbce6531c1452ff1a6d2cb9efca185b24508d406d6b5387e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ba1c9ca4574bab568a549a16fa2bdc916b9e0219eb3e1ad46c928f801160a5a0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0252", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1113/jphysiol.2006.112094", "title": "Short-term sprint interval versus traditional endurance training: similar initial adaptations in human skeletal muscle and exercise performance", "authors": "Martin J. Gibala; Jonathan P. Little; Martin van Essen; Geoffrey P. Wilkin; Kirsten A. Burgomaster; Adeel Safdar; Sandeep Raha; Mark A. Tarnopolsky", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16825308/", "doi": "10.1113/jphysiol.2006.112094", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S002", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Short-term sprint interval versus traditional endurance training: similar initial adaptations in human skeletal muscle and exercise performance", "authors": "Martin J. Gibala; Jonathan P. Little; Martin van Essen; Geoffrey P. Wilkin; Kirsten A. Burgomaster; Adeel Safdar; Sandeep Raha; Mark A. Tarnopolsky", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16825308/", "doi": "10.1113/jphysiol.2006.112094", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0908b6dd821b4c56acfad7916a74bf10a64805c510f544dc625bf51bd9c1b8f4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "eac6037385b52041e1051192aa1a4471542debd2c85a5518078591bce74a7a73" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0253", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1113/jphysiol.2007.142109", "title": "Similar metabolic adaptations during exercise after low volume sprint interval and traditional endurance training in humans", "authors": "Kirsten A. Burgomaster; Krista R. Howarth; Stuart M. Phillips; Mark Rakobowchuk; Maureen J. MacDonald; Sean L. McGee; Martin J. Gibala", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17991697/", "doi": "10.1113/jphysiol.2007.142109", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S003", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Similar metabolic adaptations during exercise after low volume sprint interval and traditional endurance training in humans", "authors": "Kirsten A. Burgomaster; Krista R. Howarth; Stuart M. Phillips; Mark Rakobowchuk; Maureen J. MacDonald; Sean L. McGee; Martin J. Gibala", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17991697/", "doi": "10.1113/jphysiol.2007.142109", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "METABOLIC_MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4e32b86ffce86651115cae9861eb4a6638c87266a9382dc6ae149d72b5358d6d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fb93c9c3df81e0ad68817bf44ef1792589ecfac053e04f4c1eb8dc60546e4d6f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0254", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1121/1.1323465", "title": "Specificity of perceptual learning in a frequency discrimination task", "authors": "D. R. Irvine; R. L. Martin; E. Klimkeit; R. Smith", "year": 2000, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11144588/", "doi": "10.1121/1.1323465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S005", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Specificity of perceptual learning in a frequency discrimination task", "authors": "D. R. Irvine; R. L. Martin; E. Klimkeit; R. Smith", "year": 2000, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11144588/", "doi": "10.1121/1.1323465", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6e065f3ba9ba81c28cdb63744af52236ff2690456cdf21c9b326315b4829bf28" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5aaf43356fd4810caf5c834f18b3c34218463e30fab2d067bb46b0c7156e84ea" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0255", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1121/1.3158600", "title": "The sensitivity of auditory-motor representations to subtle changes in auditory feedback while singing", "authors": "Keough D; Jones JA", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19640048", "doi": "10.1121/1.3158600", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S008", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "The sensitivity of auditory-motor representations to subtle changes in auditory feedback while singing", "authors": "Keough D; Jones JA", "year": 2009, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19640048", "doi": "10.1121/1.3158600", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "EXPERIENCE_ASSOCIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NONCAUSAL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "89459201c347194c9cb3164fc7b41be94bdae5c60caf4584a79111bea79cfb9f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cb63e14e23ab187e3aab11a12529e7e142bcbf3a3e465c3f4ccf8e117244b105" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0256", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1121/1.3552874", "title": "Membranous and cartilaginous vocal fold adduction in singing", "authors": "Herbst CT; Qiu Q; Schutte HK; Švec JG", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21476680", "doi": "10.1121/1.3552874", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S010", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Membranous and cartilaginous vocal fold adduction in singing", "authors": "Herbst CT; Qiu Q; Schutte HK; Švec JG", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21476680", "doi": "10.1121/1.3552874", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "SPECIALIST_CONFIGURATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "49a0b11fd58bd73db3ca7d80468bba28ab40c8124f08ddfe91aa16dd7a058253" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4992bd395dee40f1d77338e5ec137b2636840bc186a8d2c786e85f00494e8426" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0257", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1121/1.410149", "title": "Training Japanese listeners to identify English /r/ and /l/. III. Long-term retention of new phonetic categories", "authors": "Scott E. Lively; David B. Pisoni; Reiko A. Yamada; Yoh'ichi Tohkura; Tsuneo Yamada", "year": 1994, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7963022/", "doi": "10.1121/1.410149", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S010", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Training Japanese listeners to identify English /r/ and /l/. III. Long-term retention of new phonetic categories", "authors": "Scott E. Lively; David B. Pisoni; Reiko A. Yamada; Yoh'ichi Tohkura; Tsuneo Yamada", "year": 1994, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7963022/", "doi": "10.1121/1.410149", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ATTRITION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_SPECIFICITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "91bc94b10338e06fb8526ab54e2a36f6a95a6af5f607975ff615c1ee7a3e58d6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "584ae0a699c91159163a8e4c7309ff2c8f504484074e8017b5d400c7ec28beda" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0258", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1121/1.428217", "title": "Training American listeners to perceive Mandarin tones", "authors": "Yue Wang; Michelle M. Spence; Allard Jongman; Joan A. Sereno", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10615703/", "doi": "10.1121/1.428217", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S009", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Training American listeners to perceive Mandarin tones", "authors": "Yue Wang; Michelle M. Spence; Allard Jongman; Joan A. Sereno", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10615703/", "doi": "10.1121/1.428217", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "SMALL_SAMPLE", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "38df1d7aa332709d2ce31f026b06c8ae3b6ab436cfe3473e10d3b5876fc25695" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "588edbd1d1223228d4424db9fa97eeee474e572e04f77e63846566726c10223a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0259", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1121/1.4955004", "title": "Rapid auditory learning of temporal gap detection", "authors": "S. K. Mishra; M. R. Panda", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27475211/", "doi": "10.1121/1.4955004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S014", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Rapid auditory learning of temporal gap detection", "authors": "S. K. Mishra; M. R. Panda", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27475211/", "doi": "10.1121/1.4955004", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "88a112125fdcebfe4bd8541cf63934efcbe46d673b43ab1cf5f2d58b2ee33cb0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4e1877ab831a96641e156874c055051510455b4ded3c6f4eafc4d120d94e78da" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0260", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1123/ijspp.2023-0103", "title": "Efficacy of Resisted Sled Sprint Training Compared With Unresisted Sprint Training on Acceleration and Sprint Performance in Rugby Players: An 8-Week Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Marco Panascì; Simone Di Gennaro; Vittoria Ferrando; Luca Filipas; Piero Ruggeri; Emanuela Faelli", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37536676/", "doi": "10.1123/ijspp.2023-0103", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S001", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Efficacy of Resisted Sled Sprint Training Compared With Unresisted Sprint Training on Acceleration and Sprint Performance in Rugby Players: An 8-Week Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Marco Panascì; Simone Di Gennaro; Vittoria Ferrando; Luca Filipas; Piero Ruggeri; Emanuela Faelli", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37536676/", "doi": "10.1123/ijspp.2023-0103", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "21dbf42df1e3bdc8ec38d890ba8396ae211e586f2c3744beb60e0377cefbbe96" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f3b5a2d94705d61b41862dd29a708c2e42654d843bbb5cf2d48997ef2204b4ca" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0261", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1123/jsr.20.3.311", "title": "The effects of anthropometric scaling parameters on normalized muscle strength in uninjured baseball pitchers", "authors": "Wendy J. Hurd; Bernard F. Morrey; Kenton R. Kaufman", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21828383/", "doi": "10.1123/jsr.20.3.311", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S012", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "The effects of anthropometric scaling parameters on normalized muscle strength in uninjured baseball pitchers", "authors": "Wendy J. Hurd; Bernard F. Morrey; Kenton R. Kaufman", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21828383/", "doi": "10.1123/jsr.20.3.311", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "af20e782de9f63d7b507b7ba3cc0eae4df883ab36f4345d4c6037a884ad6cdf3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4e0826e7210a928b2b6671836b34cc1def61c658918566f169d9c1701f65fdb0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0262", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/sciadv.abc7606", "title": "Durable memories and efficient neural coding through mnemonic training using the method of loci", "authors": "I. C. Wagner; B. N. Konrad; P. Schuster; S. Weisig; D. Repantis; K. Ohla; S. Kühn; G. Fernández; A. Steiger; C. Lamm; M. Czisch; M. Dresler", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33658191/", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.abc7606", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S008", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Durable memories and efficient neural coding through mnemonic training using the method of loci", "authors": "I. C. Wagner; B. N. Konrad; P. Schuster; S. Weisig; D. Repantis; K. Ohla; S. Kühn; G. Fernández; A. Steiger; C. Lamm; M. Czisch; M. Dresler", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33658191/", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.abc7606", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f497bc98d44d2967b95b0fb0e0c15070ac2a4e8f15dcd65410918d3a0cb4d9b6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bd4cd369d3625bf2767870083516f5e2436a34914a7d43c7205b106cdc387556" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0263", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/sciadv.adn5290", "title": "Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content", "authors": "Anil R. Doshi; Oliver P. Hauser", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adn5290", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.adn5290", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S004", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Generative AI enhances individual creativity but reduces the collective diversity of novel content", "authors": "Anil R. Doshi; Oliver P. Hauser", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adn5290", "doi": "10.1126/sciadv.adn5290", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COLLECTIVE_DIVERSITY_COST", "CREATIVE_OUTPUT", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ae3fe1bf23a12c3d855fa936e6fea7fc1fff961c20f8e0baba8f05450ef1bce2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b89dfeae206650c0e19b2f6996e360c144584c5128cc27e964916d1b4bc6aa63" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0264", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/science.1185718", "title": "Optimally interacting minds", "authors": "Bahador Bahrami; Karsten Olsen; Peter E. Latham; Andreas Roepstorff; Geraint Rees; Chris D. Frith", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20798320/", "doi": "10.1126/science.1185718", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S007", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Optimally interacting minds", "authors": "Bahador Bahrami; Karsten Olsen; Peter E. Latham; Andreas Roepstorff; Geraint Rees; Chris D. Frith", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20798320/", "doi": "10.1126/science.1185718", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "db7328964254933401819959d1e6787f8924e84a0f388b18de997ff7c33445c8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "98c16b19de500f7f832a303c4ce96336f4468b3053cb00fd8fae9d2335c788f0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0265", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/science.1193147", "title": "Evidence for a Collective Intelligence Factor in the Performance of Human Groups", "authors": "Anita Williams Woolley; Christopher F. Chabris; Alex Pentland; Nada Hashmi; Thomas W. Malone", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20929725/", "doi": "10.1126/science.1193147", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S008", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Evidence for a Collective Intelligence Factor in the Performance of Human Groups", "authors": "Anita Williams Woolley; Christopher F. Chabris; Alex Pentland; Nada Hashmi; Thomas W. Malone", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20929725/", "doi": "10.1126/science.1193147", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONSTRUCT_HYPOTHESIS", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b97608fcd7edc897c90943a85471a7fcdd0e2eb84380e236d24272e8676343cc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c20695575f202fb66ad18df27bf27fff999550044f904aada0f93cb09b061875" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0266", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/science.1199327", "title": "Retrieval Practice Produces More Learning than Elaborative Studying with Concept Mapping", "authors": "Jeffrey D. Karpicke; Janell R. Blunt", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21252317/", "doi": "10.1126/science.1199327", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S003", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Retrieval Practice Produces More Learning than Elaborative Studying with Concept Mapping", "authors": "Jeffrey D. Karpicke; Janell R. Blunt", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21252317/", "doi": "10.1126/science.1199327", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e1cf1abc698fec6d9a9e25c335c9c8227c90754b920fbab188d109a3f29a3fdd" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "37e4dc1799a4fd4b857df5a1e81482f6fc0cccefc29eeedfdcaa468e7d7eab73" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0267", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/science.1207745", "title": "Google Effects on Memory: Cognitive Consequences of Having Information at Our Fingertips", "authors": "Betsy Sparrow; Jenny Liu; Daniel M. Wegner", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1207745", "doi": "10.1126/science.1207745", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S006", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Google Effects on Memory: Cognitive Consequences of Having Information at Our Fingertips", "authors": "Betsy Sparrow; Jenny Liu; Daniel M. Wegner", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1207745", "doi": "10.1126/science.1207745", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COGNITIVE_OFFLOADING", "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEMORY_CONTENT_VS_LOCATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "263365f7afa02b0a491c4f5c3afeda64b977d4047515b4bd9b6daddcc07104d1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8138e4404ebc628431ef1313671e1a90c19734027c79976ebc9e8acdb3563be2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0268", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1126/science.adh2586", "title": "Experimental evidence on the productivity effects of generative artificial intelligence", "authors": "Shakked Noy; Whitney Zhang", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adh2586", "doi": "10.1126/science.adh2586", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S001", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Experimental evidence on the productivity effects of generative artificial intelligence", "authors": "Shakked Noy; Whitney Zhang", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adh2586", "doi": "10.1126/science.adh2586", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "624cb9adac250c63be41ad6dde79cecab8d91a11da5e2a8d41f4ff743aea1dba" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3e390a3c534994d2edff4c2e1e0306689b0233e972412a9186faab60665f37e2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0269", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1136/bmjqs-2016-005570", "title": "Can patient involvement improve patient safety? A cluster randomised control trial of the Patient Reporting and Action for a Safe Environment (PRASE) intervention", "authors": "Rebecca Lawton; Jane Kathryn O'Hara; Laura Sheard; Gerry Armitage; Kim Cocks; Hannah Buckley; Belen Corbacho; Caroline Reynolds; Claire Marsh; Sally Moore; Ian Watt; John Wright", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28159854/", "doi": "10.1136/bmjqs-2016-005570", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S008", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Can patient involvement improve patient safety? A cluster randomised control trial of the Patient Reporting and Action for a Safe Environment (PRASE) intervention", "authors": "Rebecca Lawton; Jane Kathryn O'Hara; Laura Sheard; Gerry Armitage; Kim Cocks; Hannah Buckley; Belen Corbacho; Caroline Reynolds; Claire Marsh; Sally Moore; Ian Watt; John Wright", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28159854/", "doi": "10.1136/bmjqs-2016-005570", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a92c5d97de6f2ebbf7ed2aeca839d9828a60c6ab8c9ea3f57ec0af8f4563f993" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "789503928ee7adecdbea3af32fca8e8b1211219225b6b9c42507db0dc3d19cbe" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0270", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1136/ip.1.4.228", "title": "Water safety training as a potential means of reducing risk of young children's drowning", "authors": "K N Asher; F P Rivara; D Felix; L Vance; R Dunne", "year": 1995, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9346036/", "doi": "10.1136/ip.1.4.228", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S011", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Water safety training as a potential means of reducing risk of young children's drowning", "authors": "K N Asher; F P Rivara; D Felix; L Vance; R Dunne", "year": 1995, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9346036/", "doi": "10.1136/ip.1.4.228", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bc83c6c17880aba3a4e97ea5cd06e9711ecfc448e279a4af0cec441bd6c9621d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a6a2c1f89df1ffd6dba49ad31614ed593307f734e850248ea4607fe981692b62" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0271", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1136/jnnp.70.4.477", "title": "Reducing everyday memory and planning problems by means of a paging system: a randomised control crossover study", "authors": "B A Wilson; H C Emslie; K Quirk; J J Evans", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11254770/", "doi": "10.1136/jnnp.70.4.477", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S008", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Reducing everyday memory and planning problems by means of a paging system: a randomised control crossover study", "authors": "B A Wilson; H C Emslie; K Quirk; J J Evans", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11254770/", "doi": "10.1136/jnnp.70.4.477", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f6796f7d825fddb82c6945a3c6e41ab43770fd1f27b6f0319fd0d5d119bdd769" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e5c6aa11120b1f2f9efc1903924118e1c1600d958030ffbd7fc639e189326f57" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0272", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1145/3411764.3445717", "title": "Does the Whole Exceed its Parts? The Effect of AI Explanations on Complementary Team Performance", "authors": "Gagan Bansal; Tongshuang Wu; Joyce Zhou; Raymond Fok; Besmira Nushi; Ece Kamar; Marco Tulio Ribeiro; Daniel S. Weld", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3411764.3445717", "doi": "10.1145/3411764.3445717", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S002", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Does the Whole Exceed its Parts? The Effect of AI Explanations on Complementary Team Performance", "authors": "Gagan Bansal; Tongshuang Wu; Joyce Zhou; Raymond Fok; Besmira Nushi; Ece Kamar; Marco Tulio Ribeiro; Daniel S. Weld", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3411764.3445717", "doi": "10.1145/3411764.3445717", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BETTER_STANDALONE_BASELINE", "COMPLEMENTARITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d6c4ca57c5d47d8a2eea5a08b38412f12829bc28be095936e87fec7b31cfc96d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8f5dd3830caaa123ca995b558d0d115111e2464145cc566f968ecbea168976cd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1145/3449287", "title": "To Trust or to Think: Cognitive Forcing Functions Can Reduce Overreliance on AI in AI-assisted Decision-making", "authors": "Zana Buçinca; Maja Barbara Malaya; Krzysztof Z. Gajos", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3449287", "doi": "10.1145/3449287", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S011", "F16-S003", "F25-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15", "FAM-16", "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S011", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "To Trust or to Think: Cognitive Forcing Functions Can Reduce Overreliance on AI in AI-assisted Decision-making", "authors": "Zana Buçinca; Maja Barbara Malaya; Krzysztof Z. Gajos", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3449287", "doi": "10.1145/3449287", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRADEOFF", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8addd6e672c623d30001ad5848053b638f69d7cb9caf8ba2e3177edcd348e7d2" }, { "source_id": "F16-S003", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "To Trust or to Think: Cognitive Forcing Functions Can Reduce Overreliance on AI in AI-assisted Decision-making", "authors": "Zana Buçinca; Maja Barbara Malaya; Krzysztof Z. Gajos", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3449287", "doi": "10.1145/3449287", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "ERROR_DETECTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRADEOFF" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9921ff1832eb1c8e6c7e23a611d71e206c6389e2f1fa119e606879cecab4e0d8" }, { "source_id": "F25-S003", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "To Trust or to Think: Cognitive Forcing Functions Can Reduce Overreliance on AI in AI-assisted Decision-making", "authors": "Zana Buçinca; Maja Barbara Malaya; Krzysztof Z. Gajos", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3449287", "doi": "10.1145/3449287", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EQUITY_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE_REDUCTION", "VERIFICATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "500e844b5f3fc2e11ade6f2bd3e0a879bfa5a7e2a5d9b078ec9d0af272f36d59" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e0f9b38e626790784aac4d02cfaede931d79725552ed18d297d32b333234ee79" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0274", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1145/3613904.3642115", "title": "Designing Multispecies Worlds for Robots, Cats, and Humans", "authors": "Eike Schneiders; Steve Benford; Alan Chamberlain; Clara Mancini; Simon Castle-Green; Victor Ngo; Ju Row Farr; Matt Adams; Nick Tandavanitj; Joel Fischer", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://research.aber.ac.uk/en/publications/designing-multispecies-worlds-for-robots-cats-and-humans/", "doi": "10.1145/3613904.3642115", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S013", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Designing Multispecies Worlds for Robots, Cats, and Humans", "authors": "Eike Schneiders; Steve Benford; Alan Chamberlain; Clara Mancini; Simon Castle-Green; Victor Ngo; Ju Row Farr; Matt Adams; Nick Tandavanitj; Joel Fischer", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://research.aber.ac.uk/en/publications/designing-multispecies-worlds-for-robots-cats-and-humans/", "doi": "10.1145/3613904.3642115", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "528934a33dfb62f81874af380e2cec619bc93e2eb682f8c6a05268d8fcd76792" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f0bf02a97927669d4bd7512ae31c947b84fde375de64cca8c15efc634025eba9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0275", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/ajpregu.00128.2013", "title": "Human inflammatory and resolving lipid mediator responses to resistance exercise and ibuprofen treatment", "authors": "James F Markworth; Luke Vella; Benjamin S Lingard; Dedreia L Tull; Thusitha W Rupasinghe; Andrew J Sinclair; Krishna Rao Maddipati; David Cameron-Smith", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24089379/", "doi": "10.1152/ajpregu.00128.2013", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S011", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Human inflammatory and resolving lipid mediator responses to resistance exercise and ibuprofen treatment", "authors": "James F Markworth; Luke Vella; Benjamin S Lingard; Dedreia L Tull; Thusitha W Rupasinghe; Andrew J Sinclair; Krishna Rao Maddipati; David Cameron-Smith", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24089379/", "doi": "10.1152/ajpregu.00128.2013", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f62e6a41763dc5009153c392a3ad32af7a8b55551d3bdc09bae3f38a61f4206b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1b957b84b2e7e19c660f4a7aac3da5c4044266e4afd372cf7fa6a34d977c8f99" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0276", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/jappl.1996.81.5.2173", "title": "Effects of concentric and eccentric training on muscle strength, cross-sectional area, and neural activation", "authors": "Elizabeth J. Higbie; Kirk J. Cureton; Gordon L. Warren III; Barry M. Prior", "year": 1996, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.1996.81.5.2173", "doi": "10.1152/jappl.1996.81.5.2173", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S008", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Effects of concentric and eccentric training on muscle strength, cross-sectional area, and neural activation", "authors": "Elizabeth J. Higbie; Kirk J. Cureton; Gordon L. Warren III; Barry M. Prior", "year": 1996, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.1996.81.5.2173", "doi": "10.1152/jappl.1996.81.5.2173", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bfc2453cf7e9c180adea468fdf69bdef0b116f410223c791d97dbe0c16ad2228" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e1a995814f8483b40e132e928325afd3d254b83c929323a57251f7dfd370d62d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0277", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/jappl.1999.87.3.1003", "title": "Familial aggregation of VO(2max) response to exercise training: results from the HERITAGE Family Study.", "authors": "Claude Bouchard; Ping An; Treva Rice; James S. Skinner; Jack H. Wilmore; Jacques Gagnon; Louis Pérusse; Arthur S. Leon; D. C. Rao", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10484570/", "doi": "10.1152/jappl.1999.87.3.1003", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S001", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Familial aggregation of VO(2max) response to exercise training: results from the HERITAGE Family Study.", "authors": "Claude Bouchard; Ping An; Treva Rice; James S. Skinner; Jack H. Wilmore; Jacques Gagnon; Louis Pérusse; Arthur S. Leon; D. C. Rao", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10484570/", "doi": "10.1152/jappl.1999.87.3.1003", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "HETEROGENEITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cadf3d4561e6273b0daa98e2a0642fd4f245dfeb65a97bb2fbc3dc80d825b32b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ec2946978dc307d8af5e202b99cfa05013aba533eae237b440149df2f1bae146" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0278", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/jappl.2001.91.1.26", "title": "Effects of isometric training on the elasticity of human tendon structures in vivo", "authors": "Keitaro Kubo; Hiroaki Kanehisa; Masamitsu Ito; Tetsuo Fukunaga", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11408409/", "doi": "10.1152/jappl.2001.91.1.26", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S001", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Effects of isometric training on the elasticity of human tendon structures in vivo", "authors": "Keitaro Kubo; Hiroaki Kanehisa; Masamitsu Ito; Tetsuo Fukunaga", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11408409/", "doi": "10.1152/jappl.2001.91.1.26", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "010ee02f592c2dde4c6c6e483850c867f0dcf1657478e12a53cc7ac30d1e01dc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5ff5211bd8e2329bd5b63202021fd360858e56449d5eb2b634935b6ea48ccd97" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0279", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00283.2002", "title": "Increased rate of force development and neural drive of human skeletal muscle following resistance training", "authors": "Per Aagaard; Erik B. Simonsen; Jesper L. Andersen; Peter Magnusson; Poul Dyhre-Poulsen", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12235031/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00283.2002", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S008", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Increased rate of force development and neural drive of human skeletal muscle following resistance training", "authors": "Per Aagaard; Erik B. Simonsen; Jesper L. Andersen; Peter Magnusson; Poul Dyhre-Poulsen", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12235031/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00283.2002", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9aa43e42e0ccad0669b4399fe84e91b9da6a3833795cf5c2a80105f1642113dd" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c97d19fabbf4d8b41a613f9c658d706ca160b1ef417f8bcc61aaf754f4a946fe" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0280", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00307.2012", "title": "Resistance exercise load does not determine training-mediated hypertrophic gains in young men", "authors": "Cameron J Mitchell; Tyler A Churchward-Venne; Daniel W D West; Nicholas A Burd; Leigh Breen; Steven K Baker; Stuart M Phillips", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22518835/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00307.2012", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S005", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Resistance exercise load does not determine training-mediated hypertrophic gains in young men", "authors": "Cameron J Mitchell; Tyler A Churchward-Venne; Daniel W D West; Nicholas A Burd; Leigh Breen; Steven K Baker; Stuart M Phillips", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22518835/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00307.2012", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "911997ad944a87e99a52a7ac73ad4e7431671ca927ae9f73b0189139d2ec3f9f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "92123a83f1c2424569a04460e5282f96c12513e5dc8c5e2e0c5b102d926b32f9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0281", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00861.2003", "title": "Strength training reduces force fluctuations during anisometric contractions of the quadriceps femoris muscles in old adults", "authors": "Brian L. Tracy; William C. Byrnes; Roger M. Enoka", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14565966/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00861.2003", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S004", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Strength training reduces force fluctuations during anisometric contractions of the quadriceps femoris muscles in old adults", "authors": "Brian L. Tracy; William C. Byrnes; Roger M. Enoka", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14565966/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00861.2003", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a4fc106fa359a116cb37bfd7b421b740be6939129b20b0aa4980aaea6b052a98" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f557c1b3b840fc23af33234848e82c4fa05b1df5a78a7c4eb6d48ec6165174e7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0282", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00917.2018", "title": "Effects of training, detraining, and retraining on strength, hypertrophy, and myonuclear number in human skeletal muscle", "authors": "Niklas Psilander; Einar Eftestøl; Kristoffer Toldnes Cumming; Inga Juvkam; Maria M Ekblom; Kerstin Sunding; Mathias Wernbom; Hans-Christer Holmberg; Björn Ekblom; Jo C Bruusgaard; Truls Raastad; Kristian Gundersen", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30991013/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00917.2018", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S015", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Effects of training, detraining, and retraining on strength, hypertrophy, and myonuclear number in human skeletal muscle", "authors": "Niklas Psilander; Einar Eftestøl; Kristoffer Toldnes Cumming; Inga Juvkam; Maria M Ekblom; Kerstin Sunding; Mathias Wernbom; Hans-Christer Holmberg; Björn Ekblom; Jo C Bruusgaard; Truls Raastad; Kristian Gundersen", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30991013/", "doi": "10.1152/japplphysiol.00917.2018", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "587ecde797d8da98c22591d0626cc161a7f22a2a881d5fe3dd442e8c49f499bc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "debefd9fb6d96ffc742dc4baf8336fc00d1008587b9d02c47b78e09d405589c3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0283", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1155/2018/5459106", "title": "Dance Training Shapes Action Perception and Its Neural Implementation within the Young and Older Adult Brain", "authors": "L P Kirsch; N Diersch; D K Sumanapala; E S Cross", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30123253/", "doi": "10.1155/2018/5459106", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S013", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Dance Training Shapes Action Perception and Its Neural Implementation within the Young and Older Adult Brain", "authors": "L P Kirsch; N Diersch; D K Sumanapala; E S Cross", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30123253/", "doi": "10.1155/2018/5459106", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "199fc3c07a6234a3390c84c152768e38aa998ba214c6c9f9870d1c5c2512b1b3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cd162b93190d0cebad98c11d72d9017aa0d5793ac8a475c8b75ffb1c77395283" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0284", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1159/000448136", "title": "Voice Range Profiles of Singing Students: The Effects of Training Duration and Institution", "authors": "Lycke H; Siupsinskiene N", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27584050", "doi": "10.1159/000448136", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S009", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Voice Range Profiles of Singing Students: The Effects of Training Duration and Institution", "authors": "Lycke H; Siupsinskiene N", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27584050", "doi": "10.1159/000448136", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "EXPERIENCE_ASSOCIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NONCAUSAL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f8cb25324943d1962eb5f9ef5301b67fda6a9c1495dd7e830edc1768412592b5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5dab7e4ef1e4fc00132e260d7e89ab8636d340470989979d55f6c4ac76ad9b26" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0285", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1161/jaha.118.010201", "title": "Aerobic Exercise Training and Inducible Inflammation: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial in Healthy, Young Adults", "authors": "Richard P Sloan; Peter A Shapiro; Paula S McKinley; Matthew Bartels; Daichi Shimbo; Vincenzo Lauriola; Wahida Karmally; Martina Pavlicova; C Jean Choi; Tse-Hwei Choo; Jennifer M Scodes; Pamela Flood; Kevin J Tracey", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30371169/", "doi": "10.1161/JAHA.118.010201", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S012", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Aerobic Exercise Training and Inducible Inflammation: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial in Healthy, Young Adults", "authors": "Richard P Sloan; Peter A Shapiro; Paula S McKinley; Matthew Bartels; Daichi Shimbo; Vincenzo Lauriola; Wahida Karmally; Martina Pavlicova; C Jean Choi; Tse-Hwei Choo; Jennifer M Scodes; Pamela Flood; Kevin J Tracey", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30371169/", "doi": "10.1161/JAHA.118.010201", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3b0028ab8d26b0f723b97ed20e99d4aea08af158fb3ed44a81f5f434afd717a0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "695a5e80179300e23ea31a3fbfac92aba5179ee4f021798da0eeaaf4f01ec004" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0286", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1162/imag_a_00383", "title": "Neurofeedback-induced desynchronization of sensorimotor rhythm elicits pre-movement downregulation of intracortical inhibition that shortens simple reaction time in humans: A double-blind, sham-controlled randomized study", "authors": "Yoshihito Muraoka; Seitaro Iwama; Junichi Ushiba", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40800510/", "doi": "10.1162/imag_a_00383", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S011", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Neurofeedback-induced desynchronization of sensorimotor rhythm elicits pre-movement downregulation of intracortical inhibition that shortens simple reaction time in humans: A double-blind, sham-controlled randomized study", "authors": "Yoshihito Muraoka; Seitaro Iwama; Junichi Ushiba", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40800510/", "doi": "10.1162/imag_a_00383", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BEHAVIOURAL_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NARROW_TASK", "SIGNAL_SELF_REGULATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4502eba3c02e518c8770fa97bf98ad13cc37bd1584403b0962e68e7c39adf5ab" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4552e93de7d6a741ad76dca3252ccf5e7b0fab355f37e0b31ba5da35b045284a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0287", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1162/qjec.2006.121.2.635", "title": "Tying Odysseus to the Mast: Evidence from a Commitment Savings Product in the Philippines", "authors": "Nava Ashraf; Dean Karlan; Wesley Yin", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://isps.yale.edu/research/publications/isps06-009", "doi": "10.1162/qjec.2006.121.2.635", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S011", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Tying Odysseus to the Mast: Evidence from a Commitment Savings Product in the Philippines", "authors": "Nava Ashraf; Dean Karlan; Wesley Yin", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://isps.yale.edu/research/publications/isps06-009", "doi": "10.1162/qjec.2006.121.2.635", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "29225f938e2e82fe9bf80e1681b3721a2932115d6d7bff479271dcaeafcf60d3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cceaa8b74b2e66771deadbe6c9955a42e9d2f6fe99de92e0b72bef8d98e8cbe8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0288", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1167/16.6.16", "title": "Two-stage perceptual learning to break visual crowding", "authors": "Z. Zhu; Z. Fan; F. Fang", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27105062/", "doi": "10.1167/16.6.16", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S005", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Two-stage perceptual learning to break visual crowding", "authors": "Z. Zhu; Z. Fan; F. Fang", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27105062/", "doi": "10.1167/16.6.16", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "42121f6fcac632a2f1fb6e0c67c56dbbeeede571f9f9433bea1f8824642d62a0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bd16f99bb001b6d791784f718f43809bf3ec5efe1579ab416d858ce931c8541c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0289", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1167/iovs.05-1292", "title": "Effect of short-term, high-dose retinol on dark adaptation in aging and early age-related maculopathy", "authors": "C. Owsley; G. McGwin; G. R. Jackson; D. C. Heimburger; C. J. Piyathilake; R. Klein; M. F. White; K. Kallies", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16565362/", "doi": "10.1167/iovs.05-1292", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S012", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Effect of short-term, high-dose retinol on dark adaptation in aging and early age-related maculopathy", "authors": "C. Owsley; G. McGwin; G. R. Jackson; D. C. Heimburger; C. J. Piyathilake; R. Klein; M. F. White; K. Kallies", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16565362/", "doi": "10.1167/iovs.05-1292", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0856b9f28eb98b01e1f7cf5ae49bf901091ae313cf746564783a3f604afbdb84" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1b75188b560bf76557cbe84f0e5d8dc7a53c356c61f423388045df53d0cf944a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0290", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1167/iovs.11-7541", "title": "Training in contrast detection improves motion perception of sinewave gratings in amblyopia", "authors": "F. Hou; C.-B. Huang; L. Tao; L. Feng; Y. Zhou; Z.-L. Lu", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21693615/", "doi": "10.1167/iovs.11-7541", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S009", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Training in contrast detection improves motion perception of sinewave gratings in amblyopia", "authors": "F. Hou; C.-B. Huang; L. Tao; L. Feng; Y. Zhou; Z.-L. Lu", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21693615/", "doi": "10.1167/iovs.11-7541", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2c1fed814bd639ec308d94e7ea69029e25d3525dcae3c5d0489484a65295853f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a3d437be23f72741b7b611f30db96d88057567f49cbc33f4a995df1993ac5187" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0291", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1167/jov.20.6.7", "title": "Dissociating electrophysiological correlates of contextual and perceptual learning in a visual search task", "authors": "C. C. Le Dantec; A. R. Seitz", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32525986/", "doi": "10.1167/jov.20.6.7", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S006", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Dissociating electrophysiological correlates of contextual and perceptual learning in a visual search task", "authors": "C. C. Le Dantec; A. R. Seitz", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32525986/", "doi": "10.1167/jov.20.6.7", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "00823ae462d32c3755715ee7da5e3e17b54b74a6b17bce3254084da0869e05dc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "504f089ae8f10f286f6ea79f3b649e670f278795a69199a729375a1bbc1a1640" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0292", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1172/jci.insight.134270", "title": "Circadian rhythm phase shifts caused by timed exercise vary with chronotype", "authors": "J Matthew Thomas; Philip A Kern; Heather M Bush; Kristen J McQuerry; W Scott Black; Jody L Clasey; Julie S Pendergast", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31895695/", "doi": "10.1172/jci.insight.134270", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S003", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Circadian rhythm phase shifts caused by timed exercise vary with chronotype", "authors": "J Matthew Thomas; Philip A Kern; Heather M Bush; Kristen J McQuerry; W Scott Black; Jody L Clasey; Julie S Pendergast", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31895695/", "doi": "10.1172/jci.insight.134270", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d19abb774021f6da2143eef574e05a4c4973ee8f52e48ab073dd43493fcb62e6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "be6afcf6269eea4a90727397b406e51fe66607771ae2e223b8f2ee4f38bf62f3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0293", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.20251008", "title": "Circadian Rhythm Stabilization App to Prevent Mood Episode Recurrence in Patients With Mood Disorders: A Multicenter, Double-Blind, Sham-Controlled, Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "J W Yeom; J Jeong; E Moon; Y M Park; M S Lee; H K Yoon; C Shin; Y Yoon; J Y Seo; S Jeon; M Choi; C H Cho; H An; T Lee; J B Lee; H J Lee", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42337416/", "doi": "10.1176/appi.ajp.20251008", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S019" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S019", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Circadian Rhythm Stabilization App to Prevent Mood Episode Recurrence in Patients With Mood Disorders: A Multicenter, Double-Blind, Sham-Controlled, Randomized Clinical Trial", "authors": "J W Yeom; J Jeong; E Moon; Y M Park; M S Lee; H K Yoon; C Shin; Y Yoon; J Y Seo; S Jeon; M Choi; C H Cho; H An; T Lee; J B Lee; H J Lee", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42337416/", "doi": "10.1176/appi.ajp.20251008", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8e9e9efa60098aa1abd4c80590b1d45959215519471cc2714d90f4be18d1baa7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cab3104e6972fd6bce515a62ca2db5554323318cc70abecbef304168665976bb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0294", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0013164420940378", "title": "Disentangling Item and Testing Effects in Inoculation Research on Online Misinformation: Solomon Revisited", "authors": "Jon Roozenbeek; Rakoen Maertens; William McClanahan; Sander van der Linden", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0013164420940378", "doi": "10.1177/0013164420940378", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S007", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Disentangling Item and Testing Effects in Inoculation Research on Online Misinformation: Solomon Revisited", "authors": "Jon Roozenbeek; Rakoen Maertens; William McClanahan; Sander van der Linden", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0013164420940378", "doi": "10.1177/0013164420940378", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ITEM_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "REPLICATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a471098758c171bb0ef414267a6f0c66719a7781fe84af526fca308eb8bf2e7f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "56c7aa86fab4d5faca45f886e593d75667ff194a58989c893645ae615304d051" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0295", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0022034510375287", "title": "Age differences in orofacial sensory thresholds", "authors": "M. W. Heft; M. E. Robinson", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20651093/", "doi": "10.1177/0022034510375287", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S009", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Age differences in orofacial sensory thresholds", "authors": "M. W. Heft; M. E. Robinson", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20651093/", "doi": "10.1177/0022034510375287", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c9bc6cb24fa155719a7f2076429dd5be2ad5c3d90fa03b45d00c015bb2b16e1a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c980c3dcb5d35590cd49054745161385459906670fb786b76a14aafacdb5f8a3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0296", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/014616702237578", "title": "Culture and Self-Concept Flexibility", "authors": "Incheol Choi; Yimoon Choi", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/014616702237578", "doi": "10.1177/014616702237578", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S007", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Culture and Self-Concept Flexibility", "authors": "Incheol Choi; Yimoon Choi", "year": 2002, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/014616702237578", "doi": "10.1177/014616702237578", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d1bf75a1363bb3be87019e37ee52cb7d3766e07aa28f5220bf77754521a35556" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5bf491269e8c80ba5cda04327f8d5ac260dbc068b401089a1bc560d4e7dab78e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0297", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0146167204271308", "title": "The Interplay Between Goal Intentions and Implementation Intentions", "authors": "Paschal Sheeran; Thomas L. Webb; Peter M. Gollwitzer", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167204271308", "doi": "10.1177/0146167204271308", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S010", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "The Interplay Between Goal Intentions and Implementation Intentions", "authors": "Paschal Sheeran; Thomas L. Webb; Peter M. Gollwitzer", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167204271308", "doi": "10.1177/0146167204271308", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4bf26a175fbcd9915cd0043e1eff4c896a42a86776ded2a3c1cd7cbf681b0248" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "46ce8e5542a910b98c1e043531e1f54fa4e7b0bf63a34877a82f9f9b9971ac78" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0298", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/01461672251375500", "title": "Do People Listen to Cassandra? Persuasion and Accuracy in Geopolitical Forecasts", "authors": "Yhonatan S. Shemesh; Avi Gamoran; David Leiser; Michael Gilead", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41105022/", "doi": "10.1177/01461672251375500", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S008", "F18-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15", "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S008", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Do People Listen to Cassandra? Persuasion and Accuracy in Geopolitical Forecasts", "authors": "Yhonatan S. Shemesh; Avi Gamoran; David Leiser; Michael Gilead", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41105022/", "doi": "10.1177/01461672251375500", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "INFORMATION_HARM", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1ce434be16421d05ef14406ca03e1a9eb9f7ee65ae00f845602b00eefad170db" }, { "source_id": "F18-S001", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Do People Listen to Cassandra? Persuasion and Accuracy in Geopolitical Forecasts", "authors": "Shemesh YS; Gamoran A; Leiser D; Gilead M", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41105022", "doi": "10.1177/01461672251375500", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCURACY_DECOUPLING", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "daffbd9ce28f05b48b32170f212587c59342371b413b8a6475ac63b5105eedb0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "15d78e4b38ddc75cf8a7339d5febd7ade0d178e99baf6802c21944512829bad4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0299", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0146167295214009", "title": "Group Versus Individual Training and Group Performance: The Mediating Role of Transactive Memory", "authors": "Diane Wei Liang; Richard Moreland; Linda Argote", "year": 1995, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167295214009", "doi": "10.1177/0146167295214009", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S012", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Group Versus Individual Training and Group Performance: The Mediating Role of Transactive Memory", "authors": "Diane Wei Liang; Richard Moreland; Linda Argote", "year": 1995, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0146167295214009", "doi": "10.1177/0146167295214009", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d3d2cc643f4e4d3bd35eca4cc46095f52b7880413ff96acc629927bd0e0e8922" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a893cd02e840610c702af47a41e69dbc1fdb3ec77f7fa1b54acf682112f85185" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0300", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/01640275251321813", "title": "Promoting Successful Cognitive Aging Through Observational Drawing: A Feasibility Study", "authors": "M M Vodyanyk; S M Jaeggi", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40022660/", "doi": "10.1177/01640275251321813", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S014", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Promoting Successful Cognitive Aging Through Observational Drawing: A Feasibility Study", "authors": "M M Vodyanyk; S M Jaeggi", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40022660/", "doi": "10.1177/01640275251321813", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ffab4af6bdd34e384b35c9046beb4e8e7a1df99a337399f823bef141efc040a9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8cf66fde5b391abc08d548695321a86402627d2d716232255b2173ae1655b0da" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0301", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/02537176221141583", "title": "Empathic Accuracy Task: Indian Adaptation and Validation", "authors": "Preeti Sinha; Urvakhsh M. Mehta; Anuradha S. N.; Prerna Srivastava", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37772149/", "doi": "10.1177/02537176221141583", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S011", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Empathic Accuracy Task: Indian Adaptation and Validation", "authors": "Preeti Sinha; Urvakhsh M. Mehta; Anuradha S. N.; Prerna Srivastava", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37772149/", "doi": "10.1177/02537176221141583", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CULTURAL_VALIDATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d9a2afec94e8cb8b08531e46eb9fc4ee2b840b95212eae51d9314cb637529115" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7ff1e950b652d5a1a7ee6ac6b36f9af415f9cf9d19c95412df2053a5b0a7b20a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0302", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0269215514534087", "title": "Task-specific balance training improves self-assessed function in community-dwelling older adults with balance deficits and fear of falling: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Kirsti Skavberg Roaldsen; Alexandra Halvarsson; Theres Sahlström; Agneta Ståhle", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24895381/", "doi": "10.1177/0269215514534087", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S005", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Task-specific balance training improves self-assessed function in community-dwelling older adults with balance deficits and fear of falling: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Kirsti Skavberg Roaldsen; Alexandra Halvarsson; Theres Sahlström; Agneta Ståhle", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24895381/", "doi": "10.1177/0269215514534087", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a7b99affeb3aaf7ccc62ff6e83eaf6240e4e0889a79e0a3a2bb30c3f4c89704a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f95db5832066344df6cb06a934f5df6f2e485a8771efb841f9c35b607f6b64db" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0303", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0272989x10369008", "title": "Effect of Adding a Values Clarification Exercise to a Decision Aid on Heart Disease Prevention: A Randomized Trial", "authors": "Stacey L. Sheridan; Jennifer M. Griffith; Lindy Behrend; Ziya Gizlice; Jianwen Cai; Michael P. Pignone", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3996504/", "doi": "10.1177/0272989X10369008", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S013", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Effect of Adding a Values Clarification Exercise to a Decision Aid on Heart Disease Prevention: A Randomized Trial", "authors": "Stacey L. Sheridan; Jennifer M. Griffith; Lindy Behrend; Ziya Gizlice; Jianwen Cai; Michael P. Pignone", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3996504/", "doi": "10.1177/0272989X10369008", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "146be9e2b91927345386ea22d7b840756dbff1b64be0e4730aed4e0567248583" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "cd9eb2f1593ae99b0a4c0461dde24472597e935fe1ddd054aa72a348e06dde8d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0304", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0272989x11434601", "title": "The impact of explicit values clarification exercises in a patient decision aid emerges after the decision is actually made: evidence from a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Deb Feldman-Stewart; Christine Tong; Rob Siemens; Shabbir Alibhai; Tom Pickles; John Robinson; Michael D. Brundage", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22287534/", "doi": "10.1177/0272989X11434601", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S001", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "The impact of explicit values clarification exercises in a patient decision aid emerges after the decision is actually made: evidence from a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Deb Feldman-Stewart; Christine Tong; Rob Siemens; Shabbir Alibhai; Tom Pickles; John Robinson; Michael D. Brundage", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22287534/", "doi": "10.1177/0272989X11434601", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fdad39b18b3701aebf91ed6da7e4706314d564d3d5379a5cf15f7b0247903685" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "69cbf2ecf737502447efc4937e7b3e5a678ebaabaa7c0ec87f71ef050d5f72ee" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0305", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797612443830", "title": "Feelings into words: contributions of language to exposure therapy", "authors": "K Kircanski; M D Lieberman; M G Craske", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22902568/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797612443830", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S014", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Feelings into words: contributions of language to exposure therapy", "authors": "K Kircanski; M D Lieberman; M G Craske", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22902568/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797612443830", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "053f21e324c652d13c13fcf3cbe0051bb00fd05d7032ccbc5cc60bbca8f66de6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "64d9268f7c4de42bf49446d01d141c3700d4224c48ca1831cbf62fbeb0d0e47c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0306", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797613491968", "title": "In the eye of the beholder: eye contact increases resistance to persuasion", "authors": "Chen FS; Minson JA; Schöne M; Heinrichs M", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24068114", "doi": "10.1177/0956797613491968", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S008", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "In the eye of the beholder: eye contact increases resistance to persuasion", "authors": "Chen FS; Minson JA; Schöne M; Heinrichs M", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24068114", "doi": "10.1177/0956797613491968", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTEXT_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c7edae3019ab7870363e5ff2cbd704dead88e69bd419fa5777ec7704aaec6cc0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "37308d54cd6b63e525721305a4cbb33a4c4bec33f603723a406ba4b0ca6ca66e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0307", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797613504221", "title": "The Ultra-Rare-Item Effect", "authors": "Stephen R. Mitroff; Adam T. Biggs", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797613504221", "doi": "10.1177/0956797613504221", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S008", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "The Ultra-Rare-Item Effect", "authors": "Stephen R. Mitroff; Adam T. Biggs", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797613504221", "doi": "10.1177/0956797613504221", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3b6e6d34b9b2907512572d01578bf5a1f432835e91de7169e25d6ffd9458853d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a9c83634928be8f44abc9b0a61c96292c52530c0d9633a283c798b7665a4b8e0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0308", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797613517239", "title": "Cultural relativity in perceiving emotion from vocalizations", "authors": "Gendron M; Roberson D; van der Vyver JM; Barrett LF", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24501109", "doi": "10.1177/0956797613517239", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S007", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Cultural relativity in perceiving emotion from vocalizations", "authors": "Gendron M; Roberson D; van der Vyver JM; Barrett LF", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24501109", "doi": "10.1177/0956797613517239", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CULTURAL_VARIABILITY", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "69eac25d014da273e9c0d83d9196bd8819401c2c68ca01db8ec0702f2e9c93a9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d93a384b2a37ba462b435507937fbe8cd2d1615cd3c1f9ce91c767ff3383be89" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0309", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797615578863", "title": "Getting Over It: Long-Lasting Effects of Emotion Regulation on Amygdala Response", "authors": "B T Denny; M C Inhoff; N Zerubavel; L Davachi; K N Ochsner", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26231911/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797615578863", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S004", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Getting Over It: Long-Lasting Effects of Emotion Regulation on Amygdala Response", "authors": "B T Denny; M C Inhoff; N Zerubavel; L Davachi; K N Ochsner", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26231911/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797615578863", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7e43bd8184bceac87062a18843f919c3c5c6a8164ee9ac22c6bf9ecc92e9346a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "51ef0f2344213fca28746251c1119f6c754888d9ed26447b20acdfd876676074" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0310", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797618773357", "title": "The Nonlinear Development of Emotion Differentiation: Granular Emotional Experience Is Low in Adolescence", "authors": "E C Nook; S F Sasse; H K Lambert; K A McLaughlin; L H Somerville", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29878880/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797618773357", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S001", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "The Nonlinear Development of Emotion Differentiation: Granular Emotional Experience Is Low in Adolescence", "authors": "E C Nook; S F Sasse; H K Lambert; K A McLaughlin; L H Somerville", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29878880/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797618773357", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cfe1e219bc641698b0dfb6e28c655e923d299b998a21123f22b0d4002ea6f466" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e663084cd2d55a80f26a8308c3313da08e1801a2b513e2b50961017a6c46ed3d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0311", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/0956797618803644", "title": "Long-Term Memory for Haptically Explored Objects: Fidelity, Durability, Incidental Encoding, and Cross-Modal Transfer", "authors": "F. Hutmacher; C. Kuhbandner", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30376424/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797618803644", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S006", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Long-Term Memory for Haptically Explored Objects: Fidelity, Durability, Incidental Encoding, and Cross-Modal Transfer", "authors": "F. Hutmacher; C. Kuhbandner", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30376424/", "doi": "10.1177/0956797618803644", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3a24a8f4bfe59eb4ec3b37c2b6b54263b64ae81a83b8f14bdb777136d097eb50" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "14c4e26288556799e4c980cb3de312b632ef3848440fd151c3f093f6f1da41b3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0312", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/09567976261453813", "title": "Boosting Media Literacy Using Lateral Reading and Online Search Interventions", "authors": "Lisa Oswald; Anastasia Kozyreva; Stefan M. Herzog; Pietro Leonardo Nickl; Ralph Hertwig", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/09567976261453813", "doi": "10.1177/09567976261453813", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S004", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Boosting Media Literacy Using Lateral Reading and Online Search Interventions", "authors": "Lisa Oswald; Anastasia Kozyreva; Stefan M. Herzog; Pietro Leonardo Nickl; Ralph Hertwig", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/09567976261453813", "doi": "10.1177/09567976261453813", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "be0815ffcd7b5dc331e9f9881d2a20fdf39c5530b2e50596811ac33a34ec5f14" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "dc15c177b258610502de794fc2ec52652283972a8d98d5a2a0cf200b7a0cc957" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0313", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/1046496408317794", "title": "Guided Team Self-Correction: Impacts on Team Mental Models, Processes, and Effectiveness", "authors": "Kimberly A. Smith-Jentsch; Janis A. Cannon-Bowers; Scott I. Tannenbaum; Eduardo Salas", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1046496408317794", "doi": "10.1177/1046496408317794", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S002", "F30-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24", "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S002", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Guided Team Self-Correction: Impacts on Team Mental Models, Processes, and Effectiveness", "authors": "Kimberly A. Smith-Jentsch; Janis A. Cannon-Bowers; Scott I. Tannenbaum; Eduardo Salas", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1046496408317794", "doi": "10.1177/1046496408317794", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TEAM_LEARNING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7ec18120322a76240bc4d1ca11e90ef0bcdda908060f90540192f060204d3764" }, { "source_id": "F30-S002", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Guided Team Self-Correction: Impacts on Team Mental Models, Processes, and Effectiveness", "authors": "Kimberly A. Smith-Jentsch; Janis A. Cannon-Bowers; Scott I. Tannenbaum; Eduardo Salas", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/1046496408317794", "doi": "10.1177/1046496408317794", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "322e49c90023e0334d9d52bb5820497b921db516bd45df6d157ff52da5572b72" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "34d12f43751742c2729bc7857cc703a50fa384e7e7139a11fd886241eb489ed8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0314", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/1352458514565959", "title": "Home-based training to improve manual dexterity in patients with multiple sclerosis: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C P Kamm; H P Mattle; R M Müri; M R Heldner; V Blatter; S Bartlome; J Lüthy; D Imboden; G Pedrazzini; S Bohlhalter; R Hilfiker; T Vanbellingen", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25623246/", "doi": "10.1177/1352458514565959", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S003", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Home-based training to improve manual dexterity in patients with multiple sclerosis: A randomized controlled trial", "authors": "C P Kamm; H P Mattle; R M Müri; M R Heldner; V Blatter; S Bartlome; J Lüthy; D Imboden; G Pedrazzini; S Bohlhalter; R Hilfiker; T Vanbellingen", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25623246/", "doi": "10.1177/1352458514565959", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a9723e85eb0fa04fbccf65d19f684e5a040b7beaa59a3ca8a691725f5620e7a9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "24b73c9305d54f64016cfcdcf5e40c7bc96850f08b096b4eb23357f1a99715dc" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0315", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/1545968311402508", "title": "Bimanual training and constraint-induced movement therapy in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized trial", "authors": "A M Gordon; Y C Hung; M Brandao; C L Ferre; H C Kuo; K Friel; E Petra; A Chinnan; J R Charles", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21700924/", "doi": "10.1177/1545968311402508", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S009", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Bimanual training and constraint-induced movement therapy in children with hemiplegic cerebral palsy: a randomized trial", "authors": "A M Gordon; Y C Hung; M Brandao; C L Ferre; H C Kuo; K Friel; E Petra; A Chinnan; J R Charles", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21700924/", "doi": "10.1177/1545968311402508", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9e9418b4e8d21a2d8034af64107fc9cb5d740b05a110b5f4804268a085fe187e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8206e7dadd8a00a049d21644be764a7a0ed9695d1efae53fb60d9a6e07c98e7c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0316", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/15459683241248088", "title": "Efficacy of Walking Adaptability Training on Walking Capacity in Ambulatory People With Motor Incomplete Spinal Cord Injury: A Multicenter Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Eline Zwijgers; Rosanne B van Dijsseldonk; Marije Vos-van der Hulst; Juha M Hijmans; Alexander C H Geurts; Noël L W Keijsers", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38661122/", "doi": "10.1177/15459683241248088", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S014", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Efficacy of Walking Adaptability Training on Walking Capacity in Ambulatory People With Motor Incomplete Spinal Cord Injury: A Multicenter Pragmatic Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Eline Zwijgers; Rosanne B van Dijsseldonk; Marije Vos-van der Hulst; Juha M Hijmans; Alexander C H Geurts; Noël L W Keijsers", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38661122/", "doi": "10.1177/15459683241248088", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5e90a06809df72ec2192640880d27f69edb1bd5fcd6d9fa9dbb084d60cbfa418" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8b19fd510305b28c9e569983ac547738b578f303a9d4ec868bf18b1944d08e4d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0317", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/1747021820935776", "title": "Absolute pitch learning in adults speaking non-tonal languages", "authors": "Y. K. Wong; V. S. H. Ngan; L. Y. T. Cheung; A. C.-N. Wong", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/1747021820935776", "doi": "10.1177/1747021820935776", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S007", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Absolute pitch learning in adults speaking non-tonal languages", "authors": "Y. K. Wong; V. S. H. Ngan; L. Y. T. Cheung; A. C.-N. Wong", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/1747021820935776", "doi": "10.1177/1747021820935776", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a24dbdbff3de23acbd69ffdf9e3cd5642b93d62c212160790b3e5f0707087be8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "07fcde8dc04f84fda0d7435c3db320ddb7a0b2be283af1e4a9578c8cbd58f92e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0318", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/17470218221094306", "title": "Does interpersonal liking lead to interpersonal synchrony in musical contexts?", "authors": "Melton ZJ; Chaffin R; Kangas-Dick K; Marsh KL; Demos AP", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35361001", "doi": "10.1177/17470218221094306", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S007", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Does interpersonal liking lead to interpersonal synchrony in musical contexts?", "authors": "Melton ZJ; Chaffin R; Kangas-Dick K; Marsh KL; Demos AP", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35361001", "doi": "10.1177/17470218221094306", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "PERCEPTION_VS_PERFORMANCE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "77a8081601d0e35b2ae577db190bb34099162046f9283cc530f4cbc554faf960" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2f1479106c255b75510127a4819d0cbfb74ccb4b77850081097b1177f543e075" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0319", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/19485506231213775", "title": "Increases in Intellectual Humility From Guided Conversations Are Greater When People Perceive Affiliation With Conversation Partners", "authors": "Katherine R. Thorson; Lindsey A. Beck; Sarah Ketay; Keith M. Welker", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/19485506231213775", "doi": "10.1177/19485506231213775", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S015", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Increases in Intellectual Humility From Guided Conversations Are Greater When People Perceive Affiliation With Conversation Partners", "authors": "Katherine R. Thorson; Lindsey A. Beck; Sarah Ketay; Keith M. Welker", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/19485506231213775", "doi": "10.1177/19485506231213775", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SOCIAL_CONFIGURATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "319c0bb10daea6e77c9c646b5297b3b6bc90d9e7f2a9321638ff350998606e26" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "13a801f299ee5973d72559321b45c317ef9d77a94c09369651ea9022c34b1c7a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0320", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/2055563619837882", "title": "Do prices vary with purchase volumes in healthcare contracts?", "authors": "Robert B. Handfield; Jaikishen Venkitaraman; Shweta Murthy", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2055563619837882", "doi": "10.1177/2055563619837882", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S018" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S018", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Do prices vary with purchase volumes in healthcare contracts?", "authors": "Robert B. Handfield; Jaikishen Venkitaraman; Shweta Murthy", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2055563619837882", "doi": "10.1177/2055563619837882", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9675b756a822e7c21719fd70d1ce8c659ef2b2e638c5e494a8ad594c494545cc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "15e6c786817483365a693a53cf7173d27f6506210eb66d43cf603131ee89f641" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0321", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/2059204318794369", "title": "Rhythm Workers: A music-based serious game for training rhythm skills", "authors": "Valentin Bégel; Antoine Seilles; Simone Dalla Bella", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/2059204318794369", "doi": "10.1177/2059204318794369", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S002", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Rhythm Workers: A music-based serious game for training rhythm skills", "authors": "Valentin Bégel; Antoine Seilles; Simone Dalla Bella", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/2059204318794369", "doi": "10.1177/2059204318794369", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CEILING_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fe09a12508ee54ab65156669ba7900c59b5c7bf43c84477d5e69de0c21573f2b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "806bdb36ed8065609f188409ab5ea1e1969d42947483054d22a7c948f7f8090a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0322", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1177/2372732215600886", "title": "Debiasing Decisions", "authors": "Carey K. Morewedge; Haewon Yoon; Irene Scopelliti; Carl W. Symborski; James H. Korris; Karim S. Kassam", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/2372732215600886", "doi": "10.1177/2372732215600886", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S006", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Debiasing Decisions", "authors": "Carey K. Morewedge; Haewon Yoon; Irene Scopelliti; Carl W. Symborski; James H. Korris; Karim S. Kassam", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/2372732215600886", "doi": "10.1177/2372732215600886", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7a1795760326ecdad57bb5da17d3cc0e2d17e43b25bcfb11ee74f596a6564c8e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "431f50a5b48ab56fea76656a19b0ebf9a7b774f20d8eaf2045af5f64b921d532" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0323", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/1471-2474-15-59", "title": "Tactile acuity training for patients with chronic low back pain: a pilot randomised controlled trial", "authors": "C. Ryan; N. Harland; B. T. Drew; D. Martin", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24571855/", "doi": "10.1186/1471-2474-15-59", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S002", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Tactile acuity training for patients with chronic low back pain: a pilot randomised controlled trial", "authors": "C. Ryan; N. Harland; B. T. Drew; D. Martin", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24571855/", "doi": "10.1186/1471-2474-15-59", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c4eab14792f764f95b03ecd1b8f32c657a1973886cc75a70a3feba1ae7bed872" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a22d518c898ae5f09343137bd56dda8837b4d7a5a1f6e6483352950320697607" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0324", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12877-019-1029-y", "title": "Effect of interactive cognitive-motor training on eye-hand coordination and cognitive function in older adults", "authors": "P T Chan; W C Chang; H L Chiu; C C Kao; D Liu; H Chu; K R Chou", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30691404/", "doi": "10.1186/s12877-019-1029-y", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S007", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Effect of interactive cognitive-motor training on eye-hand coordination and cognitive function in older adults", "authors": "P T Chan; W C Chang; H L Chiu; C C Kao; D Liu; H Chu; K R Chou", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30691404/", "doi": "10.1186/s12877-019-1029-y", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "153f831c857abc9bc328b1dddc1b638c1377838930e27c5477ad3f42cf220a2a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "714da77cdf6ddb2ebdccd1b807087501cd934d15b5e9247e35782eea683aaa30" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0325", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12884-014-0367-1", "title": "Team training in obstetric and neonatal emergencies using highly realistic simulation in Mexico: impact on process indicators", "authors": "Dilys Walker; Susanna Cohen; Jimena Fritz; Marisela Olvera; Hector Lamadrid-Figueroa; Jessica Greenberg Cowan; Dolores Gonzalez Hernandez; Julia C. Dettinger; Jenifer O. Fahey", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25409895/", "doi": "10.1186/s12884-014-0367-1", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S010", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Team training in obstetric and neonatal emergencies using highly realistic simulation in Mexico: impact on process indicators", "authors": "Dilys Walker; Susanna Cohen; Jimena Fritz; Marisela Olvera; Hector Lamadrid-Figueroa; Jessica Greenberg Cowan; Dolores Gonzalez Hernandez; Julia C. Dettinger; Jenifer O. Fahey", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25409895/", "doi": "10.1186/s12884-014-0367-1", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "IMPLEMENTATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9a4abd864fa0f19b672d2bba41f5febac616501f7275124b59daca7c401c50ea" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "16b2bfe1ef1526b3c3381eef18f5ffac229cc22981ee2d027fb1d551fd916e4d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0326", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12889-019-7658-4", "title": "'Teach-back' is a simple communication tool that improves disease knowledge in people with chronic hepatitis B - a pilot randomized controlled study", "authors": "Tran S; Bennett G; Richmond J; Nguyen T; Ryan M; Hong T; Howell J; Demediuk B; Desmond P; Bell S; Thompson A", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31647001", "doi": "10.1186/s12889-019-7658-4", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S005", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "'Teach-back' is a simple communication tool that improves disease knowledge in people with chronic hepatitis B - a pilot randomized controlled study", "authors": "Tran S; Bennett G; Richmond J; Nguyen T; Ryan M; Hong T; Howell J; Demediuk B; Desmond P; Bell S; Thompson A", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31647001", "doi": "10.1186/s12889-019-7658-4", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LANGUAGE_ACCESS_LIMIT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ce987b8cee3e19c242214876fe16b6232697461d21dac5df5fbc38da170e4c51" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c62b12549929cc7c281180e6d6f8944438f57855c570d7df45beec1dee51ac69" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0327", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12889-025-21340-3", "title": "The relationship between environmental literacy, ecological footprint awareness, and environmental behavior in adults", "authors": "Mehmet Salih Yildirim; Ayşe Elkoca; Gönül Gökçay; Dursun Alper Yilmaz; Metin Yıldız", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39930452/", "doi": "10.1186/s12889-025-21340-3", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S007", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "The relationship between environmental literacy, ecological footprint awareness, and environmental behavior in adults", "authors": "Mehmet Salih Yildirim; Ayşe Elkoca; Gönül Gökçay; Dursun Alper Yilmaz; Metin Yıldız", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39930452/", "doi": "10.1186/s12889-025-21340-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "edf550b65bb34621136ef586cc2b85a3d6cc7246f01da9139079a11b8fa14ca6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ebd33ed4d7943f12a39b181f03017834d8d019c6b3096543009efe7dfd1e1b2c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0328", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12893-021-01385-y", "title": "Transference of skills in robotic vs. laparoscopic simulation: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "J J Kanitra; N Khogali-Jakary; S B Gambhir; A T Davis; M Hollis; C Moon; R Gupta; P S Haan; C Anderson; D Collier; D Henry; S Kavuturu", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34711220/", "doi": "10.1186/s12893-021-01385-y", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S011", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Transference of skills in robotic vs. laparoscopic simulation: a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "J J Kanitra; N Khogali-Jakary; S B Gambhir; A T Davis; M Hollis; C Moon; R Gupta; P S Haan; C Anderson; D Collier; D Henry; S Kavuturu", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34711220/", "doi": "10.1186/s12893-021-01385-y", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6ffae77c445c2b5d114d908df4f45415ffdba8ec51a44271d5232ef06b394322" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "337d80d83520df48a825d4fc747f972c2f509c21f81b11a651b6a897faf6e43c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0329", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12909-024-05998-8", "title": "Augmented reality visualization for ultrasound-guided interventions: a pilot randomized crossover trial to assess trainee performance and cognitive load", "authors": "S C Liao; S C Shao; S Y Gao; E C Lai", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39334275/", "doi": "10.1186/s12909-024-05998-8", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S005", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Augmented reality visualization for ultrasound-guided interventions: a pilot randomized crossover trial to assess trainee performance and cognitive load", "authors": "S C Liao; S C Shao; S Y Gao; E C Lai", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39334275/", "doi": "10.1186/s12909-024-05998-8", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1140e0762943623cec8a3cc5eff1ea38b74c21146de61ac9376d2d6b44437cfb" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "578647c1e6b8ad79c1cd3aac8f606dfc0094287478566405fd8ff1aa952ff9b0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0330", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12909-024-06017-6", "title": "Zoom Improv is accessible and enhances medical student empathy", "authors": "Amjadi MF; Kociubuk J; Hollnagel F; Tsenkova VK; Zelenski AB", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39334240", "doi": "10.1186/s12909-024-06017-6", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S010", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Zoom Improv is accessible and enhances medical student empathy", "authors": "Amjadi MF; Kociubuk J; Hollnagel F; Tsenkova VK; Zelenski AB", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39334240", "doi": "10.1186/s12909-024-06017-6", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SELF_REPORT_BOUNDARY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8521fd7d289108bda0c4a2060f53c695c301d578035afd42d10d99703d85db5e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "51fc2c8a994b3388f566cfe41525efa250a38af777768ba131b4c223d6f8fecd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0331", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12984-017-0320-4", "title": "Restoration of motor control and proprioceptive and cutaneous sensation in humans with prior upper-limb amputation via multiple Utah Slanted Electrode Arrays implanted in residual peripheral arm nerves", "authors": "Suzanne Wendelken; David M Page; Tyler Davis; Heather A C Wark; David T Kluger; Christopher Duncan; David J Warren; Douglas T Hutchinson; Gregory A Clark", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29178940/", "doi": "10.1186/s12984-017-0320-4", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S010", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Restoration of motor control and proprioceptive and cutaneous sensation in humans with prior upper-limb amputation via multiple Utah Slanted Electrode Arrays implanted in residual peripheral arm nerves", "authors": "Suzanne Wendelken; David M Page; Tyler Davis; Heather A C Wark; David T Kluger; Christopher Duncan; David J Warren; Douglas T Hutchinson; Gregory A Clark", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29178940/", "doi": "10.1186/s12984-017-0320-4", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2d1b963f8ea03ba0991dbd0d684306881bc4883bc928960bedd03eebd4ae64cc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d2f8faf8fade40e06490ae3cc6061e04e28449428671b37f7bdb46b868c20d7b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0332", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s12984-023-01158-z", "title": "Exoskeleton-based training improves walking independence in incomplete spinal cord injury patients: results from a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Ángel Gil-Agudo; Álvaro Megía-García; José Luis Pons; Isabel Sinovas-Alonso; Natalia Comino-Suárez; Vicente Lozano-Berrio; Antonio J. Del-Ama", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36964574/", "doi": "10.1186/s12984-023-01158-z", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S008", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Exoskeleton-based training improves walking independence in incomplete spinal cord injury patients: results from a randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Ángel Gil-Agudo; Álvaro Megía-García; José Luis Pons; Isabel Sinovas-Alonso; Natalia Comino-Suárez; Vicente Lozano-Berrio; Antonio J. Del-Ama", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36964574/", "doi": "10.1186/s12984-023-01158-z", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_SECONDARY_OUTCOMES", "REHABILITATION", "WALKING_INDEPENDENCE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7ce26a5e7b9807e4c3fb6bd8d7e0838dce943eaaf94c08f1646cd2db3fa43cf4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f76aa4275e548f44110443bcbcb07e6d4a25be2b7e0904a0245bec25c56d3462" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0333", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s13030-020-00179-7", "title": "Effects of interoceptive training on decision making, anxiety, and somatic symptoms", "authors": "A. Sugawara; Y. Terasawa; R. Katsunuma; A. Sekiguchi", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32206084/", "doi": "10.1186/s13030-020-00179-7", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S024" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S024", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Effects of interoceptive training on decision making, anxiety, and somatic symptoms", "authors": "A. Sugawara; Y. Terasawa; R. Katsunuma; A. Sekiguchi", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32206084/", "doi": "10.1186/s13030-020-00179-7", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ca76c2b48e2432f28348bc5a6a3a00e583be4bcf9ee34aa095a3baa02c558218" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ff4267ad70db8e2641e4404fc907a6c6f719976dbe7e0f214fa681e48d9fd7b6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0334", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s13102-019-0146-4", "title": "Six weeks of balance or power training induce no generalizable improvements in balance performance in healthy young adults", "authors": "Louis-Solal Giboin; Markus Gruber; Andreas Kramer", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31719991/", "doi": "10.1186/s13102-019-0146-4", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S006", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Six weeks of balance or power training induce no generalizable improvements in balance performance in healthy young adults", "authors": "Louis-Solal Giboin; Markus Gruber; Andreas Kramer", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31719991/", "doi": "10.1186/s13102-019-0146-4", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "be4840f4e6ae9b7ab55a78463e556c8c07389754926d41b458500ac4f6e35542" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2831045ba4e6e6b556a39ddfeabb7f2027ed71d5963f6428df52934e36abed12" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0335", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s40345-026-00418-w", "title": "The effect of smartphone-based monitoring and treatment including clinical feedback in progressed bipolar disorder: the SmartBipolar trial randomised controlled parallel-group trial", "authors": "M Faurholt-Jepsen; A Risom; M S Dyreholt; N B Kyster; E M Christensen; B Smidt; U Knorr; K Brøndmark; A Mathiesen; D Cululejevic; R Sjaelland; H Nørbak-Emig; L L Sponsor; D Mardosas; J D Bukh; T V Heller; N Iversen; M Vinberg; E Budtz-Jørgensen; L V Kessing", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41865316/", "doi": "10.1186/s40345-026-00418-w", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S012", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "The effect of smartphone-based monitoring and treatment including clinical feedback in progressed bipolar disorder: the SmartBipolar trial randomised controlled parallel-group trial", "authors": "M Faurholt-Jepsen; A Risom; M S Dyreholt; N B Kyster; E M Christensen; B Smidt; U Knorr; K Brøndmark; A Mathiesen; D Cululejevic; R Sjaelland; H Nørbak-Emig; L L Sponsor; D Mardosas; J D Bukh; T V Heller; N Iversen; M Vinberg; E Budtz-Jørgensen; L V Kessing", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41865316/", "doi": "10.1186/s40345-026-00418-w", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "31d3ceefa655204357adee46f404109aa4a485e63ba31609b2a1ee308cae4918" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "950c9e0ec5cf2a1301abef7765b9e2d86d5a7d4ff173ff2c82f2d5f8ff40c34f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0336", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s41235-021-00347-5", "title": "Causal theory error in college students’ understanding of science studies", "authors": "Colleen M. Seifert; Michael Harrington; Audrey L. Michal; Priti Shah", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35022946/", "doi": "10.1186/s41235-021-00347-5", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S004", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Causal theory error in college students’ understanding of science studies", "authors": "Colleen M. Seifert; Michael Harrington; Audrey L. Michal; Priti Shah", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35022946/", "doi": "10.1186/s41235-021-00347-5", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f328f9d49d33b009292d17b4fd2f8f9b7d827016478e1f5f20467a0187168249" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3df647788abd216ed286daf441be9095cf738387b556be46c9597f75be475c66" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0337", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1186/s41235-023-00529-3", "title": "The impact of AI errors in a human-in-the-loop process", "authors": "Ujué Agudo; Karlos G. Liberal; Miren Arrese; Helena Matute", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1186/s41235-023-00529-3", "doi": "10.1186/s41235-023-00529-3", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S012", "F25-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15", "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S012", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "The impact of AI errors in a human-in-the-loop process", "authors": "Ujué Agudo; Karlos G. Liberal; Miren Arrese; Helena Matute", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1186/s41235-023-00529-3", "doi": "10.1186/s41235-023-00529-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "ORDER_EFFECT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "48158900c237cc354100e181a14690de610421dde848306fecb07154191bc5f8" }, { "source_id": "F25-S008", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "The impact of AI errors in a human-in-the-loop process", "authors": "Ujué Agudo; Karlos G. Liberal; Miren Arrese; Helena Matute", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38185767/", "doi": "10.1186/s41235-023-00529-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AUTOMATION_BIAS", "FALLBACK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SEQUENCING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "37f96128cce595b5ba94acb8a966fa883fd9f35b25910765ac012e0918d7c3d9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "61e38e441e60b661e5c9e8d39e00e1ae71141c5955224b3fe13e4c84438d3f1f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0338", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1249/01.mss.0000155700.72702.76", "title": "Effect of distance feedback on pacing strategy and perceived exertion during cycling", "authors": "Yumna Albertus; Ross Tucker; Alan St Clair Gibson; Estelle V. Lambert; David B. Hampson; Timothy D. Noakes", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15741846/", "doi": "10.1249/01.mss.0000155700.72702.76", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S011", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Effect of distance feedback on pacing strategy and perceived exertion during cycling", "authors": "Yumna Albertus; Ross Tucker; Alan St Clair Gibson; Estelle V. Lambert; David B. Hampson; Timothy D. Noakes", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15741846/", "doi": "10.1249/01.mss.0000155700.72702.76", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3091a175bfbcbae07a18f3d5b96f60ac789a4c9ed0726cdd884b9c09535b4442" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d1ab9538e4cf0bee1784df84f9a3e7650830328f38642b39960709a0d654c2c7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0339", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1249/mss.0000000000001036", "title": "Seven Passive 1-h Hypoxia Exposures Do Not Prevent AMS in Susceptible Individuals", "authors": "M Faulhaber; E Pocecco; H Gatterer; M Niedermeier; M Huth; T Dünnwald; V Menz; L Bernardi; M Burtscher", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27414687/", "doi": "10.1249/MSS.0000000000001036", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S008", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Seven Passive 1-h Hypoxia Exposures Do Not Prevent AMS in Susceptible Individuals", "authors": "M Faulhaber; E Pocecco; H Gatterer; M Niedermeier; M Huth; T Dünnwald; V Menz; L Bernardi; M Burtscher", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27414687/", "doi": "10.1249/MSS.0000000000001036", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "644b551de6455a3475a885116a11a6ba86b3d2355fe16b542c1f1dc803bc7ca3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1e37923ccf09c1640aa7945c1f125cd9c66897d7b548cda26f9f891494dd15ed" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0340", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1249/mss.0b013e318207c15d", "title": "Exercise dosing to retain resistance training adaptations in young and older adults", "authors": "C Scott Bickel; James M Cross; Marcas M Bamman", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21131862/", "doi": "10.1249/MSS.0b013e318207c15d", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S006", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Exercise dosing to retain resistance training adaptations in young and older adults", "authors": "C Scott Bickel; James M Cross; Marcas M Bamman", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21131862/", "doi": "10.1249/MSS.0b013e318207c15d", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cde01e1fca785d0158f6052f11d31eb6140f8fa78f98b11a8c17ac4c0cb555b7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c3c3bbac0d9d66c4cda885e454b163dd87fb8d7f07794eae55533a5433dc0534" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0341", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1287/mnsc.1040.0257", "title": "Knowledge and Performance in Knowledge-Worker Teams: A Longitudinal Study of Transactive Memory Systems", "authors": "Kyle Lewis", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/abs/10.1287/mnsc.1040.0257", "doi": "10.1287/mnsc.1040.0257", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S013", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Knowledge and Performance in Knowledge-Worker Teams: A Longitudinal Study of Transactive Memory Systems", "authors": "Kyle Lewis", "year": 2004, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/abs/10.1287/mnsc.1040.0257", "doi": "10.1287/mnsc.1040.0257", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "FIELD_ASSOCIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "700d41ef2784a33fb1efb8bb5b5ee7afc693f83c88e813380d8afaf91cbc1173" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7d504ab4d5155a60f8ba0bb55547f78e3657815f39ea315d5c11edae8889c107" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0342", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002112", "title": "Social Dancing and Incidence of Falls in Older Adults: A Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial", "authors": "D Merom; E Mathieu; E Cerin; R L Morton; J M Simpson; C Rissel; K J Anstey; C Sherrington; S R Lord; R G Cumming", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27575534/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pmed.1002112", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S005", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Social Dancing and Incidence of Falls in Older Adults: A Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial", "authors": "D Merom; E Mathieu; E Cerin; R L Morton; J M Simpson; C Rissel; K J Anstey; C Sherrington; S R Lord; R G Cumming", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27575534/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pmed.1002112", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d3e11f79f47d381ceef33a55c59dd3952a8e6577642d55c5021aee26782c7b0e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9bcde90cbff79d227fa6fb02175b92a1c7bdd83a02a82fb5a719039005a19485" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0343", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0011297", "title": "The effect of visual cues on auditory stream segregation in musicians and non-musicians", "authors": "Marozeau J; Innes-Brown H; Grayden DB; Burkitt AN; Blamey PJ", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20585606", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0011297", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S004", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "The effect of visual cues on auditory stream segregation in musicians and non-musicians", "authors": "Marozeau J; Innes-Brown H; Grayden DB; Burkitt AN; Blamey PJ", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20585606", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0011297", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ASSISTED_CONFIGURATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1a51073665a91469da8db973c7ab6a67dd4883363fb9d5c7961e8f7485f12688" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0d31d5ec66beca54cfe321e823b10de9531412407e97ee2c9756a1f7cddd33b9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0344", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0058244", "title": "Neurocognitive and somatic components of temperature increases during g-tummo meditation: legend and reality", "authors": "Maria Kozhevnikov; James Elliott; Jennifer Shephard; Klaus Gramann", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23555572/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0058244", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S009", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Neurocognitive and somatic components of temperature increases during g-tummo meditation: legend and reality", "authors": "Maria Kozhevnikov; James Elliott; Jennifer Shephard; Klaus Gramann", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23555572/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0058244", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM_DECOMPOSITION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1fe9207478035012eeb203baad27e2e6cf999dac60b1ca820e153478b96919ff" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7ce10345b28f527002e8b021e15c04c7f3b677f3d0811217d1b125a104216ae6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0345", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0058546", "title": "Enhancing cognition with video games: a multiple game training study", "authors": "Adam C Oei; Michael D Patterson", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23516504/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0058546", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S003", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Enhancing cognition with video games: a multiple game training study", "authors": "Adam C Oei; Michael D Patterson", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23516504/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0058546", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "40f8358c0980dc1fdcb79bd5310b2528464720427f8e6d94f53097eae0a3cb47" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e13aa18b53216596f0867d809e3125ed8d3612b9f80584641bb63d5beb4aebe9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0346", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0166647", "title": "Learning New Sensorimotor Contingencies: Effects of Long-Term Use of Sensory Augmentation on the Brain and Conscious Perception", "authors": "S U König; F Schumann; J Keyser; C Goeke; C Krause; S Wache; A Lytochkin; M Ebert; V Brunsch; B Wahn; K Kaspar; S K Nagel; T Meilinger; H Bülthoff; T Wolbers; C Büchel; P König", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27959914/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0166647", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S001", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Learning New Sensorimotor Contingencies: Effects of Long-Term Use of Sensory Augmentation on the Brain and Conscious Perception", "authors": "S U König; F Schumann; J Keyser; C Goeke; C Krause; S Wache; A Lytochkin; M Ebert; V Brunsch; B Wahn; K Kaspar; S K Nagel; T Meilinger; H Bülthoff; T Wolbers; C Büchel; P König", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27959914/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0166647", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3dff8991b8c28696bd6a683e384f0a60867e1301e3645858f0adec3529e45514" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0d7f710420b5c5d9ec6e82330c8c45f6899d9f2b72cfc22a7d35eda598b045a8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0347", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0229132", "title": "Adaptive trust calibration for human-AI collaboration", "authors": "Kazuo Okamura; Seiji Yamada", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7034851/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0229132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S007", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Adaptive trust calibration for human-AI collaboration", "authors": "Kazuo Okamura; Seiji Yamada", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7034851/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0229132", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "856578623722f631f8de0ef755774c55203ac9a945773da8a3e347d066afe1ca" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2241754f16b1bbc8a6d5e81eb99a6d5d0486ff3bfe2eb7dd42a78e29c1f10573" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0348", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "title": "Navigation aid for blind persons by visual-to-auditory sensory substitution: a pilot study", "authors": "A. Neugebauer; K. Rifai; M. Getzlaff; S. Wahl", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S023", "F26-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10", "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S023", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Navigation aid for blind persons by visual-to-auditory sensory substitution: a pilot study", "authors": "A. Neugebauer; K. Rifai; M. Getzlaff; S. Wahl", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1fe5c8e47fb3e35305b6334b8ed5af0a1fc4f137bd488f5ff2fb030e330b9ff5" }, { "source_id": "F26-S003", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Navigation aid for blind persons by visual-to-auditory sensory substitution: a pilot study", "authors": "A. Neugebauer; K. Rifai; M. Getzlaff; S. Wahl", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0237344", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CANE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "SENSORY_SUBSTITUTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b158bbc3458b93cfd3ac8257590817d44b97a4046a11e8db44a241e59d21549c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5fcd83ce47527b55d098216f0947686becf995492be2a7811f5c7429d363e463" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0349", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0252330", "title": "Human click-based echolocation: Effects of blindness and age, and real-life implications in a 10-week training program", "authors": "L. J. Norman; C. Dodsworth; D. Foresteire; L. Thaler", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0252330", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0252330", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S016", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Human click-based echolocation: Effects of blindness and age, and real-life implications in a 10-week training program", "authors": "L. J. Norman; C. Dodsworth; D. Foresteire; L. Thaler", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0252330", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0252330", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a694262687b2cb3f7968ede1bd43e333a3b56c83431080cf41e2de418f59e97e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "98118a49cffea677905f290e69b61bfbb8f4aa6732339d6bf25055966c01c762" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0350", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0263480", "title": "Nurturing compassion in schools: A randomized controlled trial of the effectiveness of a Compassionate Mind Training program for teachers", "authors": "M Matos; I Albuquerque; A Galhardo; M Cunha; M Pedroso Lima; L Palmeira; N Petrocchi; K McEwan; F A Maratos; P Gilbert", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35231057/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0263480", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S017", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Nurturing compassion in schools: A randomized controlled trial of the effectiveness of a Compassionate Mind Training program for teachers", "authors": "M Matos; I Albuquerque; A Galhardo; M Cunha; M Pedroso Lima; L Palmeira; N Petrocchi; K McEwan; F A Maratos; P Gilbert", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35231057/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0263480", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "73085bf99e84b0b6c0a313ccb1cd8cabd5d2c0548b1e8b04168ad08ead772a3b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "85ac4f78379d73e09ba80624f33f42b42bd29e331bbb176f7f141f23066acc9d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0351", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0278646", "title": "Uneven terrain treadmill walking in younger and older adults", "authors": "Ryan J Downey; Natalie Richer; Rohan Gupta; Chang Liu; Erika M Pliner; Arkaprava Roy; Jungyun Hwang; David J Clark; Chris J Hass; Todd M Manini; Rachael D Seidler; Daniel P Ferris", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36534645/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0278646", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S013", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Uneven terrain treadmill walking in younger and older adults", "authors": "Ryan J Downey; Natalie Richer; Rohan Gupta; Chang Liu; Erika M Pliner; Arkaprava Roy; Jungyun Hwang; David J Clark; Chris J Hass; Todd M Manini; Rachael D Seidler; Daniel P Ferris", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36534645/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0278646", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b902bd1bca535fd5066657886b638155df5e5c7c0fd230a324974fb2bd34672a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4b09a60fea1a120c7f64a8d2be4e6932e0af2c0c282a71f7cbceb780ed49cf24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0352", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0301124", "title": "A pilot randomised controlled trial comparing the effectiveness of the MaTerre180 participatory tool including a serious game versus an intervention including carbon footprint awareness-raising on behaviours among academia members in France", "authors": "Claudia Teran-Escobar; Nicolas Becu; Nicolas Champollion; Nicolas Gratiot; Benoît Hingray; Gérémy Panthou; Isabelle Ruin", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38547300/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0301124", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S006", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "A pilot randomised controlled trial comparing the effectiveness of the MaTerre180 participatory tool including a serious game versus an intervention including carbon footprint awareness-raising on behaviours among academia members in France", "authors": "Claudia Teran-Escobar; Nicolas Becu; Nicolas Champollion; Nicolas Gratiot; Benoît Hingray; Gérémy Panthou; Isabelle Ruin", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38547300/", "doi": "10.1371/journal.pone.0301124", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5c474e715894a7cb19b295aeb700c36d4d2295e6632933dab6dc5936bf1a36e2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6def15df89d40dc88a0e4201ea3f09148e7523a6c608f60722e84f7a18dea861" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0353", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.14814/phy2.14916", "title": "Effects of sprint interval training on substrate oxidation in adults living with and without obesity: The i-FLEX study", "authors": "Benjamin H. Colpitts; Ken Seaman; Ashley L. Eadie; Keith R. Brunt; Danielle R. Bouchard; Martin Sénéchal", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34110721/", "doi": "10.14814/phy2.14916", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S012", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Effects of sprint interval training on substrate oxidation in adults living with and without obesity: The i-FLEX study", "authors": "Benjamin H. Colpitts; Ken Seaman; Ashley L. Eadie; Keith R. Brunt; Danielle R. Bouchard; Martin Sénéchal", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34110721/", "doi": "10.14814/phy2.14916", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BIOMARKER_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d6db854eff549c65455ca8243d547c621da25d55cba3a30f94038bed59b439be" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7649014e32755e52b9ef7a35405dc875ce3b0117601201ddadcf0bc32e08167c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0354", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/00124278-200108000-00009", "title": "Specificity of sprint and agility training methods", "authors": "Warren B. Young; Mark H. McDowell; Bentley J. Scarlett", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11710657/", "doi": "10.1519/00124278-200108000-00009", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S005", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Specificity of sprint and agility training methods", "authors": "Warren B. Young; Mark H. McDowell; Bentley J. Scarlett", "year": 2001, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11710657/", "doi": "10.1519/00124278-200108000-00009", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "561e41d2e4818f84d539c433579e99e4492e99af8e74fe2fd087687c0f40ca4c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8111279ed8ccdb2f9b62f38fedecaab7e9527e022cbe3eda262363a08e53f862" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0355", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/jsc.0000000000000847", "title": "Effects of Six Weeks of Medicine Ball Training on Throwing Velocity, Throwing Precision, and Isokinetic Strength of Shoulder Rotators in Female Handball Players", "authors": "Christian Raeder; Jaime Fernandez-Fernandez; Alexander Ferrauti", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26102258/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000000847", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S006", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Effects of Six Weeks of Medicine Ball Training on Throwing Velocity, Throwing Precision, and Isokinetic Strength of Shoulder Rotators in Female Handball Players", "authors": "Christian Raeder; Jaime Fernandez-Fernandez; Alexander Ferrauti", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26102258/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000000847", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "69fa9b5585632aa9824c4e8912aa9cb3b53ed1609f7a03ed0ad0e72a91747974" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0a633461c62ea2d65e7c74bda3780608aee3ca225faea963133ebf152247516e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0356", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/jsc.0000000000001216", "title": "Changes in Sprint and Jump Performances After Traditional, Plyometric, and Combined Resistance Training in Male Youth Pre- and Post-Peak Height Velocity", "authors": "Rhodri S. Lloyd; John M. Radnor; Mark B. A. De Ste Croix; John B. Cronin; Jon L. Oliver", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26422612/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000001216", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S003", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Changes in Sprint and Jump Performances After Traditional, Plyometric, and Combined Resistance Training in Male Youth Pre- and Post-Peak Height Velocity", "authors": "Rhodri S. Lloyd; John M. Radnor; Mark B. A. De Ste Croix; John B. Cronin; Jon L. Oliver", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26422612/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000001216", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e397e7fc57d21596a96cae0e114b5206d19808cb2f90626f36dd283a7fe7cdef" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0d80fedc6d3ec31bdc9dec533a58e56253db3c2353c11aaf9e3e850f4f1e507a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0357", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/jsc.0000000000001339", "title": "Passive Recovery Promotes Superior Performance and Reduced Physiological Stress Across Different Phases of Short-Distance Repeated Sprints", "authors": "Aaron T. Scanlan; Maria C. Madueno", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26808862/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000001339", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S013", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Passive Recovery Promotes Superior Performance and Reduced Physiological Stress Across Different Phases of Short-Distance Repeated Sprints", "authors": "Aaron T. Scanlan; Maria C. Madueno", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26808862/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000001339", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMPARATOR", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "aec1ecac0034d76ad4ec004e99cca744e816860d5f000ccdc6665db925bf6b69" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7a864ce765c6c68f6b490836daccfa423c97ca6610483aa09b1794479afcc90e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0358", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/jsc.0000000000002524", "title": "Moderate Load Resisted Sprints Do Not Improve Subsequent Sprint Performance in Varsity-Level Sprinters", "authors": "Kyle M. A. Thompson; Alanna K. Whinton; Shane Ferth; Lawrence L. Spriet; Jamie F. Burr", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29570579/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000002524", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S011", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Moderate Load Resisted Sprints Do Not Improve Subsequent Sprint Performance in Varsity-Level Sprinters", "authors": "Kyle M. A. Thompson; Alanna K. Whinton; Shane Ferth; Lawrence L. Spriet; Jamie F. Burr", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29570579/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0000000000002524", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a5a21dd48327415aa33c8cf2f033db7bc2a6271dc44769864ec1daa52564034d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8f747cf6d3e322e27695e8a319c45a078a84db12fa948263c43188ed74c4f758" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0359", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/jsc.0b013e31821624aa", "title": "Resistance training vs. static stretching: effects on flexibility and strength", "authors": "Sam K Morton; James R Whitehead; Ronald H Brinkert; Dennis J Caine", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21969080/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0b013e31821624aa", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S001", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Resistance training vs. static stretching: effects on flexibility and strength", "authors": "Sam K Morton; James R Whitehead; Ronald H Brinkert; Dennis J Caine", "year": 2011, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21969080/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0b013e31821624aa", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7a4c9cd62cccddd8ae44c5eee5ab16e071b63f360e2858c96cdf6b1a52a7c3a4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d71ac795dc3f8147e2e009430100b7707de872b090e6491ef72616b317712d40" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0360", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1519/jsc.0b013e318297143a", "title": "Impact of range of motion during ecologically valid resistance training protocols on muscle size, subcutaneous fat, and strength", "authors": "Gerard E McMahon; Christopher I Morse; Adrian Burden; Keith Winwood; Gladys L Onambélé", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23629583/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0b013e318297143a", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S003", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Impact of range of motion during ecologically valid resistance training protocols on muscle size, subcutaneous fat, and strength", "authors": "Gerard E McMahon; Christopher I Morse; Adrian Burden; Keith Winwood; Gladys L Onambélé", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23629583/", "doi": "10.1519/JSC.0b013e318297143a", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e37821a747d9a8ed17d930b0176abcdc269a01f0663abe783e367284e8eb3d60" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "14d71c0108168636b3e89421233312fcead8b4e85e0ee367f52c4f7179720175" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0361", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1523/eneuro.0122-17.2017", "title": "Structural Learning in a Visuomotor Adaptation Task Is Explicitly Accessible", "authors": "K. M. Bond; J. A. Taylor", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28856241/", "doi": "10.1523/ENEURO.0122-17.2017", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S016", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Structural Learning in a Visuomotor Adaptation Task Is Explicitly Accessible", "authors": "K. M. Bond; J. A. Taylor", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28856241/", "doi": "10.1523/ENEURO.0122-17.2017", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9fd379b86c72181557c6d4d946c882888f841718b81ec469f179de0eb827ef6b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "325b2758cbf7d7576d6c6362360028b0145dd31e168afcf375747ebca9bd3e33" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0362", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1523/jneurosci.0514-13.2013", "title": "A physical constraint on perceptual learning: tactile spatial acuity improves with training to a limit set by finger size", "authors": "M. Wong; R. M. Peters; D. Goldreich", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23719803/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0514-13.2013", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S001", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "A physical constraint on perceptual learning: tactile spatial acuity improves with training to a limit set by finger size", "authors": "M. Wong; R. M. Peters; D. Goldreich", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23719803/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0514-13.2013", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "BIOLOGICAL_LIMIT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b9f5c11fe65b3bd83e1ed717f92cc801246944ea3f5d701e3b5a45bc6ae60b4d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d258e342183ab4acb44b4962f79a59548f9898e06960e0924c8432e679f62a69" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0363", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1523/jneurosci.4706-12.2013", "title": "Motor Learning Interference Is Proportional to Occlusion of LTP-Like Plasticity", "authors": "Gabriela Cantarero; Byron Tang; Rebecca O’Malley; Rachel Salas; Pablo Celnik", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23486938/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4706-12.2013", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S010", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Motor Learning Interference Is Proportional to Occlusion of LTP-Like Plasticity", "authors": "Gabriela Cantarero; Byron Tang; Rebecca O’Malley; Rachel Salas; Pablo Celnik", "year": 2013, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23486938/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4706-12.2013", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "INTERFERENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "32574d64d42604246343075bdce91baa4bce83d1e8367224ae5d2c80962b1624" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b5ea72c35828734fcd7fc400cfb4917af9e33b92809900c0a2f5f21abe7e076f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0364", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1523/jneurosci.4769-13.2014", "title": "Connecting to create: expertise in musical improvisation is associated with increased functional connectivity between premotor and prefrontal areas", "authors": "Pinho AL; de Manzano Ö; Fransson P; Eriksson H; Ullén F", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24790186", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4769-13.2014", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S006", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Connecting to create: expertise in musical improvisation is associated with increased functional connectivity between premotor and prefrontal areas", "authors": "Pinho AL; de Manzano Ö; Fransson P; Eriksson H; Ullén F", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24790186", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.4769-13.2014", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "NONCAUSAL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "85aa4fcdbb3b65ad06e7b99dd45086359ecec39e3a84aa0b841f6b8a6535c296" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5c737df77cf074de6d370d2f752cc45eefdfd6e7af42acd8e95c053ca8cb7ecb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0365", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1523/jneurosci.5488-09.2010", "title": "Adaptive reweighting of auditory localization cues in response to chronic unilateral earplugging in humans", "authors": "D. P. Kumpik; O. Kacelnik; A. J. King", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20371808/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5488-09.2010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S001", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Adaptive reweighting of auditory localization cues in response to chronic unilateral earplugging in humans", "authors": "D. P. Kumpik; O. Kacelnik; A. J. King", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20371808/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5488-09.2010", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b0d177282108ba0bab8311122fefe7436adc029b7ec0667077873ed668b0ffb8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "318e42cc913d707d6d6534c8824da6edf0d01178f7f4fcc75f1175c7688c49cd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0366", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1523/jneurosci.5732-11.2012", "title": "Perceptual learning evidence for tuning to spectrotemporal modulation in the human auditory system", "authors": "A. T. Sabin; D. A. Eddins; B. A. Wright", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22573676/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5732-11.2012", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S012", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Perceptual learning evidence for tuning to spectrotemporal modulation in the human auditory system", "authors": "A. T. Sabin; D. A. Eddins; B. A. Wright", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22573676/", "doi": "10.1523/JNEUROSCI.5732-11.2012", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a95a5aedfaf61820f815d72731e8bae4a60868b9cbc3cbffd8d51e7c13b4d74c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3540d15fa12d29bda7993d2f78daa0691dc3e8608dd1a1c880356615c1caad41" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0367", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1682/jrrd.2010.02.0012", "title": "Evaluation of semiautonomous navigation assistance system for power wheelchairs with blindfolded nondisabled individuals", "authors": "Vinod Sharma; Richard C. Simpson; Edmund LoPresti; Mark Schmeler", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21174252/", "doi": "10.1682/JRRD.2010.02.0012", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S010", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Evaluation of semiautonomous navigation assistance system for power wheelchairs with blindfolded nondisabled individuals", "authors": "Vinod Sharma; Richard C. Simpson; Edmund LoPresti; Mark Schmeler", "year": 2010, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21174252/", "doi": "10.1682/JRRD.2010.02.0012", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COLLISION_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "SLOWER_PERFORMANCE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "892f2d4cf3883c865e6b0dae5736cfa2b0401a9245477102f9161922e676e6a2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b6676315290b329d76d87f277ff13e01d49de4ac482ee394fe9bd6ef86910c82" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0368", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.1787/ac8ed8e8-en", "title": "OECD Public Integrity Handbook", "authors": "Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2020/05/oecd-public-integrity-handbook_598692a5.html", "doi": "10.1787/ac8ed8e8-en", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S012", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "OECD Public Integrity Handbook", "authors": "Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2020/05/oecd-public-integrity-handbook_598692a5.html", "doi": "10.1787/ac8ed8e8-en", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "912abad90aa87e5826c6b328f00a8caeffd0518d3898b8b0bf2c9fac9227b6ae" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1174d8f5ef80adcc7d7f654ecb4ba6d6a9e807662fd5bd85a530732f07391504" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0369", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.21053/ceo.2023.00206", "title": "Feasibility of Virtual Reality-Based Auditory Localization Training With Binaurally Recorded Auditory Stimuli for Patients With Single-Sided Deafness", "authors": "L. Shim; J. Lee; J. H. Han; H. Jeon; S. K. Hong; H. J. Lee", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37080730/", "doi": "10.21053/ceo.2023.00206", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S002", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Feasibility of Virtual Reality-Based Auditory Localization Training With Binaurally Recorded Auditory Stimuli for Patients With Single-Sided Deafness", "authors": "L. Shim; J. Lee; J. H. Han; H. Jeon; S. K. Hong; H. J. Lee", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37080730/", "doi": "10.21053/ceo.2023.00206", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d25b83db49b8bcb3e0d5bf18e92f1aaf2962955b82ce02ef8a38788f5824227b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6cc0e4cbb119bbfaaf2c15d9a6da11751b25eb2244e73e7f0e543ddfe59afe24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0370", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.2147/cia.s174756", "title": "Effect of passive finger exercises on grip strength and the ability to perform activities of daily living for older people with dementia: a 12-week randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Bingbing Liu; Xueping Chen; Yang Li; Hui Liu; Shasha Guo; Ping Yu", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30464426/", "doi": "10.2147/CIA.S174756", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S010", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "Effect of passive finger exercises on grip strength and the ability to perform activities of daily living for older people with dementia: a 12-week randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Bingbing Liu; Xueping Chen; Yang Li; Hui Liu; Shasha Guo; Ping Yu", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30464426/", "doi": "10.2147/CIA.S174756", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5d0a97f8e6ccc4cb5caa6dbc1b8022833bb4015780f40081c4d38d985c2ece07" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "39401af1616432b44379d5745312c72bac3192e82b07277befc6a1abe39dd60c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0371", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.2196/64902", "title": "Effect of Uncertainty-Aware AI Models on Pharmacists' Reaction Time and Decision-Making in a Web-Based Mock Medication Verification Task: Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Corey Lester; Brigid Rowell; Yifan Zheng; Zoe Co; Vincent Marshall; Jin Yong Kim; Qiyuan Chen; Raed Kontar; X. Jessie Yang", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40249341/", "doi": "10.2196/64902", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S014", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Effect of Uncertainty-Aware AI Models on Pharmacists' Reaction Time and Decision-Making in a Web-Based Mock Medication Verification Task: Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Corey Lester; Brigid Rowell; Yifan Zheng; Zoe Co; Vincent Marshall; Jin Yong Kim; Qiyuan Chen; Raed Kontar; X. Jessie Yang", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40249341/", "doi": "10.2196/64902", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "UNCERTAINTY", "VERIFICATION_BURDEN" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3f3228db3d290b2c07f97a0c16e8d8d387bc526753b44ccd7d78d2fb021314a9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a5f50f2123a5eba386006190b20edf30afde8dd5eef7d51ac0844b8752d8de8b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0372", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.2196/84323", "title": "The Effectiveness of Digital Cognitive Behavioral Therapy to Treat Insomnia Disorder in US Adults: Nationwide Decentralized Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Aric A Prather; Andrew D Krystal; Richard Emsley; Jenna Carl; Tali Ball; Kathryn Tarnai; Adrian Aguilera; Colin A Espie; Alasdair L Henry", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41343796/", "doi": "10.2196/84323", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S001", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "The Effectiveness of Digital Cognitive Behavioral Therapy to Treat Insomnia Disorder in US Adults: Nationwide Decentralized Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Aric A Prather; Andrew D Krystal; Richard Emsley; Jenna Carl; Tali Ball; Kathryn Tarnai; Adrian Aguilera; Colin A Espie; Alasdair L Henry", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41343796/", "doi": "10.2196/84323", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b7913dd563b7eee3be3c6278f0469d0b045c0c8570ed8da3cad96a8287a08036" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f0af396922ec609cefc4df43c83bdc723cfb228d2943994eda0c2cb4600fb019" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0373", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.2337/db15-1661", "title": "One Week of Bed Rest Leads to Substantial Muscle Atrophy and Induces Whole-Body Insulin Resistance in the Absence of Skeletal Muscle Lipid Accumulation", "authors": "Marlou L Dirks; Benjamin T Wall; Bas van de Valk; Tanya M Holloway; Graham P Holloway; Adrian Chabowski; Gijs H Goossens; Luc J C van Loon", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27358494/", "doi": "10.2337/db15-1661", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S013", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "One Week of Bed Rest Leads to Substantial Muscle Atrophy and Induces Whole-Body Insulin Resistance in the Absence of Skeletal Muscle Lipid Accumulation", "authors": "Marlou L Dirks; Benjamin T Wall; Bas van de Valk; Tanya M Holloway; Graham P Holloway; Adrian Chabowski; Gijs H Goossens; Luc J C van Loon", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27358494/", "doi": "10.2337/db15-1661", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6b7e3e889e5ba16864116bd4f58de811a85cab765d49cded0d32f0468ec818aa" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1082078f1e0e175b2cca1dd7daeef3a8ebaa9bd145b3e3078a2c929e9e2346eb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0374", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.23736/s1973-9087.26.09085-4", "title": "Clinical outcomes of rehabilitation with a robotic anthropomorphic exoskeleton in patients with motor-incomplete spinal cord injury: a multicenter randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Corrado Zenesini; Ilaria Baroncini; Roberto Di Palma; Alessandra Bigioni; Pawel Kiper; Francesca Bettini; Laura Simoncini; Valeria Petrone; Ilaria Sermasi; Alice Portillo; Flora Morara; Paola Paglierani; Iolanda Pisotta; Giorgio Scivoletto; Giovanni Lazzaro; Martina Regazzetti; Elena Antelmi", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42266158/", "doi": "10.23736/S1973-9087.26.09085-4", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S009", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Clinical outcomes of rehabilitation with a robotic anthropomorphic exoskeleton in patients with motor-incomplete spinal cord injury: a multicenter randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Corrado Zenesini; Ilaria Baroncini; Roberto Di Palma; Alessandra Bigioni; Pawel Kiper; Francesca Bettini; Laura Simoncini; Valeria Petrone; Ilaria Sermasi; Alice Portillo; Flora Morara; Paola Paglierani; Iolanda Pisotta; Giorgio Scivoletto; Giovanni Lazzaro; Martina Regazzetti; Elena Antelmi", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42266158/", "doi": "10.23736/S1973-9087.26.09085-4", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "REHABILITATION", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ff4b5579340e50d5809b71a897b4fb266af1797c018b144725d9669db294e555" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5699d1ca2b46d9f213ac56a23b0075bb900113649df90d1c5711ac0729bcfd72" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0375", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.2519/jospt.2003.33.7.408", "title": "The effect of static stretching of the calf muscle-tendon unit on active ankle dorsiflexion range of motion", "authors": "James W Youdas; David A Krause; Kathleen S Egan; Terry M Therneau; Edward R Laskowski", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12918866/", "doi": "10.2519/jospt.2003.33.7.408", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S002", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "The effect of static stretching of the calf muscle-tendon unit on active ankle dorsiflexion range of motion", "authors": "James W Youdas; David A Krause; Kathleen S Egan; Terry M Therneau; Edward R Laskowski", "year": 2003, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12918866/", "doi": "10.2519/jospt.2003.33.7.408", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "09f1180d30b434dd861a7c47e2c465f133825e6f66cdc2c6bafb55a85d40b7fb" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f7d84b78d1ae71c99e3d453ac48c4704a5359cedab7a75427b770dca73d7c9aa" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0376", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3233/rnn-150575", "title": "Perceptual learning leads to long lasting visual improvement in patients with central vision loss", "authors": "Marcello Maniglia; Andrea Pavan; Giovanni Sato; Giulio Contemori; Sonia Montemurro; Luca Battaglini; Clara Casco", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27567754/", "doi": "10.3233/RNN-150575", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S006", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Perceptual learning leads to long lasting visual improvement in patients with central vision loss", "authors": "Marcello Maniglia; Andrea Pavan; Giovanni Sato; Giulio Contemori; Sonia Montemurro; Luca Battaglini; Clara Casco", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27567754/", "doi": "10.3233/RNN-150575", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "13c00fc264d42d049061916731a35006c633514e0c13513bb1062a58031da163" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "aed2be5314f306aed95d30a03ba16dfd95d8dd21bda44934ca83404169235ae3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0377", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3233/rnn-170731", "title": "Perceptual learning improves contrast sensitivity, visual acuity, and foveal crowding in amblyopia", "authors": "M. Barollo; G. Contemori; L. Battaglini; A. Pavan; C. Casco", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28800339/", "doi": "10.3233/RNN-170731", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S003", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Perceptual learning improves contrast sensitivity, visual acuity, and foveal crowding in amblyopia", "authors": "M. Barollo; G. Contemori; L. Battaglini; A. Pavan; C. Casco", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28800339/", "doi": "10.3233/RNN-170731", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5e7531e1e61a13bc48922922f1e8eafda52d24eb25329b84371509ea5a229601" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0c4e4fce3873a916455739ee6dabf9eb1746fdd49a778809b6e292a5ec0811ea" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0378", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3348/kjr.2021.0476", "title": "Improving the Performance of Radiologists Using Artificial Intelligence-Based Detection Support Software for Mammography: A Multi-Reader Study", "authors": "Jeong Hoon Lee; Ki Hwan Kim; Eun Hye Lee; Jong Seok Ahn; Jung Kyu Ryu; Young Mi Park; Gi Won Shin; Young Joong Kim; Hye Young Choi", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35434976/", "doi": "10.3348/kjr.2021.0476", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S013", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Improving the Performance of Radiologists Using Artificial Intelligence-Based Detection Support Software for Mammography: A Multi-Reader Study", "authors": "Jeong Hoon Lee; Ki Hwan Kim; Eun Hye Lee; Jong Seok Ahn; Jung Kyu Ryu; Young Mi Park; Gi Won Shin; Young Joong Kim; Hye Young Choi", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35434976/", "doi": "10.3348/kjr.2021.0476", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_ONLY_BASELINE", "ASSISTED_PERCEPTION", "EXPERIENCE_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5b19141dd41881b88c02eef3430ab71039bc8ca60d35da3b536996c6af325bad" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "390ba87d95a825486bbb59fd17515719c0adfef5faa4b2fdc76f0545ae31143f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0379", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3357/amhp.6481.2024", "title": "Sensitization of Visually Induced Motion Sickness by Prior Provocative Physical Motion", "authors": "John F Golding; Daniel Alund; Michael A Gresty; Maria B Flynn", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39431702/", "doi": "10.3357/AMHP.6481.2024", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S016", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Sensitization of Visually Induced Motion Sickness by Prior Provocative Physical Motion", "authors": "John F Golding; Daniel Alund; Michael A Gresty; Maria B Flynn", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39431702/", "doi": "10.3357/AMHP.6481.2024", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "488e8df75453f0fc4330ff972379f2f843527046f3c47d8d50b2e4277a08956b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "429dff41e8ae8737f2be931217002ee571924b470ee69094053ae14a07aa9f36" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0380", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fnagi.2017.00069", "title": "Limited Effects of Set Shifting Training in Healthy Older Adults", "authors": "Pia Grönholm-Nyman; Anna Soveri; Juha O Rinne; Elina Ek; Anna Nyholm; Anna Stigsdotter Neely; Matti Laine", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28386226/", "doi": "10.3389/fnagi.2017.00069", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S010", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Limited Effects of Set Shifting Training in Healthy Older Adults", "authors": "Pia Grönholm-Nyman; Anna Soveri; Juha O Rinne; Elina Ek; Anna Nyholm; Anna Stigsdotter Neely; Matti Laine", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28386226/", "doi": "10.3389/fnagi.2017.00069", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bb26797a76f7d90bccaf56a8b5ff4f82ed200b5e31884b4852207410af442cde" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "67de380b1eaeee33f0b2af5161bfab71b7a2f2b82f8ccb0268416580fd9c6ef5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0381", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fnagi.2022.816512", "title": "Multisensory visual-vestibular training improves visual heading estimation in younger and older adults", "authors": "G. A. Gabriel; L. R. Harris; D. Y. P. Henriques; M. Pandi; J. L. Campos", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36092809/", "doi": "10.3389/fnagi.2022.816512", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S028" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S028", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Multisensory visual-vestibular training improves visual heading estimation in younger and older adults", "authors": "G. A. Gabriel; L. R. Harris; D. Y. P. Henriques; M. Pandi; J. L. Campos", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36092809/", "doi": "10.3389/fnagi.2022.816512", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d5c5919235ae3b084989c67cf8d4603a44de499fe316d91d5185ef29cc808d90" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4dc172fea24634acd770ac04a87edd53267728f174502cf239fb03df8ea4ec66" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0382", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fneur.2020.606873", "title": "Effects of Computerized Updating and Inhibition Training in Older Adults: The ACTOP Three-Arm Randomized Double-Blind Controlled Trial", "authors": "Amélie Boujut; L V Verty; Sotirios Maltezos; Maxime Lussier; Samia Mellah; Louis Bherer; Sylvie Belleville", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33343503/", "doi": "10.3389/fneur.2020.606873", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S012", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Effects of Computerized Updating and Inhibition Training in Older Adults: The ACTOP Three-Arm Randomized Double-Blind Controlled Trial", "authors": "Amélie Boujut; L V Verty; Sotirios Maltezos; Maxime Lussier; Samia Mellah; Louis Bherer; Sylvie Belleville", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33343503/", "doi": "10.3389/fneur.2020.606873", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "301dccfa72d4f6f78178e34609a974575169affd72907ccab702ca467a939f53" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "29eb6e10acd04f534ea16cf2b7a69d8a4a68cfdbea80bbfa7717d17a793ec07e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0383", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fnhum.2017.00529", "title": "Cognitive Flexibility Training: A Large-Scale Multimodal Adaptive Active-Control Intervention Study in Healthy Older Adults", "authors": "Jessika I V Buitenweg; Renée M van de Ven; Sanne Prinssen; Jaap M J Murre; K Richard Ridderinkhof", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29209183/", "doi": "10.3389/fnhum.2017.00529", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S015", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Cognitive Flexibility Training: A Large-Scale Multimodal Adaptive Active-Control Intervention Study in Healthy Older Adults", "authors": "Jessika I V Buitenweg; Renée M van de Ven; Sanne Prinssen; Jaap M J Murre; K Richard Ridderinkhof", "year": 2017, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29209183/", "doi": "10.3389/fnhum.2017.00529", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "06b9aab08f5b93854ef3c8a5266cb1b939b75f26ded7bb9835200c41064253b9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4570490f9fc43d42a4025dde5cf80c23e7e677000fd911b1931bb0477485f2a4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0384", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fnhum.2025.1515334", "title": "Effects of a mindfulness intervention on emotion differentiation and heart rate variability", "authors": "S Guendelman; M Lutz; J Koenig; M Bayer; I Dziobek", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40672745/", "doi": "10.3389/fnhum.2025.1515334", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S002", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Effects of a mindfulness intervention on emotion differentiation and heart rate variability", "authors": "S Guendelman; M Lutz; J Koenig; M Bayer; I Dziobek", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40672745/", "doi": "10.3389/fnhum.2025.1515334", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1873352b1c061a8a3eb185e4b76a18db5f93b14372471d06c9ef2df1ce13e6b1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6127ee52a7324c308505339769faba2c9e9c60a4b603f05cb63879f7e9bf5bc4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0385", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fnins.2020.00590", "title": "Volitional Control of Piloerection: Objective Evidence and Its Potential Utility in Neuroscience Research", "authors": "Kenji Katahira; Ai Kawakami; Akitoshi Tomita; Noriko Nagata", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32581701/", "doi": "10.3389/fnins.2020.00590", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S007", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Volitional Control of Piloerection: Objective Evidence and Its Potential Utility in Neuroscience Research", "authors": "Kenji Katahira; Ai Kawakami; Akitoshi Tomita; Noriko Nagata", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32581701/", "doi": "10.3389/fnins.2020.00590", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RELIABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ae2e059fbacbeed07301c7e8226543cf2c5dc16f88a529bd2e01cdad1780b426" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8bcf0f685fa07af3d52d24af954820fa7dad38dfa98de9a78ffb1f9bcf6b29a5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0386", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fnins.2020.569212", "title": "Audio-Visual Training in Older Adults: 2-Interval-Forced Choice Task Improves Performance", "authors": "J. M. O'Brien; J. S. Chan; A. Setti", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33304234/", "doi": "10.3389/fnins.2020.569212", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S026" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S026", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Audio-Visual Training in Older Adults: 2-Interval-Forced Choice Task Improves Performance", "authors": "J. M. O'Brien; J. S. Chan; A. Setti", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33304234/", "doi": "10.3389/fnins.2020.569212", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "31bf66acc8185e0561224caa1cf3ba36053991d478d81cbed6f9882bd1f327c3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f24a64bd10eddbc147ff369518e67ca82d907d6b14e1a700ce6eefcea82fd898" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0387", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fphys.2018.00156", "title": "Effects of Resisted Sprint Training and Traditional Power Training on Sprint, Jump, and Balance Performance in Healthy Young Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Olaf Prieske; Tom Krüger; Markus Aehle; Erik Bauer; Urs Granacher", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29551981/", "doi": "10.3389/fphys.2018.00156", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S004", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Effects of Resisted Sprint Training and Traditional Power Training on Sprint, Jump, and Balance Performance in Healthy Young Adults: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Olaf Prieske; Tom Krüger; Markus Aehle; Erik Bauer; Urs Granacher", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29551981/", "doi": "10.3389/fphys.2018.00156", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "36e94c5d210edf66b466a180f7021d2d31e9283b26d62978f062026c0d64032a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f5318f8629050cecaeed90335d7a4e78e14136cb62d129fdbb7b78672f8d5036" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0388", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fphys.2019.01080", "title": "Post-exercise Hot Water Immersion Elicits Heat Acclimation Adaptations That Are Retained for at Least Two Weeks", "authors": "M J Zurawlew; J A Mee; N P Walsh", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31555140/", "doi": "10.3389/fphys.2019.01080", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S002", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Post-exercise Hot Water Immersion Elicits Heat Acclimation Adaptations That Are Retained for at Least Two Weeks", "authors": "M J Zurawlew; J A Mee; N P Walsh", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31555140/", "doi": "10.3389/fphys.2019.01080", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "da1a4465e681a5ee87071bcbcf73f3bcfee60e28881aab428ddb3e6f6727fbf1" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "49c37b27a32ce3f1a4dccf4b7a64e8cf034e7b49614dab39346462a867385218" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0389", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01332", "title": "Aligning Leader Behaviors With Innovation Requirements Improves Performance: An Experimental Study", "authors": "Gerlach F; Heinigk K; Rosing K; Zacher H", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32733310", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01332", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S006", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Aligning Leader Behaviors With Innovation Requirements Improves Performance: An Experimental Study", "authors": "Gerlach F; Heinigk K; Rosing K; Zacher H", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32733310", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01332", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURATION_INTERACTION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "55decf0935a046112f902dfb7ba7c7f3787350579a825a2c20c79a7caf61bdec" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "31884e4fc2bdca3e1fbe1384c54cb5f3a814783f564e9d8527cd4ec57299735f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0390", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2021.695002", "title": "Design Training and Creativity: Students Develop Stronger Divergent but Not Convergent Thinking", "authors": "Xia T; Kang M; Chen M; Ouyang J; Hu F", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34671286", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2021.695002", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S009", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Design Training and Creativity: Students Develop Stronger Divergent but Not Convergent Thinking", "authors": "Xia T; Kang M; Chen M; Ouyang J; Hu F", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34671286", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2021.695002", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTRADICTION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NONCAUSAL" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a4e2314e997ddd48f6b8c4c3ebff3837869ec83465f98873d34b7cb465ae2bc8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "25653de35fbcbcb3c1b7e6240d4a7957dbb477bfef923209557e5a8545320642" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0391", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2021.749957", "title": "Keeping Connected With School: Implementing Telepresence Robots to Improve the Wellbeing of Adolescent Cancer Patients", "authors": "Thomasin Powell; Jennifer Cohen; Pandora Patterson", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34867634/", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2021.749957", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S014", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Keeping Connected With School: Implementing Telepresence Robots to Improve the Wellbeing of Adolescent Cancer Patients", "authors": "Thomasin Powell; Jennifer Cohen; Pandora Patterson", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34867634/", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2021.749957", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "IMPLEMENTATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PARTICIPATION", "TELEPRESENCE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e7eaa0394383f1db82f4e3eb53690d33e5aa41c4651562eec5d9dbf8367173b5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "26e0acf14977b9f02fd52451daf83025dd8ec15d80f8a8d3888c3ff347150dda" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0392", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1150210", "title": "The Mental Models Training App: Enhancing verbal reasoning through a cognitive training mobile application", "authors": "Robert A. Cortes; Adam B. Weinberger; Adam E. Green", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36968736/", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1150210", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S001", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "The Mental Models Training App: Enhancing verbal reasoning through a cognitive training mobile application", "authors": "Robert A. Cortes; Adam B. Weinberger; Adam E. Green", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36968736/", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1150210", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8f79cef2d63443f10795de0b8ec9b7fbf17cecd7817ae79a4f11ace8230336a6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f00638a443b098cd21cc9f85d69f61e2a0ed4dedfc36e05f2a04e1f3c466838a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0393", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1398457", "title": "Ethnocultural empathy development of future language teachers through digital multiliteracy resources for low-literacy adult migrants", "authors": "Analí Fernández-Corbacho; Esther Cores-Bilbao; Patricia Flor-Arasil", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1398457/full", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1398457", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S010", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Ethnocultural empathy development of future language teachers through digital multiliteracy resources for low-literacy adult migrants", "authors": "Analí Fernández-Corbacho; Esther Cores-Bilbao; Patricia Flor-Arasil", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1398457/full", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1398457", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b2ab0ce5c65c814f90296b0a4b749af3d7195e4582c3362e52f9af2fb8eb45eb" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4c9de710007dbadd76409fc52f77eb09b42b43415a8b3f3a76fd4b51ddfee266" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0394", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fpsyt.2021.576662", "title": "Effectiveness of CRSCE-Based De-escalation Training on Reducing Physical Restraint in Psychiatric Hospitals: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Junrong Ye; Zhichun Xia; Chen Wang; Yao Liao; Yu Xu; Yunlei Zhang; Lin Yu; Sijue Li; Jiankui Lin; Aixiang Xiao", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33679467/", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyt.2021.576662", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S002", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Effectiveness of CRSCE-Based De-escalation Training on Reducing Physical Restraint in Psychiatric Hospitals: A Cluster Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Junrong Ye; Zhichun Xia; Chen Wang; Yao Liao; Yu Xu; Yunlei Zhang; Lin Yu; Sijue Li; Jiankui Lin; Aixiang Xiao", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33679467/", "doi": "10.3389/fpsyt.2021.576662", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESTRICTED", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0e2b221934e38bf60671a70d307ca831d69081b5ac9904626652b8895da29f1d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "685fd1034fba292413f2ee15d0f606c64b89e899240308777f7ae110de77f31b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0395", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3389/fragi.2024.1322705", "title": "Four weeks of meditation training improves sustained attention in community-dwelling older adults: a proof-of-concept randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Sabrina D Ford; Lindsay S Nagamatsu", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38496316/", "doi": "10.3389/fragi.2024.1322705", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-13" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F13-S001", "family_id": "FAM-13", "title": "Four weeks of meditation training improves sustained attention in community-dwelling older adults: a proof-of-concept randomized controlled trial", "authors": "Sabrina D Ford; Lindsay S Nagamatsu", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38496316/", "doi": "10.3389/fragi.2024.1322705", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7efba0addc8b222991727f552f878e46d1ff324bf48d4da1ee9df7600a39c5e2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6c27e627acd8b16b8696026c464fd0492d10572ef62f58082f2875e9e25c3ffd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0396", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/bioengineering11080831", "title": "EchoSee: An Assistive Mobile Application for Real-Time 3D Environment Reconstruction and Sonification Supporting Enhanced Navigation for People with Vision Impairments", "authors": "B S Schwartz; S King; T Bell", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39199789/", "doi": "10.3390/bioengineering11080831", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S003", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "EchoSee: An Assistive Mobile Application for Real-Time 3D Environment Reconstruction and Sonification Supporting Enhanced Navigation for People with Vision Impairments", "authors": "B S Schwartz; S King; T Bell", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39199789/", "doi": "10.3390/bioengineering11080831", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e9cbd7a86e9c4c0274cacff55afe63ad7eb9a77dddd6c9aabb276e506ad3495d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d869e63b6b51a67b03d949fc41cb1bb845f84107e93d8081bbcbec3aa953d791" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0397", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/brainsci13050720", "title": "Improved Spatial Knowledge Acquisition through Sensory Augmentation", "authors": "Vincent Schmidt; Sabine U König; Rabia Dilawar; Tracy Sánchez Pacheco; Peter König", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37239192/", "doi": "10.3390/brainsci13050720", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S009", "F28-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12", "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S009", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Improved Spatial Knowledge Acquisition through Sensory Augmentation", "authors": "Vincent Schmidt; Sabine U König; Rabia Dilawar; Tracy Sánchez Pacheco; Peter König", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37239192/", "doi": "10.3390/brainsci13050720", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "162d2157a8531c2a3d01cb78fa5e4dcba5538cad018da5486f6ee185055f2995" }, { "source_id": "F28-S002", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Improved Spatial Knowledge Acquisition through Sensory Augmentation", "authors": "V Schmidt; S U König; R Dilawar; T Sánchez Pacheco; P König", "year": 2023, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37239192/", "doi": "10.3390/brainsci13050720", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f976158834edd5a5cee57bc1c7117dc9114fca435a5dfbc88b029d88c385f3b9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d2855a1d4492b2f269a08c4851151df287f9332b4052887d74219b523b214b29" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0398", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/clockssleep4020021", "title": "Combining Wake-Up-Back-to-Bed with Cognitive Induction Techniques: Does Earlier Sleep Interruption Reduce Lucid Dream Induction Rate?", "authors": "Daniel Erlacher; Vitus Furrer; Matthias Ineichen; John Braillard; Daniel Schmid", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35645242/", "doi": "10.3390/clockssleep4020021", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S008", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Combining Wake-Up-Back-to-Bed with Cognitive Induction Techniques: Does Earlier Sleep Interruption Reduce Lucid Dream Induction Rate?", "authors": "Daniel Erlacher; Vitus Furrer; Matthias Ineichen; John Braillard; Daniel Schmid", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35645242/", "doi": "10.3390/clockssleep4020021", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "41ec522c7681ee6f38821d2ce4b3cbbaeda3fd34df76fc47d72ea921100b445a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f5992940399c93f4d2f2f06a81ef955677d894770222e8145de6c77d944e4a3b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0399", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/ijerph16183495", "title": "Effects of Traditional vs. iPad-Enhanced Aerobic Exercise on Wayfinding Efficacy and Cognition: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "David Palac; Tiffany Bullard; Jennifer D Cohen; Linh T Nguyen; Raksha A Mudar; Sean P Mullen", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31546856/", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph16183495", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S010", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Effects of Traditional vs. iPad-Enhanced Aerobic Exercise on Wayfinding Efficacy and Cognition: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "David Palac; Tiffany Bullard; Jennifer D Cohen; Linh T Nguyen; Raksha A Mudar; Sean P Mullen", "year": 2019, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31546856/", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph16183495", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e837c9dd96b3d6d9cdb4c92727d98628099ba42c5bc74ed1df7997bbcb1473c0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a24d578a45c9cecb8672266ab4e296b2948d57255379fa0a2eda1e1f39c01ab4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0400", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/ijerph22030398", "title": "A Mixed-Methods Cluster Randomised Waitlist-Controlled Trial of a Goal-Based Behaviour Change Intervention Implemented in Workplaces", "authors": "Laura Kudrna; James Yates; Lailah Alidu; Karla Hemming; Laura Quinn; Kelly Ann Schmidtke; Janet Jones; Lena Al-Khudairy; Kate Jolly; Paul Bird; Niyah Campbell; Ila Bharatan; Agnieszka Latuszynska; Graeme Currie; Richard Lilford", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40238435/", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph22030398", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S002", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "A Mixed-Methods Cluster Randomised Waitlist-Controlled Trial of a Goal-Based Behaviour Change Intervention Implemented in Workplaces", "authors": "Laura Kudrna; James Yates; Lailah Alidu; Karla Hemming; Laura Quinn; Kelly Ann Schmidtke; Janet Jones; Lena Al-Khudairy; Kate Jolly; Paul Bird; Niyah Campbell; Ila Bharatan; Agnieszka Latuszynska; Graeme Currie; Richard Lilford", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40238435/", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph22030398", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "40c4b0d831dc5955250785bc29c676c0a4dd472a846d9766441b1140204c1663" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bba4ec49245cfc15251ee399c36fcf491b5dcac9068ba84f01ea3daeaef8b26f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0401", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/ijerph22071082", "title": "The Effectiveness of Two Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Emergency Preparedness Amongst Enrollees of the World Trade Center Health Registry: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "H E Alper; L M Gargano; M K Hamwey; L F Leon; L Friedman", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40724149/", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph22071082", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S016", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "The Effectiveness of Two Interventions for Improving Knowledge of Emergency Preparedness Amongst Enrollees of the World Trade Center Health Registry: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "H E Alper; L M Gargano; M K Hamwey; L F Leon; L Friedman", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40724149/", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph22071082", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "713973eb0425c50712c08a35d60e43a70c6739f4b329b86dde759c43b3798a93" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0ecc25416bc2ba68a140d76bbb520cc10153aaa0cd152769a411ef665da2637b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0402", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/ijerph23060716", "title": "Sitting by the Fire: Dene Perspectives on Indigenous Traditional Ecological Knowledges, Land Stewardship, and Community Wellbeing", "authors": "Danya Carroll; Jennie Vandermeer; Dëneze Nakehk’o; John B. Zoe; Celine Mackenzie Vukson; Nicole Redvers", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph23060716", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph23060716", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S012", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Sitting by the Fire: Dene Perspectives on Indigenous Traditional Ecological Knowledges, Land Stewardship, and Community Wellbeing", "authors": "Danya Carroll; Jennie Vandermeer; Dëneze Nakehk’o; John B. Zoe; Celine Mackenzie Vukson; Nicole Redvers", "year": 2026, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph23060716", "doi": "10.3390/ijerph23060716", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d300b759e36843ee2fbfde42fa6ca384c7b2ff804115d02c538adc3d0ab96948" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1815177ef101abed2e5f1bd9ecb986722d5f5d94b029f0bcc72f329131a99ec6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0403", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/jcm11102880", "title": "Effect of Serious Gaming on Speech-in-Noise Intelligibility in Adult Cochlear Implantees: A Randomized Controlled Study", "authors": "P. Reynard; V. Attina; S. Idriss; R. Hermann; C. Barilly; E. Veuillet; C. A. Joly; H. Thai-Van", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35629004/", "doi": "10.3390/jcm11102880", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S010", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Effect of Serious Gaming on Speech-in-Noise Intelligibility in Adult Cochlear Implantees: A Randomized Controlled Study", "authors": "P. Reynard; V. Attina; S. Idriss; R. Hermann; C. Barilly; E. Veuillet; C. A. Joly; H. Thai-Van", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35629004/", "doi": "10.3390/jcm11102880", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5b22619b569095be506c73307b6ebc4596fe8359ff6dc6807d7fb84fa1057c7f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "01eca727c439c1b84bb2471b488c60873b557cc9c93ae9b4d95b829c54f176e1" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0404", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/jcm14155293", "title": "Backward Chaining Method for Teaching Long-Term Care Residents to Stand Up from the Floor: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Anna Zsófia Kubik; Zsigmond Gyombolai; András Simon; Éva Kovács", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40806915/", "doi": "10.3390/jcm14155293", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S015", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "Backward Chaining Method for Teaching Long-Term Care Residents to Stand Up from the Floor: A Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Anna Zsófia Kubik; Zsigmond Gyombolai; András Simon; Éva Kovács", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40806915/", "doi": "10.3390/jcm14155293", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f41df181d332dbd9de4d8be8853dd305bc74861232896ffac0001d3f36b8db4e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1c1ad372e8f4a22a8b2d434e2b330fcee5092a7099fa95ec7c3c669d51833d6e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0405", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/jintelligence13090119", "title": "Examining the Impact of Brief Mindfulness Practice on Sustained Attention, Attentional Inhibition and Convergent Thinking", "authors": "Hughes ZD; Ball LJ; Atanasov P; Judge J", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41003259", "doi": "10.3390/jintelligence13090119", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S011", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Examining the Impact of Brief Mindfulness Practice on Sustained Attention, Attentional Inhibition and Convergent Thinking", "authors": "Hughes ZD; Ball LJ; Atanasov P; Judge J", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41003259", "doi": "10.3390/jintelligence13090119", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "76dc94502c11a4f9bc2ebd3c53303d1166755a6f29c996918c308d7d70bb87a3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2d1dc46a768f84e2ec9d914efa9b4c2d223f35e1ec9466a550a80ed74f236b17" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0406", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/nu16203442", "title": "Caffeine Intake Alters Recovery Sleep after Sleep Deprivation", "authors": "Benoit Pauchon; Vincent Beauchamps; Danielle Gomez-Mérino; Mégane Erblang; Catherine Drogou; Pascal Van Beers; Mathias Guillard; Michaël Quiquempoix; Damien Léger; Mounir Chennaoui; Fabien Sauvet", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39458438/", "doi": "10.3390/nu16203442", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S007", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Caffeine Intake Alters Recovery Sleep after Sleep Deprivation", "authors": "Benoit Pauchon; Vincent Beauchamps; Danielle Gomez-Mérino; Mégane Erblang; Catherine Drogou; Pascal Van Beers; Mathias Guillard; Michaël Quiquempoix; Damien Léger; Mounir Chennaoui; Fabien Sauvet", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39458438/", "doi": "10.3390/nu16203442", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "RECOVERY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cde5e73e6dd09900e405308d53e3fc313b75a20fd2c3d7985c90e752563422f3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8de124d8fb1928b865a7bf0bc26208e527831ab418b0d8e24a9fd8a7c0ac68dd" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0407", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/s21082700", "title": "Blindness and the Reliability of Downwards Sensors to Avoid Obstacles: A Study with the EyeCane", "authors": "M. Bleau; S. Paré; I. Djerourou; D. R. Chebat; R. Kupers; M. Ptito", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/s21082700", "doi": "10.3390/s21082700", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S022", "F26-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10", "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S022", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Blindness and the Reliability of Downwards Sensors to Avoid Obstacles: A Study with the EyeCane", "authors": "M. Bleau; S. Paré; I. Djerourou; D. R. Chebat; R. Kupers; M. Ptito", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/s21082700", "doi": "10.3390/s21082700", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0273e4564e9f5b4938d7563900edffdc9b40f32d0489d97e44eb483685207ce0" }, { "source_id": "F26-S004", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Blindness and the Reliability of Downwards Sensors to Avoid Obstacles: A Study with the EyeCane", "authors": "M. Bleau; S. Paré; I. Djerourou; D. R. Chebat; R. Kupers; M. Ptito", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/s21082700", "doi": "10.3390/s21082700", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY", "WEARABLE_NAVIGATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c4c135824129b1d774a8336426cb565d01998f7fb54c3ed7a1aee885f275162a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9d8566e348a28ea7963bcd7eb9aad79aff572f4cae135da26c9599887c968f03" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0408", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/s22051859", "title": "The Unfolding Space Glove: A Wearable Spatio-Visual to Haptic Sensory Substitution Device for Blind People", "authors": "Jakob Kilian; Alexander Neugebauer; Lasse Scherffig; Siegfried Wahl", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/s22051859", "doi": "10.3390/s22051859", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S005", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "The Unfolding Space Glove: A Wearable Spatio-Visual to Haptic Sensory Substitution Device for Blind People", "authors": "Jakob Kilian; Alexander Neugebauer; Lasse Scherffig; Siegfried Wahl", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/s22051859", "doi": "10.3390/s22051859", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CANE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "WEARABLE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b12176a775120e2944dea4a1528f698900285b3c0e2d69c74ce353da857fb900" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "64dfe1a1cbc4f44f7efa8aa1b96c4d71c8f8472638ec209ac2bcf1147cdb1071" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0409", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/sports9060073", "title": "Change of Direction Speed and Technique Modification Training Improves 180° Turning Performance, Kinetics, and Kinematics", "authors": "Thomas Dos'Santos; Christopher Thomas; Alistair McBurnie; Paul Comfort; Paul A. Jones", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34073842/", "doi": "10.3390/sports9060073", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S010", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Change of Direction Speed and Technique Modification Training Improves 180° Turning Performance, Kinetics, and Kinematics", "authors": "Thomas Dos'Santos; Christopher Thomas; Alistair McBurnie; Paul Comfort; Paul A. Jones", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34073842/", "doi": "10.3390/sports9060073", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION_GAP", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "09fdeb19c06c73a60895ed8b6930e8e9795647c7d9d53b2406af51b3aeff0415" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2ff19b560bf3dec74f609144db35cff4fbc9ac8430f7b629e1a49b351ab94a87" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0410", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3390/su14010394", "title": "An Empirical Study of the Impact of Systems Thinking and Simulation on Sustainability Education", "authors": "Caroline Green; Owen Molloy; Jim Duggan", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su14010394", "doi": "10.3390/su14010394", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S013", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "An Empirical Study of the Impact of Systems Thinking and Simulation on Sustainability Education", "authors": "Caroline Green; Owen Molloy; Jim Duggan", "year": 2021, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3390/su14010394", "doi": "10.3390/su14010394", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COGNITIVE_LOAD", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "78864a965183b10eb9b52de78d5e92f609ac8f40c5e2d77786c368436e8cfbe8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1a12d085688cbed30a3d5e1558d8e89e3a7c6b544473928e8cf898e50b7f05e8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0411", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3399/bjgp15x684853", "title": "Effects of patient safety culture interventions on incident reporting in general practice: a cluster randomised trial", "authors": "Natasha J. Verbakel; Maaike Langelaan; Theo J. M. Verheij; Cordula Wagner; Dorien L. M. Zwart", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4408525/", "doi": "10.3399/bjgp15X684853", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S007", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Effects of patient safety culture interventions on incident reporting in general practice: a cluster randomised trial", "authors": "Natasha J. Verbakel; Maaike Langelaan; Theo J. M. Verheij; Cordula Wagner; Dorien L. M. Zwart", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4408525/", "doi": "10.3399/bjgp15X684853", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5057a94a538211ca586bb9d193861310982c86ff25a6f8f4149856d5146cffbf" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c2839c4a05e8f4188db2622fc5ab3e5f98e29a3aa46ee24e18db92d73a049b6b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0412", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3758/bf03206733", "title": "Absolute memory for musical pitch: evidence from the production of learned melodies", "authors": "D. J. Levitin", "year": 1994, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03206733", "doi": "10.3758/BF03206733", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S019" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S019", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Absolute memory for musical pitch: evidence from the production of learned melodies", "authors": "D. J. Levitin", "year": 1994, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3758/BF03206733", "doi": "10.3758/BF03206733", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "dc0eaa145b3b8fd8e74ecb8c3627b61b4ed04f3dddbc2563ea39352657d64d71" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "aab596669a3e79541044b4f46b755ac7bea64f7e4650f6ec7c1a9eb516861a42" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0413", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3758/bf03206848", "title": "Velocity-dependent improvements in single-dot direction discrimination", "authors": "Nestor Matthews; Leslie Welch", "year": 1997, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9038408/", "doi": "10.3758/BF03206848", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-14" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F14-S016", "family_id": "FAM-14", "title": "Velocity-dependent improvements in single-dot direction discrimination", "authors": "Nestor Matthews; Leslie Welch", "year": 1997, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9038408/", "doi": "10.3758/BF03206848", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TASK_SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3694844cd0e3e9cc093d898af79305e8ca7d0af1fd212658bbb778165bc41890" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b6716eca3096891af7fd25694a341264fb7bb0e89e3c683481255bfbe5ba8fab" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0414", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3758/bf03212967", "title": "Analogical encoding facilitates knowledge transfer in negotiation", "authors": "Loewenstein J; Thompson L; Gentner D", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10682201", "doi": "10.3758/BF03212967", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S002", "F18-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17", "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S002", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Analogical encoding facilitates knowledge transfer in negotiation", "authors": "Loewenstein J; Thompson L; Gentner D", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10682201", "doi": "10.3758/BF03212967", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "828732c6db9db257facb4bfe2f0154aee6bb42c5249e0d7159812631b30676f2" }, { "source_id": "F18-S002", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Analogical encoding facilitates knowledge transfer in negotiation", "authors": "Loewenstein J; Thompson L; Gentner D", "year": 1999, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10682201", "doi": "10.3758/BF03212967", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fec0a3e233a864dbb2654e16d8a91a26662c2c8a2596180fea71d4cc9c7ecfea" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1147960b5380867b4c462293a382531d76169dcb35dbd3060c87ddc4d361ed31" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0415", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3758/s13414-019-01869-3", "title": "Is it impossible to acquire absolute pitch in adulthood?", "authors": "Y. K. Wong; K. F. H. Lui; K. H. M. Yip; A. C.-N. Wong", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3758/s13414-019-01869-3", "doi": "10.3758/s13414-019-01869-3", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S020", "F19-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10", "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S020", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Is it impossible to acquire absolute pitch in adulthood?", "authors": "Y. K. Wong; K. F. H. Lui; K. H. M. Yip; A. C.-N. Wong", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.3758/s13414-019-01869-3", "doi": "10.3758/s13414-019-01869-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "21a374e501d4e353664d9a297b91c481f9b470c225f366984132443e7e7fcfd8" }, { "source_id": "F19-S001", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Is it impossible to acquire absolute pitch in adulthood?", "authors": "Wong YK; Lui KFH; Yip KHM; Wong AC", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31686378", "doi": "10.3758/s13414-019-01869-3", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESPONDER_VARIATION", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "938b5d7d7252e285c90c8ed4d6848c66ca1d69417b2c40f0913e1fd6ff550b4a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d6466fb40ce9f45d6a8bad34b1839d5ed4864dc7280435c36db4cdb8cb5f6af6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0416", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.3758/s13421-018-0815-7", "title": "Level of initial training moderates the effects of distributing practice over multiple days with expanding, contracting, and uniform schedules: Evidence for study-phase retrieval", "authors": "Toppino TC; Phelan HA; Gerbier E", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29728945", "doi": "10.3758/s13421-018-0815-7", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S004", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Level of initial training moderates the effects of distributing practice over multiple days with expanding, contracting, and uniform schedules: Evidence for study-phase retrieval", "authors": "Toppino TC; Phelan HA; Gerbier E", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29728945", "doi": "10.3758/s13421-018-0815-7", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DOSE_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c9f73db339df881f336c1538b2a398e984f381139804c60e240aabd2ffb63e81" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "639399f12aec611398f932082965b6022c28c692ba7287dc34da62911950b53d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0417", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.4085/1062-6040-50.1.05", "title": "Sport-specific training targeting the proximal segments and throwing velocity in collegiate throwing athletes", "authors": "Thomas Palmer; Timothy L. Uhl; Dana Howell; Timothy E. Hewett; Kert Viele; Carl G. Mattacola", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25844854/", "doi": "10.4085/1062-6040-50.1.05", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S007", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "Sport-specific training targeting the proximal segments and throwing velocity in collegiate throwing athletes", "authors": "Thomas Palmer; Timothy L. Uhl; Dana Howell; Timothy E. Hewett; Kert Viele; Carl G. Mattacola", "year": 2015, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25844854/", "doi": "10.4085/1062-6040-50.1.05", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0809afbe3f7f0c28e9d095350b108c94067160f20d96e3d1681c068e228e4b5b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c4a009bcbd60006560fe026c2eddfd0440435f54e786a15f682c970a052dcf13" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0418", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.4193/rhin24.081", "title": "Olfactory training for the treatment of COVID-19 related smell loss: a randomised double-blind controlled trial", "authors": "T. L. I. Serrano; M. A. Antonio; L. T. Giacomin; A. M. Morcillo; J. Dirceu Ribeiro; E. Sakano", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40202093/", "doi": "10.4193/Rhin24.081", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S015", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Olfactory training for the treatment of COVID-19 related smell loss: a randomised double-blind controlled trial", "authors": "T. L. I. Serrano; M. A. Antonio; L. T. Giacomin; A. M. Morcillo; J. Dirceu Ribeiro; E. Sakano", "year": 2025, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40202093/", "doi": "10.4193/Rhin24.081", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0f6b6c3ef827752b8f29e958941219c318fc91d3696b3d2a68d5d032966a5018" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "974df80fd748f5175a6828b48116c44d61465e37dd97ece3d4ba3c7bb4600554" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0419", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.52082/jssm.2024.907", "title": "The Effect of Speed Endurance Versus Core Training on The Repeated Sprint Ability of Youth Male Soccer Players - A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Olavo Maciel; Ricardo Martins; Fábio Y. Nakamura; Pedro Figueiredo; José Afonso; Ivan Baptista", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39649563/", "doi": "10.52082/jssm.2024.907", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S012", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "The Effect of Speed Endurance Versus Core Training on The Repeated Sprint Ability of Youth Male Soccer Players - A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Olavo Maciel; Ricardo Martins; Fábio Y. Nakamura; Pedro Figueiredo; José Afonso; Ivan Baptista", "year": 2024, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39649563/", "doi": "10.52082/jssm.2024.907", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "926d72dd1109b8f91ef0674f2de5fde04fbc1e4005b8ec2f35909e36e627f600" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2f858c6ce7d3c392c1a47a2759652f4e4c26be723946eaf4f427a2781490a88b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0420", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.5334/dsj-2020-043", "title": "CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance", "authors": "Global Indigenous Data Alliance", "year": 2019, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gida-global.org/careprinciples", "doi": "10.5334/dsj-2020-043", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S011", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "CARE Principles for Indigenous Data Governance", "authors": "Global Indigenous Data Alliance", "year": 2019, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gida-global.org/careprinciples", "doi": "10.5334/dsj-2020-043", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "f83af16a0ee73a025351bcca37775728a78f44ecd06fcf177a7f4a69e7f7fcb5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "697c337526a358c9da5324e40abb0419142cfbece5a2ce93d04e4c49271416b2" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0421", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.5334/joc.91", "title": "Good News about Bad News: Gamified Inoculation Boosts Confidence and Cognitive Immunity Against Fake News", "authors": "Melisa Basol; Jon Roozenbeek; Sander van der Linden", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.5334/joc.91", "doi": "10.5334/joc.91", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F16-S006", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Good News about Bad News: Gamified Inoculation Boosts Confidence and Cognitive Immunity Against Fake News", "authors": "Melisa Basol; Jon Roozenbeek; Sander van der Linden", "year": 2020, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://doi.org/10.5334/joc.91", "doi": "10.5334/joc.91", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "IMMEDIATE_TRANSFER", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "02a2482da6b675eaffc97c6f197af2b62ad64b6c385051d1e036e1ce25fb571a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8355a9420210c5101135c986d77ad9bc12705a351441b44570bff4c2ceadae3d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.6028/nist.ai.100-1", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0)", "authors": "Elham Tabassi; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/artificial-intelligence-risk-management-framework-ai-rmf-10", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.AI.100-1", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S015", "F28-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25", "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S015", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0)", "authors": "Elham Tabassi; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/artificial-intelligence-risk-management-framework-ai-rmf-10", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.AI.100-1", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCOUNTABILITY", "GOVERNANCE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VALIDITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bde0a969420cf97d124462d0f26e8160fc8cef1cfeca8d8831024bab616f88ef" }, { "source_id": "F28-S013", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0)", "authors": "E Tabassi; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/artificial-intelligence-risk-management-framework-ai-rmf-10", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.AI.100-1", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "17dd50f3bc256494a96a08682efceef4953fd98308d0d36160d244cb45157a99" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "df08aa96e42ed8f2be8c7e02d2f523b817c77bd484214d3aec3aba04722f75ac" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0423", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.6028/nist.ai.600-1", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile", "authors": "C. Autio; R. Schwartz; J. Dunietz; S. Jain; M. Stanley; E. Tabassi; P. Hall; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/artificial-intelligence-risk-management-framework-generative-artificial-intelligence", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S016", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile", "authors": "C. Autio; R. Schwartz; J. Dunietz; S. Jain; M. Stanley; E. Tabassi; P. Hall; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/artificial-intelligence-risk-management-framework-generative-artificial-intelligence", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MISUSE", "MODEL_DRIFT", "PRIVACY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "eb39abddf4c138bf0433cea85f16dcc5756e05ccefc84db3cc8623a4a76199b5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2f131711c387bee89a04515fb164acdfcc0acebd663dcbfab2f705d7132f2979" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.6028/nist.cswp.01162020", "title": "NIST Privacy Framework: A Tool for Improving Privacy Through Enterprise Risk Management, Version 1.0", "authors": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/nist-privacy-framework-tool-improving-privacy-through-enterprise-risk-management", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.CSWP.01162020", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017", "F27-S014", "F28-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-25", "FAM-27", "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F25-S017", "family_id": "FAM-25", "title": "NIST Privacy Framework: A Tool for Improving Privacy Through Enterprise Risk Management, Version 1.0", "authors": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/nist-privacy-framework-tool-improving-privacy-through-enterprise-risk-management", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.CSWP.01162020", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "222befe65341b4622934f64f9a8bcea503df1e369884ac7e2e28fb96c922dd33" }, { "source_id": "F27-S014", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "NIST Privacy Framework: A Tool for Improving Privacy Through Enterprise Risk Management, Version 1.0", "authors": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/nist-privacy-framework-tool-improving-privacy-through-enterprise-risk-management", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.CSWP.01162020", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cef7ea7b9be2e5851316c57d5b50cc101df6a33e6a61202a3cf554d852ba92f0" }, { "source_id": "F28-S010", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "NIST Privacy Framework: A Tool for Improving Privacy Through Enterprise Risk Management, Version 1.0", "authors": "K Boeckl; N Lefkovitz; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/publications/nist-privacy-framework-tool-improving-privacy-through-enterprise-risk-management", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.CSWP.01162020", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ed7a20b774ddb6618645c6e843664ce0844bcff2e2a08dbf3a0a38a677500bc8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1030cc6437bbbcdfca66a24b187a13809ee66aa0fb4ef8d99e08d7c9f207af55" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0425", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.6028/nist.sp.800-34r1", "title": "Contingency Planning Guide for Federal Information Systems (NIST SP 800-34 Rev. 1)", "authors": "Marianne Swanson; Pauline Bowen; Amy Phillips; Dean Gallup; David Lynes; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2010, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/34/r1/upd1/final", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.SP.800-34r1", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S004", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Contingency Planning Guide for Federal Information Systems (NIST SP 800-34 Rev. 1)", "authors": "Marianne Swanson; Pauline Bowen; Amy Phillips; Dean Gallup; David Lynes; National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2010, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/34/r1/upd1/final", "doi": "10.6028/NIST.SP.800-34r1", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "143496464a463414ca8e5fc603a8755cfb9aab4e4aa60c9343d0a49b68065232" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8a21fc527fa2654f5b1f6fb10edc668e05057a60664b1dffa599a10f51c1677a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0426", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.7205/milmed.171.8.742", "title": "Can simple anthropometric and physical performance tests track training-induced changes in load-carriage ability?", "authors": "Alun G. Williams", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16933815/", "doi": "10.7205/MILMED.171.8.742", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F03-S008", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "Can simple anthropometric and physical performance tests track training-induced changes in load-carriage ability?", "authors": "Alun G. Williams", "year": 2006, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16933815/", "doi": "10.7205/MILMED.171.8.742", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "71962919876d119a06ad8c53344e73f101b6e0d0e67622f58ce1ca5c3de800b0" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "21abfed4bc45fe304032a96dbc60f70fe88d727d08c54693a45da8b441065718" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0427", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.7326/0003-4819-156-6-201203200-00004", "title": "Peer Mentoring and Financial Incentives to Improve Glucose Control in African American Veterans", "authors": "Judith A. Long; Erica C. Jahnle; Diane M. Richardson; George Loewenstein; Kevin G. Volpp", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22431674/", "doi": "10.7326/0003-4819-156-6-201203200-00004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S007", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Peer Mentoring and Financial Incentives to Improve Glucose Control in African American Veterans", "authors": "Judith A. Long; Erica C. Jahnle; Diane M. Richardson; George Loewenstein; Kevin G. Volpp", "year": 2012, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22431674/", "doi": "10.7326/0003-4819-156-6-201203200-00004", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "19516d5941595d10d4ae5c40ab5779240e31a565cb92ee4ae4daa75ac7db45db" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "22497916257228b2ff46a1cbc23cd0037e64df23344469f9b8d9282e57fb29d3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0428", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.7554/elife.10762", "title": "Massive cortical reorganization in sighted Braille readers", "authors": "K. Siuda-Krzywicka; Ł. Bola; M. Paplińska; E. Sumera; K. Jednoróg; A. Marchewka; M. W. Śliwińska; A. Amedi; M. Szwed", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26976813/", "doi": "10.7554/eLife.10762", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S004" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S004", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Massive cortical reorganization in sighted Braille readers", "authors": "K. Siuda-Krzywicka; Ł. Bola; M. Paplińska; E. Sumera; K. Jednoróg; A. Marchewka; M. W. Śliwińska; A. Amedi; M. Szwed", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26976813/", "doi": "10.7554/eLife.10762", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bc6bee7076f5dc1893b2d65fb3bf0418910f46035f05ccef1d04172cf1c42bce" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "300f04983af2c9c094ee2b931177a5858ba4f3e3c7718a0280374bde3fa24eba" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0429", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.7554/elife.63405", "title": "Influence of sensory modality and control dynamics on human path integration", "authors": "Akis Stavropoulos; Kaushik J Lakshminarasimhan; Jean Laurens; Xaq Pitkow; Dora E Angelaki", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35179488/", "doi": "10.7554/eLife.63405", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-12" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F12-S005", "family_id": "FAM-12", "title": "Influence of sensory modality and control dynamics on human path integration", "authors": "Akis Stavropoulos; Kaushik J Lakshminarasimhan; Jean Laurens; Xaq Pitkow; Dora E Angelaki", "year": 2022, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35179488/", "doi": "10.7554/eLife.63405", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9cb5feaa95a75c29575c7922e6c4cd3b3eaca5903e1cceb4e302075f83d53bb9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "05cc5fac3d11074e4961c2e7c51bcbf885d117c6bdffe36e2f090ccf762c6f2c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0430", "canonical_identity": "doi:10.7717/peerj.5292", "title": "The voluntary control of piloerection", "authors": "James A J Heathers; Kirill Fayn; Paul J Silvia; Niko Tiliopoulos; Matthew S Goodwin", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30083447/", "doi": "10.7717/peerj.5292", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S006", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "The voluntary control of piloerection", "authors": "James A J Heathers; Kirill Fayn; Paul J Silvia; Niko Tiliopoulos; Matthew S Goodwin", "year": 2018, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30083447/", "doi": "10.7717/peerj.5292", "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "79524d6a449e0e62e57b6363258a7f4c7a785d71cd532f27bf6cb96a591db8f5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "7aacd61f326a0d3128b75029ecea963f0bb246528b2e06e04769f20027de333d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0431", "canonical_identity": "url:https://aasm.org/advocacy/position-statements/consumer-sleep-technology", "title": "Consumer Sleep Technology: An American Academy of Sleep Medicine Position Statement", "authors": "American Academy of Sleep Medicine Board of Directors", "year": 2018, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://aasm.org/advocacy/position-statements/consumer-sleep-technology/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S012", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Consumer Sleep Technology: An American Academy of Sleep Medicine Position Statement", "authors": "American Academy of Sleep Medicine Board of Directors", "year": 2018, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://aasm.org/advocacy/position-statements/consumer-sleep-technology/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "MEASUREMENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2d114458cdc814c1cf010059896d7c70d858530806128220edb3c9a77f51658b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a6dfab8a87ed0f1dfac20512c495496537c817a1f523a668beea0f40ec979451" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0432", "canonical_identity": "url:https://ada.gov/resources/effective-communication", "title": "ADA Requirements: Effective Communication", "authors": "United States Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REGULATION", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ada.gov/resources/effective-communication/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S011", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "ADA Requirements: Effective Communication", "authors": "United States Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REGULATION", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ada.gov/resources/effective-communication/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9da4feaaf590905a82351b7f129f3214ca103c63aa55f4d34685ca0ec5eb7537" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "2372d9a8e777b7a3fd9e7c2c95115408883f17fb60b4713d5b4355e0516a36b0" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0433", "canonical_identity": "url:https://ahrq.gov/health-literacy/improve/precautions/tool5.html", "title": "Use the Teach-Back Method: Tool 5", "authors": "Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ahrq.gov/health-literacy/improve/precautions/tool5.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S012", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Use the Teach-Back Method: Tool 5", "authors": "Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ahrq.gov/health-literacy/improve/precautions/tool5.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COMPREHENSION_CHECK", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HIGH_STAKES_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2cb225466ba6a64c3a70afab1d50f1231fccf90539bd491592d088964323662d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "9529a6f5a2e6b19a834a66864d092baa86d9d32f2afa4e5c0803d80bfccbd420" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0434", "canonical_identity": "url:https://ahrq.gov/teamstepps-program/updated/index.html", "title": "TeamSTEPPS 3.0", "authors": "Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_TRAINING_FRAMEWORK", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ahrq.gov/teamstepps-program/updated/index.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S018" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F24-S018", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "TeamSTEPPS 3.0", "authors": "Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_TRAINING_FRAMEWORK", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ahrq.gov/teamstepps-program/updated/index.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "05f8616e2396e50d08983c474c20b634159383dcf3f613ad7789a6fbdc84b848" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "0eb7891b574f093a235aa231b452080c91af621839eeadf9ffe29aefcfd1f785" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0435", "canonical_identity": "url:https://asha.org/practice-portal/clinical-topics/aphasia", "title": "Aphasia", "authors": "American Speech-Language-Hearing Association", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/clinical-topics/aphasia/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S015", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Aphasia", "authors": "American Speech-Language-Hearing Association", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/clinical-topics/aphasia/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LEGITIMACY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0db91158bd6a90ba45bb11a6fae156e70dfabd831b53139c68c0461430aab516" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "29f7fb25448671fc9f4b90335829a72fbb5244bf03a208c65fb251493ed65226" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0436", "canonical_identity": "url:https://asha.org/practice-portal/professional-issues/augmentative-and-alternative-communication", "title": "Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC)", "authors": "American Speech-Language-Hearing Association", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/professional-issues/augmentative-and-alternative-communication/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S002", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Augmentative and Alternative Communication (AAC)", "authors": "American Speech-Language-Hearing Association", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.asha.org/practice-portal/professional-issues/augmentative-and-alternative-communication/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ABANDONMENT", "AUTHORSHIP", "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MULTIMODAL_ACCESS" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "7b97908fd846de5ce5ab4dae7c248cb3b562f2dbaabd114a95342d6ff75adc3c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "585bdc030296392743577697a5aeae951ac5f7359744138599685ba3811a274f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0437", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cdc.gov/niosh/centers/fatigue.html", "title": "Center for Work and Fatigue Research", "authors": "US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/centers/fatigue.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S015", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Center for Work and Fatigue Research", "authors": "US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/centers/fatigue.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "577df2d488efa4bd1a8fb4bb74aa51b12db01a201ddb45273cc4a7874152c1aa" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "61517c016554fa602a739043e09bbcf4e6e085f6d991252251e8f92068155d9c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0438", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cdc.gov/niosh/cold-stress/about/index.html", "title": "Cold and Work: Types, Causes, Preparation", "authors": "National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/cold-stress/about/index.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S007", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Cold and Work: Types, Causes, Preparation", "authors": "National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/cold-stress/about/index.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "89bd8b47ff8b3627b5eefac68918207021003c0303e5b7a29c721d144a0d4810" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "91780aec4bb2e773311f98ff1ced4f0be18d8e628e2f3194004d879831e26758" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0439", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cdc.gov/niosh/heat-stress/recommendations", "title": "Workplace Recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/heat-stress/recommendations/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S001" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S001", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Workplace Recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/heat-stress/recommendations/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3155fa2709db2e7fae21a2b58492e52575b0dfa35abdf1bd31853fd252c61829" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "075fc9f771f9ed61ac8d9658c4810c20daf70ef1538afbb91be5f9ad342b0946" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0440", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cdc.gov/niosh/motor-vehicle/driver-fatigue/index.html", "title": "Driver Fatigue on the Job", "authors": "US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/motor-vehicle/driver-fatigue/index.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S013", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Driver Fatigue on the Job", "authors": "US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/motor-vehicle/driver-fatigue/index.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "c484ddfffbb8daf7a78fef8c9aaa91981fe4006abe4b4bc53e8f8ce6673f536d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "49bb010e8628d7e7a78901617ab7e1c8625a5ed94363ad44e605b5dac893cd21" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0441", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cdc.gov/winter-weather/prevention/index.html", "title": "Preventing Hypothermia", "authors": "US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/winter-weather/prevention/index.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S014", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Preventing Hypothermia", "authors": "US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/winter-weather/prevention/index.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5b90d5b01394c8f4abb2d96417dc48f9a3252327796f633615effe4e72fbed1f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "f72846d8ef1f3f7169aa5a97f0e12805989dbae67927ebc5c36817fe4be58482" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0442", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cdc.gov/yellow-book/hcp/environmental-hazards-risks/high-altitude-travel-and-altitude-illness.html", "title": "High-Altitude Travel and Altitude Illness", "authors": "P H Hackett; D R Shlim; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/yellow-book/hcp/environmental-hazards-risks/high-altitude-travel-and-altitude-illness.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S009", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "High-Altitude Travel and Altitude Illness", "authors": "P H Hackett; D R Shlim; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cdc.gov/yellow-book/hcp/environmental-hazards-risks/high-altitude-travel-and-altitude-illness.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "bf802b7cfd4107e476e6ed40a712ea95cc8b7d2e5ad6f765ae430f466ecd2bf6" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "77131f3d10b92bea68c78319bdd4f41236b380fa8d6f792eb9586bab9b4d1281" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0443", "canonical_identity": "url:https://cnib.ca/en/getting-around", "title": "Getting around: orientation and mobility", "authors": "CNIB Foundation", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cnib.ca/en/getting-around", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S024" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S024", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Getting around: orientation and mobility", "authors": "CNIB Foundation", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.cnib.ca/en/getting-around", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2940c05a785a55a0833101ced5e11a8533d958af00f4137be94d3904b51e3b28" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "54fb3340aaec2032023e8e79a3ef5e7b7089486fc117aaba404941396b96a703" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0444", "canonical_identity": "url:https://coe.int/en/web/common-european-framework-reference-languages/cefr-descriptors", "title": "Common European Framework of Reference for Languages: Learning, teaching, assessment – Companion volume", "authors": "Council of Europe", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.coe.int/en/web/common-european-framework-reference-languages/cefr-descriptors", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S003", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Common European Framework of Reference for Languages: Learning, teaching, assessment – Companion volume", "authors": "Council of Europe", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.coe.int/en/web/common-european-framework-reference-languages/cefr-descriptors", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6ff06c96b9ed6544e03e55ea63a26cbe53424932a28d929df700209a1ef850ca" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "07e2e271e12721fc7a61ad63dffad3eaecfaf24b18da6efe3e89bc309af5177b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "canonical_identity": "url:https://copyright.gov/AI", "title": "Copyright and Artificial Intelligence", "authors": "United States Copyright Office", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.copyright.gov/AI/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S012", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Copyright and Artificial Intelligence", "authors": "United States Copyright Office", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.copyright.gov/AI/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "28954154ec6e699d9ea963c580fbebab2e0b909c51c949bc527e046a255e604a" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "192d541363fc12238b43d3a74b0f74ade002c0876151edaf3a78c292467d85bc" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0446", "canonical_identity": "url:https://ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-H/part-886/subpart-F/section-886.5905", "title": "21 CFR 886.5905: Oral electronic vision aid", "authors": "United States Food and Drug Administration / Electronic Code of Federal Regulations", "year": 2015, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REGULATION", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-H/part-886/subpart-F/section-886.5905", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S025" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S025", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "21 CFR 886.5905: Oral electronic vision aid", "authors": "United States Food and Drug Administration / Electronic Code of Federal Regulations", "year": 2015, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REGULATION", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-H/part-886/subpart-F/section-886.5905", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "REGULATORY_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "724016a389ea4a710440fcf0988b1a35dccc406f0e2cee6332f89c03ee43219c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b5f1bc23d7c5dbc06de4c2de3c6bbc48c5b92fa3959c4e624d2b9c722786090f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0447", "canonical_identity": "url:https://england.nhs.uk/long-read/patient-safety-incident-response-framework", "title": "Patient Safety Incident Response Framework", "authors": "NHS England", "year": 2022, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/patient-safety-incident-response-framework/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S010", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Patient Safety Incident Response Framework", "authors": "NHS England", "year": 2022, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.england.nhs.uk/long-read/patient-safety-incident-response-framework/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6317e29fc033faa9f2913262fed135fdc2ca66ea9cb9468ecf78a9bd146eb1d9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8e9a33e823fafb421d12bfbcf7f2f11b23d3a37d207c324068006f85db8b3bae" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0448", "canonical_identity": "url:https://faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/aim/aim0801.html", "title": "Aeronautical Information Manual, Chapter 8: Medical Facts for Pilots", "authors": "Federal Aviation Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/aim/aim0801.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S013", "F29-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09", "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S013", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Aeronautical Information Manual, Chapter 8: Medical Facts for Pilots", "authors": "Federal Aviation Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/aim/aim0801.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "2788e4df7bf5a95e5c5a0eadc72a7c95c8793988da347355e67da77ef5b54797" }, { "source_id": "F29-S014", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Aeronautical Information Manual, Chapter 8: Medical Facts for Pilots", "authors": "Federal Aviation Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/aim/aim0801.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e0cf847b911d762706783c38f09247351bd15c588f4ee38291598a12f4bf624f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "1647ed49eccb72b51bff0d2887ef697af15da40937eec372511b366bdbe3724d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0449", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/spilling-beans-how-much-caffeine-too-much", "title": "Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine is Too Much?", "authors": "US Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/spilling-beans-how-much-caffeine-too-much", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-07" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F07-S014", "family_id": "FAM-07", "title": "Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine is Too Much?", "authors": "US Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/spilling-beans-how-much-caffeine-too-much", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4cc2d6794046f354a1fb531727d6f0f5583a328230d74be28b0ee713bb51787c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "fec1ba39808ecba2d6442d1c1579198dbb7807cb41668c50e6c2eda8b69685a9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0450", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fda.gov/medical-devices/medical-device-regulatory-science-research-programs-conducted-osel/credibility-computational-models-program-research-computational-models-and-simulation-associated", "title": "Credibility of Computational Models Program: Research on Computational Models and Simulation Associated with Medical Devices", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Office of Science and Engineering Laboratories", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/medical-device-regulatory-science-research-programs-conducted-osel/credibility-computational-models-program-research-computational-models-and-simulation-associated", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S012", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Credibility of Computational Models Program: Research on Computational Models and Simulation Associated with Medical Devices", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Office of Science and Engineering Laboratories", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/medical-device-regulatory-science-research-programs-conducted-osel/credibility-computational-models-program-research-computational-models-and-simulation-associated", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b666dac935c24f4aaa5a033a97e528fcd1192e788711292be157dd39b480bc55" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5946a15d5d3a54434a7083cb8e2a5f59851dbdfe8b9911b8fc89b6822079cc30" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0451", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/clinical-decision-support-software", "title": "Clinical Decision Support Software", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/clinical-decision-support-software", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S015", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Clinical Decision Support Software", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/clinical-decision-support-software", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "015e6ec5a61ad241c68dfc95961a6e8703733668430a833945747b7a0e203cf5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "e3b365cd8693e7f9cf7b58ad4c942a2ad405d18fda35d2c3111d30f723622482" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/cybersecurity-medical-devices-quality-management-system-considerations-and-content-premarket", "title": "Cybersecurity in Medical Devices: Quality Management System Considerations and Content of Premarket Submissions", "authors": "United States Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/cybersecurity-medical-devices-quality-management-system-considerations-and-content-premarket", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012", "F28-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27", "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S012", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Cybersecurity in Medical Devices: Quality Management System Considerations and Content of Premarket Submissions", "authors": "United States Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/cybersecurity-medical-devices-quality-management-system-considerations-and-content-premarket", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cf6621ef1a7c1cb6d164898ee360105b98bd4c377864337df92efd21c8eee9af" }, { "source_id": "F28-S011", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Cybersecurity in Medical Devices: Quality Management System Considerations and Content of Premarket Submissions", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/cybersecurity-medical-devices-quality-management-system-considerations-and-content-premarket", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6b1271fd3e7051e735fe96eb4226b95e8f96a25651e3e1a7b14ef51c224858ce" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "eb3be8e3a6b05bf6231114a275d5ad2c47ea7a2dbb37dfeb54910f2c23a3d72d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0453", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/implanted-brain-computer-interface-bci-devices-patients-paralysis-or-amputation-non-clinical-testing", "title": "Implanted Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) Devices for Patients with Paralysis or Amputation — Non-clinical Testing and Clinical Considerations", "authors": "United States Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/implanted-brain-computer-interface-bci-devices-patients-paralysis-or-amputation-non-clinical-testing", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S011", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Implanted Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) Devices for Patients with Paralysis or Amputation — Non-clinical Testing and Clinical Considerations", "authors": "United States Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/implanted-brain-computer-interface-bci-devices-patients-paralysis-or-amputation-non-clinical-testing", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM_RISK", "REGULATED_DEVICE" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "864745304f1a6ad0f79609ca7bc41dbad8c6171f2bf6639823c9e5b89bacc343" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5ce340ccd3b00b777c4be9abfa822deb46fb786573f722512d97566e87cd833f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0454", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/marketing-submission-recommendations-predetermined-change-control-plan-artificial-intelligence", "title": "Marketing Submission Recommendations for a Predetermined Change Control Plan for Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Device Software Functions", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/marketing-submission-recommendations-predetermined-change-control-plan-artificial-intelligence", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-28" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F28-S014", "family_id": "FAM-28", "title": "Marketing Submission Recommendations for a Predetermined Change Control Plan for Artificial Intelligence-Enabled Device Software Functions", "authors": "U.S. Food and Drug Administration", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/marketing-submission-recommendations-predetermined-change-control-plan-artificial-intelligence", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3d08f9a20230e4cdb6207f4bfa561572f2ac8dec63dafe2f0ba9fabaa21d1dba" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "dd41067b20c07bf52289575295199730025785c960c7af3a54c20925dc4e8255" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0455", "canonical_identity": "url:https://fema.gov/emergency-managers/national-preparedness/continuity/toolkit", "title": "Continuity Guidance Circular", "authors": "Federal Emergency Management Agency", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fema.gov/emergency-managers/national-preparedness/continuity/toolkit", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S018" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S018", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Continuity Guidance Circular", "authors": "Federal Emergency Management Agency", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.fema.gov/emergency-managers/national-preparedness/continuity/toolkit", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e2f92eb4406ecf9c1f600f389816817d7f24e33e32539dae2205b9a3ee2a6d18" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "97f4acdac5d9003c768ec7c4d734fcfa8c9053fa058b5006504d8ba608abaf96" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0456", "canonical_identity": "url:https://gov.uk/government/publications/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-statutory-guidance-framework", "title": "Controlling or coercive behaviour: statutory guidance framework", "authors": "Home Office", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STATUTORY_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-statutory-guidance-framework", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S009" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S009", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Controlling or coercive behaviour: statutory guidance framework", "authors": "Home Office", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STATUTORY_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/controlling-or-coercive-behaviour-statutory-guidance-framework", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COERCION", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFEGUARDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5419de607343b1d6b4bf412bdf9dc65c3a1ac82ef87f742fe3bc9b44bd240e46" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "649e010e43520a1c381374e969f9f0a7e46efbf35e516f1a95f96e4b2a7275b5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0457", "canonical_identity": "url:https://gov.uk/government/publications/orange-book/the-orange-book-management-of-risk-principles-and-concepts", "title": "The Orange Book: Management of Risk — Principles and Concepts", "authors": "HM Treasury", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/orange-book/the-orange-book-management-of-risk-principles-and-concepts", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S005", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "The Orange Book: Management of Risk — Principles and Concepts", "authors": "HM Treasury", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/orange-book/the-orange-book-management-of-risk-principles-and-concepts", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "44e01074331c56d1f82184f41f2e9ef394b82dce891338fc20ce44b2fda0adf3" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "6ac9bb1531992065856d70c9e5fd11fd51f107ed173eadc428e37e8be0805f24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0458", "canonical_identity": "url:https://gov.uk/government/publications/the-7-principles-of-public-life/the-7-principles-of-public-life--2", "title": "The Seven Principles of Public Life", "authors": "Committee on Standards in Public Life", "year": 1995, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-7-principles-of-public-life/the-7-principles-of-public-life--2", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S005" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S005", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "The Seven Principles of Public Life", "authors": "Committee on Standards in Public Life", "year": 1995, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-7-principles-of-public-life/the-7-principles-of-public-life--2", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "1cd843f37f9982ff1b31ee6075f99073e1d88182fd7618b801e533afaa1889b9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "14064595fd12e1e8f244be11cdb748b6fe9f9fd9146d78d3380fa9bb623a4213" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0459", "canonical_identity": "url:https://gov.uk/government/publications/the-magenta-book", "title": "Magenta Book: Central Government guidance on evaluation", "authors": "HM Treasury and Evaluation Task Force", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-magenta-book", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S011", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Magenta Book: Central Government guidance on evaluation", "authors": "HM Treasury and Evaluation Task Force", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-magenta-book", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "6678683c106c6b4f8a06727d71707de6a093cce7e6c0c36034a2d6219beadcff" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bd278f12a31943ee17b19ac43a1335fd485f8bf2ea0a603a0e6f6b8f7ecce573" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0460", "canonical_identity": "url:https://gov.uk/guidance/whistleblowing-guidance-for-employers", "title": "Whistleblowing guidance for employers and code of practice", "authors": "UK Department for Business and Trade", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/guidance/whistleblowing-guidance-for-employers", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-31" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F31-S006", "family_id": "FAM-31", "title": "Whistleblowing guidance for employers and code of practice", "authors": "UK Department for Business and Trade", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.gov.uk/guidance/whistleblowing-guidance-for-employers", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b013324302e8ff91bc7af415171e2f41837ce25535d4457ea8570f72661503f7" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "079325df1a7e50a2dd6128a678c996e3734958818ba07e7c886346aca8b000fa" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0461", "canonical_identity": "url:https://heart.org/en/health-topics/arrhythmia/symptoms-diagnosis--monitoring-of-arrhythmia/syncope-fainting", "title": "Syncope (Fainting)", "authors": "American Heart Association", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/arrhythmia/symptoms-diagnosis--monitoring-of-arrhythmia/syncope-fainting", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-06" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F06-S015", "family_id": "FAM-06", "title": "Syncope (Fainting)", "authors": "American Heart Association", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.heart.org/en/health-topics/arrhythmia/symptoms-diagnosis--monitoring-of-arrhythmia/syncope-fainting", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "cbb6b0ec28fdd454362a2cf36a8604f60213a9cf600823f7842268b28ca1b744" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c06fdb710547c7abcd49098b01accd7a319403aa30c793b92e532fcfeafcfa8b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0462", "canonical_identity": "url:https://hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/guidance/faq/informed-consent/index.html", "title": "Informed Consent FAQs", "authors": "United States Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Human Research Protections", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REGULATION", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/guidance/faq/informed-consent/index.html", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-18" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F18-S013", "family_id": "FAM-18", "title": "Informed Consent FAQs", "authors": "United States Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Human Research Protections", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REGULATION", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/guidance/faq/informed-consent/index.html", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "COERCION_BOUNDARY", "CONSENT", "HIGH_STAKES_GOVERNANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "23cb3379bb6cd03feb55d515f09a950aef39bfa585fac1788ce61aee7a8bdd0b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3a87b42a7d99b363399c22ac9f4c559bdfc94bb0f443ed20fe4276a8e17a7c02" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "canonical_identity": "url:https://hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg438.htm", "title": "Assessment of repetitive tasks of the upper limbs (the ART tool)", "authors": "UK Health and Safety Executive", "year": 2010, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg438.htm", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-20" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F20-S017", "family_id": "FAM-20", "title": "Assessment of repetitive tasks of the upper limbs (the ART tool)", "authors": "UK Health and Safety Executive", "year": 2010, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/indg438.htm", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "dd3e37b218fa77d9dc38b907ccd20132eb642b1ad8a7fb3b8f30c98680b8a4b9" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "c7cf9ebfd31f7b0b8e85b02268206fa5669176910ade3af58ac7808aea5da20e" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0464", "canonical_identity": "url:https://iasp-pain.org/resources/terminology", "title": "IASP Terminology: pain, nociception and related terms", "authors": "International Association for the Study of Pain", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.iasp-pain.org/resources/terminology/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S013", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "IASP Terminology: pain, nociception and related terms", "authors": "International Association for the Study of Pain", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.iasp-pain.org/resources/terminology/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LEGITIMACY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5c8bc023d65c63874e741d3c1bcefaebbfc6f99b0eb8ce5bc1941683043b22a4" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "181093d10ec8aa8e0bd86aeaca2f8fb2475b34a0f810dd633499c40b92df1b50" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "canonical_identity": "url:https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/employment/monitoring-workers", "title": "Employment practices and data protection: monitoring workers", "authors": "Information Commissioner’s Office", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/employment/monitoring-workers/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017", "F24-S019" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-22", "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F22-S017", "family_id": "FAM-22", "title": "Employment practices and data protection: monitoring workers", "authors": "Information Commissioner’s Office", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/employment/monitoring-workers/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "49a5ca91feae5c30c2325671e5bbf21f2279d32134490764f2f8abdaedd2d8e5" }, { "source_id": "F24-S019", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Employment practices and data protection: monitoring workers", "authors": "Information Commissioner’s Office", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/employment/monitoring-workers/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ab0d9c4733fb17e8d9e013ae7a624c381b7da8c5ef390e2b59d52424a93c886b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "45fde28cb94f724807d81dba69f7667b6a658178562ade7890c62814193afcd8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0466", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nasa.gov/reference/risk-of-reduced-cardiorespiratory-and-musculoskeletal-fitness", "title": "Risk of Reduced Cardiorespiratory and Musculoskeletal Fitness", "authors": "National Aeronautics and Space Administration", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/reference/risk-of-reduced-cardiorespiratory-and-musculoskeletal-fitness/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S014", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Risk of Reduced Cardiorespiratory and Musculoskeletal Fitness", "authors": "National Aeronautics and Space Administration", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nasa.gov/reference/risk-of-reduced-cardiorespiratory-and-musculoskeletal-fitness/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3ed8f9bf3b03a56e8e5b5436358849358d5b9cd8dd97439f5e9a857a81c0b77d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "36222002685e75cdd0098f90ff6b50aac295267e05fa262d5a2d7385a144844c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0467", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nice.org.uk/guidance/cg185/chapter/recommendations", "title": "Bipolar disorder: assessment and management — recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2014, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg185/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S011", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Bipolar disorder: assessment and management — recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2014, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg185/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ab06ca01381f73ede48f9bb3cd2bbcf44c919ab3e60ce4496f562a76ec1b3d67" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "50fd32acb0018e673c018ec499f68f9b2b7cd8ad791d2639a0ac2ba0b42424f5" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0468", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nice.org.uk/guidance/ng116/chapter/recommendations", "title": "Post-traumatic stress disorder — recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2018, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng116/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-21" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F21-S015", "family_id": "FAM-21", "title": "Post-traumatic stress disorder — recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2018, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng116/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b270a128d324ddfe90502f011f8c217497d3ae965b15530e9292294375355676" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "058d44e3c4e8a719f11346227459caa885ab5ebc21fcafaae2e4f96979dad9b3" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0469", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nice.org.uk/guidance/ng125/chapter/recommendations", "title": "Surgical site infections: prevention and treatment (NICE guideline NG125)", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2019, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng125/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-05" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F05-S010", "family_id": "FAM-05", "title": "Surgical site infections: prevention and treatment (NICE guideline NG125)", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2019, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng125/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "8515a5b07cb22c63585b11d219715adeecfda0d1fc0832c012a9d949dfd393be" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "33e4d5f9599ba145e814ebf70890b2157cb58f448d552ff6a84d36578c1da92a" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nice.org.uk/guidance/ng197", "title": "Shared decision making", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDELINE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng197", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S016", "F24-S020" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23", "FAM-24" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S016", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "Shared decision making", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDELINE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng197", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "459487b64bc7ef627e05c0c0b0368fcb3e8e60b8121a2a420d5ada0d72f0ac9f" }, { "source_id": "F24-S020", "family_id": "FAM-24", "title": "Shared decision making", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDELINE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng197", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "70ee94baf4fe9429d430054ed3219dcca4a82333dde16c72e0e03c6e5a622e39" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "eeb339a4271493151ac03b4c72220e3801768c432834813532dc0451d586352f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0471", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nice.org.uk/guidance/NG206/chapter/recommendations", "title": "Myalgic encephalomyelitis (or encephalopathy)/chronic fatigue syndrome: diagnosis and management — Recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/NG206/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S014" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S014", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Myalgic encephalomyelitis (or encephalopathy)/chronic fatigue syndrome: diagnosis and management — Recommendations", "authors": "National Institute for Health and Care Excellence", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/NG206/chapter/recommendations", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LEGITIMACY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b3322008082157991d3a30bc793970c5cb582793ce990a0c9ac9dca620193cbc" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3c7580e5885426ca453e69a973926fc57c4f87e261ebe31ca34de43ea5feda72" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0472", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nidcd.nih.gov/health/smell-disorders", "title": "Smell (Olfactory) Disorders", "authors": "U.S. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/smell-disorders", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S017" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S017", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Smell (Olfactory) Disorders", "authors": "U.S. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/smell-disorders", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "ca54e1a7839893e6d29bccab729b06061cfa6175a2eab14c7ad987d89405af88" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8990454006b68acf275acfb30b2f0f9b33ec601f38c04f19e6ebef89e9d6b639" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0473", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nidcd.nih.gov/health/taking-care-your-voice", "title": "Taking Care of Your Voice", "authors": "National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/taking-care-your-voice", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S011" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F19-S011", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Taking Care of Your Voice", "authors": "National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/taking-care-your-voice", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ASSISTIVE_SUPPORT", "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VOCAL_SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "83bccdac9288a1763fd20e1f960b3c997ff5c7c424cf344e2a50bd650885510f" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d828a3c883e5ecd4c952699af25310914f383eb4a89b3a9669cd1a7a1ca0813d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0474", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nidcd.nih.gov/health/taste-disorders", "title": "Taste Disorders", "authors": "U.S. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/taste-disorders", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S019" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S019", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Taste Disorders", "authors": "U.S. National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/taste-disorders", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5047dc4b365988e176bb23bebf38879bca755b455b1ac4c21c5fae854a8c8f31" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b35389aa39ecb87d81abafa2d7e83a9d3ac5dc23842342acd3a459ee5edd0ef6" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "canonical_identity": "url:https://nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0)", "authors": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S014", "F16-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-15", "FAM-16" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F15-S014", "family_id": "FAM-15", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0)", "authors": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b1f17ba10e2a3dfe15c7d4e4140baaf1e7fd7f7cde2bb577ed57ab3d37fc9943" }, { "source_id": "F16-S016", "family_id": "FAM-16", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0)", "authors": "National Institute of Standards and Technology", "year": 2023, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "0a01fb1d4acb4b3921eca4cef021fc05395a9826a0cdceba784fb1028f5c15ad" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "407d3a6f25a03477991927f6d4bc411bf44b61a50cc583f060702f003e303cc7" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0476", "canonical_identity": "url:https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16230978", "title": "The effects of resisted sled-pulling sprint training on acceleration and maximum speed performance", "authors": "Andreas Zafeiridis; Ploutarhos Saraslanidis; Vasiliki Manou; Panagiotis Ioakimidis; Konstantina Dipla; Stavros Kellis", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16230978/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S002" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-02" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F02-S002", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "The effects of resisted sled-pulling sprint training on acceleration and maximum speed performance", "authors": "Andreas Zafeiridis; Ploutarhos Saraslanidis; Vasiliki Manou; Panagiotis Ioakimidis; Konstantina Dipla; Stavros Kellis", "year": 2005, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16230978/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "d84555f812678c9c8878f94a29bbafaba7cdb64d44301fc899dab50739d2d111" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "86bbd06b3740acce8ccef763bcb7b064f368ce4c57da08b79cd67071ad82ef3f" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0477", "canonical_identity": "url:https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18431002", "title": "Acute neglect rehabilitation using repetitive prism adaptation: a randomized placebo-controlled trial", "authors": "G. M. Nys; E. H. de Haan; A. Kunneman; P. L. de Kort; H. C. Dijkerman", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18431002/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-09" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F09-S015", "family_id": "FAM-09", "title": "Acute neglect rehabilitation using repetitive prism adaptation: a randomized placebo-controlled trial", "authors": "G. M. Nys; E. H. de Haan; A. Kunneman; P. L. de Kort; H. C. Dijkerman", "year": 2008, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18431002/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "117f9ebced4c58bc3d76b4d3d010d1f136da095c13b4c9f203a89e552979dfa2" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "81af9ba78db79051b1743b35d005fb399ac29ab2420ba7e6286f83d20285f6bb" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0478", "canonical_identity": "url:https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25349861", "title": "The Effect of Conflict Resolution Training on Children’s Behavioral Problems in Shiraz, Southern Iran: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Sara Soleimani; Farkhondeh Sharif; Arash Mani; Sareh Keshavarzi", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25349861/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S008" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-23" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F23-S008", "family_id": "FAM-23", "title": "The Effect of Conflict Resolution Training on Children’s Behavioral Problems in Shiraz, Southern Iran: A Randomized Controlled Trial", "authors": "Sara Soleimani; Farkhondeh Sharif; Arash Mani; Sareh Keshavarzi", "year": 2014, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25349861/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fe33d701b2ad9034feeccbef6423aab3b1100655770be80eda3b59cc01c3751c" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "d8ecb85c9a37dbdcba84744178b3ad7aabbf675024a819896765fd3b75410216" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0479", "canonical_identity": "url:https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29957910", "title": "Do Congenitally Blind Individuals have Better Haptic Object Perception Compared to Blindfolded Sighted Individuals?", "authors": "B. G. Bhirud; L. M. Chandan; A. Chawla", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29957910/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S007" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-11" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F11-S007", "family_id": "FAM-11", "title": "Do Congenitally Blind Individuals have Better Haptic Object Perception Compared to Blindfolded Sighted Individuals?", "authors": "B. G. Bhirud; L. M. Chandan; A. Chawla", "year": 2016, "source_type": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "source_class": "PRIMARY_RESEARCH", "url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29957910/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "a8380b629775eb2bdcfefbcd359c6e1d53ed2c7e2719487bd67866269b7c8ec8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a1cbe2ca05d83f42184594e956c62ff31a44e0c906235be0c60819014eb52572" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0480", "canonical_identity": "url:https://ready.gov", "title": "Plan Ahead for Disasters", "authors": "Federal Emergency Management Agency", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ready.gov/", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S015", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "Plan Ahead for Disasters", "authors": "Federal Emergency Management Agency", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.ready.gov/", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "48ec02da45929ef32f402736d0767ac9f36be10ffa20e86474c23941cce3486b" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "58dcadac42207054ef6c1327c8dbda962c571fc23ce9c9a56ef88a644ab51f0c" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0481", "canonical_identity": "url:https://social.desa.un.org/issues/indigenous-peoples/united-nations-declaration-on-the-rights-of-indigenous-peoples", "title": "United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples", "authors": "United Nations General Assembly", "year": 2007, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://social.desa.un.org/issues/indigenous-peoples/united-nations-declaration-on-the-rights-of-indigenous-peoples", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S010", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples", "authors": "United Nations General Assembly", "year": 2007, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://social.desa.un.org/issues/indigenous-peoples/united-nations-declaration-on-the-rights-of-indigenous-peoples", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "acddadf2634322f6a9e909b3846fadc035c388a3fb3054c3bbc9d0a8da84d6aa" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ceb5a28bb1364a7c2e2f59bfa29c797e608a72476829db66520d90f04da266e9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0482", "canonical_identity": "url:https://unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-ethics-neurotechnology", "title": "Recommendation on the Ethics of Neurotechnology", "authors": "United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_INSTRUMENT", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-ethics-neurotechnology", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S013" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-27" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F27-S013", "family_id": "FAM-27", "title": "Recommendation on the Ethics of Neurotechnology", "authors": "United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization", "year": 2025, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_INSTRUMENT", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-ethics-neurotechnology", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CONSENT", "EQUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MENTAL_INTEGRITY", "NEURORIGHTS" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3330dd106e62944dd6986c860d5866e49bfff54ef7ce584cea3fff7033aa4b06" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "3b0648bf9d112fbe507261644df8049b45380ce80de4efcca91615eb12b69378" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/assistive-technology", "title": "Assistive technology", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/assistive-technology", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-08" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F08-S016", "family_id": "FAM-08", "title": "Assistive technology", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/assistive-technology", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "e58055c112de1751c6b16e424862b33b502ab79dd4d63679782643aea6d7f37e" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "351ad1005361fe46f9672d407b45715af0723cf1525c159bf1eeb29b78d59855" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0484", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/coronavirus-disease-covid-19-ethics-resource-allocation-and-priority-setting", "title": "Coronavirus disease (COVID-19): Ethics, resource allocation and priority setting", "authors": "World Health Organization Working Group on Ethics and COVID-19", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/coronavirus-disease-covid-19-ethics-resource-allocation-and-priority-setting", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S006" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S006", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Coronavirus disease (COVID-19): Ethics, resource allocation and priority setting", "authors": "World Health Organization Working Group on Ethics and COVID-19", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/coronavirus-disease-covid-19-ethics-resource-allocation-and-priority-setting", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "5aed62dcd035dde15df47bf6254d2cd72ba1e23bc420dfef9fb979ba9fa17385" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "5e447299c1055aa33beced199dc27ff62e0925fef56bcdbeac4462b617a225c8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/deafness-and-hearing-loss-safe-listening", "title": "Deafness and hearing loss: Safe listening", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/deafness-and-hearing-loss-safe-listening", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026", "F19-S012" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-10", "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F10-S026", "family_id": "FAM-10", "title": "Deafness and hearing loss: Safe listening", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/deafness-and-hearing-loss-safe-listening", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "b33c8e2dfa2c76c7ee213823d080ccfefb0c6f46ac260feea00d2eaeead0abf0" }, { "source_id": "F19-S012", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Deafness and hearing loss: Safe listening", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/news-room/questions-and-answers/item/deafness-and-hearing-loss-safe-listening", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "77ca26ea911fc30b070432a22a2d7ccf4804451a7a3f5cb8a7e85230f61beaa8" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "ce68d2917217930e0235605082b2e72b7beca0ab5bc61d65731d3d18ce98a1b9" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/publications/b/55518", "title": "WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/b/55518", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S011", "F02-S013", "F03-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-01", "FAM-02", "FAM-03" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F01-S011", "family_id": "FAM-01", "title": "WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/b/55518", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "84a97a9350ccca5cee44f42ff8b5e2853ec39eb786df0f457ac89f9ed41eba7e" }, { "source_id": "F02-S013", "family_id": "FAM-02", "title": "WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/b/55518", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "df9efc6295182a40d5110523352640fcbcb8f62b8277cd082bedea58e5cea1b9" }, { "source_id": "F03-S015", "family_id": "FAM-03", "title": "WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/b/55518", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "9e7e75ab207a9909996ec60138f83c57db3da0512052fe2922e8d62413e00b72" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "b071fb02f7e0dda42e269aede408fe25ec1078d65cb34a14be621f5bd3df9f24" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0487", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/publications/i/item/9789240015128", "title": "WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240015128", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-04" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F04-S016", "family_id": "FAM-04", "title": "WHO guidelines on physical activity and sedentary behaviour", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2020, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240015128", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "804c9cb5a1570b71f3cd21229b784b22db22feaedfb564f93ba329f55d043629" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "abac754c595ba6ad65b7b00a15d181e7196452e163f0c9d26e0bc021410afc9d" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0488", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/publications/i/item/9789240030008", "title": "WHO Guideline on the prevention of drowning through provision of day-care and basic swimming and water safety skills", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240030008", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S010" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-29" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F29-S010", "family_id": "FAM-29", "title": "WHO Guideline on the prevention of drowning through provision of day-care and basic swimming and water safety skills", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2021, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240030008", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "4764f1d77025fccd383ae0d14e833349c7b34f67a41ec739b5516d4cb7aaa141" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "4b9cfbe65297b6760b7819d167831b280aad56249ab05999f2b3c7247b15e1e8" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/publications/i/item/9789240049451", "title": "Global report on assistive technology", "authors": "World Health Organization; United Nations Children's Fund", "year": 2022, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REPORT", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240049451", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-26" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F26-S015", "family_id": "FAM-26", "title": "Global report on assistive technology", "authors": "World Health Organization; United Nations Children's Fund", "year": 2022, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_REPORT", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240049451", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "73a3734ebf63970393a634adfeec8d07b30a846045c2b7a28e6bfecc524b57d5" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "a01b5e2705a24511df685521594966e3d622fa5833ba55abc4de7d8011e5b3d4" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0490", "canonical_identity": "url:https://who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-WHE-CPI-2019.4", "title": "Guidance for after action review (AAR)", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2019, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-WHE-CPI-2019.4", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S003" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-30" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F30-S003", "family_id": "FAM-30", "title": "Guidance for after action review (AAR)", "authors": "World Health Organization", "year": 2019, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GUIDANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/WHO-WHE-CPI-2019.4", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "58d07aa669ab3c88e67950954cc4b3afcf65e8fabd9ce216f55d37a8a7a55991" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "bf465aff0f29995c5a0e06775b2af14ebd87ecb934a8ef2f1ed6efb22a4b3e64" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "canonical_identity": "url:https://wipo.int/en/web/traditional-knowledge/traditional-cultural-expressions/index", "title": "Traditional Cultural Expressions", "authors": "World Intellectual Property Organization", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GOVERNANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.wipo.int/en/web/traditional-knowledge/traditional-cultural-expressions/index", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013", "F19-S015" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-17", "FAM-19" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F17-S013", "family_id": "FAM-17", "title": "Traditional Cultural Expressions", "authors": "World Intellectual Property Organization", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GOVERNANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.wipo.int/en/web/traditional-knowledge/traditional-cultural-expressions/index", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "21faf84b6424471d81245bdfbbe4c29bc7b97278f78c163f50c21c190579c382" }, { "source_id": "F19-S015", "family_id": "FAM-19", "title": "Traditional Cultural Expressions", "authors": "World Intellectual Property Organization", "year": 2026, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_GOVERNANCE", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.wipo.int/en/web/traditional-knowledge/traditional-cultural-expressions/index", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "3a607f188bdcbeaa7682b6c5206d35fee2689f09d9a4d532ce158c2c2eea5d64" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "36320b08a18faaae201fdb62ea4ece863246f3e0b87155ef79c0ae3fbb1b0c9b" }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0492", "canonical_identity": "url:https://woah.org/fileadmin/Home/eng/Health_standards/tahc/2024/en_titre_1.7.htm", "title": "Terrestrial Animal Health Code, Chapter 7.1: Introduction to the recommendations for animal welfare", "authors": "World Organisation for Animal Health", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.woah.org/fileadmin/Home/eng/Health_standards/tahc/2024/en_titre_1.7.htm", "doi": null, "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S016" ], "family_ids": [ "FAM-32" ], "source_aliases": [ { "source_id": "F32-S016", "family_id": "FAM-32", "title": "Terrestrial Animal Health Code, Chapter 7.1: Introduction to the recommendations for animal welfare", "authors": "World Organisation for Animal Health", "year": 2024, "source_type": "OFFICIAL_STANDARD", "source_class": "OFFICIAL_AUTHORITY", "url": "https://www.woah.org/fileadmin/Home/eng/Health_standards/tahc/2024/en_titre_1.7.htm", "doi": null, "declared_evidence_roles": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ], "source_metadata_sha256": "fffe00541b04d48bcbe2af5207cdc8b6f975235a0513a5289862af80ff85c73d" } ], "canonical_metadata_sha256": "8c07aa19918ac18898276c42e4d94a194e88146a81e1c0dd474c3f160a87c716" } ], "powers": [ { "power_id": "PWR-001", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Maximal force production", "definition": "Capability to develop or express maximal force production in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, maximal force production can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use a standardised force or torque test with reliability/error bounds; a 1RM or dynamometer peak establishes performance in that declared test, not whole-body strength or safety under arbitrary loads.", "negative_findings": [ "Large test-specific strength gains do not guarantee improvement in gait speed or a different movement.", "Mode, joint angle, apparatus and prior training affect the result." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman maximal force production.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0003", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0028", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0158", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0197", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0276", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0281", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Maximal force production is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Limitless strength", "metric": "Peak voluntary force or torque in a declared movement and contraction mode, plus a separate functional transfer task", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-002", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Relative strength", "definition": "Capability to develop or express relative strength in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A relative-strength result is interpretable only when the absolute force, task, population and exact normalisation method are reported together.", "measurement_boundary": "Report absolute force and the exact ratio or allometric model together; do not turn a sample-specific normalisation into a universal ranking or health score.", "negative_findings": [ "Simple force divided by body mass is not universally size-independent.", "A ratio can improve without increased absolute force and can obscure assistance or body-composition context." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman relative strength.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0003", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0261", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Relative strength is a calculation that relates declared force performance to a declared body-size measure. Titan reports the absolute result and formula rather than treating the ratio as a universal human ranking.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Pound-for-pound supremacy", "metric": "Absolute task force plus a predeclared, population-appropriate size-adjusted index", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-003", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Isometric strength", "definition": "Capability to develop or express isometric strength in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, isometric strength can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare joint angle, posture, lever arm, ramp instructions and dynamometer reliability; peak isometric torque says nothing by itself about dynamic speed, balance or pain.", "negative_findings": [ "Strength training in older adults did not change gait speed in the Symons trial.", "Force steadiness during submaximal isometric contraction did not improve in the Tracy trial although anisometric steadiness did." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman isometric strength.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0197", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0276", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Isometric strength is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unshakeable static power", "metric": "Peak isometric force/torque and force-time characteristics at a specified joint angle", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-004", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Eccentric strength", "definition": "Capability to develop or express eccentric strength in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, eccentric strength can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure eccentric peak/mean torque at specified velocity and range, with a separate lowering or braking transfer task; do not infer tendon safety or injury prevention from torque alone.", "negative_findings": [ "Eccentric gains may not generalise to concentric performance.", "Strength or pain change does not guarantee chair-rise, stair, walking or community-ambulation improvement." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman eccentric strength.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0197", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0221", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0276", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Eccentric strength is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Indestructible negative strength", "metric": "Controlled eccentric torque and task-specific energy absorption under declared conditions", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-005", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Strength endurance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express strength endurance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, strength endurance can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare load relative to a valid maximum, cadence, range, termination rule and force decrement; separate local muscular endurance from cardiorespiratory endurance.", "negative_findings": [ "High-repetition adaptation differs from maximal-strength adaptation.", "A laboratory repetition count does not prove safe occupational endurance or sustained quality." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman strength endurance.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0028", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0074", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Strength endurance is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Muscles that never tire", "metric": "Repetitions or sustained time at a declared load with force/technique decrement tracked", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-006", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Functional lifting and carrying", "definition": "Capability to develop or express functional lifting and carrying in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, functional lifting and carrying can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use a bounded object-handling task with load, origin/destination, distance, time, technique and assistance declared; do not infer spinal safety or occupational readiness from gym strength alone.", "negative_findings": [ "Passive finger exercise did not improve grip strength despite changes in selected ADL scores.", "Knee-strength gains in osteoarthritis did not improve the trial's functional performance scores." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman functional lifting and carrying.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0003", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0158", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0197", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0221", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0370", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Functional lifting and carrying is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Effortless lifting of anything", "metric": "Successful, repeatable lift/carry of a declared object over a declared route with safe technique and assistance recorded", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-007", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Grip and pinch force", "definition": "Capability to develop or express grip and pinch force in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, grip and pinch force can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Standardise dynamometer/pinch gauge, handle setting, arm posture and trials; pair force with a relevant object-manipulation task and declare adaptive devices.", "negative_findings": [ "Passive finger exercise produced no grip-strength gain in older adults with dementia.", "A stronger dynamometer score does not establish dexterity or every activity of daily living." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman grip and pinch force.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0074", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0196", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0370", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Grip and pinch force is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A crushing, universal grip", "metric": "Maximum and repeated grip/pinch force in a standardised posture plus a task-specific hand-function measure", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-008", "family_id": "FAM-01", "family": "Strength & Force Production", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Force steadiness", "definition": "Capability to develop or express force steadiness in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, force steadiness can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Report target level, absolute and normalised variability, contraction mode, duration and filtering; lower variability is not always better and cannot diagnose neurological disease.", "negative_findings": [ "The Tracy trial found no change in submaximal isometric force variability despite anisometric improvement.", "The evidence base here is small and concentrated in older adults and laboratory tasks." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman force steadiness.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0196", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0281", "source_alias_ids": [ "F01-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Force steadiness is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfectly unwavering force", "metric": "Force/position coefficient of variation around a declared target, with a separate precision task", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-009", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Acceleration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express acceleration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, acceleration can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use instrumented split times or velocity-time data with surface, footwear, start and aid declared; do not infer reaction ability, agility or safety from a 10-m time.", "negative_findings": [ "Moderate resisted conditioning sprints gave no acute potentiation advantage in varsity sprinters.", "Resisted training that improved acceleration did not necessarily improve maximum-speed phase or jump more than comparison training." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman acceleration.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0029", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0260", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0356", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0358", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0387", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0476", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Acceleration is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Instant zero-to-maximum speed", "metric": "Velocity change and split time over a predeclared distance with start method and environment fixed", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-010", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Maximum locomotor speed", "definition": "Capability to develop or express maximum locomotor speed in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, maximum locomotor speed can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use flying-split or continuous velocity measurement with run-in, distance, surface and assistance declared; distinguish peak speed from acceleration and average sprint time.", "negative_findings": [ "Sled training improved early acceleration but not maximum-speed phase in one controlled study.", "Straight sprint training showed limited transfer to increasingly complex agility tests." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman maximum locomotor speed.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0260", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0354", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0358", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0387", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0476", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Maximum locomotor speed is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Superhuman running speed", "metric": "Peak or flying-split velocity in a declared locomotor and environmental configuration", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-011", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Jumping power", "definition": "Capability to develop or express jumping power in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, jumping power can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Report jump type, arm use, take-off constraints, height/flight-time method, force-time impulse and landing outcome; do not equate flight time with universal explosive power.", "negative_findings": [ "Different active programmes can yield similar jump changes despite different sprint adaptations.", "Jump height alone cannot distinguish impulse, technique, body mass or landing control." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman jumping power.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0260", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0279", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0356", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0387", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Jumping power is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Gravity-defying leaps", "metric": "Jump height and mass-specific take-off power/impulse in a standardised jump, plus landing control", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-012", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Throwing and striking power", "definition": "Capability to develop or express throwing and striking power in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, throwing and striking power can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare implement, technique, distance, radar/video method, accuracy target and joint-load monitoring; never treat impact damage as a capability endpoint.", "negative_findings": [ "Throwing velocity and precision are separable outcomes.", "Evidence from trained throwing athletes cannot be generalised to untrained public striking or self-defence claims." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman throwing and striking power.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0355", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0417", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Throwing and striking power is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A devastating one-hit strike", "metric": "Projectile/implement velocity and target accuracy under a declared technique, with joint-load and pain monitoring", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-013", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Reactive strength", "definition": "Capability to develop or express reactive strength in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, reactive strength can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare sprint mode, distance/duration, repetitions, recovery, best/mean/total performance and decrement formula; do not collapse these into one stamina score.", "negative_findings": [ "Two distinct training groups improved similarly in a youth soccer trial with no passive control.", "A fatigue index can remain unchanged while mean or total work improves." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman reactive strength.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0029", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0419", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Reactive strength is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Endless explosive bursts", "metric": "Best, mean and total repeated-sprint performance plus a predeclared decrement under fixed recovery", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-014", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Deceleration and braking", "definition": "Capability to develop or express deceleration and braking in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, deceleration and braking can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure approach speed, stopping distance/time, horizontal braking impulse, contacts and technique; normalise for entry speed and report pain or loss of control.", "negative_findings": [ "No delayed retention test was performed.", "Pre-planned 180-degree turn improvement does not establish reactive braking or injury prevention." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman deceleration and braking.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0409", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION_GAP", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Deceleration and braking is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Instant stopping with no consequence", "metric": "Stopping time/distance and braking impulse from a controlled entry speed with technique and load recorded", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-015", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Change of direction", "definition": "Capability to develop or express change of direction in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, change of direction can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare course, angle, entry speed and timing method; separate total time, COD deficit and reactive decision latency.", "negative_findings": [ "Agility training did not improve straight sprint performance in the Young study.", "Pre-planned COD gains do not establish decision-making or opponent-responsive agility." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman change of direction.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0354", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0387", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0409", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION_GAP", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Change of direction is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Impossible agility", "metric": "Pre-planned COD completion and COD deficit at a fixed approach speed, with reactive agility tested separately", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-016", "family_id": "FAM-02", "family": "Power, Speed & Agility", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Rapid force sequencing", "definition": "Capability to develop or express rapid force sequencing in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, rapid force sequencing can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use synchronised kinematics, kinetics and event timing for the target action; do not infer whole-body coordination from one muscle's RFD.", "negative_findings": [ "Laboratory quadriceps RFD was not tested in an unrelated real-world skill.", "Short interventions did not establish retention of revised movement timing." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman rapid force sequencing.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0279", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0409", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION_GAP", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0417", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F02-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Rapid force sequencing is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect explosive coordination on demand", "metric": "Phase-specific impulse, onset timing and segment sequence in a named action, alongside task outcome", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-017", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Aerobic endurance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express aerobic endurance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, aerobic endurance can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use a reliable mode-specific performance test and, where justified, VO2peak/max with criteria; separate physiological capacity from task endurance and symptoms.", "negative_findings": [ "HERITAGE showed large response heterogeneity under a standardised programme.", "Short-term interval equivalence in young men does not establish long-term equivalence, adherence or safety across populations." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman aerobic endurance.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0209", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY_BOUNDARY", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0252", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0253", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "METABOLIC_MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0277", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "HETEROGENEITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Aerobic endurance is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A bottomless aerobic engine", "metric": "Time/distance or sustainable power in a declared mode plus validated oxygen-uptake measures where appropriate", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-018", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Anaerobic work capacity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express anaerobic work capacity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, anaerobic work capacity can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare the work test and estimation model (for example accumulated oxygen deficit or repeated work); report reliability and avoid treating lactate as a direct capacity meter.", "negative_findings": [ "Moderate endurance training in the Tabata experiment improved VO2max but not anaerobic capacity.", "Metabolic-marker change is not itself a real-world performance gain." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman anaerobic work capacity.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0029", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FATIGUE_PROFILE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0209", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY_BOUNDARY", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0252", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0253", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "METABOLIC_MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0353", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIOMARKER_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Anaerobic work capacity is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlimited anaerobic reserves", "metric": "Work above a declared aerobic reference or repeated high-intensity work in a validated task-specific test", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-019", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Respiratory-muscle endurance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express respiratory-muscle endurance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, respiratory-muscle endurance can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use validated inspiratory pressure/endurance measures with spirometry or medical assessment where indicated; do not infer disease treatment or oxygenation control.", "negative_findings": [ "Improved inspiratory performance did not mean increased lung volume or VO2max.", "Small trained-male cyclist studies cannot justify forceful breathing or breath-hold claims for the public." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman respiratory-muscle endurance.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0172", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0210", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Respiratory-muscle endurance is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Superhuman lungs", "metric": "Sustained inspiratory pressure/work and a separate task performance outcome; lung function reported separately", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-020", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Fatigue resistance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express fatigue resistance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, fatigue resistance can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Track absolute output, quality/error and predeclared decrement over a realistic task; pair with symptoms and stop rules rather than using lactate alone.", "negative_findings": [ "Mean performance, peak performance and decrement need not change together.", "Active recovery can help, harm or make no performance difference depending on placement, duration and task." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman fatigue resistance.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0029", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FATIGUE_PROFILE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0172", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0173", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTORY_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0210", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0252", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0277", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "HETEROGENEITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0357", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Fatigue resistance is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Never feeling tired", "metric": "Preserved task output and quality across a fixed workload/recovery schedule, with symptoms and errors recorded", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-021", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Load-carriage endurance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express load-carriage endurance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "In selected people and declared configurations, load-carriage endurance can be measured and may improve with task-relevant practice; retention, transfer and meaningful value require separate testing.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare absolute and relative load, distribution, distance, terrain, speed, footwear and symptoms; test the actual bounded task and record assistive equipment.", "negative_findings": [ "Prediction error from simple tests was as large as average training gains in one recruit cohort.", "Three backpack variants produced no objective advantage at the tested load." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman load-carriage endurance.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0051", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0426", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Load-carriage endurance is real as a bounded, measurable capability, but the evidence is task- and population-specific. Titan separates improvement in the test from retention, transfer and meaningful function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "March forever under any load", "metric": "Completion time/physiological cost for a declared load-route configuration, with pain, gait and post-task performance monitored", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-022", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Pacing", "definition": "Capability to develop or express pacing in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Pacing can be described as a task-specific work-rate pattern; general trainability, durable retention and cross-task transfer remain unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Analyse power/speed/work-rate over predeclared task segments with total outcome, perception and environment; do not diagnose motivation from a pacing curve.", "negative_findings": [ "Start and finish pacing showed greater variability even when whole-trial performance was reproducible.", "Incorrect distance feedback did not alter time or pacing in the cited trial, contradicting a simple feedback-control claim." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman pacing.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0030", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0338", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pacing patterns can be measured and may be reproducible in a familiar task. The bound evidence does not yet establish a general trainable pacing skill, durable retention or transfer across activities.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect energy management in every challenge", "metric": "Segment-by-segment work-rate distribution and total outcome in a declared task", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-023", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Metabolic flexibility", "definition": "Capability to develop or express metabolic flexibility in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Standardised indirect calorimetry can describe context-sensitive substrate-use responses; Titan does not currently classify this biomarker as a demonstrated voluntary functional capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Treat indirect-calorimetry substrate switching as a context-sensitive biomarker; standardise diet, fasting, prior exercise and workload and do not turn it into a consumer score.", "negative_findings": [ "The i-FLEX study found no resting substrate-oxidation change and no correlation between oxidation and insulin-sensitivity changes.", "Insulin sensitivity decreased in participants without obesity after the short intervention." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman metabolic flexibility.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0253", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "METABOLIC_MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0353", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIOMARKER_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Metabolic flexibility is best treated here as a context-sensitive research biomarker, not a proven voluntary human power. A laboratory oxidation shift does not establish weight control, health or real-world function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Switching fat burning on at will", "metric": "Change in respiratory exchange/substrate oxidation across standardised metabolic demands, reported as a biomarker not a voluntary ability", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-024", "family_id": "FAM-03", "family": "Endurance & Metabolic Work Capacity", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Between-bout recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express between-bout recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Between-bout recovery can be measured for a defined task and interval; strategy effects are configuration-specific and no universal recovery method is established.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare the fatiguing bout, recovery duration/activity and next-task outcome; measure actual performance restoration rather than a single biomarker.", "negative_findings": [ "Active recovery can reduce lactate yet worsen short-interval sprint performance.", "No universal recovery mode is supported across running and swimming configurations." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Titan proves anyone can develop unlimited or superhuman between-bout recovery.", "One test score reveals whole-person capability, health, discipline, potential or worth.", "Improvement guarantees injury prevention, clinical benefit, occupational readiness or transfer to every real-world task." ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0029", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FATIGUE_PROFILE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0173", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTORY_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0357", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0486", "source_alias_ids": [ "F03-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Between-bout recovery is measurable, but the better strategy depends on the preceding effort, interval and next task. No universal active or passive recovery method is supported.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Instant recovery", "metric": "Fraction of task performance restored after a fixed recovery interval, with recovery activity and symptoms declared", "boundary": "The metric is valid only for its declared task and cannot establish universal ability, character, diagnosis, safety or far transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-025", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Active range of motion", "definition": "Capability to develop or express active range of motion in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can sometimes increase active range in a specific joint and movement, but effects vary by method and do not prove better function.", "measurement_boundary": "Degrees of active motion establish range in the tested setup; they do not establish tissue health, pain relief, movement quality or whole-body mobility.", "negative_findings": [ "Six weeks of daily calf stretching did not improve active ankle dorsiflexion in the cited trial." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Unlock every joint", "Permanent flexibility", "Pain means the tissue is opening", "More range is always superior" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0359", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0375", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain active versus passive range", "Measure one chosen joint/task consistently", "Discuss accessible alternatives without normative targets" ], "site_summary": "Active range is the motion a person can produce and control themselves. It can change, but gains are joint-specific and not guaranteed to improve real-life function.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become infinitely flexible", "metric": "Joint-specific active degrees plus a declared task", "boundary": "Range alone cannot show control, comfort, safety or function." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-026", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "End-range control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express end-range control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "End-range performance can improve, usually in an angle- and task-specific way; broad transfer is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Angle-specific torque or task accuracy measures tested capacity in that position, not tissue integrity or safety in every movement.", "negative_findings": [ "Isometric strength gains were limited to the trained and adjacent angles." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Bulletproof joints", "Own every range", "Loaded stretching repairs injuries", "End range prevents all injury" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0020", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0360", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain angle specificity", "Use unloaded demonstrations only", "Show that accessible supports are part of configuration" ], "site_summary": "End-range control is not just reaching a position; it is producing stable, accurate action there. Training effects are real but highly specific.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Own impossible joint angles", "metric": "Accuracy and force at a declared angle", "boundary": "One-angle strength cannot prove whole-range control or tissue safety." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-027", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Static balance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express static balance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Static balance can improve on practiced tasks, but gains often fail to generalize to untrained balance situations.", "measurement_boundary": "Time, sway or errors in a specified stance establish task performance only, not universal balance or fall immunity.", "negative_findings": [ "Six weeks of varied balance or power training did not improve two untrained balance tasks." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Perfect balance", "Never fall again", "One-leg stance predicts all mobility", "Balance boards make anyone stable" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0302", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0334", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0487", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain configuration specificity", "Offer seated and supported variants conceptually", "Require fall-safe surroundings" ], "site_summary": "Balance is many tasks, not one trait. You can improve a practiced stance, while a different surface or movement may remain unchanged.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become unshakeable", "metric": "Errors or sway in one declared stance", "boundary": "One stance cannot establish stability everywhere." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-028", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Reactive balance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express reactive balance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Protected perturbation training can improve recovery from similar laboratory slips and trips, while real-world fall reduction is uncertain.", "measurement_boundary": "Harness-defined laboratory falls and stability metrics establish response to that perturbation; only prospective community falls can establish real-world transfer.", "negative_findings": [ "A 2023 randomized trial found no statistically significant reduction in daily-life fall rate or other daily-life fall metrics." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Fall-proof yourself", "Practice slipping at home", "A harness drill prevents all falls", "One session inoculates anyone" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0009", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0198", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can learn to recover better from controlled slips and trips. That does not make unsupervised perturbation practice safe or prove fewer real-life falls.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train until you cannot be knocked over", "metric": "Falls during standardized protected perturbations plus community follow-up", "boundary": "Laboratory recovery cannot prove real-world fall immunity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-029", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Gait efficiency", "definition": "Capability to develop or express gait efficiency in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can adapt aspects of gait control and energetic cost, but “efficiency” must name the metric, task and assistance.", "measurement_boundary": "Oxygen cost, step pattern, variability and smoothness answer different questions and cannot be collapsed into one gait score.", "negative_findings": [ "Adaptation to a robotic energy landscape does not establish durable device-off benefit." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Perfect walking form", "Fix your gait from one metric", "Symmetry is always optimal", "AI can optimize anyone’s walk" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0053", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0071", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Gait efficiency can mean using less energy, moving more smoothly or completing a task safely. Titan keeps those outcomes separate.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Find the one perfect way to walk", "metric": "Declared energy cost, variability, smoothness and task result", "boundary": "One gait metric cannot define safety, comfort or participation." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-030", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Quiet locomotion", "definition": "Capability to develop or express quiet locomotion in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can acutely reduce footstep sound and impact in a laboratory, often by changing speed or foot strike; durable skill and injury benefit are unproven.", "measurement_boundary": "Decibels establish sound in the measurement setup; force plates establish loading. Neither alone establishes tissue safety or stealth.", "negative_findings": [ "Peak sound was not directly associated with peak ground-reaction force or loading rate in the running experiment." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Move like a ghost", "Silent walking prevents injury", "Sound reveals force exactly", "Forefoot striking is universally safer" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0170", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0174", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Compare sound and loading as distinct metrics", "Use conceptual low-risk observation only", "Include prosthetic and aid-related sound respectfully" ], "site_summary": "Quiet movement is measurable—not mystical. People can change footstep sound, but quieter does not automatically mean safer or more efficient.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Walk in supernatural silence", "metric": "Footstep decibels, loading rate and speed on a declared surface", "boundary": "Quiet sound cannot prove invisibility, safety or universal technique." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-031", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Terrain adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express terrain adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People adjust walking to terrain, and configured practice may help; superiority over conventional rehabilitation and broad outdoor transfer are not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Variability, obstacle errors and speed quantify specified conditions; they do not establish safe independent travel in every environment.", "negative_findings": [ "Specialized VR walking-adaptability training was not superior to dose-matched conventional training in motor-incomplete spinal cord injury." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Conquer any terrain", "Terrain instincts", "Train without looking", "A treadmill makes outdoor mobility safe" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0316", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0351", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Terrain adaptation is a configured skill: person, surface, vision, footwear and assistance all matter. Specialized technology is not automatically better.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become at home on any terrain", "metric": "Errors, stability and completion on a specified route with declared aid", "boundary": "One surface cannot prove universal outdoor mobility." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-032", "family_id": "FAM-04", "family": "Mobility, Balance & Locomotion", "superdomain": "Body & Performance", "power": "Transitions, crawling and climbing", "definition": "Capability to develop or express transitions, crawling and climbing in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Specific transitions such as rising from the floor can be practiced in supported settings, but crawling and climbing require separate evidence and safety routes.", "measurement_boundary": "Task completion, time and assistance level establish that transition only; they do not establish that moving after a fall is medically safe.", "negative_findings": [ "The pilot found no significant between-group improvement in Timed Up and Go or strength." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Escape any fall", "Move like an animal", "Climb anything", "Everyone should get up without help" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0404", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0487", "source_alias_ids": [ "F04-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Transitions are practical superpowers when they matter—but floor rise, crawling and climbing are different tasks and safety comes first.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Always spring back to your feet", "metric": "Completion, time and assistance for one declared transition", "boundary": "A task score cannot rule out injury or prove climbing ability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-033", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Tendon adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express tendon adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Tendons adapt to repeated mechanical loading, but the response is tendon- and dose-specific and does not make tissue unbreakable.", "measurement_boundary": "Stiffness, elongation and cross-sectional area characterize the tested tendon under load; they do not prove pain-free function or injury immunity.", "negative_findings": [ "The studies do not establish injury prevention, long-term retention or a safe maximum strain." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Unbreakable tendons", "Pain hardens tissue", "Maximum strain grows the strongest tendon", "One protocol works for every tendon" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0084", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0278", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Tendons are living tissues that adapt to load. That adaptation is slow, specific and nothing like becoming unbreakable.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build unbreakable tendons", "metric": "Tendon stiffness, elongation and function at a named site", "boundary": "Tissue metrics cannot prove immunity from rupture or pain." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-034", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Bone adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express bone adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Bone can adapt to loading, but measured gains are site- and programme-specific and high-impact routes need screening and supervision.", "measurement_boundary": "DXA aBMD is a clinically useful site-specific proxy; it does not directly measure microarchitecture, falls or individual fracture immunity.", "negative_findings": [ "A nine-month randomized trial found no resistance-training effect on lumbar-spine, femoral-neck or total-body aBMD." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Make bones indestructible", "Jump away osteoporosis", "BMD proves fracture-proofing", "Stop medication and train instead" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0015", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0061", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Bones respond to load, but not every programme changes every bone site. Strong training can be safe only in the screened, supervised configuration tested.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Forge unbreakable bones", "metric": "Site-specific BMD, geometry and fracture outcomes", "boundary": "A BMD change cannot prove fracture immunity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-035", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Muscle hypertrophy and atrophy resistance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express muscle hypertrophy and atrophy resistance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Muscle can grow with multiple resistance-training configurations, and some gains can be maintained with less training; exact needs differ by person and outcome.", "measurement_boundary": "Imaging or fiber area measures size; one-repetition maximum measures task-specific strength. Neither alone establishes health or independence.", "negative_findings": [ "Maintenance requirements differed between young and older adults and between strength and muscle-size outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Guaranteed muscle growth", "Never lose muscle", "Heavy is always best", "Supplements replace training or food" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0280", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0340", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Muscle is highly trainable, but growth, strength and resistance to loss are different outcomes. Maintenance needs change with age and context.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build permanent muscle armor", "metric": "Declared muscle size, strength and function over training and detraining", "boundary": "Muscle size cannot prove permanent function or health." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-036", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Connective-tissue resilience", "definition": "Capability to develop or express connective-tissue resilience in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some diagnosed tendon problems respond to progressive loading, but connective-tissue resilience is not a single trainable or measurable superpower.", "measurement_boundary": "Pain, function, structure and mechanics are separate outcomes; none alone validates a whole-body resilience score.", "negative_findings": [ "Low-intensity pulsed ultrasound did not outperform sham for chronic patellar tendinopathy." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Harden every connective tissue", "Cure tendinopathy yourself", "Ultrasound heals tendons", "Pain proves adaptation" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0201", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0243", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "“Connective tissue” covers many different structures. Titan will not turn one tendon treatment into a claim of whole-body resilience.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Make all connective tissue invincible", "metric": "Tissue-specific symptoms, function and mechanics", "boundary": "One tendon result cannot establish whole-body resilience." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-037", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Wound and tissue recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express wound and tissue recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Wound recovery is a clinically important biological outcome, not a generally trainable voluntary capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Closure, infection and scar measures describe the wound in its clinical context; they do not measure willpower or a stable personal capability.", "negative_findings": [ "In 1548 trauma-surgery participants, incisional negative-pressure therapy did not significantly reduce deep surgical-site infection." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Heal wounds at will", "Biohack tissue repair", "Negative pressure makes anyone heal faster", "Ignore infection signs" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0005", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0469", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Healing matters enormously, but it is not a voluntary superpower. Titan records the evidence and keeps wound care inside clinical governance.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Command your body to close wounds", "metric": "Clinical closure, infection and recovery outcomes", "boundary": "Healing outcomes cannot establish voluntary control." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-038", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Inflammation resolution and recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express inflammation resolution and recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Exercise can change inflammatory biology, but people do not have a demonstrated voluntary “inflammation off-switch,” and biomarkers do not equal recovery.", "measurement_boundary": "Cytokines, CRP and lipid mediators sample different pathways and time points; they cannot establish global inflammation or useful recovery alone.", "negative_findings": [ "A 12-week randomized training trial increased aerobic fitness by 15% without improving its prespecified inflammatory outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Turn inflammation off", "Master your immune system", "One CRP result scores recovery", "Suppress inflammation to heal faster" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0275", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0285", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Inflammation is a coordinated biological response, not a dial you can simply turn down. Fitness can improve while common markers do not.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Switch inflammation off at will", "metric": "Predeclared mediator panel plus clinical function over time", "boundary": "A biomarker cannot prove immune mastery or faster healing." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-039", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Capability preservation during unloading", "definition": "Capability to develop or express capability preservation during unloading in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Capability can decline quickly during unloading, and configured countermeasures may preserve part of it; no method prevents every loss.", "measurement_boundary": "Change from a pre-unloading baseline in muscle, strength and meaningful tasks measures preservation; a single biomarker cannot.", "negative_findings": [ "Seven days of strict bed rest caused substantial loss in healthy young men; NASA reports that current countermeasures do not protect every crew member fully." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Never lose muscle on bed rest", "Beat microgravity at home", "One maintenance dose fits everyone", "Exercise against medical restrictions" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0340", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0373", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0466", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Use it or lose it is real—but preservation during bed rest or microgravity is a configured medical and engineering problem, not a willpower test.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become immune to deconditioning", "metric": "Change from baseline in muscle, strength, fitness and task function", "boundary": "Partial preservation cannot prove complete protection." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-040", "family_id": "FAM-05", "family": "Tissue Adaptation, Repair & Reacquisition", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Reacquisition after detraining", "definition": "Capability to develop or express reacquisition after detraining in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Previously trained people can regain lost strength, but human studies do not support a guaranteed biological shortcut or identical return curve.", "measurement_boundary": "Time to regain a predeclared strength, size or task threshold measures reacquisition of that endpoint only.", "negative_findings": [ "In one controlled human study, the previously trained leg did not respond better than the untrained leg during retraining." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Muscle remembers forever", "Return at your old loads", "Rebuild twice as fast", "Prior fitness protects after illness" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0073", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0282", "source_alias_ids": [ "F05-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "“Muscle memory” is real in some senses and overstated in others. Strength can return, but a prior-trained limb has not always regained faster than a control limb.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Your muscles never forget", "metric": "Time to regain a named strength, size or functional threshold", "boundary": "A molecular trace cannot guarantee faster real-world recovery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-041", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Voluntary breathing regulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express voluntary breathing regulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn bounded control of breathing pattern, sometimes with measurable short-term physiological effects, when the method and population are declared.", "measurement_boundary": "Respiratory rate, volume, blood gases and declared cardiovascular measures index the configured task; HRV alone does not establish vagal tone, health or direct organ control.", "negative_findings": [ "The endotoxaemia study bundled breathing, meditation and cold, so it cannot identify a breathing-only effect.", "No broad durable functional transfer is established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "control the autonomic nervous system at will", "one breathing rate works for everyone", "breathing treats immune, cardiac or psychiatric disease", "safe hyperventilation or breath-hold challenge" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0035", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0165", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0211", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0250", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0344", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM_DECOMPOSITION" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Voluntary breathing is real and trainable in bounded settings; downstream health and autonomic claims remain limited.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Master your autonomic system with breath", "metric": "Respiratory accuracy, blood-gas safety, HRV/baroreflex measures and delayed functional performance", "boundary": "A proxy change or bundled intervention does not establish whole-system control." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-042", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Autonomic arousal downregulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express autonomic arousal downregulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some adults can learn short-term downregulation of declared arousal-linked signals with feedback.", "measurement_boundary": "Pupil diameter, respiratory pattern, HRV and subjective arousal are related but non-equivalent signals; none alone establishes emotional state or clinical recovery.", "negative_findings": [ "No unique superiority over mindfulness or physical activity was shown in one comparative trial.", "Durable emotional and real-world transfer remains unestablished." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "switch off stress on command", "control adrenaline at will", "biofeedback cures anxiety", "calmness proves safety or competence" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0036", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0136", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0165", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Biofeedback can make some arousal-linked signals more controllable for a short period; it does not confer emotional mastery.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become unshakably calm", "metric": "Declared physiological recovery time plus calibrated task performance under stress", "boundary": "A lower signal does not prove safety, judgment or mental-health treatment." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-043", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Thermoregulatory influence", "definition": "Capability to develop or express thermoregulatory influence in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Measured temperature influence exists in selected expert and biofeedback settings, but it is narrow and configuration-dependent.", "measurement_boundary": "Peripheral skin temperature and core temperature are different outcomes; both require calibrated instruments and environmental controls.", "negative_findings": [ "Temperature biofeedback did not produce significant clinical improvement in the Raynaud/scleroderma trial.", "Novice trainability, retention and cold-environment function are not established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "generate mystical heat", "become immune to cold", "control core temperature at will", "treat Raynaud phenomenon with thought", "burn calories through thermogenesis practice" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0021", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0165", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0344", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM_DECOMPOSITION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0441", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Some experts and biofeedback participants can shift measured temperature, but this is not cold immunity or a public challenge.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become immune to freezing conditions", "metric": "Calibrated peripheral and core temperature change under controlled ambient conditions", "boundary": "A temperature shift does not establish survival, health benefit or safe cold exposure." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-044", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Cardiovascular response regulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cardiovascular response regulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected cardiovascular responses can be influenced through trained breathing, feedback or physical manoeuvres in declared populations.", "measurement_boundary": "Heart rate, HRV, blood pressure and baroreflex sensitivity are non-equivalent; symptom recurrence and safe function are separate endpoints.", "negative_findings": [ "Counterpressure evidence does not apply without a recognizable prodrome.", "Bundled autonomic studies do not show arbitrary control of heart rate or immunity." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "control your heart at will", "prevent every faint", "replace blood-pressure treatment", "HRV score proves cardiovascular health" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0035", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0080", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BOUNDARY", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0165", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0211", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0461", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Some cardiovascular responses are trainable in selected settings; this is not arbitrary heart control.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Control your heartbeat and never faint", "metric": "Declared HR/BP/baroreflex response plus recurrence and injury outcomes", "boundary": "A physiological shift does not diagnose the cause or guarantee safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-045", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Voluntary pupil modulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express voluntary pupil modulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some people can modulate pupil size directly or learn short-term pupil-linked regulation with laboratory feedback.", "measurement_boundary": "Pupil diameter requires isoluminant stimuli and controls for accommodation, vergence, luminance, medication and cognitive effort; it is not a direct readout of one mental state.", "negative_findings": [ "The direct-control evidence is a single case.", "No delayed retention or real-world function is established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "control the iris like a muscle", "gain night vision", "read or control emotions through pupils", "permanent pupil control" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0078", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0136", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Voluntary pupil modulation exists and short-term biofeedback training is promising, but practical value is unknown.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Change your pupils to unlock enhanced vision", "metric": "Calibrated bidirectional pupil-diameter change with delayed no-feedback reliability", "boundary": "Diameter change alone does not establish direct iris control, night vision or emotional mastery." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-046", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Voluntary piloerection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express voluntary piloerection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A small subgroup can produce objectively observable piloerection voluntarily.", "measurement_boundary": "Objective hair/skin imaging is required; subjective chills, feeling moved and piloerection are non-equivalent.", "negative_findings": [ "Self-report coincided with observed piloerection only 31.8% of the time in emotional-piloerection studies.", "No trainability, retention, transfer or function is established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "learn goosebumps on command", "control emotion through goosebumps", "regulate body temperature", "proof of spiritual energy" ], "risk_level": "LOW", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0249", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0385", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RELIABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0430", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Voluntary goosebumps are real in a small subgroup; nobody has shown that others can learn them or that they do anything useful.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Switch on goosebumps as an emotional or thermal superpower", "metric": "Objectively detected piloerection onset, extent and repeatability", "boundary": "A goosebump report does not prove an event, control, trainability or function." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-047", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Stress-state recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express stress-state recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some configured practices can improve selected short-term stress-recovery measures.", "measurement_boundary": "Recovery should be a time course across subjective state, physiology and task function; a single post-stressor reading is insufficient.", "negative_findings": [ "HRV biofeedback was not superior to mindfulness or physical activity in one comparative trial.", "Long-term real-world recovery and functional benefit remain insufficiently tested." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "become immune to stress", "recover instantly", "a calm HRV pattern proves resilience", "biofeedback treats trauma" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0036", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0136", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0165", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0250", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Stress recovery can improve in bounded training settings, but no method makes a person stress-proof.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become unbreakable under stress", "metric": "Time to recover physiology, judgment and meaningful task performance after a declared stressor", "boundary": "Fast physiological recovery alone does not establish wisdom, safety or mental health." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-048", "family_id": "FAM-06", "family": "Autonomic & Physiological Self-Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Closed-loop physiological biofeedback", "definition": "Capability to develop or express closed-loop physiological biofeedback in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Closed-loop biofeedback can help people learn control of selected measured signals in bounded tasks.", "measurement_boundary": "The sensor, preprocessing, feedback rule and task form one versioned system; proxy validity and device-off performance must be tested separately.", "negative_findings": [ "Peripheral temperature acquisition did not improve Raynaud clinical outcomes.", "HRV biofeedback was not uniquely superior to active alternatives in one stress trial." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "hack your nervous system", "a high HRV score means health", "wearables diagnose stress", "permanent control after one session" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0021", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0036", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0136", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0211", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0250", "source_alias_ids": [ "F06-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Biofeedback can make selected body signals trainable; every claim belongs to a particular person–sensor–feedback–task system.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Hack your physiology with a wearable", "metric": "Signal-specific learning, device-off retention, functional transfer, burden and harms", "boundary": "A responsive graph does not establish diagnosis, health or general self-control." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-049", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Sleep initiation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express sleep initiation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured CBT-I can improve insomnia and sleep initiation for many adults in defined treatment settings.", "measurement_boundary": "Sleep diary onset latency, actigraphy and polysomnography differ; insomnia is not diagnosed from one consumer metric.", "negative_findings": [ "In one large 2025 trial, sleep-onset latency was not significant at the adjusted threshold despite insomnia-severity improvement.", "Objective cognitive improvement did not accompany self-reported cognitive improvement in another trial." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "fall asleep on command", "cure insomnia with discipline", "one perfect bedtime", "wearable proves sleep onset" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0204", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0205", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0372", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0431", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "MEASUREMENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Sleep initiation can improve with structured insomnia treatment; it is not an on-command superpower.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Fall asleep instantly whenever you choose", "metric": "Sleep-onset latency, insomnia severity, next-day function and adverse effects", "boundary": "A shorter diary estimate does not diagnose or cure insomnia." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-050", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Sleep continuity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express sleep continuity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured insomnia treatment can improve sleep continuity in diagnosed adults.", "measurement_boundary": "Wake after sleep onset, awakening count, sleep efficiency and restorative quality are distinct; consumer stage labels are not diagnostic.", "negative_findings": [ "Consumer trackers vary against polysomnography and cannot diagnose causes.", "Objective cognitive benefit can remain absent despite subjective improvement." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "sleep through anything", "eliminate every awakening", "tracker sleep score equals restorative sleep", "fix fragmented sleep without assessment" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0204", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0205", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0372", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0431", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "MEASUREMENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Sleep continuity can improve, especially through structured insomnia care, but repeated waking has many causes.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train yourself never to wake", "metric": "Validated wake-after-sleep-onset, sleep efficiency, symptoms and daytime function", "boundary": "Fewer detected awakenings do not prove restorative or safe sleep." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-051", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Circadian phase alignment", "definition": "Capability to develop or express circadian phase alignment in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Circadian phase is modifiable by timed cues, and response depends on internal phase and chronotype.", "measurement_boundary": "Clock time, chronotype questionnaires, actigraphy and DLMO are not interchangeable; phase alignment requires a declared target schedule.", "negative_findings": [ "Evening exercise advanced later chronotypes but delayed earlier chronotypes in the cited study.", "No delayed retention or functional benefit followed from the phase-marker result alone." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "reset your body clock instantly", "one timing works for everyone", "morning exercise fixes every circadian problem", "wearable knows your circadian phase" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0205", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0292", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0431", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "MEASUREMENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Circadian timing can shift, but direction and benefit depend on when, for whom and toward what schedule.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Reset your body clock in one move", "metric": "Change in verified circadian phase plus sleep and real-world function relative to a declared target", "boundary": "A clock-time routine or wearable estimate does not prove internal phase or benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-052", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Nap efficiency", "definition": "Capability to develop or express nap efficiency in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Naps can improve subjective alertness and selected outcomes, but effects vary by timing, duration and endpoint.", "measurement_boundary": "Sleep achieved, timing, prior sleep, inertia, vigilance and the target task must all be measured; planned time in bed is not nap sleep.", "negative_findings": [ "Processing speed did not improve and only one tested nap condition improved memory encoding.", "Longer naps produced short-lived sleep inertia." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "perfect power nap", "ten minutes restores every brain", "nap instead of sleep", "nap makes fatigued driving safe" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0206", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0440", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Naps can help some outcomes for a few hours, but there is no universal perfect nap.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Take the perfect power nap and fully recharge", "metric": "Polysomnographic sleep, post-wake inertia, vigilance and target-task performance", "boundary": "Feeling better does not certify safe or fully restored performance." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-053", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Function under partial sleep loss", "definition": "Capability to develop or express function under partial sleep loss in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Individuals differ in vulnerability to sleep loss, but functioning under deprivation is not established as a safely trainable capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Use objective vigilance and task error, prior sleep, circadian time and recovery—not self-rated alertness alone.", "negative_findings": [ "Caffeine did not restore well-rested performance.", "Caffeine impaired subsequent recovery sleep.", "Subjective and objective vulnerability did not align." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "train yourself to need less sleep", "elite sleep-loss resilience", "caffeine restores full performance", "prove toughness by staying awake" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0023", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0207", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "PREDICTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0406", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "RECOVERY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0437", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0440", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0449", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People differ under sleep loss, but nobody should treat deprivation tolerance as a trainable superpower.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train to function perfectly without sleep", "metric": "Objective lapses, errors, judgment, health and recovery under declared sleep history", "boundary": "Subjective alertness or stimulant-assisted performance does not prove safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-054", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Dream recall and lucid-dream skill", "definition": "Capability to develop or express dream recall and lucid-dream skill in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some people can become lucid and exchange limited verified signals during REM sleep.", "measurement_boundary": "Polysomnographic REM plus prearranged signals is stronger than retrospective report; dream recall and lucid-dream verification are separate.", "negative_findings": [ "One induction condition yielded zero lucid dreams; other rates were low.", "No durable training or daytime functional benefit is established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "control every dream", "learn lucid dreaming reliably overnight", "use dreams to treat trauma alone", "unlock daytime genius" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0072", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0398", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Lucid dreams are real and can sometimes support verified communication, but reliable training and daytime benefit remain open.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Master your dreams and unlock hidden powers", "metric": "Verified REM lucidity rate, signal accuracy, sleep quality and delayed repeatability", "boundary": "Dream report alone does not establish REM verification, trainability or daytime value." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-055", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Recovery forecasting", "definition": "Capability to develop or express recovery forecasting in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Recovery and fatigue can be forecast probabilistically, but forecasts are configuration-specific and uncertain.", "measurement_boundary": "Forecast discrimination, calibration and decision utility must be tested against a future declared outcome; a readiness score is not the outcome itself.", "negative_findings": [ "Consumer device accuracy varies by device and metric.", "Caffeine can improve apparent performance while worsening recovery sleep.", "Subjective and objective vulnerability can diverge." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "your wearable knows when you are recovered", "readiness score guarantees safety", "AI predicts your body perfectly", "one metric proves recovery" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0099", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INDIVIDUAL_VARIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0205", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0207", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "PREDICTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0406", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "RECOVERY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0431", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "MEASUREMENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0437", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0440", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Recovery forecasts may help planning, but a score is only as good as its device, model, context and calibration.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Your readiness score knows your limits", "metric": "Prospective calibration and decision benefit for a declared future task", "boundary": "A wearable estimate cannot diagnose sleep or guarantee safe performance." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-056", "family_id": "FAM-07", "family": "Sleep, Circadian & Recovery Regulation", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Wakefulness stabilisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express wakefulness stabilisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Short-term wakefulness can be supported, but no countermeasure replaces sleep or produces a durable sleep-loss capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Objective vigilance, microsleeps, errors and recovery must accompany subjective wakefulness; stimulant use is part of the configuration.", "negative_findings": [ "Repeated caffeine did not restore well-rested performance.", "Caffeine altered recovery sleep.", "Repeated caffeine showed adaptation/withdrawal effects and not clear-cut benefit in one study." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "stay awake indefinitely", "caffeine makes sleep optional", "train your brain never to tire", "readiness score clears you to drive" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0023", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0099", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INDIVIDUAL_VARIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0207", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "PREDICTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0406", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "RECOVERY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0431", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "MEASUREMENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0437", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0440", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0449", "source_alias_ids": [ "F07-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Wakefulness can be supported temporarily, but sleep cannot be hacked away.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Stay perfectly alert for as long as needed", "metric": "Objective vigilance, error rate, recovery sleep and adverse effects", "boundary": "Feeling awake or taking a stimulant does not prove safe performance." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-057", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Motor recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express motor recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected people can regain meaningful motor function through diagnosis-specific rehabilitation.", "measurement_boundary": "Use impairment and meaningful activity/participation outcomes; laboratory movement speed alone does not establish independence.", "negative_findings": [ "High-dose very early mobilisation within 24 hours of stroke reduced favorable outcomes in AVERT.", "EXCITE applies only to an eligible post-stroke subgroup." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "recover from paralysis through willpower", "more and earlier therapy is always better", "one exercise repairs the brain", "assistance means failure" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0006", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0106", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Motor recovery is possible for selected people, but the right task, dose, timing and support matter.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Force the brain to rewire and recover any movement", "metric": "Diagnosis-specific motor and daily-use outcomes, harms and one-year retention", "boundary": "One improved clinic task does not establish full recovery or independence." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-058", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Sensory recovery and retraining", "definition": "Capability to develop or express sensory recovery and retraining in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected sensory functions can be retrained or supplied through a configured rehabilitation/device pathway.", "measurement_boundary": "Psychophysical thresholds, discrimination, proprioception, task function and embodiment are separate; device-on effects are not biological recovery.", "negative_findings": [ "The lower-limb stroke pilot found no between-group differences for most outcomes.", "Home prosthesis evidence involved only two participants and device interruptions." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "regrow lost nerves through practice", "restore every sense", "prosthesis becomes biologically identical", "sensory games cure stroke" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0052", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0140", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EMBODIMENT", "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0331", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Sensation can sometimes be retrained or supplied through technology, but recovery and substitution must not be confused.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Restore lost sensation completely", "metric": "Modality-specific thresholds, discrimination, task function, device state and user value", "boundary": "A reported percept does not establish natural sensation, broad recovery or independence." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-059", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Pain self-management", "definition": "Capability to develop or express pain self-management in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn strategies that reduce chronic-pain interference and improve function in selected clinical pathways.", "measurement_boundary": "Pain intensity, interference, function, participation, medication burden and adverse events are distinct; biomarker absence does not invalidate pain.", "negative_findings": [ "Most brief online-intervention effects were absent at ten months.", "Effects were weaker in the fibromyalgia subgroup and several psychosocial endpoints were null." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "pain is all in your brain", "think pain away", "ignore pain signals", "self-manage instead of seeking diagnosis" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0004", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0212", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pain self-management can improve life and function without denying pain or promising a cure.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Master pain through mindset", "metric": "Pain interference, meaningful function, participation, medication burden and harms", "boundary": "A lower rating or changed belief does not prove cure or absence of tissue/neurological disease." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-060", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Energy conservation and pacing", "definition": "Capability to develop or express energy conservation and pacing in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Person-led, condition-specific pacing and energy conservation can support meaningful activity, but no universal dose exists.", "measurement_boundary": "Track personally meaningful activity, delayed symptom exacerbation, recovery time and participation; steps or heart rate alone do not define capacity.", "negative_findings": [ "Two pacing treatments did not reduce average pain or usual fatigue in the fibromyalgia trial.", "NICE refuses fixed incremental activity programmes for ME/CFS." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "increase activity every week", "pacing cures fatigue", "push through to expand your energy envelope", "everyone has the same energy budget" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0088", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0242", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0471", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LEGITIMACY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pacing is not doing more every week; it is using available energy to protect meaningful life without triggering avoidable worsening.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Expand your energy envelope by steadily pushing harder", "metric": "Meaningful activity, delayed symptom exacerbation, recovery and participation", "boundary": "More activity or steps do not prove health, and fixed increases can cause harm." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-061", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Communication recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express communication recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Communication can improve or be effectively supported after neurological injury through multiple legitimate routes.", "measurement_boundary": "Message success, participation, partner burden and person-defined communication matter alongside impairment tests; speech output alone is insufficient.", "negative_findings": [ "The intensive-trial population and comparison interval were narrow.", "No single modality fits all people or contexts." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "restore normal speech for everyone", "speech is the only real recovery", "aphasia means reduced intelligence", "AAC prevents recovery" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0107", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0435", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LEGITIMACY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Communication can be recovered, supported or rerouted—and speech is only one valid path.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Restore speech and return to normal", "metric": "Reliable message exchange, participation, fatigue and person-chosen modality", "boundary": "More spoken words do not alone establish communication, cognition or autonomy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-062", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Cognitive rehabilitation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cognitive rehabilitation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected people with acquired brain injury can learn strategies that improve everyday executive functioning, often with external cues.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate impairment tests, strategy use, device-on function, device-off retention and everyday participation.", "negative_findings": [ "Both trial groups improved on most neuropsychological tests.", "The effect belongs to a programme including external cueing, not an unaided faculty." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "restore your whole brain", "unlock executive function", "text reminders prove unaided recovery", "brain games cure injury" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0112", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Cognitive rehabilitation can improve daily functioning—often by combining learning with external supports.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Retrain the brain back to full power", "metric": "Everyday goal completion, test performance, cue dependence, burden and retention", "boundary": "A brain-game score or aided gain does not establish global or unaided recovery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-063", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Prosthetic embodiment", "definition": "Capability to develop or express prosthetic embodiment in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some users can develop a stronger functional and experiential relationship with a fitted sensory prosthesis.", "measurement_boundary": "Report ownership/agency scales, task function, wear time, device state, maintenance burden, adverse events and the user’s own value judgment.", "negative_findings": [ "The home study involved two participants and device interruptions.", "Device-off persistence and broad population benefit are not established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "prosthesis becomes a natural limb", "cyborg upgrade", "everyone should embody a device", "implant restores the biological hand" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0140", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EMBODIMENT", "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0331", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A prosthesis can sometimes feel and function more like part of the body—but only within a fitted, supported person-device system.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Merge with a prosthesis and regain a natural limb", "metric": "User-defined embodiment, task function, wear choice, device state and burden", "boundary": "Embodiment scores do not prove biological restoration, universal preference or effortless use." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-064", "family_id": "FAM-08", "family": "Health, Rehabilitation & Adaptive Independence", "superdomain": "Regulation & Recovery", "power": "Adaptive self-care independence", "definition": "Capability to develop or express adaptive self-care independence in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Adaptive self-care can improve through person-led strategies, assistance and environmental modification.", "measurement_boundary": "Use person-chosen ADLs, safety, effort, time, assistance, participation and caregiver burden; lower help does not automatically mean better outcome.", "negative_findings": [ "The post-hospitalization CAPABLE trial did not improve overall ADLs.", "IADL improvement in the 2019 CAPABLE trial was not statistically significant." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "become fully independent", "need no help", "overcome disability through effort", "assistive technology fixes access" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0008", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EQUITY", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0242", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0245", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "SUBGROUP" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0483", "source_alias_ids": [ "F08-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "EQUITY", "GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Independence can mean doing a task, directing assistance or redesigning the environment—not doing everything alone.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become independent enough to need no help", "metric": "Safe completion of chosen activities with declared effort, assistance, environment and burden", "boundary": "Reduced help is not automatically safer, preferred or more autonomous." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-065", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Visual acuity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express visual acuity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected people with amblyopia can improve measured visual acuity through structured treatment that includes perceptual practice; this is clinical recovery, not proof of eagle-like vision.", "measurement_boundary": "Use calibrated logMAR or equivalent acuity with declared correction and test conditions; acuity does not establish contrast, field, search, depth, low-light or functional safety.", "negative_findings": [ "Fluoxetine did not add a visual-training benefit in a phase 2 trial.", "Not every visual outcome or treatment comparison favoured perceptual learning." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Train eyesight beyond human limits", "Throw away glasses", "Cure every lazy eye", "Medication unlocks adult visual plasticity" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0102", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0141", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0161", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0247", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0290", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0377", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Visual acuity can improve in selected amblyopia treatment settings, but this is not a route to superhuman eyesight.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Eagle eyesight", "metric": "Corrected logMAR acuity change plus delayed functional vision", "boundary": "A smaller chart threshold does not prove superior vision across contrast, depth, periphery, motion or low light." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-066", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Contrast sensitivity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express contrast sensitivity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Defined contrast-sensitivity measures can improve with perceptual learning in selected amblyopic populations; transfer beyond related visual tests is incomplete.", "measurement_boundary": "Record a full contrast-sensitivity function or validated bounded threshold at declared luminance and correction; do not substitute chart acuity or subjective sharpness.", "negative_findings": [ "Clinical improvements do not establish enhancement in healthy eyes.", "Fluoxetine offered no added benefit over placebo in the reviewed visual-learning trial." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "See through darkness", "Make every visual task sharper", "Repair the retina by gaming", "Biohack contrast with prescription drugs" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0102", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0141", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0161", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0247", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0290", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0377", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Contrast sensitivity can be trained in some clinical settings, but a better test threshold is not generally enhanced vision.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See every hidden detail", "metric": "Contrast-sensitivity function by spatial frequency and luminance", "boundary": "A trained threshold does not confer night vision, field expansion or universal object recognition." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-067", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Peripheral target detection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express peripheral target detection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Peripheral detection can improve on selected crowding tasks, while rare, unexpected targets remain a major failure mode.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare eccentricity, target, clutter, prevalence, sensitivity and false alarms; a reaction-time gain alone may reflect criterion shift rather than better perception.", "negative_findings": [ "Rare targets are often missed even by practised observers.", "Crowding-task improvement does not establish broader peripheral awareness." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Expand your visual field", "Develop 360-degree vision", "Never miss a hazard", "Cure neglect with a home drill" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0130", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0177", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0288", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0291", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0448", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0477", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Peripheral targets can be practised, but clutter and rarity create stubborn miss risks; this is not wider vision.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Eyes in the back of your head", "metric": "Sensitivity and false alarms for prespecified peripheral targets by eccentricity and prevalence", "boundary": "No task demonstrates a larger anatomical visual field or zero-miss hazard detection." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-068", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Motion perception", "definition": "Capability to develop or express motion perception in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Motion-direction discrimination can improve through task-specific perceptual learning; transfer depends on the training and exposure configuration.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare motion type, speed, coherence, direction, retinal location and threshold method; do not equate one motion threshold with optic flow, pursuit or reaction speed.", "negative_findings": [ "Standard motion learning can remain specific to the trained direction.", "No mapped study established broad sport, driving or mobility transfer." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Bullet-time vision", "Track anything at any speed", "Train motion perception to prevent every collision", "Motion games cure amblyopia" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0103", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0290", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Motion perception is trainable on defined tasks, but ‘faster eyes’ is not supported.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See the world in slow motion", "metric": "Direction/coherence threshold for an unfamiliar motion configuration", "boundary": "A lower laboratory threshold does not slow subjective time or guarantee sport and traffic anticipation." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-069", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Depth perception", "definition": "Capability to develop or express depth perception in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some adults with abnormal binocular vision have recovered measurable stereopsis through intensive supervised perceptual learning; general recovery and daily-life transfer remain unproven.", "measurement_boundary": "Report stereoacuity/disparity threshold and task, plus monocular cues and functional configuration; stereoacuity cannot diagnose or summarise all depth perception.", "negative_findings": [ "A paediatric randomised comparison did not show a between-treatment stereoacuity advantage.", "Evidence does not erase legitimate monocular and assistive depth strategies." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Unlock 3D vision for everyone", "Depth perception is one stereo score", "Patching yourself retrains both eyes", "No stereopsis means no usable depth" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0163", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0247", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Stereopsis can sometimes be recovered in selected adults, but depth perception is larger than binocular disparity.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock perfect 3D vision", "metric": "Stereoacuity plus an unfamiliar functional depth task", "boundary": "Stereo improvement does not establish every form of depth perception or remove need for correction and adaptations." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-070", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Visual search", "definition": "Capability to develop or express visual search in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Visual search is trainable for defined targets and contexts, yet low-prevalence targets remain easy to miss and broad transfer is not guaranteed.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare target class, prevalence, sensitivity, false alarms, response time and unfamiliar-scene transfer; keep speed–accuracy trade-offs visible.", "negative_findings": [ "Rare targets were missed at disturbingly high rates.", "Contextual learning can improve a repeated scene without improving a new one." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Photographic scanning", "Never miss an anomaly", "One game trains every search job", "Reaction time proves safer inspection" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0130", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0177", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0288", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0291", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0448", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0477", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Search practice can sharpen a defined search, but rare things remain disproportionately easy to miss.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Human anomaly scanner", "metric": "Sensitivity, miss and false-alarm rates on rare unfamiliar targets", "boundary": "Fast finding of frequent trained targets does not establish expert anomaly detection." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-071", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Low-light adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express low-light adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Humans naturally become more light-sensitive in darkness, but the state takes time, is age- and health-dependent and can be lost within seconds of bright light.", "measurement_boundary": "Use rod/cone recovery curves or declared low-luminance thresholds after standardised bleach and adaptation; do not use subjective confidence or a daytime chart.", "negative_findings": [ "Most dark-adaptation outcomes did not improve with short high-dose retinol.", "Bright light rapidly destroys the adapted state." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Train permanent night vision", "See in total darkness", "Megadose vitamin A for superior sight", "Practise driving blind to adapt" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0104", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0289", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0448", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Dark adaptation is a temporary physiological state, not a permanent superpower—and bright light can erase it quickly.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Night vision", "metric": "Time-resolved scotopic threshold under standardised lighting", "boundary": "Temporary sensitivity does not permit vision without light or establish safe night driving." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-072", "family_id": "FAM-09", "family": "Visual Perception & Search", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Visuomotor integration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express visuomotor integration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People adapt to altered visual–movement mappings and can reuse related task structure, but this is configured adaptation rather than a universal hand-eye upgrade.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate online error reduction, after-effects, explicit strategy, retention, savings and untrained function; a lower endpoint error alone does not identify mechanism.", "negative_findings": [ "A small acute-neglect trial did not show a durable one-month treatment advantage.", "Some measured change reflects explicit re-aiming rather than implicit recalibration." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Instant hand-eye mastery", "Prism goggles cure neglect", "Train while driving or using machinery", "One remapping transfers to every motor skill" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; CLINICAL_WHEN_VISUAL_DISORDER_OR_PRISM", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0177", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0361", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0477", "source_alias_ids": [ "F09-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "The brain can adapt movement to altered visual feedback, but the learning is structured and often task-specific.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect hand-eye coordination", "metric": "Error, after-effect and delayed transfer under a declared remapping", "boundary": "Adaptation to one rotation or prism does not confer expert coordination across tools and environments." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-073", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Sound localisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express sound localisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Sound localisation can adapt to a changed or asymmetric cue configuration, but improvement remains task-, anatomy-, hearing- and environment-specific.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare azimuth/elevation/distance, source spectrum, room, head movement, device state and error distribution; no single localisation score covers spatial hearing.", "negative_findings": [ "Ten weeks of click-echolocation practice did not improve two ordinary sound-localisation measures.", "Some no-training change and cue specificity limit causal and transfer claims." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Supernatural 3D hearing", "Locate anything through walls", "Earplug one ear to strengthen the other", "Echolocation automatically improves ordinary localisation" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0025", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0142", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0365", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0369", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Spatial hearing can adapt, but it is a calibrated skill—not a universal sonar upgrade.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Hear exactly where anything is", "metric": "Angular/distance error for unfamiliar sources and rooms", "boundary": "One trained array cannot establish accurate localisation across every spectrum, elevation and reverberant space." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-074", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Pitch discrimination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express pitch discrimination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Pitch discrimination can improve with practice on a defined frequency or harmonic stimulus, while generalisation is limited.", "measurement_boundary": "Use a calibrated just-noticeable difference with declared carrier, harmonic structure, level and procedure; keep naming, memory and discrimination separate.", "negative_findings": [ "Frequency learning can be tightly centred on the trained frequency.", "Absolute-pitch naming practice did not improve fine pitch discrimination or relative-pitch judgement." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Hear every frequency perfectly", "Develop perfect pitch by discrimination drills", "Superior pitch means superior musician", "Louder practice trains faster" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0034", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0254", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0317", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pitch thresholds can sharpen, usually for what was actually practised—not hearing as a whole.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect ears", "metric": "Pitch/frequency difference threshold across trained and unfamiliar stimuli", "boundary": "A smaller just-noticeable difference does not confer note naming, memory, musicianship or general hearing acuity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-075", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Speech-in-noise understanding", "definition": "Capability to develop or express speech-in-noise understanding in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Speech-in-noise training can improve selected materials or configured tasks, but broad everyday listening transfer is inconsistent.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare speech corpus, language, masker, spatial layout, SNR, device state and fatigue; separate trained-material accuracy from new-speaker and real-conversation outcomes.", "negative_findings": [ "A large at-home trial found durable trained-word learning without broad nontrained or self-report transfer.", "A phoneme-training trial did not produce consistent general speech-in-noise benefit." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Hear any conversation anywhere", "Train away hearing loss", "Stop using hearing aids or captions", "One app fixes auditory processing" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0213", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0214", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0403", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Listening in noise can improve on selected tasks; an app score is not the same as easier real conversation.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Hear every word in a crowd", "metric": "Untrained speech reception threshold plus real-conversation participation", "boundary": "Trained-item accuracy does not establish effortless listening, cure hearing loss or replace preferred communication access." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-076", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Auditory scene analysis", "definition": "Capability to develop or express auditory scene analysis in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn to separate selected auditory patterns, but the learning may be tightly tuned and does not establish general ‘cocktail-party’ mastery.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare number/type of sources, cue dimensions, target, masker, accuracy and new-scene transfer; neural responses remain mechanism measures.", "negative_findings": [ "Learning on one spectrotemporal modulation did not generalise broadly and some untrained detection worsened.", "No mapped study established daily multi-speaker transfer." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Isolate any sound at will", "Switch off background noise with the brain", "Train universal auditory scene analysis", "Neural change proves real-world benefit" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0108", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0366", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "The brain can learn a specific sound pattern without becoming a universal noise filter.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Choose one voice in any crowd", "metric": "Target-source accuracy in novel multi-source scenes with fatigue", "boundary": "A trained vowel or modulation threshold does not create universal selective hearing." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-077", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Auditory temporal resolution", "definition": "Capability to develop or express auditory temporal resolution in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Auditory gap and interval thresholds can improve, but the gain is tied to the test configuration and has not been shown to sharpen hearing generally.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare marker spectrum, gap/interval, ear, adaptive rule and reliability; use multiple measures before any broader interpretation.", "negative_findings": [ "Two accepted temporal-resolution tests do not classify performance identically.", "Transfer failed across some spectral-marker changes and remained interval-specific." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Speed up the auditory brain", "Hear microscopic gaps in all sound", "A gap test diagnoses auditory processing", "Temporal drills guarantee better speech" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0157", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0225", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0259", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can learn a particular auditory timing test; that does not prove a universally faster ear.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Hear between milliseconds", "metric": "Reliable threshold across untrained gap and interval configurations", "boundary": "A lower trained threshold does not establish speech, music or global processing-speed benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-078", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Human echolocation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express human echolocation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Blind and sighted adults can learn click-based echolocation for defined spatial tasks, including selected within-domain transfer; it does not create general hearing enhancement or replace safe mobility support.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate echo detection, localisation, material, distance bias, object discrimination and mobility; record click, room, target, vision status, aid use and collision type.", "negative_findings": [ "Ten-week echolocation training did not improve two ordinary sound-localisation tasks.", "Echolocation reduced head-level but not ground-level collisions in a controlled walking study.", "Novices systematically underestimated some echo distances." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Human sonar makes sight unnecessary", "Perfect navigation by sound", "Blindfold yourself outdoors to train", "Echolocation sharpens all hearing" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0025", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0026", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIAS", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0128", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0349", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Click echolocation is a real learnable spatial skill—powerful, bounded and not a substitute for safe mobility tools.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Bat-like sonar", "metric": "Novel echo-task accuracy plus objective delayed mobility performance by obstacle type", "boundary": "Human echolocation is not perfect, visual restoration or universal independent navigation." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-079", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Absolute and relational pitch memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express absolute and relational pitch memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Adults can possess latent long-term pitch memory and some can learn accurate reference-free pitch labels, but gains are variable and do not confer perfect or superior musical hearing.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate familiar-pitch memory, isolated-note naming, relational interval judgement, timbre/octave transfer and delayed retention; avoid a single binary label.", "negative_findings": [ "Explicit naming practice did not improve relative-pitch judgement or fine discrimination.", "Only a minority reached stringent all-category criteria and methods vary." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Anyone can acquire perfect pitch", "Absolute pitch makes a better musician", "Pitch naming improves all hearing", "Use medication to reopen a critical period" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0317", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0412", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0415", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S020" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pitch memory is more widespread than note naming, and some adults can learn the labels—without becoming musically superior.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect pitch", "metric": "Accuracy, calibration and retention across memory, naming and relation tasks", "boundary": "Reference-free labelling is neither perfect nor a general measure of hearing or musicianship." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-080", "family_id": "FAM-10", "family": "Auditory Perception, Localization & Echolocation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Auditory navigation and substitution", "definition": "Capability to develop or express auditory navigation and substitution in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Auditory and haptic substitution can add selected navigation information in a declared device-plus-user configuration; it does not restore biological vision or universally replace a cane, guide dog or O&M training.", "measurement_boundary": "Report intended-user status, training, device on/off, cane/guide-dog/human support, collision type, speed, cognitive load, dropout and failure mode; no device-only score is capability in full.", "negative_findings": [ "One pilot system did not outperform the white cane and device-only travel was slower with more collisions.", "A downward sensor missed low steps at unsafe rates.", "Helpful camera/AI output also slowed walking in a controlled comparison." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Restore sight through sound", "Throw away the cane", "AI makes blind travel autonomous", "A blindfolded sighted test proves blind-user safety" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE; MOBILITY_OR_CLINICAL_CONFIGURATION_CAN_BE_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0128", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0153", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S021" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DEVICE_COMPARISON", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0348", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S023" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0407", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S022" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0443", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S024" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0446", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S025" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "REGULATORY_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F10-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Sensory-substitution tools can add real spatial information—but the capability belongs to person, device, training, mobility tools and environment together.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See with sound", "metric": "Device-on/off added value in intended users with established aids, failures and delayed use", "boundary": "Encoded spatial information is not biological vision, universal safety or authority to remove a person's chosen mobility tools." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-081", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Tactile acuity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express tactile acuity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Tactile acuity can improve through discriminative practice at a trained body site, with smaller transfer and physical limits.", "measurement_boundary": "Use a reliable site-specific grating/tactile threshold with skin condition, finger geometry and response method declared; do not substitute two-point distance or pain change without validation.", "negative_findings": [ "A pilot chronic-low-back-pain trial did not beat sham and the intervention group reported worse pain.", "Training gains approached a limit related to fingertip size and transferred less to an untrained finger." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Superhuman touch everywhere", "Grow new receptors", "Braille is a generic brain hack", "Tactile drills cure chronic pain" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0096", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0323", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0362", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIOLOGICAL_LIMIT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0428", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Touch can sharpen where and how it is practised, but it does not become a universal extra sense.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Read the world with a fingertip", "metric": "Site-specific tactile threshold plus unfamiliar-material and functional transfer", "boundary": "A trained finger threshold does not establish whole-body touch, pain cure or instant Braille literacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-082", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Haptic object recognition", "definition": "Capability to develop or express haptic object recognition in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Humans can recognise and retain rich information about objects through active touch, but performance depends on object, scale, experience and access.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare object familiarity, scale, exploration time, hand/motor access, vision condition and same- versus crossmodal test; report errors by object class.", "negative_findings": [ "Age and reduced object scale lowered haptic shape discrimination.", "A group comparison cannot establish that blindness biologically enhances touch." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Blind people have automatically superior touch", "Identify any object instantly", "Haptic memory replaces every other sense", "One object test measures tactile intelligence" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0144", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0311", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0428", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0479", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Active touch can build detailed, durable object knowledge—through a route whose performance depends on experience and object design.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Know any object by touch", "metric": "Novel-object identification and delayed crossmodal recognition by scale and access", "boundary": "Memory for handled familiar objects does not establish universal material, hazard or navigation recognition." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-083", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Thermal discrimination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express thermal discrimination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People discriminate warm and cold, but thresholds depend strongly on body site, age and body state; durable enhancement through training is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Use calibrated noninjurious warm/cold detection thresholds at a named site and starting temperature; never equate detection with tissue safety or thermoregulatory control.", "negative_findings": [ "Whole-body cooling changes local sensitivity rather than simply improving it.", "No mapped primary study established retained thermal-discrimination training." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become immune to heat or cold", "Train away burn warnings", "Cold exposure sharpens thermal sense", "A threshold proves metabolic or autonomic control" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0045", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0064", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0091", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTEXT_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0295", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Thermal sensitivity is a protective, context-dependent sense—not a route to heat or cold immunity.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Temperature-proof skin", "metric": "Calibrated warm/cold threshold by body site and state", "boundary": "Detection does not establish tolerance, tissue safety, core-temperature control or training." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-084", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Nociceptive discrimination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express nociceptive discrimination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Nociceptive discrimination exists, but Titan has no public route for training it; pain and nociception must remain distinct, and stronger tolerance is not assumed to be safer.", "measurement_boundary": "Name the controlled stimulus and discrimination outcome while recording the person's pain report separately; stimulus intensity is not pain and neural activity cannot settle lived experience.", "negative_findings": [ "Noxious temporal-spatial discrimination was worse than innocuous tactile discrimination.", "Tactile pain interventions are mixed and do not establish nociceptive training." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become pain-proof", "Condition nerves with repeated injury", "A high pain threshold proves toughness", "Infer pain from biomarkers or behaviour" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0045", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0096", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0216", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0295", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0323", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0464", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LEGITIMACY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pain is not a toughness score. Nociceptive discrimination is real, but deliberate painful training is not authorised.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Pain immunity", "metric": "Ethically controlled noxious discrimination plus separate pain and harm outcomes", "boundary": "Higher tolerance, lower report or altered threshold does not prove safety, health or superior capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-085", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Olfactory discrimination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express olfactory discrimination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Olfactory training may help some people with specific acquired smell loss, but effects are condition- and outcome-dependent and a rigorous COVID-19 trial found no advantage over placebo.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate threshold, discrimination, identification, distortion and participant-valued function; record diagnosis, baseline, spontaneous recovery and environmental safety supports.", "negative_findings": [ "Training was not superior to placebo for COVID-19-related smell loss in one randomised double-blind trial.", "Post-traumatic training showed only mild threshold change without broad recovery." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Super-smell", "Detect every danger by nose", "Olfactory training cures all anosmia", "Sniff irritants or chemicals to toughen receptors" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0017", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0194", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0418", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0472", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_BOUNDARY", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Smell training can help in some conditions, not all—and real safety still depends on alarms and environmental supports.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Bloodhound nose", "metric": "Validated threshold, discrimination and identification plus delayed daily function", "boundary": "One smell-test gain does not confer universal hazard detection, diagnosis or healthy-person enhancement." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-086", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Gustatory discrimination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express gustatory discrimination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Healthy adults improved short-term recognition thresholds for four basic tastes after a small controlled recall-training study; retention and real-food transfer remain unknown.", "measurement_boundary": "Use controlled food-safe detection/recognition concentrations by taste quality and separate smell, trigeminal sensation, intensity, liking and diet outcomes.", "negative_findings": [ "No delayed retention or functional food outcome was established.", "Many apparent taste problems are actually smell-related flavour problems." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become a supertaster on demand", "Taste allergens or poison safely", "Cure flavour loss with tongue drills", "More sensitive taste guarantees a better diet" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0147", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0295", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "POPULATION_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0474", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Basic taste recognition may be trainable—but it is not the same as flavour, nutrition or poison detection.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Supertaster at will", "metric": "Delayed food-safe recognition thresholds across basic tastes and novel samples", "boundary": "Threshold sensitivity does not establish flavour expertise, safety, diet quality or disease treatment." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-087", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Interoceptive accuracy", "definition": "Capability to develop or express interoceptive accuracy in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Interoceptive accuracy is real but difficult to measure. Heartbeat counting is heavily contaminated by expectation, and training has not yet shown reliable cross-task or real-world transfer.", "measurement_boundary": "Use multiple validated channel-specific discrimination/detection tasks plus confidence and symptoms; never treat heartbeat counting or a wearable agreement score as a universal interoception measure.", "negative_findings": [ "Heartbeat-counting scores dropped sharply when non-sensory estimation was restricted.", "Immediate and delayed feedback improved counting similarly, implicating beliefs.", "Experienced meditators were not objectively better at heartbeat detection despite greater confidence.", "Training-related change did not transfer from counting to discrimination." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Read every body signal perfectly", "Heartbeat counting diagnoses health", "Meditation guarantees superior interoception", "Provoke stress or symptoms to train accuracy" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0057", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S021" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0058", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S020" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0059", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S023" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "SAFETY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0241", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S022" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0333", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S024" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Sensing the body is not one hidden meter. The most common heartbeat test can reward good guessing rather than better perception.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect inner radar", "metric": "Convergent accuracy across independent channel-specific tasks plus calibrated confidence", "boundary": "One heartbeat-counting score does not diagnose the body, prove emotional mastery or authorise ignoring symptoms." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-088", "family_id": "FAM-11", "family": "Touch, Chemosensation & Interoception", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Multisensory integration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express multisensory integration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Multisensory timing and cue use can be trained on defined tasks, including in older adults, but benefits depend on congruence and do not establish generally ‘heightened senses.’", "measurement_boundary": "Declare modalities, reliability, timing, congruence, illusion/task, age and device state; compare unimodal and combined performance and record overload/conflict.", "negative_findings": [ "Older adults showed less change in some prior crossmodal expectations despite temporal improvement.", "No mapped study established durable everyday function or universal benefit from extra cues." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Fuse senses into a sixth sense", "More cues always improve performance", "Multisensory games prevent falls", "Neural integration proves broad cognitive enhancement" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE; CHEMICAL_THERMAL_PAIN_AND_CLINICAL_ROUTES_RESTRICTED", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0068", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S027" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CROSSMODAL_TRANSFER", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0095", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S025" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AGE_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0381", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S028" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0386", "source_alias_ids": [ "F11-S026" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "The senses learn to cooperate—but extra signals help only when timing, reliability and accessibility fit the task.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock a sixth sense", "metric": "Added value of combined versus best unimodal cues on an unfamiliar delayed task", "boundary": "A multisensory illusion or lab gain does not establish a new sense, general cognition or real-world safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-089", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Proprioceptive accuracy", "definition": "Capability to develop or express proprioceptive accuracy in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can sometimes improve position accuracy for a specific joint and task, but proprioception is not one trainable whole-body sense and passive tape is not a reliable shortcut.", "measurement_boundary": "Absolute or variable reposition error describes the tested joint, target and apparatus; it does not establish tissue health, pain cause, balance or real-world safety.", "negative_findings": [ "Kinesiology tape did not improve wrist force sense and showed no consistent joint-position advantage over placebo/control." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Perfect body awareness", "Injury-proof proprioception", "Tape rewires your nervous system", "Pain proves poor proprioception" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0085", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0087", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Your sense of joint position can change in a specific task. It is not a single “sixth sense,” and tools or tape must be tested rather than assumed to help.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock flawless body awareness", "metric": "Joint-specific reposition or force-reproduction error plus declared function", "boundary": "One joint test cannot establish global proprioception or injury immunity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-090", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Vestibular adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express vestibular adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People with diagnosed peripheral vestibular hypofunction can improve selected gaze, balance and functional outcomes through clinician-configured rehabilitation.", "measurement_boundary": "Dynamic visual acuity, vestibular tests, symptom measures, gait and participation describe different outcomes; none alone establishes “vestibular strength.”", "negative_findings": [ "The guideline rejects eye-only saccade or smooth-pursuit drills without head movement as a gaze-stability treatment, and its recommendations do not cover undiagnosed or central disorders." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Reset your inner ear", "Cure all vertigo", "Train until dizzy", "Vestibular immunity" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0002", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0219", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "The balance system can compensate and adapt, but dizziness is not a do-it-yourself training signal. Effective routes are diagnosis-specific and clinically supervised.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Make yourself immune to dizziness", "metric": "Diagnosis-specific gaze, balance, symptom and participation outcomes", "boundary": "A laboratory adaptation cannot certify safe movement or cure every cause of vertigo." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-091", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Path integration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express path integration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can estimate position by integrating self-motion cues, but the estimate accumulates error and is highly dependent on vision, proprioception and motion dynamics.", "measurement_boundary": "Homing distance/angle error in a declared cue configuration measures that task only; it does not measure general navigation or safety.", "negative_findings": [ "Vestibular cues alone produced chance or strongly biased performance in key conditions, and participants did not fully adapt to changing control dynamics." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Human dead reckoning is a compass", "Navigate blind anywhere", "Perfect internal GPS", "Vestibular signals always tell distance" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0065", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0429", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Humans do have a form of internal dead reckoning—but it drifts, depends on available senses, and is not a substitute for landmarks or safe navigation tools.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Activate your internal GPS", "metric": "Cue-specific homing distance and heading error", "boundary": "A good laboratory homing trial cannot establish reliable real-world navigation." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-092", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Cognitive mapping", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cognitive mapping in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can build useful environment-specific cognitive maps through prolonged experience, tactile maps or declared sensory support, but expertise can be selective and transfer is not automatic.", "measurement_boundary": "Pointing, distance, route choice, sketch maps and destination success sample different map knowledge; MRI volume is not a personal capability metric.", "negative_findings": [ "Taxi expertise did not produce broad memory enhancement and was associated with poorer new visuospatial learning on some measures." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Grow your hippocampus on command", "Photographic map memory", "One navigation style is superior", "Indigenous navigation belongs to Titan" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0014", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0070", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0146", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0155", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0397", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can build remarkably detailed maps of places. Those maps may be visual, tactile, auditory or technology-supported—and their value is always environment-specific.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build a perfect map in your head", "metric": "Route, survey, landmark and destination measures in a named environment", "boundary": "A brain scan or one map test cannot establish universal navigation skill." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-093", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Wayfinding", "definition": "Capability to develop or express wayfinding in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Wayfinding can be supported by tactile maps, landmarks and declared technology, but virtual or device training does not yet show reliable unaided real-world transfer.", "measurement_boundary": "Arrival, errors, time, route quality, assistance and safety in a named environment measure wayfinding; confidence alone does not.", "negative_findings": [ "Ten weeks of iPad-enhanced exercise did not improve real-building wayfinding performance or spatial memory relative to matched exercise." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Never get lost again", "Throw away GPS", "Navigate any city from one map", "Assistive navigation is dependency" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0146", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0397", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0399", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Wayfinding is not “never using GPS.” It is reaching a destination safely with whatever maps, cues, people or devices make that possible.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Never be lost", "metric": "Safe destination arrival, route errors, assistance and fallback in a named environment", "boundary": "Confidence or virtual practice cannot certify live independent travel." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-094", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Body schema", "definition": "Capability to develop or express body schema in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "The brain’s action-oriented representation of the body can update during tool use and multisensory illusions, but durable voluntary control and broad function are not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Kinematics, localization drift, ownership ratings and object judgments operationalize different constructs and cannot be combined into one body-schema score.", "negative_findings": [ "Effects were short laboratory after-effects, not durable functional training; a 12-person illusion cannot support clinical claims." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Expand your body at will", "Own any prosthesis instantly", "Rewrite your body image", "A rubber-hand illusion treats trauma" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0069", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0160", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Your brain’s working model of the body is flexible enough to incorporate tools—temporarily. That is fascinating, but it is not yet a voluntary body-rewriting power.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Extend your body at will", "metric": "Declared movement, localization or ownership measure before and after tool/illusion exposure", "boundary": "A temporary illusion cannot prove durable embodiment or recovery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-095", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Spatial memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express spatial memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Spatial memory can become exceptionally detailed for a practiced environment, but the gain is specific and does not imply generally superior memory.", "measurement_boundary": "Location error, pointing, route recall and landmark recognition must be declared separately; hippocampal volume is not performance.", "negative_findings": [ "Taxi drivers showed poorer acquisition of some new visuospatial information despite exceptional London knowledge." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Photographic spatial memory", "Grow a memory center", "Never forget a route", "Navigation expertise boosts every memory" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0014", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0070", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0155", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Spatial memory can become extraordinary for one place—without making someone better at every kind of memory. Expertise has boundaries and sometimes trade-offs.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Remember every place forever", "metric": "Delayed location, relation and route accuracy in a named environment", "boundary": "Environment-specific expertise cannot establish universal memory." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-096", "family_id": "FAM-12", "family": "Spatial Orientation, Proprioception & Navigation", "superdomain": "Perception & Sensorimotor", "power": "Orientation under motion", "definition": "Capability to develop or express orientation under motion in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Motion tolerance can improve in a tightly controlled configuration, but the wrong exposure can sensitize symptoms and no universal vestibular immunity is supported.", "measurement_boundary": "Symptom scores, time tolerated, autonomic signals, orientation error and task performance are separate; symptom reduction is not safe operational performance.", "negative_findings": [ "Prior provocative physical motion made later visually induced sickness worse in a randomized study." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Train away all motion sickness", "Spin until adapted", "VR nausea means neuroplasticity", "Motion-proof yourself" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0075", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0219", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0379", "source_alias_ids": [ "F12-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Motion tolerance is trainable for some people—but exposure can also make it worse. This is a supervised frontier, not a “push through the nausea” challenge.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become motion-proof", "metric": "Environment-specific symptoms, orientation and task performance with delayed retest", "boundary": "Less nausea in one setup cannot certify tolerance or safety elsewhere." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-097", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Sustained attention", "definition": "Capability to develop or express sustained attention in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Sustained-attention performance can change on a practiced task, but current controlled evidence is conflicting and does not establish a broad or durable attention upgrade.", "measurement_boundary": "Accuracy, errors, reaction-time variability, time-on-task decline and real-task completion must be reported separately; no one measure establishes general attention.", "negative_findings": [ "A 100-person active-controlled post-TBI trial found no between-group effect on its preregistered primary sustained-attention outcome.", "A large online study found practiced-task improvement without transfer to independent cognitive tests." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Build unlimited focus", "Cure attention problems with meditation", "VR repairs attention after brain injury", "One vigilance score diagnoses attention" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0054", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0395", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain distinct sustained-attention measures", "Show how context and breaks form part of the configuration", "No clinical, meditation-dose or VR protocol" ], "site_summary": "People can get better at staying with a particular attention task. Whether that becomes durable focus elsewhere is still uncertain—and a strong primary trial found no sustained-attention benefit.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock endless concentration", "metric": "Predeclared vigilance accuracy and variability over time plus an independent real-task endpoint", "boundary": "Practice on one attention test cannot establish durable focus everywhere." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-098", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Selective attention", "definition": "Capability to develop or express selective attention in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selective-attention practice can improve closely related tasks, but transfer follows shared task demands and has not been shown to improve mobility.", "measurement_boundary": "Target sensitivity, search time, errors and distractor cost must be tied to a named modality and task; they do not measure general awareness.", "negative_findings": [ "Older adults improved a visual-attention measure without improving any tested balance or mobility outcome." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "See everything at once", "Train away distraction permanently", "A game gives fighter-pilot attention", "Screen training prevents falls" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0031", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0345", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Compare search, filtering and useful-field-of-view tasks conceptually", "Explain near transfer through common demands", "No road, fall-prevention or clinical protocol" ], "site_summary": "Attention training can sharpen what a particular task asks you to notice. That does not mean it improves balance, mobility or every form of awareness.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Notice everything others miss", "metric": "Target sensitivity and distractor cost in a declared sensory task, plus a different functional endpoint", "boundary": "A better screen score cannot certify broad situational awareness." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-099", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Divided attention", "definition": "Capability to develop or express divided attention in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can improve coordination of two closely related low-risk tasks, but the gains are narrow and do not abolish multitasking costs.", "measurement_boundary": "Dual-task cost must report each component’s accuracy and speed against its single-task baseline; one aggregate can hide sacrifice of the priority task.", "negative_findings": [ "Heterogeneous dual-task practice produced only limited advantages, and the large online brain-training study showed no transfer to untrained tasks." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become a perfect multitasker", "Train while driving", "Double your mental bandwidth", "A dual-task score certifies safe work" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0120", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0200", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "You can practice coordinating two particular tasks. You cannot train away the cost of doing two things at once—and real safety never follows from a lab score.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Do two things with no cost", "metric": "Each task’s speed and accuracy relative to its single-task baseline", "boundary": "A smaller lab cost cannot certify safe simultaneous action in the real world." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-100", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Inhibitory control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express inhibitory control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People improve on practiced inhibition tasks, but current controlled evidence does not establish a transferable inhibitory-control capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Stroop cost, commission errors and stop-signal latency are task-specific research measures; none establishes character, diagnosis or real-world impulse control.", "negative_findings": [ "Adaptive inhibition training failed to outperform active controls at post-test or follow-up and produced no near or far transfer." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Build unbreakable willpower", "Cure impulsivity with a game", "Measure moral self-control", "Train your brain to say no" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0046", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0125", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0382", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Inhibition games are good at training inhibition games. Strong controlled studies do not show that the benefit becomes broader self-control.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Install stronger willpower", "metric": "Performance on distinct inhibition tasks plus a predeclared life outcome", "boundary": "Practice effects cannot establish transferable self-control." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-101", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Task switching", "definition": "Capability to develop or express task switching in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Task-switching speed can improve on practiced laboratory rules, but far transfer and durable real-world value remain conflicting.", "measurement_boundary": "Switch cost, mixing cost, errors and resumption failure must be separated; faster responses alone do not show better task management.", "negative_findings": [ "An active-controlled trial found only one limited near-transfer effect and no far transfer despite extensive testing." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become interruption-proof", "Switch instantly with no cost", "Train ADHD away", "Fast switching means flexible intelligence" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0237", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0380", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain switch and mixing costs", "Compare human practice with workflow redesign conceptually", "No safety-critical interruption drill" ], "site_summary": "People can get faster at switching between practiced rules. That is not the same as becoming interruption-proof or making better decisions.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Switch instantly between anything", "metric": "Switch and mixing costs, errors and resumption in a declared workflow", "boundary": "Faster laboratory alternation cannot establish judgment or interruption immunity." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-102", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Working-memory updating", "definition": "Capability to develop or express working-memory updating in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Working-memory updating tasks are trainable as tasks, but strong controlled studies do not show broader cognitive-ability transfer.", "measurement_boundary": "Accuracy and load on a declared updating task cannot establish intelligence, learning capacity or everyday memory; independent construct measures are required.", "negative_findings": [ "A randomized placebo-controlled study found no positive transfer from 20 dual-n-back sessions to any measured cognitive ability." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Increase IQ with n-back", "Expand working memory permanently", "Prevent dementia with brain games", "External memory weakens the brain" ], "risk_level": "LOW", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0123", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0382", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Working-memory games can make you better at working-memory games. High-powered trials do not show that this raises intelligence or broad mental ability.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Expand your mental RAM", "metric": "Performance on the trained task and independent functional memory outcomes after delay", "boundary": "Task practice cannot establish IQ, general cognition or dementia prevention." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-103", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Goal maintenance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express goal maintenance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Goal-management rehabilitation with external cues can improve reported everyday function after acquired brain injury, but results do not generalize across clinical groups or prove unaided executive recovery.", "measurement_boundary": "Goal completion, resumption error, assistance and personally meaningful participation must accompany self-report and task tests; support use is part of the result.", "negative_findings": [ "In depression, Goal Management Training did not outperform computerized cognitive training on any outcome; after brain injury, most neuropsychological tests improved in both groups." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Repair executive function yourself", "Stop using reminders", "One system treats brain injury and depression", "Productivity proves recovery" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0081", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0112", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "External reminders can be part of a real capability. In one brain-injury trial, a cue-supported programme improved reported everyday function for six months; that result remains clinical and specific.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Install perfect follow-through", "metric": "Meaningful goal completion and resumption with assistance recorded over time", "boundary": "A supported clinical result cannot establish unaided executive recovery or a universal productivity system." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-104", "family_id": "FAM-13", "family": "Attention & Executive Control", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Cognitive flexibility", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cognitive flexibility in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People improve on practiced switching games, but active-controlled trials do not establish broad cognitive flexibility or real-world adaptability.", "measurement_boundary": "Set-shift cost and rule-change errors are task measures; they do not establish creativity, open-mindedness, resilience or social conformity.", "negative_findings": [ "A large 58-session active-controlled trial found no training-specific cognitive benefit; improvements were consistent with retest, expectancy or motivation." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become infinitely adaptable", "Train away autistic rigidity", "Brain games make you open-minded", "Flexibility prevents cognitive decline" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0237", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0380", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0383", "source_alias_ids": [ "F13-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Brain games can train their own rule changes. They have not been shown to make people broadly more adaptable—and routine or predictability may be the right support.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become adaptable to anything", "metric": "Rule-change cost and errors plus a separate meaningful adaptation outcome", "boundary": "A game cannot establish creativity, resilience, open-mindedness or human worth." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-105", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Episodic memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express episodic memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can improve recall for selected material using tested retrieval and mnemonic methods, with durability demonstrated for some configured tasks.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare material, encoding, cueing, assistance, accuracy, false alarms, confidence, delay and ecological task; recall quantity is not truth verification.", "negative_findings": [ "Laboratory recall gains do not establish more accurate autobiographical memory.", "Suggestion can produce confident reports of events that did not occur." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "photographic memory", "perfect autobiographical recall", "recover hidden memories", "brain rewiring proves superior memory" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0094", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0139", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "REACQUISITION", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0179", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INFORMATION_HARM", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0208", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0262", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain evidence, measurement, task specificity, accessible alternatives and negative findings; no dose prescription or performance promise." ], "site_summary": "Episodic memory can improve for selected material, but stronger recall is not the same as a perfectly accurate record of the past.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock photographic memory", "metric": "Accuracy, false alarms and confidence for declared material after a declared delay", "boundary": "No laboratory score proves complete or historically infallible autobiographical memory." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-106", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Semantic memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express semantic memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured retrieval can strengthen retention of selected facts and concepts, including for older learners.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare content validity, language, prior knowledge, cueing, error correction, delay, application test and assistance; factual recall does not establish judgment.", "negative_findings": [ "No retrieval schedule was universally best across delays.", "Remembering medication facts did not establish safe prescribing or clinical competence." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "download knowledge", "learn anything instantly", "unlimited knowledge", "memory score proves expertise" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0118", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0184", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SELF_REGULATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0266", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain evidence, measurement, task specificity, accessible alternatives and negative findings; no dose prescription or performance promise." ], "site_summary": "People can strengthen selected knowledge through retrieval, but remembering a fact is not the same as applying it well.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Download expert knowledge", "metric": "Accurate recall and appropriate application of declared content after delay", "boundary": "Retention of facts does not prove expertise, wisdom or transfer to unrelated domains." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-107", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Procedural learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express procedural learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can acquire and retain specified procedures through structured practice, with outcomes bound to the procedure and context.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare procedural steps, errors, timing, assistance, scenario fidelity, delay and live-function endpoint; speed alone is not competence.", "negative_findings": [ "Sleep did not produce automatic offline enhancement after stronger controls.", "Simulated resuscitation performance did not establish live patient benefit." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "muscle memory never forgets", "master any procedure automatically", "simulation proves field competence", "practice makes permanent" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0024", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0101", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0119", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0363", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INTERFERENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Procedures can become more reliable through practice, but simulation success is not automatic real-world competence.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Install perfect muscle memory", "metric": "Accurate, safe completion of a declared procedure after delay", "boundary": "Fluent repetition cannot certify judgment, field transfer or authorization." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-108", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Motor learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express motor learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Motor skills can improve through structured practice, while retention and interference depend on task timing and configuration.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare movement, accuracy, variability, speed, effort, pain, fatigue, device/support, delay and novel-task transfer; faster is not automatically safer.", "negative_findings": [ "Controlled experiments did not support automatic sleep enhancement of motor-sequence learning.", "Closely timed tasks produced interference rather than unlimited accelerated learning." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "rewire movement overnight", "sleep installs motor skill", "practice through pain", "one drill improves every movement" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0024", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0119", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0363", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INTERFERENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Movement skills can be learned, retained and also disrupted by competing practice—so the exact task and schedule matter.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Rewire any movement overnight", "metric": "Accuracy, variability and safety on a declared movement after delay and on a novel task", "boundary": "One motor-sequence gain does not prove universal athletic, occupational or rehabilitation transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-109", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Perceptual learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express perceptual learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected perceptual performance can improve through task-specific practice, with some retained transfer in a small clinical sample.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare sensory modality, diagnosis, stimulus, threshold, eye/device, error, fatigue, delay and functional task; a threshold change is not whole-sense restoration.", "negative_findings": [ "The clinical study was extremely small and diagnosis-specific.", "Independent experiments found practice effects contingent on stimulus direction, velocity or line length.", "Neither source establishes restored normal vision, broad perceptual enhancement or generalized daily function." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "eagle eyesight", "restore normal vision", "unlock super senses", "train away sensory disability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0376", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0413", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TASK_SPECIFICITY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Some perceptual skills can improve with practice, but task gains are not restored vision or universal sensory enhancement.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train eagle-like super-vision", "metric": "Threshold, error and chosen visual function under declared viewing conditions", "boundary": "A trained visual task cannot establish normal vision or a generalized super-sense." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-110", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Accelerated skill acquisition", "definition": "Capability to develop or express accelerated skill acquisition in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some learning configurations improve the rate or efficiency of acquiring a specified skill without implying a universal learning accelerator.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare baseline, criterion, trials/time, errors, coaching, assistance, retention and transfer; time-to-criterion without quality is incomplete.", "negative_findings": [ "No cited intervention accelerated every skill or established far transfer.", "Additional or closely packed training can create interference and cognitive load." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "learn anything ten times faster", "hack neuroplasticity", "instant mastery", "AI makes expertise effortless" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0094", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0101", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0184", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SELF_REGULATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0262", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0266", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0363", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INTERFERENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain evidence, measurement, task specificity, accessible alternatives and negative findings; no dose prescription or performance promise." ], "site_summary": "Learning can sometimes be made more efficient—but there is no universal shortcut to mastery.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Learn anything ten times faster", "metric": "Time or trials to a declared performance criterion, plus delayed retention and transfer", "boundary": "A faster task score does not prove universal acceleration, mastery or wellbeing." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-111", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Long-term retention", "definition": "Capability to develop or express long-term retention in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some learning methods improve delayed retention for specified material or skills, and the delay and testing conditions must be stated.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare interval, maintenance practice, cues, assistance, attrition, accuracy, errors and transfer task; repeated exposure is not unaided retention.", "negative_findings": [ "The best retrieval schedule changed with the test delay.", "Sleep protected some motor performance but did not automatically enhance learning." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "never forget", "permanent learning", "one session lasts forever", "retention score proves transfer" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0024", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0094", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0101", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0118", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0119", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0184", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SELF_REGULATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0208", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0262", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0376", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain evidence, measurement, task specificity, accessible alternatives and negative findings; no dose prescription or performance promise." ], "site_summary": "What matters is not only learning today, but what remains available later—under clearly stated conditions.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Make learning permanent", "metric": "Performance after a predeclared delay with maintenance and assistance declared", "boundary": "A delayed test cannot by itself establish lifelong memory or transfer." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-112", "family_id": "FAM-14", "family": "Memory, Learning & Skill Acquisition", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Reacquisition and reconsolidation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express reacquisition and reconsolidation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Previously learned associations may sometimes be relearned more efficiently, while strong human reconsolidation-update claims remain conflicting.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate reacquisition rate from reconsolidation mechanism; declare conditioning, retrieval timing, errors, physiological measure, follow-up and clinical relevance.", "negative_findings": [ "A high-powered registered replication found no persistent reactivation-extinction advantage.", "Suggestive interviewing can create confident reports of fabricated events." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "rewrite traumatic memories", "erase fear", "recover true hidden memories", "reprogram the past" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0066", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "REPLICATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0131", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RECONSOLIDATION_HYPOTHESIS" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0139", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "REACQUISITION", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0179", "source_alias_ids": [ "F14-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INFORMATION_HARM", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Relearning is real; claims that memories can be safely rewritten or erased are not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Rewrite or erase a memory", "metric": "Reacquisition rate and predeclared return-of-response measures after delay", "boundary": "Laboratory conditioning cannot establish trauma-memory erasure, historical truth or clinical benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-113", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Deductive reasoning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express deductive reasoning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Deductive reasoning on specified problems may improve with structured practice, but the active-control advantage and durable transfer remain uncertain.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare formalism, language, item novelty, active control, response accuracy, explanation, delay and transfer domain; one task is not general rationality.", "negative_findings": [ "The training app did not outperform its active control.", "Abstract logic principles alone had little effect unless mapping to concrete examples was made available.", "Neither source tested durable retention or consequential real-world transfer." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "become perfectly logical", "logic app raises intelligence", "never make a reasoning error", "deductive score proves rationality" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0044", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTEXT_SPECIFICITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0392", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded tasks, structured reflection, declared tools and verification; no operational high-stakes decision rule." ], "site_summary": "Deductive reasoning can be practiced, but one logic app or test cannot certify a generally rational mind.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become perfectly logical", "metric": "Accuracy and explanation on predeclared novel deduction problems after delay", "boundary": "A logic-task gain does not prove global intelligence or better high-stakes decisions." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-114", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Inductive inference", "definition": "Capability to develop or express inductive inference in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Targeted inductive-reasoning training produced durable task gains in older adults, with limited evidence of everyday functional benefit.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare inference domain, item novelty, baseline cognition, sensory/language access, delay and functional tasks; trained test performance is not diagnosis or prevention.", "negative_findings": [ "Objective functional transfer in ACTIVE was not uniform.", "A large independent online trial found trained-task improvement without transfer to untrained tasks.", "Neither study establishes dementia prevention or general reasoning enhancement." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "reverse cognitive ageing", "raise general intelligence", "prevent dementia", "pattern training transfers everywhere" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0007", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0132", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINED_TASK_IMPROVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded tasks, structured reflection, declared tools and verification; no operational high-stakes decision rule." ], "site_summary": "Inductive reasoning can remain improved for years after targeted training, but everyday transfer is limited and uneven.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Reverse cognitive ageing with pattern drills", "metric": "Accuracy on novel inductive problems and objective chosen functions after delay", "boundary": "Durable task gains do not prove dementia prevention or general intelligence." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-115", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Probabilistic reasoning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express probabilistic reasoning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Probabilistic reasoning can improve through representation training and configured forecasting practice, with gains bound to problem form and system design.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare event set, base rates, elicitation format, calibration, resolution, scoring rule, aggregation, missing outcomes and decision consequences.", "negative_findings": [ "Frequency format did not add the expected benefit after nested-set training.", "Tournament performance intertwined training, teams, aggregation, selection and attrition." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "predict the future", "become a human probability engine", "Bayesian training eliminates uncertainty", "forecast score proves wisdom" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0127", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0188", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded tasks, structured reflection, declared tools and verification; no operational high-stakes decision rule." ], "site_summary": "Probability judgment can improve—but only when the questions, outcomes, scoring and support system are made explicit.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Predict the future with certainty", "metric": "Calibration, resolution and proper score on a predeclared event set", "boundary": "Good forecasts in one domain do not establish foresight, certainty or safe high-stakes authority." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-116", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Causal reasoning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express causal reasoning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Instruction can reduce selected causal-reasoning errors in science-report interpretation, with short delayed retention.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare causal question, design, alternatives, confounding, mechanism, uncertainty, data limits and decision context; diagram quality is not causal truth.", "negative_findings": [ "Evidence remains bounded to science-report and control-of-variables tasks.", "Probe questions without direct instruction did not improve children’s unconfounded experimental reasoning.", "No real policy, clinical or organizational outcome was tested." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "see the true cause of anything", "causal training proves expertise", "correlation never matters", "one diagram explains a social system" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0229", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AGE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0336", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded tasks, structured reflection, declared tools and verification; no operational high-stakes decision rule." ], "site_summary": "Causal reasoning can be improved for selected errors, but no short course reveals the true cause of every complex event.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See the true cause of anything", "metric": "Accurate causal classification and alternative-cause generation on novel declared cases", "boundary": "A training-task gain cannot certify causality in a complex real system." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-117", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Systems thinking", "definition": "Capability to develop or express systems thinking in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Systems-thinking tools can help people and communities represent relationships, but training and transfer evidence is mixed.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare map boundary, participants, missing voices, evidence for links, uncertainty, simulation assumptions, decision and observed outcomes; complexity is not validity.", "negative_findings": [ "Explicit systems-thinking material did not show the expected main effect in one experiment.", "Combining simulation and instruction could increase cognitive load and reduce performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "see the whole system", "solve complexity", "map proves causation", "digital twin predicts society" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0220", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "IMPLEMENTATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0410", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COGNITIVE_LOAD", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Systems maps can make relationships visible—but they are models with boundaries, not the whole world.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See and control the whole system", "metric": "Model accuracy, stakeholder coverage, decision trace and observed outcome under declared assumptions", "boundary": "A complex map or simulation cannot prove causal completeness or guarantee outcomes." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-118", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Expert judgement", "definition": "Capability to develop or express expert judgement in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Expert judgment can be assessed and sometimes improved within a defined domain, feedback environment and accountable decision system.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare domain, case mix, outcome delay, base rates, calibration, discrimination, conflicts, AI/version, overrides and appeals; credentials and confidence are not outcome accuracy.", "negative_findings": [ "Confidence and eloquence can increase persuasion independently of forecast accuracy.", "Incorrect AI advice reduced human accuracy, and interface protections were incomplete and configuration-specific." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "expert intuition is always right", "debias the expert", "AI plus expert cannot fail", "one score identifies the best decision-maker" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0127", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRADEOFF", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0298", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INFORMATION_HARM", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0322", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0337", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "ORDER_EFFECT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Expert judgment is real but conditional: accuracy, calibration, domain, incentives and tools all matter.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Expert intuition never fails", "metric": "Calibration, discrimination and consequential outcomes on a declared case set", "boundary": "Credentials, eloquence or one domain score cannot certify universal judgment." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-119", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Decision under uncertainty", "definition": "Capability to develop or express decision under uncertainty in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected components of decision-making under uncertainty can improve, but outcomes depend on the person, information, values, interface, institution and stakes.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare options, values, probabilities, data, AI/version, timing, incentives, affected groups, process, outcome and appeal; accuracy is not the only legitimate value.", "negative_findings": [ "Incorrect AI advice reduced accuracy even in human-in-the-loop designs.", "A human-first interface reduced but did not eliminate AI influence, and one forcing design reduced usability." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "make the optimal decision every time", "remove uncertainty", "trust the algorithm", "decision score overrides lived experience" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0093", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0127", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRADEOFF", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0322", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0337", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_FINDING", "ORDER_EFFECT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Good decisions under uncertainty are built by a configured system—not by confidence, a single formula or an AI answer.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Always choose the optimal answer", "metric": "Decision process, calibration, value alignment, harms and outcomes under declared uncertainty", "boundary": "No laboratory task or model output can determine universally correct high-stakes choices." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-120", "family_id": "FAM-15", "family": "Reasoning, Judgement & Strategy", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Strategic planning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express strategic planning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Teams and leaders can improve selected planning processes, while durable strategic capability and causal impact remain context-specific.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare goal legitimacy, assumptions, dependencies, resources, contingencies, execution trace, adaptation, outcomes, harms and affected groups; plan quality is not success.", "negative_findings": [ "Only 58.8% of local simulation goals were achieved.", "Goal achievement was not associated with knowledge, self-efficacy or teamwork scores." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "master strategy", "guarantee execution", "outthink any opponent", "AI writes the winning plan" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0093", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0325", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "IMPLEMENTATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F15-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A plan is not a capability until people can execute, adapt and learn from it under real constraints.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Write the winning master plan", "metric": "Goal attainment, adaptation quality, harms and resource use under declared constraints", "boundary": "A persuasive plan or simulation cannot guarantee execution, legitimacy or outcomes." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-121", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Confidence calibration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express confidence calibration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Confidence can be scored against outcomes, but scalable calibration training has conflicting task-dependent evidence.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare question class, resolution rules, probability scale, calibration, resolution, base rate, scoring, sample size and missing outcomes; average confidence is not calibration.", "negative_findings": [ "Practical-scoring feedback failed in two large experiments.", "Automated feedback improved calibration in modified blackjack but not overall calibration in a more realistic baseball task." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "always know what you do not know", "eliminate overconfidence", "calibration score proves wisdom", "AI gives objective confidence" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0010", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0013", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "NULL_FINDING", "REPLICATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "ERROR_DETECTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRADEOFF" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded verification and communication principles using benign examples; no realistic misinformation-generation or surveillance protocol." ], "site_summary": "Calibration means matching confidence to outcomes—not simply becoming less confident.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Always know exactly how sure to be", "metric": "Calibration and resolution over a predeclared set of resolved judgments", "boundary": "Good calibration in one question class does not prove wisdom or transfer to another." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-122", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Error detection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express error detection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected interfaces can reduce specific human–AI and rare-target errors, but this is configured system performance rather than a universal human faculty.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare error taxonomy, prevalence, base rate, false alarms, misses, correction path, model/version, workload and consequences; high accuracy can hide rare catastrophic misses.", "negative_findings": [ "Very rare targets produced high miss rates despite extensive task exposure.", "Cognitive forcing reduced overreliance but lowered user ratings and varied across people." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "spot every mistake", "human lie detector", "AI-proof your mind", "error score identifies careless people" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0238", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INTERFACE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_CONFIGURATION", "ERROR_DETECTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRADEOFF" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0307", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Error detection improves when people and interfaces are designed together—but rare mistakes remain easy to miss.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Spot every hidden error", "metric": "Miss rate, false-alarm rate, time to correction and harm under declared prevalence", "boundary": "One detection task cannot establish universal vigilance, honesty detection or safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-123", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Bias resistance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express bias resistance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Brief prompts and transparent games can reduce selected misinformation-related errors, but they do not create general immunity to bias.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare bias/error type, content, ground truth, item novelty, intention versus behavior, delay, false positives and political/cultural context.", "negative_findings": [ "Most accuracy-prompt outcomes were sharing intentions rather than observed long-term behavior.", "Inoculation estimates were sensitive to the examples used." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "become immune to misinformation", "remove cognitive bias", "mental vaccine", "program people against wrong beliefs" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0134", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BEHAVIORAL_INTENTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "REPLICATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0294", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ITEM_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "REPLICATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0421", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "IMMEDIATE_TRANSFER", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can become better at spotting selected manipulation techniques—but nobody becomes immune to misinformation.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Vaccinate the mind against misinformation", "metric": "Accuracy, false positives and observed behavior on novel benign items after delay", "boundary": "A prompt or game cannot create general immunity, political correctness or permanent resistance." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-124", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Source evaluation and lateral reading", "definition": "Capability to develop or express source evaluation and lateral reading in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Lateral reading and deliberate source checking can improve selected credibility judgments, with small and not uniformly retained effects.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare claim, source chain, search environment, language, access barriers, independent corroboration, time, accuracy and delayed novel-item test.", "negative_findings": [ "Many intervention estimates were null at two weeks.", "No between-intervention advantage was detected at follow-up." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "instantly know what is true", "Google it and verify anything", "become scam-proof", "source score proves credibility" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0134", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BEHAVIORAL_INTENTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "REPLICATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0312", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded verification and communication principles using benign examples; no realistic misinformation-generation or surveillance protocol." ], "site_summary": "Source checking can be learned, but search access, language, platform design and time shape what is possible.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Know instantly whether anything online is true", "metric": "Accurate source/provenance judgments on novel claims with search path declared", "boundary": "One checklist, search result or AI citation cannot certify truth or make someone scam-proof." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-125", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Anomaly detection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express anomaly detection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Rare anomalies are systematically easy to miss, and selected interface designs can reduce misses in bounded search tasks.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare target definition/prevalence, misses, false alarms, search time, fatigue, correction interface, ground truth and downstream escalation.", "negative_findings": [ "Millions of game trials still showed very high miss rates for ultra-rare targets.", "Correction benefits were interface-dependent and not validated in professional field settings." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "spot the invisible pattern", "never miss a threat", "superhuman vigilance", "anomaly score proves expert inspection" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0238", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INTERFACE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0307", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "MEASUREMENT_BOUNDARY", "NEGATIVE_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "The rarer the target, the easier it can be to miss—even for experienced searchers.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Never miss a hidden threat", "metric": "Miss and false-alarm rates at declared target prevalence under realistic workload", "boundary": "A game or lab search cannot certify professional detection, intuition or public safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-126", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Uncertainty communication", "definition": "Capability to develop or express uncertainty communication in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Numeric uncertainty can often be communicated without large trust loss, while wording and cultural context materially affect reception.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare uncertainty type, format, source, audience, language, comprehension, trust, decision and equity; trust is not the sole success criterion.", "negative_findings": [ "Vague verbal uncertainty could reduce trust.", "Effects differed by country, source and topic, and comprehension/decision quality were not always established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "one perfect uncertainty phrase", "numbers make communication objective", "trust proves understanding", "AI can calibrate any message automatically" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0166", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMMUNICATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0223", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMMUNICATION", "CROSS_CULTURAL", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded verification and communication principles using benign examples; no realistic misinformation-generation or surveillance protocol." ], "site_summary": "Uncertainty can be communicated honestly without automatically destroying trust—but format and audience matter.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Use the perfect phrase and everyone will understand risk", "metric": "Comprehension, calibrated trust and decision quality for a declared uncertainty message", "boundary": "A trusted message is not necessarily understood, accurate, fair or actionable." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-127", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Belief updating", "definition": "Capability to develop or express belief updating in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Corrections can improve accuracy for targeted false claims across countries, but effects on attitudes, intentions and lasting behavior are limited and inconsistent.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare claim, prior belief, evidence/source, correction, confidence, delay, attitudes, intentions, behavior and autonomy; movement toward authority is not automatically accuracy.", "negative_findings": [ "A large vaccine-misinformation correction changed accuracy only slightly and did not change attitudes or intentions.", "Two-week persistence in that study was uncertain." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "change anyone’s mind", "correct beliefs permanently", "facts automatically change behavior", "belief update score identifies irrational people" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0169", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BELIEF_UPDATE", "CROSS_CULTURAL", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0222", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BELIEF_UPDATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FUNCTIONAL_FINDING", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0475", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_GOVERNANCE", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Facts can shift specific beliefs, but changing a belief does not automatically change an attitude, intention or action.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Change anyone’s mind with the right facts", "metric": "Appropriate confidence change after verified evidence, plus delayed behavior where relevant", "boundary": "Belief movement does not prove coercive success, durable action or universal agreement." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-128", "family_id": "FAM-16", "family": "Metacognition & Epistemic Resilience", "superdomain": "Cognition & Learning", "power": "Epistemic humility", "definition": "Capability to develop or express epistemic humility in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Brief interventions and affiliated conversations can increase selected topic-specific humility measures, but broad behavior change is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare topic, self-report versus behavior, accuracy, power relation, affiliation, dissent, delay and willingness to revise; lower confidence is not automatically humility.", "negative_findings": [ "The intervention did not increase engagement with diverse viewpoints.", "General humility and self-rated knowledge effects were inconsistent, and conversation results relied on self-report and affiliation." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "become ego-free", "humility score proves wisdom", "make opponents open-minded", "doubt yourself more" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0011", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "REPLICATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0319", "source_alias_ids": [ "F16-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SOCIAL_CONFIGURATION" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded verification and communication principles using benign examples; no realistic misinformation-generation or surveillance protocol." ], "site_summary": "Intellectual humility can grow in specific contexts—but it is not self-erasure, indecision or obedience.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become ego-free and always open-minded", "metric": "Accuracy-sensitive revision, expressed uncertainty and behavioral engagement on declared topics", "boundary": "Lower confidence or polite language cannot prove wisdom, fairness or genuine openness." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-129", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Divergent ideation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express divergent ideation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected strategies can improve some components of divergent ideation on defined tasks, but not necessarily originality or unfamiliar-task performance.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclared counts plus independent novelty, diversity and usefulness ratings on practised and unfamiliar briefs. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "Fluency/flexibility gains occurred without originality gains, and one semantic strategy did not improve alternate divergent tasks.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Unlock unlimited creativity", "Prove that a person is creative", "More ideas always means better ideas" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0185", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_TRANSFER", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0234", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "OBJECTIVE_VS_JUDGED_OUTCOME", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Selected strategies can improve some components of divergent ideation on defined tasks, but not necessarily originality or unfamiliar-task performance.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A creativity switch produces endless original ideas", "metric": "Predeclared counts plus independent novelty, diversity and usefulness ratings on practised and unfamiliar briefs", "boundary": "Predeclared counts plus independent novelty, diversity and usefulness ratings on practised and unfamiliar briefs. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-130", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Convergent synthesis", "definition": "Capability to develop or express convergent synthesis in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Convergent synthesis can be measured as selection and integration under declared constraints; a reliable general training route is not yet established.", "measurement_boundary": "Constraint satisfaction, feasibility, error, independent usefulness and rationale quality on a preregistered task. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "Brief mindfulness did not improve the convergent rebus outcome, and opening plus closing behaviour was not universally superior.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Mindfulness makes anyone an inventor", "One best thinking style fits every innovation phase", "A high score proves sound judgement" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0151", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSTRUCT_VALIDITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0389", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION_INTERACTION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0405", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Convergent synthesis can be measured as selection and integration under declared constraints; a reliable general training route is not yet established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A universal genius mode instantly finds the one right answer", "metric": "Constraint satisfaction, feasibility, error, independent usefulness and rationale quality on a preregistered task", "boundary": "Constraint satisfaction, feasibility, error, independent usefulness and rationale quality on a preregistered task. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-131", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Analogical transfer", "definition": "Capability to develop or express analogical transfer in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured comparison of multiple cases can improve transfer of a shared principle to some new problems.", "measurement_boundary": "Correct relational mapping, mismatch detection and solution success on a predeclared structurally related unfamiliar problem. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "One-example and surface-cue conditions frequently failed to produce spontaneous transfer.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Analogies prove that two situations are the same", "One example teaches a universal rule", "Analogical skill replaces domain expertise" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0043", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_CONDITIONS", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0414", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Structured comparison of multiple cases can improve transfer of a shared principle to some new problems.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A master analogy reveals hidden truth in any domain", "metric": "Correct relational mapping, mismatch detection and solution success on a predeclared structurally related unfamiliar problem", "boundary": "Correct relational mapping, mismatch detection and solution success on a predeclared structurally related unfamiliar problem. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-132", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Conceptual blending", "definition": "Capability to develop or express conceptual blending in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Conceptual combinations can be generated and evaluated on declared tasks; general trainability and real invention transfer remain unproven.", "measurement_boundary": "Independent novelty, coherence, feasibility, provenance and user-value ratings on a constrained blend task. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "Analogy prompts did not reliably trigger transfer, and the Fusion Innovation Test is measurement evidence rather than acquisition evidence.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Mixing any two ideas creates innovation", "AI-generated blends are automatically the user's authorship", "Novelty alone establishes value" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0043", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_CONDITIONS", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0151", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSTRUCT_VALIDITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Conceptual combinations can be generated and evaluated on declared tasks; general trainability and real invention transfer remain unproven.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Combining concepts automatically creates a breakthrough", "metric": "Independent novelty, coherence, feasibility, provenance and user-value ratings on a constrained blend task", "boundary": "Independent novelty, coherence, feasibility, provenance and user-value ratings on a constrained blend task. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-133", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Design thinking", "definition": "Capability to develop or express design thinking in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Design practice involves separable divergent and convergent performances, but current cross-sectional evidence does not prove a general design-thinking training effect.", "measurement_boundary": "Independent user-defined utility, accessibility, constraint satisfaction, iteration quality and harm findings from a declared design brief. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "More design exposure coincided with stronger divergent but not convergent performance; causality was not established.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Design thinking guarantees innovation", "A workshop makes anyone a designer", "User empathy can be inferred without user participation" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0390", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NONCAUSAL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Design practice involves separable divergent and convergent performances, but current cross-sectional evidence does not prove a general design-thinking training effect.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A branded workshop turns every problem into an innovation", "metric": "Independent user-defined utility, accessibility, constraint satisfaction, iteration quality and harm findings from a declared design brief", "boundary": "Independent user-defined utility, accessibility, constraint satisfaction, iteration quality and harm findings from a declared design brief. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-134", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Scientific hypothesis generation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express scientific hypothesis generation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Practice may improve hypothesis generation on a defined task; scientific discovery, calibration and cross-domain transfer remain unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Number of distinct falsifiable hypotheses, calibration, prior plausibility, ethical testability and independent domain-expert rating. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "No active comparator, delayed retention, cross-domain transfer or real discovery endpoint was established.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Brain activation proves scientific talent", "More hypotheses means better science", "A hypothesis-generation exercise authorises research on people" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0056", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Practice may improve hypothesis generation on a defined task; scientific discovery, calibration and cross-domain transfer remain unestablished.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A trained brain can generate scientific breakthroughs on demand", "metric": "Number of distinct falsifiable hypotheses, calibration, prior plausibility, ethical testability and independent domain-expert rating", "boundary": "Number of distinct falsifiable hypotheses, calibration, prior plausibility, ethical testability and independent domain-expert rating. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-135", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Improvisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express improvisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Improvisation activities can be delivered accessibly and may change selected self-reports; performance, retention and professional transfer remain open.", "measurement_boundary": "Blinded task-appropriate ratings of responsiveness, constraint adherence, partner support and recovery from error on unfamiliar scenarios. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "The trial did not measure observed improvisation, delayed retention, clinical behaviour or patient outcomes.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Improv creates empathy", "Spontaneity proves social competence", "Participants must disclose or perform vulnerability" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0330", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SELF_REPORT_BOUNDARY", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Improvisation activities can be delivered accessibly and may change selected self-reports; performance, retention and professional transfer remain open.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Thinking instantly on your feet is a universal social superpower", "metric": "Blinded task-appropriate ratings of responsiveness, constraint adherence, partner support and recovery from error on unfamiliar scenarios", "boundary": "Blinded task-appropriate ratings of responsiveness, constraint adherence, partner support and recovery from error on unfamiliar scenarios. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-136", "family_id": "FAM-17", "family": "Creativity, Discovery & Invention", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Iterative invention", "definition": "Capability to develop or express iterative invention in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Iterative invention can be decomposed into measurable generation, selection and revision stages, but a general trainable capability is not yet established.", "measurement_boundary": "Independent improvement in user-defined value, feasibility, safety, originality and error correction across versioned artefacts. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "Available sources do not isolate acquisition, retention or real-world invention, and no single opening/closing pattern worked universally.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Iteration guarantees invention", "More versions mean more progress", "AI output is proof of the user's independent capability" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0151", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSTRUCT_VALIDITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0389", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION_INTERACTION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0445", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTHORSHIP", "COPYRIGHT", "DISCLOSURE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F17-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Iterative invention can be decomposed into measurable generation, selection and revision stages, but a general trainable capability is not yet established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Endless iteration inevitably creates a world-changing invention", "metric": "Independent improvement in user-defined value, feasibility, safety, originality and error correction across versioned artefacts", "boundary": "Independent improvement in user-defined value, feasibility, safety, originality and error correction across versioned artefacts. Judge scores reflect a declared rubric and audience, not an objective universal essence of creativity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-137", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Multilingual comprehension", "definition": "Capability to develop or express multilingual comprehension in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can develop measurable components of additional-language comprehension, with some retained near transfer; whole-language proficiency requires broader criterion assessment.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclared criterion performance in reception, interaction and mediation across familiar and unfamiliar speakers/signers and contexts. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Phonetic transfer remained talker- and contrast-specific, and criterion frameworks do not themselves prove a training effect.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become fluent instantly", "One accent is the correct measure of language ability", "Sign language is a substitute for spoken language" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0257", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRITION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_SPECIFICITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0258", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "SMALL_SAMPLE", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0432", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0444", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can develop measurable components of additional-language comprehension, with some retained near transfer; whole-language proficiency requires broader criterion assessment.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A trick unlocks effortless universal fluency", "metric": "Predeclared criterion performance in reception, interaction and mediation across familiar and unfamiliar speakers/signers and contexts", "boundary": "Predeclared criterion performance in reception, interaction and mediation across familiar and unfamiliar speakers/signers and contexts. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-138", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Rapid language learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express rapid language learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Training schedule and stimulus variability can affect the rate and retention of selected language components; no universal rapid-language method is established.", "measurement_boundary": "Time and trials to a predeclared accuracy criterion plus delayed retention and unfamiliar-context performance. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Schedule advantage depended on initial learning dose, and phonetic gains did not equal full language acquisition.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Fluency in days", "A single schedule is fastest for everyone", "Slow acquisition means low capability" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0257", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRITION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_SPECIFICITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0258", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "SMALL_SAMPLE", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0416", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DOSE_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Training schedule and stimulus variability can affect the rate and retention of selected language components; no universal rapid-language method is established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "One accelerated method makes anyone fluent at superhuman speed", "metric": "Time and trials to a predeclared accuracy criterion plus delayed retention and unfamiliar-context performance", "boundary": "Time and trials to a predeclared accuracy criterion plus delayed retention and unfamiliar-context performance. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-139", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Verbal fluency", "definition": "Capability to develop or express verbal fluency in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Components that support fluent communication can improve, but fluency is mode-, language- and task-specific and is not synonymous with speaking speed.", "measurement_boundary": "Accuracy, comprehensibility, repair, turn completion and audience understanding in the declared communication mode. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Vocabulary and sound-task gains do not establish spontaneous discourse, and effective aids differ by person and context.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Fast speech proves intelligence", "Accent removal is capability", "AAC or interpreted communication is inferior" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0257", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRITION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_SPECIFICITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0258", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER", "RETENTION", "SMALL_SAMPLE", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0416", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DOSE_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0432", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0444", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Components that support fluent communication can improve, but fluency is mode-, language- and task-specific and is not synonymous with speaking speed.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "True fluency means speaking instantly and flawlessly", "metric": "Accuracy, comprehensibility, repair, turn completion and audience understanding in the declared communication mode", "boundary": "Accuracy, comprehensibility, repair, turn completion and audience understanding in the declared communication mode. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-140", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Persuasive communication", "definition": "Capability to develop or express persuasive communication in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Persuasive effects exist, but they are context-sensitive and can be unrelated to accuracy; Titan does not teach coercive or deceptive influence.", "measurement_boundary": "Comprehension, factual accuracy, calibrated trust, voluntary choice, reversibility and attitude change reported separately. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Eye contact increased resistance in a tested context, while confident/eloquent forecasts could persuade without being more accurate.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Make anyone say yes", "Eye contact guarantees persuasion", "Confidence proves truth", "Exploit cognitive bias or vulnerability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0298", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCURACY_DECOUPLING", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0306", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTEXT_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0462", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COERCION_BOUNDARY", "CONSENT", "HIGH_STAKES_GOVERNANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Persuasive effects exist, but they are context-sensitive and can be unrelated to accuracy; Titan does not teach coercive or deceptive influence.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A persuasion technique can control any mind", "metric": "Comprehension, factual accuracy, calibrated trust, voluntary choice, reversibility and attitude change reported separately", "boundary": "Comprehension, factual accuracy, calibrated trust, voluntary choice, reversibility and attitude change reported separately. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-141", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Explanatory clarity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express explanatory clarity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Teach-back can help test and improve understanding in configured settings, with limited evidence of one-month knowledge retention.", "measurement_boundary": "Accurate audience teach-back, error detection, action demonstration and delayed understanding using accessible mode. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "The trial did not establish broad behaviour or cross-domain transfer and applied language eligibility restrictions.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "If they repeat it, they fully understand", "Simple language replaces informed consent", "Teach-back tests intelligence or memory" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0326", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LANGUAGE_ACCESS_LIMIT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0432", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0433", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPREHENSION_CHECK", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HIGH_STAKES_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Teach-back can help test and improve understanding in configured settings, with limited evidence of one-month knowledge retention.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A gifted explainer can make anyone understand anything once", "metric": "Accurate audience teach-back, error detection, action demonstration and delayed understanding using accessible mode", "boundary": "Accurate audience teach-back, error detection, action demonstration and delayed understanding using accessible mode. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-142", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Negotiation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express negotiation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Comparing structurally related cases can improve transfer of a negotiation principle in bounded simulations.", "measurement_boundary": "Joint value, error, fairness, informed consent, reversibility and outcome durability under declared alternatives and power. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Evidence concerns near structural transfer and does not establish durable mastery, fair outcomes or high-stakes competence.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Always win any negotiation", "Pressure is persuasion", "Agreement proves fairness", "Use asymmetry or disability to gain compliance" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0414", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0462", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COERCION_BOUNDARY", "CONSENT", "HIGH_STAKES_GOVERNANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Comparing structurally related cases can improve transfer of a negotiation principle in bounded simulations.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A master negotiator can make anyone accept any deal", "metric": "Joint value, error, fairness, informed consent, reversibility and outcome durability under declared alternatives and power", "boundary": "Joint value, error, fairness, informed consent, reversibility and outcome durability under declared alternatives and power. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-143", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Nonverbal communication", "definition": "Capability to develop or express nonverbal communication in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Nonverbal effects exist but are culturally and contextually variable; no universal body-language code is supported.", "measurement_boundary": "Context-specific communication accuracy, partner understanding and repair—not inferred private mental state. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Vocal-emotion perception was culturally relative, and greater eye contact increased rather than reduced resistance in one persuasion context.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Read anyone like a book", "Eye contact proves honesty", "A facial or vocal cue diagnoses emotion", "Require normative gaze" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0306", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTEXT_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0308", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_VARIABILITY", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0432", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Nonverbal effects exist but are culturally and contextually variable; no universal body-language code is supported.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Body language exposes every hidden thought", "metric": "Context-specific communication accuracy, partner understanding and repair—not inferred private mental state", "boundary": "Context-specific communication accuracy, partner understanding and repair—not inferred private mental state. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-144", "family_id": "FAM-18", "family": "Language, Explanation & Persuasion", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "High-stakes communication", "definition": "Capability to develop or express high-stakes communication in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Brief training can improve selected behaviours in a high-stakes simulation; real-world retention, transfer and outcomes remain unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Observed accuracy, comprehension, emotional safety, escalation, decision error and follow-through in role-specific simulation and practice. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "The randomised study did not establish patient outcomes or workplace transfer; remote interpretation is not effective in every configuration.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "This tutorial qualifies you to break bad news", "Calm delivery guarantees safety", "A family member can always interpret", "Communication skill replaces escalation" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0097", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_REAL_WORLD_TRANSFER", "SIMULATION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0432", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESSIBILITY", "ASSISTANCE_CONFIGURATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIGN_LANGUAGE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0433", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COMPREHENSION_CHECK", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HIGH_STAKES_BOUNDARY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0462", "source_alias_ids": [ "F18-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COERCION_BOUNDARY", "CONSENT", "HIGH_STAKES_GOVERNANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Brief training can improve selected behaviours in a high-stakes simulation; real-world retention, transfer and outcomes remain unestablished.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A script makes anyone flawless in a crisis conversation", "metric": "Observed accuracy, comprehension, emotional safety, escalation, decision error and follow-through in role-specific simulation and practice", "boundary": "Observed accuracy, comprehension, emotional safety, escalation, decision error and follow-through in role-specific simulation and practice. Audience change does not establish truth, consent, professional competence or ethical legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-145", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Pitch control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express pitch control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Pitch control and pitch-category performance can improve for some learners on defined tasks; perfect or universal pitch is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Cents error, stability, correction latency and task-appropriate independent judgement with feedback configuration declared. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "Only a subset reached the adult study criterion, the design lacked a fully comparable active control, and multimodal training did not isolate its pitch component.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Anyone can gain perfect pitch", "One tuning system defines musical ability", "Pitch accuracy alone proves singing talent" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0246", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0255", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "EXPERIENCE_ASSOCIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NONCAUSAL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0415", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESPONDER_VARIATION", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pitch control and pitch-category performance can improve for some learners on defined tasks; perfect or universal pitch is not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Perfect pitch is a universal musical superpower anyone can unlock", "metric": "Cents error, stability, correction latency and task-appropriate independent judgement with feedback configuration declared", "boundary": "Cents error, stability, correction latency and task-appropriate independent judgement with feedback configuration declared. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-146", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Rhythm synchronisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express rhythm synchronisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected rhythm-perception and synchronisation outcomes are trainable in configured tasks; broad transfer and retention remain limited.", "measurement_boundary": "Asynchrony, variability, phase correction and perceptual accuracy under declared auditory/visual/haptic and individual/group configuration. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "The tapping endpoint showed ceiling limitations, and group/individual and perception/production effects cannot be collapsed.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Never miss a beat", "Perfect synchrony is always desirable", "Movement limitations imply poor rhythm" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0143", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "GROUP_EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PHYSIOLOGICAL_SYNCHRONY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0246", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0321", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CEILING_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Selected rhythm-perception and synchronisation outcomes are trainable in configured tasks; broad transfer and retention remain limited.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Training creates a flawless internal metronome", "metric": "Asynchrony, variability, phase correction and perceptual accuracy under declared auditory/visual/haptic and individual/group configuration", "boundary": "Asynchrony, variability, phase correction and perceptual accuracy under declared auditory/visual/haptic and individual/group configuration. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-147", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Voice projection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express voice projection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some voice-use measures can change with structured exercises, but broad projection and long-term safety require further evidence and qualified oversight.", "measurement_boundary": "Listener intelligibility at distance, calibrated level, effort/symptom report and acoustic measures in the declared room and amplification configuration. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "The randomised trial did not show clear between-group superiority, and cross-sectional range differences do not prove training causation.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Project without limits", "Push through hoarseness", "One exercise treats voice disorders", "Loudness equals authority" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_WITH_HEARING_AND_VOICE_GATES", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0092", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_BETWEEN_GROUP", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0284", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "EXPERIENCE_ASSOCIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NONCAUSAL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0473", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ASSISTIVE_SUPPORT", "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VOCAL_SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Some voice-use measures can change with structured exercises, but broad projection and long-term safety require further evidence and qualified oversight.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A trained voice can fill any room without strain", "metric": "Listener intelligibility at distance, calibrated level, effort/symptom report and acoustic measures in the declared room and amplification configuration", "boundary": "Listener intelligibility at distance, calibrated level, effort/symptom report and acoustic measures in the declared room and amplification configuration. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-148", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Vocal timbre control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express vocal timbre control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Different vocal timbres can involve measurable laryngeal adjustments in selected singers; safe novice trainability is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Acoustic spectrum plus laryngeal/effort and blinded style-appropriate judgement, with symptoms and assistance declared. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "No novice acquisition, delayed retention, cross-style transfer or public-safe protocol was tested.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Reshape your voice instantly", "Force the larynx into a position", "Copy any cultural vocal style without attribution", "Treat dysphonia yourself" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_WITH_HEARING_AND_VOICE_GATES", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0256", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "SPECIALIST_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0473", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ASSISTIVE_SUPPORT", "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VOCAL_SAFETY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Different vocal timbres can involve measurable laryngeal adjustments in selected singers; safe novice trainability is not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Anyone can engineer any voice quality by manipulating the throat", "metric": "Acoustic spectrum plus laryngeal/effort and blinded style-appropriate judgement, with symptoms and assistance declared", "boundary": "Acoustic spectrum plus laryngeal/effort and blinded style-appropriate judgement, with symptoms and assistance declared. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-149", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Polyphonic listening", "definition": "Capability to develop or express polyphonic listening in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Visual cues can assist auditory stream segregation in a defined task; unaided trainability and broad transfer are not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Source-identification accuracy and separation error across declared mixtures, levels and cue-on/off conditions. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "The evidence concerns cue-assisted performance rather than unaided learning and does not establish retention.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Hear every instrument perfectly", "Musicians have universally superior hearing", "Louder practice sharpens listening" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0343", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ASSISTED_CONFIGURATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Visual cues can assist auditory stream segregation in a defined task; unaided trainability and broad transfer are not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Training lets you isolate every sound in any mix", "metric": "Source-identification accuracy and separation error across declared mixtures, levels and cue-on/off conditions", "boundary": "Source-identification accuracy and separation error across declared mixtures, levels and cue-on/off conditions. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-150", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Instrumental coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express instrumental coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured music instruction can develop instrument-specific coordination; broad cognitive or cross-instrument transfer is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Timing, note/gesture accuracy, error recovery and repertoire completion under declared instrument and adaptation configuration. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "Transfer claims exceed the instrumental outcomes, and combined programmes do not isolate individual components.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Playing an instrument makes everyone smarter", "One technique fits every body", "Pain is required for mastery" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0199", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0246", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Structured music instruction can develop instrument-specific coordination; broad cognitive or cross-instrument transfer is not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Instrument practice creates universal brain and motor mastery", "metric": "Timing, note/gesture accuracy, error recovery and repertoire completion under declared instrument and adaptation configuration", "boundary": "Timing, note/gesture accuracy, error recovery and repertoire completion under declared instrument and adaptation configuration. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-151", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Musical improvisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express musical improvisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Musical improvisation exists as measurable real-time performance; distinct trainability, retention and cross-genre transfer remain under-established.", "measurement_boundary": "Constraint adherence, timing, interaction, originality/provenance and blinded style-appropriate ratings reported separately. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "Experience associations are not causal, and the combined child programme cannot isolate improvisation effects.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Improvisation is pure inborn genius", "Brain connectivity proves talent", "Any style is free material to copy", "Improvisation transfers to all creativity" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0246", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COMPARATOR", "COMPONENT_AMBIGUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0364", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM", "NONCAUSAL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Musical improvisation exists as measurable real-time performance; distinct trainability, retention and cross-genre transfer remain under-established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Improvisers create perfect music from nothing", "metric": "Constraint adherence, timing, interaction, originality/provenance and blinded style-appropriate ratings reported separately", "boundary": "Constraint adherence, timing, interaction, originality/provenance and blinded style-appropriate ratings reported separately. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-152", "family_id": "FAM-19", "family": "Music, Voice & Rhythm", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Group entrainment", "definition": "Capability to develop or express group entrainment in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Groups can synchronise during configured musical tasks, but liking, cohesion, physiology and performance are distinct outcomes and durable general training is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Individual and group timing error, leader/follower dynamics, coordination on a novel task, consent and member-level outcomes. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent.", "negative_findings": [ "A liking manipulation did not alter behavioural or perceived synchrony, and short-term triad findings do not prove lasting group capability.", "No evidence supports perfect, limitless or universal performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Music makes any group one mind", "Physiological synchrony proves trust", "Perfect timing proves cohesion", "Require touch or participation" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0143", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "GROUP_EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PHYSIOLOGICAL_SYNCHRONY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0318", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "PERCEPTION_VS_PERFORMANCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0485", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "EXPOSURE_CONFIGURATION", "HEARING_SAFETY", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0491", "source_alias_ids": [ "F19-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ATTRIBUTION", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Groups can synchronise during configured musical tasks, but liking, cohesion, physiology and performance are distinct outcomes and durable general training is not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A rhythm can fuse any group into a single perfectly coordinated mind", "metric": "Individual and group timing error, leader/follower dynamics, coordination on a novel task, consent and member-level outcomes", "boundary": "Individual and group timing error, leader/follower dynamics, coordination on a novel task, consent and member-level outcomes. Acoustic or timing accuracy does not by itself establish artistry, health, transfer or universal talent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-153", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Fine motor precision", "definition": "Capability to develop or express fine motor precision in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can improve fine precision on practiced manual tasks, but gains remain product-, body- and tool-specific and must be balanced against fatigue and pain.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare component size, allowable error, time, force, quality, assistance and fatigue; peg speed or drawing accuracy alone is not universal precision.", "negative_findings": [ "Fine-motor rehabilitation did not clearly improve all disability, daily-function, strength or self-efficacy outcomes, and drawing practice showed limited cognitive transfer." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Develop surgeon hands from drills", "Eliminate tremor through practice", "Precision proves intelligence", "Push through pain for steadier hands" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0033", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0086", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0300", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0314", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Extraordinary precision is real—and deeply specific. A person may improve one manual product without gaining universal “steady hands.”", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build impossibly steady hands", "metric": "Error, quality, time, force and fatigue on a named manual product", "boundary": "One pegboard, drawing or simulator cannot establish universal precision." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-154", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Tool control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express tool control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Control of a specific tool can be learned, retained and sometimes transferred, but poor interface fidelity can produce negative transfer.", "measurement_boundary": "Path, contact force, damage, error, product quality and completion time must be declared together; speed alone is unsafe.", "negative_findings": [ "A haptic VR programme produced worse transfer performance than control on a porcine model." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Master any tool fast", "Simulation certifies competence", "Realistic haptics always help", "Use powered tools to test yourself" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0033", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0183", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0328", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Tools become extensions of skill—but not automatically. The wrong simulator can make later performance worse.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Master every tool by feel", "metric": "Force, path, damage and accepted product on one named tool", "boundary": "Control of one interface cannot certify another or grant a credential." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-155", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Hand–eye coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express hand–eye coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Hand–eye coordination improves on some practiced visual-motor tasks, but controlled findings conflict and transfer follows task similarity.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate visual detection, reaction, trajectory, endpoint error, product damage and assistance; no single composite is a credential.", "negative_findings": [ "A double-blind active-controlled trial found no significant between-group improvement on primary eye–hand outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Unlock perfect hand–eye coordination", "A screen game prepares surgery", "Visual control is superior to tactile control", "Train through blurred vision" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0033", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0048", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0183", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0300", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0324", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Hand–eye coordination is not one global reflex. It is a set of visual and motor demands that improve unevenly from task to task.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Gain perfect hand–eye reflexes", "metric": "Visual detection, movement path, endpoint error and product result", "boundary": "A faster game score cannot certify another task or profession." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-156", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Bimanual coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express bimanual coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Bimanual coordination can improve and persist in supervised rehabilitation, but gains differ across dexterity, assisting-hand use and personally chosen goals.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare each hand’s role, timing, quality, assistance and meaningful product; symmetry alone is not success.", "negative_findings": [ "Home bimanual training improved dexterity and goals but did not improve the direct Assisting Hand Assessment." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Make both hands equally skilled", "Restrain the stronger hand yourself", "One bimanual drill fits every body", "Simulation grants procedural competence" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0033", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0048", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0236", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0315", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Two hands do not need to do the same job. Supervised rehabilitation can improve how they work together—and the meaningful goal matters more than symmetry.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Make both hands equally perfect", "metric": "Role-specific coordination and chosen task success with assistance recorded", "boundary": "Symmetry or one hand test cannot define functional partnership." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-157", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Micro-assembly and craft", "definition": "Capability to develop or express micro-assembly and craft in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "The fine-motor components of craft are trainable, but direct evidence for durable micro-assembly transfer is limited and ergonomic cost belongs in the result.", "measurement_boundary": "Use accepted-product tolerances, defects, rework, time, pain, fatigue and assistance; a pegboard cannot establish craft quality.", "negative_findings": [ "Clinical dexterity effects did not consistently produce broad daily function, and no direct unfamiliar-product transfer was demonstrated." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Master any craft with dexterity drills", "Faster hands mean better craft", "Pain is the price of mastery", "Copy traditional craft without permission" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0086", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0314", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Craft is not “fast fingers.” It is producing an accepted object through a person–tool–material tradition, with quality, safety and ownership intact.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Gain master-craft hands", "metric": "Defects, tolerances, rework and bodily cost on a named product", "boundary": "A dexterity drill cannot confer craft lineage or material mastery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-158", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Surgical and procedural dexterity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express surgical and procedural dexterity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Specific procedural dexterity can be trained and retained in simulation, but transfer may be positive, absent or harmful and never substitutes for credentialing.", "measurement_boundary": "Use errors, damage, force, quality and economy alongside time; add judgment, teamwork and patient outcomes before clinical inference.", "negative_findings": [ "A haptic simulator group performed worse than untrained controls on a porcine transfer model, and dyadic practice did not outperform individual practice on mean scores." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Learn surgery from Titan", "Simulator score makes you competent", "Fast hands make a safe surgeon", "Practice procedures outside training" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0018", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0033", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0048", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0183", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0328", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Procedural dexterity is trainable in simulators—and simulator training can also teach the wrong thing. No score replaces supervision or credentials.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train surgeon hands at home", "metric": "Validated error, force, damage and quality across simulator and supervised target task", "boundary": "Dexterity alone cannot confer clinical judgment, credential or patient safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-159", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Dance and embodied expression", "definition": "Capability to develop or express dance and embodied expression in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn specific dance sequences and develop embodied expression, but motor learning does not prove falls prevention or cultural mastery.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare form, sequence/timing accuracy, expressive/participant-defined outcome, assistance, fatigue and injury; biomarkers do not measure artistry.", "negative_findings": [ "A twelve-month cluster trial found no reduction in falls from social dancing." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Dance prevents falls", "Learn a sacred form from Titan", "Perfect body expression", "Only standing dance counts" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0283", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0342", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Dance is a real learnable capability and a cultural art—not a generic fitness pill. Sequence gains do not prove falls prevention.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock perfect embodied expression", "metric": "Declared sequence, timing and participant-defined expressive result within a named form", "boundary": "Motor gain cannot prove medical benefit or confer cultural ownership." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-160", "family_id": "FAM-20", "family": "Craft, Precision & Embodied Art", "superdomain": "Creativity & Expression", "power": "Visual composition", "definition": "Capability to develop or express visual composition in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Visual composition and drawing improve through domain-specific practice and engagement with examples, but transfer is style- and task-bound and aesthetics remain culturally situated.", "measurement_boundary": "Use a declared brief, audience, criteria, process attribution and independent output; do not collapse accuracy, novelty, meaning and beauty.", "negative_findings": [ "Art knowledge did not transfer to executive function or different styles, and a branded drawing method did not outperform an active placebo." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Learn universal beauty rules", "Copy any tradition to become creative", "Art training raises executive function", "AI output proves human composition skill" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0171", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0224", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0235", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0300", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0463", "source_alias_ids": [ "F20-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Visual composition can be learned—but there is no universal beauty score. The brief, audience, medium, references and ownership all matter.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Master universal visual harmony", "metric": "Independent output against a declared brief with provenance and rater criteria", "boundary": "Aesthetic judgment or copying cannot confer universal taste or ownership." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-161", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Emotional granularity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express emotional granularity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People differ in how specifically they distinguish feelings, and negative differentiation may change in some interventions, but durable functional benefit is not yet established.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare language, emotion set, sampling window, elicitors and calculation; a differentiation coefficient cannot diagnose emotional insight.", "negative_findings": [ "Negative differentiation gains were not associated with distress improvement, and positive differentiation did not improve in the caregiver trial." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Name every emotion perfectly", "A low score means emotionally immature", "More labels cure distress", "One culture has the correct emotion map" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0181", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0305", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0310", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0384", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Emotional precision is real, but it is not “having the right words.” Language, culture, body signals and communication access shape the result.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Name feelings with superhuman precision", "metric": "Repeated context-rich differentiation using a chosen language or communication mode", "boundary": "A vocabulary-based score cannot establish maturity, diagnosis or recovery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-162", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Emotional downregulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express emotional downregulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can downregulate aspects of emotion in a laboratory, and some effects persist for the same material, but broad real-world mastery is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Report strategy, context, subjective intensity, physiology, action and later function separately; no biomarker proves emotional control.", "negative_findings": [ "A preregistered adolescent depression trial found no differential effect on primary rumination, stress or affect outcomes, and single-session skill conditions did not beat psychoeducation." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Switch off any emotion", "Never feel fear or anger", "Reappraise trauma alone", "Calm appearance proves regulation" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0111", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0126", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0309", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0468", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Humans can change parts of an emotional response. That is not the same as switching emotions off—and sometimes the right move is to listen, act or seek support.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Turn emotions off at will", "metric": "Chosen response change plus safe action and later function in a declared context", "boundary": "A lower rating or amygdala response cannot prove emotional mastery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-163", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Motivational upregulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express motivational upregulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can amplify positive responses to selected material, but evidence does not yet show reliable motivational or goal-pursuit transfer and concurrent cognition can suffer.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate positive affect, arousal, task cost, goal initiation, persistence and completion; an EEG response is not motivation.", "negative_findings": [ "Most active-comparator interactions in a recent savoring trial were nonsignificant, and positive upregulation impaired concurrent working-memory performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Generate motivation on command", "Choose happiness in every situation", "Savoring treats depression", "Positive emotion improves all performance" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0232", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0248", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0467", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Positive emotion can be amplified in the moment. That does not prove extra motivation—and it can consume attention needed elsewhere.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Summon limitless motivation", "metric": "Positive affect plus independent goal initiation, persistence and cost", "boundary": "Feeling more positive cannot prove motivation, productivity or safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-164", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Stress recovery", "definition": "Capability to develop or express stress recovery in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some configured tools can alter immediate recovery markers after a specific stressor, but durable or cross-stressor stress resilience remains unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare stressor, baseline, subjective/physiological trajectory, time to chosen function and harms; HRV is not a diagnosis or universal resilience metric.", "negative_findings": [ "A 136-person smartphone worry-reduction trial changed neither primary 24-hour HRV nor psychological stress, and brief biofeedback did not reduce rumination." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become stress-proof", "HRV proves calm", "Train by creating extreme stress", "Recovery speed shows toughness" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0062", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0063", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0111", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0126", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0176", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0384", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0468", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Stress recovery is a trajectory, not a toughness score. One tool can change one marker while worry or function remains unchanged.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become immune to stress", "metric": "Time for feeling, physiology, thinking and chosen function to recover after a named stressor", "boundary": "One HRV pattern cannot prove resilience or health." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-165", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Distress tolerance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express distress tolerance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Clinical skills programmes can improve selected dysregulation outcomes, but distress tolerance is not forced endurance and brief online skills have not shown specific benefit.", "measurement_boundary": "Record chosen safe action, distress trajectory, support, adverse effects and later function; time endured alone can reward harm.", "negative_findings": [ "Single-session acceptance and change trainings did not outperform stress psychoeducation, and the positive DBT pilot had attrition/compliance limitations." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Train by pushing through panic", "Endure any distress", "DBT yourself from a tutorial", "Leaving means failure" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0062", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0111", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0468", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Distress tolerance is not how much suffering you can endure. It is staying safe and choosing the next useful action—with support when needed.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become unbreakable under distress", "metric": "Chosen safe action, support and later function while distress is present", "boundary": "Time endured cannot prove courage, health or recovery." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-166", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Mood stabilisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express mood stabilisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Mood-episode prevention is a legitimate clinical goal, but “mood stabilization” is not established as a self-trained power and digital trials conflict.", "measurement_boundary": "Use clinician-defined episodes, recurrence, function, adverse effects and patient goals; consumer mood variance is neither diagnosis nor control.", "negative_findings": [ "A 201-person specialist-care trial found no effect of smartphone monitoring/treatment on mood instability or secondary outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Stabilize bipolar mood yourself", "Replace medication with Titan", "Control every mood swing", "An app predicts you perfectly" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0062", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0126", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0176", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0293", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0335", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0467", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Mood stabilization is not a willpower skill. It is a clinical recovery and relapse-prevention goal supported by care, treatment, environment and sometimes technology.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Control bipolar mood at will", "metric": "Clinically assessed episode course, function and harms within an individualized care system", "boundary": "Mood logs or app feedback cannot establish diagnosis or unaided control." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-167", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Fear extinction and courage", "definition": "Capability to develop or express fear extinction and courage in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Fear responses can change through supervised learning, but extinction is context-bound and courage is not the absence of fear.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate subjective fear, physiology, approach, safety, context and meaningful function; no low-fear score defines courage.", "negative_findings": [ "Human fear returned when context changed, and affect labeling changed physiology more clearly than self-reported fear." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Erase fear", "DIY exposure therapy", "Courage means enduring danger", "Flood yourself until calm" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0240", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0305", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0468", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Fear can be relearned, not deleted. It can return in a new context—and courage may mean acting with fear, leaving danger or asking for help.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Erase fear and become fearless", "metric": "Safe chosen approach and function across contexts with fear channels recorded", "boundary": "Extinction is context-bound and cannot define courage or safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-168", "family_id": "FAM-21", "family": "Emotion Regulation & Psychological Recovery", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Compassion regulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express compassion regulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Compassion-related responses may improve with training, but results conflict across comparators and transfer to observed action is unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate self-report, observed helping, recipient impact, boundaries, cost and institutional conditions; HRV does not prove compassion.", "negative_findings": [ "An active-controlled university trial found no between-group advantage on most outcomes; teacher evidence used a waitlist and lacked independent behavior transfer." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become endlessly compassionate", "Compassion requires forgiveness", "Meditation fixes burnout", "Care for others before yourself" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0047", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0350", "source_alias_ids": [ "F21-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Compassion can be cultivated—but it is not endless self-sacrifice. Strong claims must survive active controls and show what happens in real relationships.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become infinitely compassionate", "metric": "Chosen boundaried action and recipient impact with personal cost recorded", "boundary": "Self-report or HRV cannot prove compassionate behavior or justify self-sacrifice." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-169", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Affective empathy", "definition": "Capability to develop or express affective empathy in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected training can change affective responses and patient-perceived empathy in bounded settings, while affective empathy is distinct from compassion and may produce distress.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare target stimulus, self-report versus observed behavior, distress, compassion, accuracy, relationship, culture, delay and partner outcome; neural activation or felt intensity is not proof of another person’s state.", "negative_findings": [ "Empathy-resonance training increased negative affect in the tested study.", "Short professional training did not establish a stable general empathy trait." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "feel everyone’s emotions", "become an empath", "read emotion directly", "more empathy is always better", "empathy scan for staff" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0040", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0203", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "CULTURAL_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can change how strongly they resonate with others, but more resonance is not the same as better care—and can become distressing.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Absorb anyone’s feelings like an empath", "metric": "Declared affective response, distress and recipient-valued behavior in a specified interaction", "boundary": "Feeling strongly cannot verify another person’s emotion, intent or need." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-170", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Cognitive empathy", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cognitive empathy in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Cognitive empathy can improve on selected tasks and professional behaviors when the target, language, context and assistance are declared.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare target self-report or ground truth, observer inference, language, culture, relationship, confidence, error, correction, assistance and recipient outcome; agreement is not access to a private mind.", "negative_findings": [ "Coded empathic style did not prove accurate or beneficial understanding.", "A pre–post ethnocultural programme lacked randomization, delayed retention and migrant-reported outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "know exactly what anyone feels", "mind-reading", "universal empathy score", "train cultural empathy instantly", "AI empathy detector" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0040", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0041", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0202", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0301", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_VALIDATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0393", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain constructs, measurement limits, voluntary perspective checks, accessible communication and privacy; no live person-reading, lie-detection or profiling exercise." ], "site_summary": "Understanding another person can improve—but only if they can correct you, and only within the language, culture and situation tested.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Read anyone like an open book", "metric": "Target-verified inference accuracy and correction in a declared interaction", "boundary": "No task grants access to hidden thoughts or makes one culture’s signals universal." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-171", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Theory of mind", "definition": "Capability to develop or express theory of mind in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected clinical programmes can improve bounded theory-of-mind tasks, with limited retention evidence.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare task, language, explicit cues, accuracy, confidence, diagnosis, assistance, delay and real interaction; vignette success is not a unitary trait or diagnosis.", "negative_findings": [ "The active-control digital trial did not show a specific primary interaction advantage.", "Task gains did not establish broad social functioning." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "unlock mind-reading", "fix autistic social deficits", "theory-of-mind score proves caring", "diagnose from a social puzzle" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0027", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0055", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_CONTROL", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0233", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Some social-reasoning tasks can improve in clinical programmes; that does not make one communication style the human norm.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock the universal theory-of-mind module", "metric": "Accuracy and confidence on declared belief-reasoning tasks plus participant-chosen function", "boundary": "A task score cannot prove caring, diagnosis, social worth or knowledge of a real person’s mind." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-172", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Social signal detection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express social signal detection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Recognition of selected social signals can improve in bounded clinical tasks, but cues are not culturally universal or direct windows into inner state.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare signal channel, culture, target labels, base rates, misses, false alarms, uncertainty, context and correction; cue classification is not emotion, intent or veracity.", "negative_findings": [ "The online social-cognition programme did not beat active control on primary interaction tests.", "Truth–lie judgments stayed only slightly better than chance across response formats." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "read body language perfectly", "spot every lie", "universal microexpression decoder", "emotion recognition proves intent", "AI reads your mood" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0027", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0055", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_CONTROL", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0164", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0175", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Social signals can be learned, but no face, gaze or voice gives a universal readout of emotion, truth or intent.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Decode every face and catch every lie", "metric": "Sensitivity, specificity and target-corrected classification for a declared signal set", "boundary": "Signal accuracy cannot establish private emotion, deception, diagnosis or intent." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-173", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Trust calibration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express trust calibration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Human–AI reliance can be better calibrated in some configured interfaces, but feedback effects conflict and do not transfer automatically.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare trustee or system, version, task, reliability distribution, appropriate-reliance rule, over- and under-reliance, outcome and delay; expressed trust is not calibrated trust.", "negative_findings": [ "Explicit trust-calibration feedback was null on key outcomes.", "No device-off retention or cross-domain transfer was shown." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "know who to trust instantly", "perfect trust instincts", "AI trust score", "eliminate manipulation", "rank trustworthy people" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0180", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "HUMAN_AI_CONFIGURATION", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0347", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Trust can be calibrated to a specific tool and task—but no prompt teaches a universal instinct for people or AI.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Install a perfect trust detector", "metric": "Appropriate reliance, over-reliance and under-reliance across known reliability conditions", "boundary": "Calibration to one system cannot rank people or transfer to every model, relationship or institution." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-174", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Intent inference", "definition": "Capability to develop or express intent inference in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected interventions can reduce hostile interpretations on bounded tasks; accurate real-world intent inference remains unproven.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare scenario, alternative explanations, ground truth or target report, base rate, confidence, correction and behavior; a less hostile answer is not necessarily a correct intent inference.", "negative_findings": [ "Child behavior effects were small or absent despite vignette change.", "Deception judgment remained only slightly above chance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "see anyone’s true motives", "spot predators by instinct", "read criminal intent", "know who is lying", "intent risk score" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0038", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "NEAR_TRANSFER", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0175", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0233", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can learn to question hostile assumptions; they cannot be trained to see another person’s hidden motives.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See the motive behind every action", "metric": "Accuracy, uncertainty and correction against declared resolvable intent evidence", "boundary": "A vignette or cue cannot certify deception, danger, criminality or private motive." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-175", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Cross-cultural perspective-taking", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cross-cultural perspective-taking in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Culturally situated programmes can change selected perspective-taking measures, while genuine cross-cultural benefit and retention remain unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare community, language, positionality, target-defined outcome, self-report versus behavior, error/correction, power and delay; cultural knowledge is not ownership or mastery.", "negative_findings": [ "The ethnocultural study lacked randomization and delayed outcomes.", "The Indian task was validation, not proof of training or universality." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "master any culture", "erase unconscious bias permanently", "universal cultural empathy", "think like Indigenous people", "culture-fit score" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0041", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0164", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_BOUNDARY", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0301", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_VALIDATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0393", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Cross-cultural perspective is not a downloadable script; it grows through attributed, accountable relationships with people who can correct the result.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Master every culture from a short course", "metric": "Community-validated behavior, correction and benefit in a declared cross-cultural interaction", "boundary": "No score proves cultural ownership, universality or freedom from bias." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-176", "family_id": "FAM-22", "family": "Empathy, Social Cognition & Trust", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Social memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express social memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Face–name memory can improve with mnemonic support in selected clinical tasks, while acute high-intensity exercise did not improve the tested outcome.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare material, familiarity, language, cue, assistance, accuracy, false alarms, confidence, delay and chosen real function; recognition confidence is not identity verification.", "negative_findings": [ "High-intensity acute exercise produced no supported face–name benefit.", "Task gains did not establish broad everyday social memory or freedom from false identification." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "never forget a face", "identify anyone instantly", "super-recognizer training", "exercise unlocks face memory", "facial database for social skill" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0042", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0077", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F22-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "People can improve selected face–name memory, especially with mnemonic support; that is not perfect recognition or identity verification.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Never forget another face", "metric": "Correct identification, false alarms and retained name/role recall after a declared delay", "boundary": "A memory task cannot establish biometric identity, trustworthiness or universal face recognition." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-177", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Conflict de-escalation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express conflict de-escalation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Governed clinical de-escalation programmes can reduce restraint and conflict events, but they are institutional configurations—not public confrontation techniques.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare setting, conflict taxonomy, restraint/containment events, injuries, escalation, staff/patient experience, policy, staffing and follow-up; calm appearance is not safety.", "negative_findings": [ "The systematic review did not identify one definitive high-quality universal model.", "Institutional bundles do not isolate a portable personal skill." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "control any aggressor", "talk anyone down", "de-escalate an abusive partner", "psychological compliance script", "replace security or emergency response" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0076", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0394", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESTRICTED", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0456", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COERCION", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFEGUARDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "De-escalation can work in trained, governed services. It is not a promise that anyone can safely control a confrontation.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Talk down any dangerous person", "metric": "Predeclared conflict, restraint, injury and escalation outcomes within an authorized service", "boundary": "Clinical programme evidence cannot make confrontation safe or turn abuse into a communication problem." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-178", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Active listening", "definition": "Capability to develop or express active listening in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Selected active-listening behaviors can increase feeling understood in short interactions, with context-dependent effects.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare listener behavior, speaker goal, perceived versus demonstrated understanding, correction, relationship, accessibility, distress and delay; paraphrase counts are not care.", "negative_findings": [ "Satisfaction and social attraction did not differ between active listening and advice in one experiment.", "Effects were small or context-dependent and lacked durable relationship follow-up." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "make anyone open up", "listen so well they must trust you", "active listening fixes conflict", "neural synchrony proves connection", "score someone’s listening worth" ], "risk_level": "LOW_TO_MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0060", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0156", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0182", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain bounded concepts, evidence, consent and escalation; no crisis, clinical, intimate-partner repair or confrontation protocol." ], "site_summary": "Listening can help someone feel understood, but no technique guarantees trust, agreement or a better relationship.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Use one listening trick to make anyone trust you", "metric": "Speaker-reported understanding, correction accuracy and chosen interaction outcome", "boundary": "Feeling heard does not prove agreement, safety, disclosure consent or durable relationship change." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-179", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Boundary setting", "definition": "Capability to develop or express boundary setting in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Assertiveness and supported decision processes can help people express preferences in selected settings, while culture and power determine whether boundaries are respected.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare the person’s chosen boundary, expression mode, comprehension, system response, retaliation, safety, culture and outcome; assertive style is not compliance by others.", "negative_findings": [ "Effects in international students were mixed, and expressive writing increased some distress.", "No communication script makes coercion safe or transfers responsibility from the person violating the boundary." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "one sentence makes anyone respect you", "set boundaries with an abuser to fix them", "assertiveness prevents violence", "refusal skill score", "blame people for weak boundaries" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0121", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0456", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COERCION", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFEGUARDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A boundary is a person’s decision—not a communication test they must pass, and never a guarantee that another person will behave safely.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Say the perfect line and no one can cross you", "metric": "Chosen preference or refusal communicated, understood and respected without retaliation", "boundary": "Communication skill cannot control another person or make abuse safe." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-180", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Cooperative problem solving", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cooperative problem solving in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A brief communication programme changed one bounded cooperative-thinking measure; broader cooperative problem-solving capability is not yet established.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare problem, affected people, decision rights, options, information, dissent, assistance, outcome and harm; meeting participation or consensus is not solution quality.", "negative_findings": [ "Most measured communication components were null.", "No functional workplace outcome or durable transfer was demonstrated." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "solve any conflict together", "consensus is always best", "one workshop creates collaboration", "agreement score", "use cooperation to pressure consent" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0217", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Working together is not the same as reaching agreement; the test is whether people had real voice and the result actually helped.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Turn every disagreement into effortless consensus", "metric": "Decision quality, affected-person participation, implementation and harm under declared rights", "boundary": "Consensus cannot establish consent, truth, fairness or a good outcome." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer permission. Guide permission remains NOT_READY; any guide, stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-181", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Caregiving coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express caregiving coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Configured person–caregiver–clinician–service interventions can improve selected care-transition and independence outcomes.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare care recipient goals and consent, roles, service availability, medication/record support, transitions, burden, errors, access, clinical outcomes and harms; task completion is not care quality.", "negative_findings": [ "The interventions were multi-component bundles, not isolated caregiver traits.", "Evidence in selected older clinical populations does not generalize to every condition or service system." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "families can manage complex illness alone", "become your own care coordinator", "caregiving skill prevents hospitalization", "ignore clinical advice", "score good carers" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0001", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0082", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Care coordination works best as a supported system around the person—not as unpaid heroics expected from one family member.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "One perfect carer can hold the whole system together", "metric": "Person-defined function, transition errors, rehospitalization, burden and consent in a declared care network", "boundary": "A family’s effort cannot replace clinical responsibility, services or the care recipient’s rights." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-182", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Mentoring and coaching", "definition": "Capability to develop or express mentoring and coaching in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Peer mentoring and professional coaching can improve selected outcomes in configured populations, but no universal mentor effect is established.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare mentor qualifications/lived experience, matching, goal ownership, contact, other supports, conflicts, outcome, burden, delay and referral; satisfaction is not effectiveness.", "negative_findings": [ "Small professional coaching evidence relied heavily on self-report and bundled components.", "Disease-specific peer mentoring did not isolate a general mentoring faculty." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "a mentor unlocks anyone’s potential", "coaching cures distress", "one coaching method works for all", "guru status", "mentee dependence as success" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0187", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0427", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Mentoring can help when the match, goal, boundaries and support are right—it is not a universal shortcut or a substitute for professional care.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Find one mentor and unlock limitless potential", "metric": "Mentee-chosen goal attainment and wellbeing after contact ends, with harms and other supports declared", "boundary": "A coaching result in one population cannot prove cure, universal transfer or personal authority." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-183", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Relational repair", "definition": "Capability to develop or express relational repair in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Some relationships improve after governed training or clinician-delivered therapy, but results are mixed and repair must be voluntary and safe.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare participant-defined relationship, safety, consent, accountability, satisfaction, function, dissolution, harm, culture, treatment and delay; staying together is not the sole success outcome.", "negative_findings": [ "At five years about a quarter of couples were separated or divorced and treatment differences had disappeared.", "Child behavioral outcomes were not uniformly improved." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "repair any relationship", "save every marriage", "forgive to heal", "reconcile with an abuser", "relationship failure means insufficient skill" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0122", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESTRICTED", "RETENTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0456", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COERCION", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "SAFEGUARDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0478", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CULTURAL_CONTEXT", "NULL_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Relationships can sometimes be repaired. They do not all need to be—and repair is never the answer to coercion or abuse.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Use the right method to save any relationship", "metric": "Safety, consent, satisfaction and function over time, including freely chosen separation", "boundary": "Therapy evidence cannot justify forced reconciliation or treating abuse as mutual conflict." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-184", "family_id": "FAM-23", "family": "Relationship, Conflict & Care Capability", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Collective emotional regulation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express collective emotional regulation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Dyadic listening and institutional configurations can shape short-term regulation and conflict, but durable collective emotional regulation remains unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare people, goal ownership, relationship, regulation strategy, affect, conflict, coercion, assistance, environment, recipient outcome and delay; synchrony or calm appearance is not wellbeing.", "negative_findings": [ "The dyadic study was small, brief and all-female.", "The ward trial tested a ten-component institution, not an isolated emotion skill." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "control the mood of any room", "make others calm", "emotional contagion mastery", "neural synchrony proves bond", "make victims regulate aggressors" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0060", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MECHANISM" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0076", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0156", "source_alias_ids": [ "F23-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Calm can be created together—but only when support is wanted, safe and fairly shared.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Control the emotional temperature of any room", "metric": "Recipient-chosen distress, recovery, conflict and burden under a declared support configuration", "boundary": "Synchrony or outward calm cannot prove safety, consent, wellbeing or durable regulation." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-185", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Shared mental models", "definition": "Capability to develop or express shared mental models in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Teams can improve task-relevant shared models through briefing and guided review, with evidence bounded to specialized configurations.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare task, member roles, model elicitation, agreement and accuracy, dissent, information gaps, turnover, tool support, performance and harms; similarity is not truth.", "negative_findings": [ "Low-fidelity and specialized simulations did not establish live public, clinical or institutional outcomes.", "Agreement can conceal missing information and is not itself correctness." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "one team mind", "perfect alignment", "eliminate disagreement", "shared-model score ranks teams", "culture-fit surveillance" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0113", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0313", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TEAM_LEARNING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0434", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Teams can build a clearer shared picture of the task—provided disagreement and missing information remain visible.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Fuse a team into one perfectly aligned mind", "metric": "Task-relevant model accuracy, calibrated agreement, dissent use and team outcome", "boundary": "High agreement cannot establish truth, legitimacy, learning or collective intelligence." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-186", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Distributed expertise", "definition": "Capability to develop or express distributed expertise in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Teams can access distributed expertise more reliably when leaders invite contribution and the receiving system is safe, but shared information still dominates discussion.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare information distribution, expertise validation, contribution opportunity, hierarchy, speak-up attempt, receiver response, closure, retaliation, outcome and harm; voice count is not safety.", "negative_findings": [ "Groups systematically over-discussed shared information and missed critical unshared evidence.", "Discouraging leadership cut simulated speak-up sharply despite identical junior training." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "just speak up", "expertise always surfaces", "psychological-safety score proves safety", "silent workers lack courage", "map everyone’s expertise covertly" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0016", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "PROCESS_PROXY", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0083", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPEAK_UP", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0115", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0434", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A team does not gain from expertise merely because it exists. People need safe routes to contribute—and a system that actually responds.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Hire experts and the truth will automatically surface", "metric": "Critical unshared information integrated, acted on and closed without retaliation", "boundary": "Expertise inventories, airtime or self-reported safety cannot prove that the system listens or prevents harm." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-187", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Team synchrony", "definition": "Capability to develop or express team synchrony in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Synchronous action can change immediate cooperation and affiliation, but the same mechanism can increase destructive obedience.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare activity, voluntariness, authority, affiliation, cooperation, dissent, harmful compliance, delay and real outcome; temporal alignment is not team quality.", "negative_findings": [ "Synchrony increased compliance with an ostensibly destructive request.", "No durable field-team performance or retention was shown." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "synchronize a team into trust", "cohesion is always good", "rituals make people loyal", "collective flow guarantees performance", "use synchrony to overcome resistance" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0186", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ADVERSE_RESPONSE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0239", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEAR_TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Moving together can increase cooperation—and also obedience. Titan treats synchrony as a double-edged influence, not a teamwork shortcut.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Synchronize a group into unstoppable unity", "metric": "Cooperation, dissent and harmful compliance after voluntary synchronous activity", "boundary": "Synchrony cannot prove trust, morality, safety or durable team performance." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-188", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Collective decision making", "definition": "Capability to develop or express collective decision making in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Groups can outperform individuals under specific competence, information and communication configurations—and can also perform worse.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare members, individual competence, task battery, information distribution, aggregation, confidence, best-member comparator, affected-person outcome, harms and delay; a latent factor is not human worth.", "negative_findings": [ "Dyads with unequal sensitivity could do worse than their best member.", "Later experiments did not support turn-taking or gender-composition explanations and challenged the original factor account." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "collective IQ score", "rank the smartest teams", "two heads are always better", "more women makes a team intelligent", "AI reveals group intelligence" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0079", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTRADICTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0115", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0264", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0265", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSTRUCT_HYPOTHESIS", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEASUREMENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0434", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S020" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Groups can be smarter than their members in one configuration and worse in another. Titan will not reduce that complexity to a collective IQ.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Measure the intelligence of any team with one score", "metric": "Outcome relative to best member and alternatives under declared information, competence and rights", "boundary": "A task-battery factor cannot rank team worth, guarantee wisdom or erase affected-person rights." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-189", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Swarm coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express swarm coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Human crowds show emergent movement coordination under simple tasks, but trainability and safe transfer are not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare crowd size, density, environment, informed members, goal, visibility, trajectories, collisions, consent, authority and safety outcome; emergence is not wisdom or trainability.", "negative_findings": [ "Local rules can generate dangerous turbulence at extreme density.", "Simple walking coordination does not establish deliberate trainable collective intelligence." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "human hive mind", "train swarm intelligence", "control a crowd invisibly", "leaderless crowds are wise", "DIY evacuation experiment" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0049", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EMERGENT_COORDINATION", "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0162", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SAFETY_BOUNDARY", "SYSTEM_MODEL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Crowds can self-organize through simple local behavior. At high density the same dynamics can become deadly—so this is a modeling field, not a public tutorial.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Unlock a human hive mind", "metric": "Trajectory coordination, time, error and collision risk in an authorized declared crowd model", "boundary": "Emergent movement cannot establish trainability, wisdom, consent or safe real-event control." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-190", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Transactive memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express transactive memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Teams trained together can develop transactive memory that improves a bounded group task, with field associations in project teams.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare expertise domains, validation, retrieval, records, membership stability, access, error, redundancy, communication channel, delay and team outcome; knowing whom to ask is not knowledge retention.", "negative_findings": [ "Evidence relied on stable small groups and bounded tasks.", "Face-to-face communication effects did not generalize to every channel, and observational field associations do not prove causation." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "team memory never forgets", "map who knows everything", "replace documentation with key people", "identify expendable workers", "organizational memory score" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0299", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0341", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CHANGE_OVER_TIME", "FIELD_ASSOCIATION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0434", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Teams can remember more by knowing who knows what—but only if knowledge is accessible, documented and resilient when people leave.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build a team that never forgets", "metric": "Correct retrieval, redundancy and task outcome across delay and membership change", "boundary": "An expertise map cannot replace documentation, prove institutional memory or justify surveillance." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-191", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Group creativity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express group creativity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "LOW_RISK_GUIDE_READY" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "READY_BOUNDED_NON_PRESCRIPTIVE", "external_confirmation_gate": "NOT_REQUIRED_FOR_CURRENT_BOUNDED_PERMISSION", "external_confirmation_triggers": [], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured written idea exchange can aid generation, while conventional interactive brainstorming often underperforms pooled individuals.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare prompt, individual baseline, interaction format, quantity, independent novelty/feasibility, selection, implementation, attribution, power and delay; enthusiasm is not creativity.", "negative_findings": [ "Interactive brainstorming groups generated fewer ideas than nominal groups under common conditions.", "Idea quantity did not establish novelty, feasibility, implementation or equitable credit." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "brainstorming unlocks genius", "more voices always mean more creativity", "idea count proves innovation", "AI owns the group idea", "leader gets sole credit" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": true, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0019", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURED_PERFORMANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0116", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEGATIVE_BOUNDARY", "PROCESS_MECHANISM" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [ "Explain system architecture, measurement, benign reflection and negative findings; no high-stakes operational, crowd-control, surveillance or coercive cohesion protocol." ], "site_summary": "Groups are not automatically more creative. The format matters: ordinary brainstorming can block ideas, while structured exchange can help.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Put smart people in a room and creativity multiplies", "metric": "Independent novelty, feasibility, implementation and equitable attribution versus individual baselines", "boundary": "Idea volume or group excitement cannot prove innovation, value or fair ownership." }, "next_gate": "No external confirmation is required for the current bounded explainer and non-prescriptive guide-frame permissions; any stronger efficacy, generalisation, protocol, promotion or independent-validation claim requires a new adjudication." }, { "power_id": "PWR-192", "family_id": "FAM-24", "family": "Team & Collective Intelligence", "superdomain": "Emotion & Social", "power": "Institutional learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express institutional learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured reviews can improve later team performance, but institutional learning requires a receiving system that acts, protects, retains and closes feedback.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare institution, event/outcome, evidence, reporting route, receiver action, policy/practice change, implementation, retention, recurrence, retaliation, affected-person remedy and delay; review completion is a proxy.", "negative_findings": [ "Evidence is strongest for bounded teams and repeated training tasks, not whole institutions.", "Self-reported safety, report volume and review completion do not prove correction or affected-person benefit." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "learning organization score", "every failure makes us stronger", "blame-free means consequence-free", "one after-action review fixes culture", "count reports as improvement" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0016", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "PROCESS_PROXY", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0083", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SPEAK_UP", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0114", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0313", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "TEAM_LEARNING", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0434", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_FRAMEWORK", "SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0465", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S019" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0470", "source_alias_ids": [ "F24-S020" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AFFECTED_PERSON_RIGHTS", "CONSENT", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "An institution has not learned because it held a review. Learning means the system changed, the lesson survived and affected people saw the result.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Run one debrief and become a learning organization", "metric": "Verified change, recurrence, outcome, retention and affected-person remedy after review", "boundary": "Reports, meetings, psychological-safety surveys or policies cannot alone prove institutional learning." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-193", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "AI-assisted reasoning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ai-assisted reasoning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "AI can improve selected reasoning tasks in a declared configuration, but it can also transmit error and add verification work.", "measurement_boundary": "Accuracy, calibration, time, verification effort and harm-weighted error versus human-only, AI-only and the better standalone baseline. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Explanations did not reliably create complementarity and incorrect advice sometimes reduced performance below the human-only baseline.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "AI makes a person universally smarter", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0148", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIAS_TRANSFER", "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0149", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXPLANATION_NULL", "HIGH_IMPACT_BOUNDARY", "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0268", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0272", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BETTER_STANDALONE_BASELINE", "COMPLEMENTARITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EQUITY_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE_REDUCTION", "VERIFICATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0337", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTOMATION_BIAS", "FALLBACK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SEQUENCING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0371", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "UNCERTAINTY", "VERIFICATION_BURDEN" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCOUNTABILITY", "GOVERNANCE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VALIDITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0423", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MISUSE", "MODEL_DRIFT", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "AI can improve selected reasoning tasks in a declared configuration, but it can also transmit error and add verification work.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "AI makes a person universally smarter", "metric": "Accuracy, calibration, time, verification effort and harm-weighted error versus human-only, AI-only and the better standalone baseline", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-194", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "AI-assisted memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ai-assisted memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "AI-supported memory is a configured retrieval capability; what is remembered by the person and what remains in the system must be reported separately.", "measurement_boundary": "Device-on retrieval accuracy, source traceability and latency plus delayed unaided recall and performance after system loss. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Expectation of external access changed what people recalled, and biased AI exposure produced later unassisted errors rather than improvement.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "An AI second brain permanently expands memory", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0148", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIAS_TRANSFER", "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0152", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_BASELINE", "CONFIGURATION_DEPENDENCE", "LEARNING", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0154", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION", "DESKILLING_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP", "SELF_EFFICACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0267", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COGNITIVE_OFFLOADING", "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEMORY_CONTENT_VS_LOCATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0268", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0423", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MISUSE", "MODEL_DRIFT", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "AI-supported memory is a configured retrieval capability; what is remembered by the person and what remains in the system must be reported separately.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "An AI second brain permanently expands memory", "metric": "Device-on retrieval accuracy, source traceability and latency plus delayed unaided recall and performance after system loss", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-195", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "AI-assisted creativity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ai-assisted creativity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "AI can assist selected creative outputs, sometimes most for lower-baseline performers, while narrowing collective diversity.", "measurement_boundary": "Blinded novelty/usefulness, corpus diversity, provenance, human contribution, time and delayed unaided performance. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Assisted stories became more similar to one another, and passive reliance reduced ownership, meaning and self-efficacy.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "AI unlocks unlimited personal creativity", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0154", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION", "DESKILLING_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP", "SELF_EFFICACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0263", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COLLECTIVE_DIVERSITY_COST", "CREATIVE_OUTPUT", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0423", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MISUSE", "MODEL_DRIFT", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "AI can assist selected creative outputs, sometimes most for lower-baseline performers, while narrowing collective diversity.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "AI unlocks unlimited personal creativity", "metric": "Blinded novelty/usefulness, corpus diversity, provenance, human contribution, time and delayed unaided performance", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-196", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "AI-assisted perception", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ai-assisted perception in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "AI can assist selected perceptual judgements, but performance belongs to the versioned reader-tool-workflow configuration.", "measurement_boundary": "Sensitivity, specificity, calibration, time and severity-weighted misses versus expert-only, AI-only and combined conditions. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Some combined teams did not exceed the best standalone component, and incorrect advice or explanations could induce overreliance.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "AI gives superhuman sight", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0150", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ASSISTED_PERCEPTION", "EXPERT_CONFIGURATION", "EXPLANATION_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0378", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AI_ONLY_BASELINE", "ASSISTED_PERCEPTION", "EXPERIENCE_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "AI can assist selected perceptual judgements, but performance belongs to the versioned reader-tool-workflow configuration.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "AI gives superhuman sight", "metric": "Sensitivity, specificity, calibration, time and severity-weighted misses versus expert-only, AI-only and combined conditions", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-197", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "AI-assisted decision calibration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ai-assisted decision calibration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Reliance on AI can be made more selective in some interfaces, but no explanation or warning guarantees good judgement.", "measurement_boundary": "Calibration, appropriate acceptance/rejection, verification rate, workload and harm-weighted errors across advice-quality strata. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Incorrect AI reduced accuracy, explanations often failed to help, and acquired AI bias persisted into later unaided decisions.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A confidence score makes AI safe to trust", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0148", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIAS_TRANSFER", "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0149", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXPLANATION_NULL", "HIGH_IMPACT_BOUNDARY", "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0272", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BETTER_STANDALONE_BASELINE", "COMPLEMENTARITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EQUITY_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE_REDUCTION", "VERIFICATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0337", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTOMATION_BIAS", "FALLBACK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SEQUENCING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0371", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "UNCERTAINTY", "VERIFICATION_BURDEN" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCOUNTABILITY", "GOVERNANCE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VALIDITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Reliance on AI can be made more selective in some interfaces, but no explanation or warning guarantees good judgement.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A confidence score makes AI safe to trust", "metric": "Calibration, appropriate acceptance/rejection, verification rate, workload and harm-weighted errors across advice-quality strata", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-198", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Agent delegation and orchestration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express agent delegation and orchestration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Humans can delegate bounded tasks to agents, but the capability is the governed person-agent workflow, not autonomous output alone.", "measurement_boundary": "Task completion, error recovery, intervention rate, verification burden, authority violations and human-only/agent-only/team performance. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Delegation increased payoff inequality in one game, hybrid nudging did not improve group success, and participants shifted responsibility to agents.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "One prompt lets an agent safely run everything", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0145", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DELEGATION", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "INEQUALITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESPONSIBILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0154", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION", "DESKILLING_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP", "SELF_EFFICACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCOUNTABILITY", "GOVERNANCE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VALIDITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0423", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MISUSE", "MODEL_DRIFT", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Humans can delegate bounded tasks to agents, but the capability is the governed person-agent workflow, not autonomous output alone.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "One prompt lets an agent safely run everything", "metric": "Task completion, error recovery, intervention rate, verification burden, authority violations and human-only/agent-only/team performance", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-199", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "AI tutoring and adaptive learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ai tutoring and adaptive learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A structured AI tutor can improve immediate learning on selected lessons; that does not prove durable or universal education benefit.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclared learning outcome, time, delayed unaided retention and unfamiliar transfer versus active human instruction and ordinary chatbot use. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Unguided use can bypass thinking, and the positive trial relied on expert prompts, prewritten solutions and only immediate post-tests.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "An AI tutor teaches every subject better than people", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0148", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIAS_TRANSFER", "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0152", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_BASELINE", "CONFIGURATION_DEPENDENCE", "LEARNING", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0267", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COGNITIVE_OFFLOADING", "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MEMORY_CONTENT_VS_LOCATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0423", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTENT_PROVENANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MISUSE", "MODEL_DRIFT", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A structured AI tutor can improve immediate learning on selected lessons; that does not prove durable or universal education benefit.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "An AI tutor teaches every subject better than people", "metric": "Predeclared learning outcome, time, delayed unaided retention and unfamiliar transfer versus active human instruction and ordinary chatbot use", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-200", "family_id": "FAM-25", "family": "Human–AI Complementarity", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Human–AI fallback collaboration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express human–ai fallback collaboration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Useful human-AI systems require tested human-only or alternative routes for model error, outage and withdrawal.", "measurement_boundary": "Failure detection, time-to-safe-state, recovery accuracy, override success and post-outage human performance versus pre-automation baseline. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "People accepted incorrect advice, inherited bias and sometimes performed below their own baseline; explanations alone did not solve fallback.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A human in the loop guarantees safety", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_GOVERNANCE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0148", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIAS_TRANSFER", "DESKILLING_RISK", "DEVICE_OFF_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0149", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXPLANATION_NULL", "HIGH_IMPACT_BOUNDARY", "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0154", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACTIVE_COLLABORATION", "DESKILLING_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OWNERSHIP", "SELF_EFFICACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0268", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONFIGURATION", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "HUMAN_ONLY_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0272", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BETTER_STANDALONE_BASELINE", "COMPLEMENTARITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0273", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EQUITY_INTERACTION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "OVERRELIANCE_REDUCTION", "VERIFICATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0337", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AUTOMATION_BIAS", "FALLBACK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SEQUENCING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0371", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "INCORRECT_ADVICE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "UNCERTAINTY", "VERIFICATION_BURDEN" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F25-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCOUNTABILITY", "GOVERNANCE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "VALIDITY" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Useful human-AI systems require tested human-only or alternative routes for model error, outage and withdrawal.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A human in the loop guarantees safety", "metric": "Failure detection, time-to-safe-state, recovery accuracy, override success and post-outage human performance versus pre-automation baseline", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION." }, { "power_id": "PWR-201", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Augmentative and alternative communication", "definition": "Capability to develop or express augmentative and alternative communication in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "AAC is a legitimate communication capability of the person-with-system-and-partners, not an inferior substitute for speech.", "measurement_boundary": "Independently authored meaning, partner comprehension, communication turns, participation and breakdown repair across settings. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "No one device fits every user, and messages produced through discredited facilitator-dependent methods must not be assumed to be the person's authorship.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A speech device speaks for a person automatically", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0190", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AAC", "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "FUNCTIONAL_INDEPENDENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0436", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ABANDONMENT", "AUTHORSHIP", "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MULTIMODAL_ACCESS" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "AAC is a legitimate communication capability of the person-with-system-and-partners, not an inferior substitute for speech.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A speech device speaks for a person automatically", "metric": "Independently authored meaning, partner comprehension, communication turns, participation and breakdown repair across settings", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-202", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Sensory substitution", "definition": "Capability to develop or express sensory substitution in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Sensory-substitution mappings can be learned, but they do not restore biological vision or replace established mobility tools.", "measurement_boundary": "Task accuracy, collision type, speed, cognitive load and chosen use versus the person's established mobility route. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Device-only travel was slower with more collisions in one pilot, low steps were detected poorly, and another glove remained slower than the cane.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A wearable gives blind people vision", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0348", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CANE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "SENSORY_SUBSTITUTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0407", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY", "WEARABLE_NAVIGATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0408", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CANE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "WEARABLE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Sensory-substitution mappings can be learned, but they do not restore biological vision or replace established mobility tools.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A wearable gives blind people vision", "metric": "Task accuracy, collision type, speed, cognitive load and chosen use versus the person's established mobility route", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-203", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Prosthetic control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express prosthetic control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Prosthetic control can be learned and sustained within a fitted person-device system; benefit and risk vary by interface and user.", "measurement_boundary": "Task success, control error, comfort, wear time, abandonment, maintenance and device-on/off daily participation. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "One pilot kinematic measure did not improve, and a corrected implanted case series included sepsis and infection requiring explantation.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A bionic arm becomes a perfect natural limb", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0159", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CORRECTED_RECORD", "HOME_USE", "IMPLANT_RISK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PROSTHETIC_CONTROL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0218", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DEVICE_SPECIFIC", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE", "TRAINABILITY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Prosthetic control can be learned and sustained within a fitted person-device system; benefit and risk vary by interface and user.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A bionic arm becomes a perfect natural limb", "metric": "Task success, control error, comfort, wear time, abandonment, maintenance and device-on/off daily participation", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-204", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Exoskeleton-assisted mobility", "definition": "Capability to develop or express exoskeleton-assisted mobility in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Exoskeleton-assisted mobility is a supervised configured capability with mixed evidence for added rehabilitation benefit.", "measurement_boundary": "Device-on mobility, assistance level, falls, fatigue and personally relevant independence plus delayed device-off walking outcomes. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "A multicentre 2026 trial found no significant advantage over standard rehabilitation on any outcome, and a 2023 trial had null results beyond WISCI-II.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A robotic suit makes paralysis disappear", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0332", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_SECONDARY_OUTCOMES", "REHABILITATION", "WALKING_INDEPENDENCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0374", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "REHABILITATION", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Exoskeleton-assisted mobility is a supervised configured capability with mixed evidence for added rehabilitation benefit.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A robotic suit makes paralysis disappear", "metric": "Device-on mobility, assistance level, falls, fatigue and personally relevant independence plus delayed device-off walking outcomes", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-205", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Neurofeedback", "definition": "Capability to develop or express neurofeedback in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Neurofeedback may teach control of a specified signal, but broad cognitive, emotional or clinical enhancement is not established.", "measurement_boundary": "Prespecified signal change, sham difference, responder rate, no-feedback transfer and independent functional outcome. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Insomnia outcomes did not outperform sham despite target-signal learning, contradicting the master baseline's implication of uniformly strong coverage.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Training brainwaves upgrades the brain", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0195", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEUROFEEDBACK", "PLACEBO_BOUNDARY", "SHAM_CONTROL" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0286", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BEHAVIOURAL_EFFECT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NARROW_TASK", "SIGNAL_SELF_REGULATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Neurofeedback may teach control of a specified signal, but broad cognitive, emotional or clinical enhancement is not established.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Training brainwaves upgrades the brain", "metric": "Prespecified signal change, sham difference, responder rate, no-feedback transfer and independent functional outcome", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-206", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Wearable navigation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express wearable navigation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Wearable navigation aids can add cues in controlled settings; they are adjuncts until real-world safety and reliability are demonstrated.", "measurement_boundary": "Collision type, drop-off/head obstacle detection, speed, auditory masking, workload, failure recovery and user-chosen adoption. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Low steps were poorly detected, device-only travel produced more collisions in one pilot, and glove travel was slower than cane use.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A smart wearable guarantees independent navigation", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0348", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CANE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_COMPARATOR", "SENSORY_SUBSTITUTION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0407", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NULL_FINDING", "SAFETY", "WEARABLE_NAVIGATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0408", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CANE_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "TRAINABILITY", "WEARABLE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Wearable navigation aids can add cues in controlled settings; they are adjuncts until real-world safety and reliability are demonstrated.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A smart wearable guarantees independent navigation", "metric": "Collision type, drop-off/head obstacle detection, speed, auditory masking, workload, failure recovery and user-chosen adoption", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-207", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Environmental control systems", "definition": "Capability to develop or express environmental control systems in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Environmental controls can increase autonomy for selected users when fitted, maintained and backed up as a complete service.", "measurement_boundary": "Correct and false commands, time, assistance avoided, user control, failure recovery, maintenance and home participation. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "A smart-home study recorded false operations, and wellbeing evidence remains a small uncontrolled pilot.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A smart home creates total independence", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0189", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CAREGIVER_SUPPORT", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PILOT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0190", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "AAC", "DEVICE_ON_OFF", "FUNCTIONAL_INDEPENDENCE", "LIMITING_FINDING" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0227", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ENVIRONMENTAL_CONTROL", "FALSE_OPERATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Environmental controls can increase autonomy for selected users when fitted, maintained and backed up as a complete service.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A smart home creates total independence", "metric": "Correct and false commands, time, assistance avoided, user control, failure recovery, maintenance and home participation", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-208", "family_id": "FAM-26", "family": "Assistive & Restorative Technology", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Remote telepresence and embodiment", "definition": "Capability to develop or express remote telepresence and embodiment in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Telepresence can support connection and participation in some configured services; it does not reproduce full physical presence.", "measurement_boundary": "User-controlled participation, connection, communication, access barriers, privacy incidents, technical failure and chosen continued use. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Implementation was constrained by stakeholder misunderstanding and individual fit, and the evidence did not test objective learning or broad embodiment.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A robot lets anyone be anywhere as if physically present", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH_CLINICAL_OR_MOBILITY", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0391", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "IMPLEMENTATION", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PARTICIPATION", "TELEPRESENCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0489", "source_alias_ids": [ "F26-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "ACCESS", "AFFORDABILITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERVICE_SYSTEM", "USER_INVOLVEMENT" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Telepresence can support connection and participation in some configured services; it does not reproduce full physical presence.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A robot lets anyone be anywhere as if physically present", "metric": "User-controlled participation, connection, communication, access barriers, privacy incidents, technical failure and chosen continued use", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-209", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Brain–computer communication", "definition": "Capability to develop or express brain–computer communication in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Implanted BCI communication can be functionally valuable for selected people, but performance belongs to the complete regulated person-device-decoder-support system.", "measurement_boundary": "Person-confirmed message accuracy, rate, correction, calibration/support time, home uptime, privacy and safe fallback versus best alternative access. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Earlier evidence was single-participant laboratory proof, and even long-term home use still required implantation, care-partner setup and adaptive software.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A brain implant reads thoughts perfectly", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0137", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BRAIN_COMPUTER_COMMUNICATION", "DRIFT", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0138", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CARE_PARTNER_SUPPORT", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0453", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM_RISK", "REGULATED_DEVICE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0482", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSENT", "EQUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MENTAL_INTEGRITY", "NEURORIGHTS" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Implanted BCI communication can be functionally valuable for selected people, but performance belongs to the complete regulated person-device-decoder-support system.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A brain implant reads thoughts perfectly", "metric": "Person-confirmed message accuracy, rate, correction, calibration/support time, home uptime, privacy and safe fallback versus best alternative access", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-210", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Brain-controlled prostheses", "definition": "Capability to develop or express brain-controlled prostheses in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Neural interfaces can control selected prosthetic movements; they do not create a natural, invulnerable or unaided limb.", "measurement_boundary": "Task success, movement error/time, unintended activation, daily wear/use, adverse events, maintenance and fallback versus best alternative control. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Robotic-arm control was slower and less accurate than able-bodied use, and long-term implanted prosthesis evidence included serious infection.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "The mind can control a perfect bionic limb", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0133", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BRAIN_CONTROLLED_PROSTHESIS", "FUNCTIONAL_TASK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0159", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIOHYBRID_INTERFACE", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERIOUS_ADVERSE_EVENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0453", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM_RISK", "REGULATED_DEVICE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0482", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSENT", "EQUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MENTAL_INTEGRITY", "NEURORIGHTS" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Neural interfaces can control selected prosthetic movements; they do not create a natural, invulnerable or unaided limb.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "The mind can control a perfect bionic limb", "metric": "Task success, movement error/time, unintended activation, daily wear/use, adverse events, maintenance and fallback versus best alternative control", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-211", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Neural sensory feedback", "definition": "Capability to develop or express neural sensory feedback in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Neural feedback can add useful artificial sensation to a prosthesis for selected users; it is not restoration of normal touch.", "measurement_boundary": "Force error, object identification, visual-attention burden, sensation stability, adverse events and unfamiliar-task performance device-on/off. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Evidence is dominated by single/few participants and implanted-device configurations, with no device-off sensory restoration.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Electronic nerves restore perfect natural touch", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0159", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIOHYBRID_INTERFACE", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERIOUS_ADVERSE_EVENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0193", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEURAL_SENSORY_FEEDBACK", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0453", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM_RISK", "REGULATED_DEVICE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0482", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSENT", "EQUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MENTAL_INTEGRITY", "NEURORIGHTS" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Neural feedback can add useful artificial sensation to a prosthesis for selected users; it is not restoration of normal touch.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Electronic nerves restore perfect natural touch", "metric": "Force error, object identification, visual-attention burden, sensation stability, adverse events and unfamiliar-task performance device-on/off", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-212", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Robotic strength augmentation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express robotic strength augmentation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Robotic supports can reduce selected physical demands while worn; they do not make the user biologically stronger.", "measurement_boundary": "Supported task output, whole-body loading, discomfort, heat, balance, errors, discontinuation and device-off strength. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Three of twenty workers discontinued in the field trial, and reduced back activity does not prove lower injury risk or total-body benefit.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "An exoskeleton gives permanent super-strength", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0050", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DISCONTINUATION", "FIELD_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "ROBOTIC_AUGMENTATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Robotic supports can reduce selected physical demands while worn; they do not make the user biologically stronger.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "An exoskeleton gives permanent super-strength", "metric": "Supported task output, whole-body loading, discomfort, heat, balance, errors, discontinuation and device-off strength", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-213", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Fine-motor teleoperation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express fine-motor teleoperation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Fine teleoperation is a trainable person-interface-robot task; assistance and autonomy must be declared.", "measurement_boundary": "Accuracy, force error, time, collisions, workload, latency/failure recovery and unaided/assisted conditions versus direct control. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Small controlled studies do not establish patient benefit, daily-life independence or safe performance when guidance or network links fail.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A robot instantly gives flawless surgical hands", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0039", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FINE_MOTOR_TELEOPERATION", "HAPTIC_GUIDANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIMULATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0226", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SHARED_AUTONOMY", "TELEOPERATION", "USER_OVERRIDE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Fine teleoperation is a trainable person-interface-robot task; assistance and autonomy must be declared.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A robot instantly gives flawless surgical hands", "metric": "Accuracy, force error, time, collisions, workload, latency/failure recovery and unaided/assisted conditions versus direct control", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-214", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Shared autonomy", "definition": "Capability to develop or express shared autonomy in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Shared autonomy can improve selected tasks, but value depends on how control, intent, override and failure are configured.", "measurement_boundary": "Task success, intent errors, override latency, workload, collisions and failure recovery versus manual, autonomous and shared control. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Studies were small or used nondisabled participants; intent inference, slower travel and failure-state agency remain unresolved.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "The robot always knows what the user wants", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0039", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "FINE_MOTOR_TELEOPERATION", "HAPTIC_GUIDANCE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SIMULATION" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0067", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTROLLED_CORRIDOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "SHARED_AUTONOMY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0226", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "SHARED_AUTONOMY", "TELEOPERATION", "USER_OVERRIDE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0367", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COLLISION_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "SLOWER_PERFORMANCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Shared autonomy can improve selected tasks, but value depends on how control, intent, override and failure are configured.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "The robot always knows what the user wants", "metric": "Task success, intent errors, override latency, workload, collisions and failure recovery versus manual, autonomous and shared control", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-215", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Autonomous mobility assistance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express autonomous mobility assistance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Autonomous mobility assistance is an emerging configured capability; current evidence is controlled and does not establish independent public travel.", "measurement_boundary": "Severity-weighted collisions, interventions, route completion/time, workload, false stops, safe-state success and intended-user agency. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "The strongest studies used six trained or blindfolded nondisabled participants, and assisted navigation could be slower despite fewer collisions.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "A smart wheelchair can safely drive anyone anywhere", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0067", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONTROLLED_CORRIDOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "SHARED_AUTONOMY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0367", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "COLLISION_COMPARATOR", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MOBILITY_ASSISTANCE", "SLOWER_PERFORMANCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Autonomous mobility assistance is an emerging configured capability; current evidence is controlled and does not establish independent public travel.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A smart wheelchair can safely drive anyone anywhere", "metric": "Severity-weighted collisions, interventions, route completion/time, workload, false stops, safe-state success and intended-user agency", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-216", "family_id": "FAM-27", "family": "Robotics, BCI & Shared Autonomy", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Biohybrid human–machine control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express biohybrid human–machine control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Biohybrid human-machine control exists in small restorative clinical systems; it is not a consumer neural-enhancement route.", "measurement_boundary": "User-chosen function, decoder and interface stability, adverse events, reversibility, repair burden, authorship and device-on/off outcomes. This measures the declared configured system and cannot by itself establish broad transfer, unaided ability, safety or legitimacy.", "negative_findings": [ "Evidence is tiny, clinically selected and device-on; one corrected series included sepsis and infection, and no broad enhancement or device-off transfer exists.", "No cited evidence supports perfect, universal or consequence-free performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Humans can safely merge with machines for limitless enhancement", "The tool or robot's output proves an unaided, universal or permanent human superpower", "A successful laboratory task proves independent real-world or clinical capability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH_REGULATED_DEVICE_OR_ROBOTICS", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0133", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BRAIN_CONTROLLED_PROSTHESIS", "FUNCTIONAL_TASK", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SMALL_SAMPLE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0138", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CARE_PARTNER_SUPPORT", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0159", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "BIOHYBRID_INTERFACE", "HOME_USE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "SERIOUS_ADVERSE_EVENT" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0193", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "LIMITING_FINDING", "NEURAL_SENSORY_FEEDBACK", "SINGLE_PARTICIPANT", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "DATA_LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "PEOPLE_HARM", "PRIVACY" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CYBERSECURITY", "FAIL_SAFE", "LIFECYCLE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RESILIENCE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0453", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CLINICAL_GATE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "LONG_TERM_RISK", "REGULATED_DEVICE" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0482", "source_alias_ids": [ "F27-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "CONSENT", "EQUITY", "LIMITING_FINDING", "MENTAL_INTEGRITY", "NEURORIGHTS" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Biohybrid human-machine control exists in small restorative clinical systems; it is not a consumer neural-enhancement route.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Humans can safely merge with machines for limitless enhancement", "metric": "User-chosen function, decoder and interface stability, adverse events, reversibility, repair burden, authorship and device-on/off outcomes", "boundary": "Report person, device/model/interface, task, assistance, failure state and comparator; the metric is not proof of unaided general capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-217", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Non-human environmental sensing", "definition": "Capability to develop or express non-human environmental sensing in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn to use a wearable sensor that converts otherwise unavailable environmental information into a tactile cue; the demonstrated ability remains device- and task-specific.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure sensor/mapping version, signal-detection accuracy, orientation error, workload, interference, device-on/off performance, delayed retention, real-route function and failures; neural change is not biological sense acquisition.", "negative_findings": [ "No durable device-off sensory capability or safety-critical independent-navigation transfer has been established; group/exposure confounding remains." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Grow a magnetic sense", "Biological magnetoreception", "Navigate safely without ordinary aids", "Install a sixth sense in anyone" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0346", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0397", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A wearable can translate magnetic north or another hidden signal into touch. The learned capability belongs to the person–device system—not a newly grown biological sense.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Grow a sixth sense", "metric": "Versioned device-on orientation accuracy, error, workload and real-route function", "boundary": "Learning a sensor mapping does not establish a new biological receptor or safe independent navigation." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-218", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Spatial-audio augmentation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express spatial-audio augmentation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A prototype can sonify a reconstructed environment and reduced obstacle contacts in six blindfolded sighted adults, but value for blind/low-vision users, dependable mobility and durable learning remain unestablished.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare user vision/hearing, route, obstacles, moving hazards, sensor field, mapping and latency; measure collisions/near misses, path error, time, workload, audio masking, device failure, aid use and user-valued function.", "negative_findings": [ "The feasibility study tested no blind/low-vision user; participants were slower when assisted, and no evidence establishes street navigation, superiority to established aids, audio-masking tolerance or safe device failure." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Sonar vision", "Replace a cane or guide dog", "See with sound automatically", "Safe navigation through any environment" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0396", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Spatial audio can turn a 3D scan into navigation cues. Early testing was only in six blindfolded sighted adults, so real value for blind and low-vision users remains an open, user-led question.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "See the world through sonar", "metric": "Route completion, obstacle/near-miss rate, localization error, workload and fallback use in intended users", "boundary": "A sighted-blindfolded prototype study cannot establish sight, safe street mobility or replacement of established aids." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-219", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Haptic data perception", "definition": "Capability to develop or express haptic data perception in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn particular wearable tactile codes, including direction and phoneme patterns, but retention and generalization beyond the trained device and mapping remain open.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare actuator layout, waveform, body site, mapping, feedback and alternative channel; measure discrimination, confusion matrix, free response, delayed device/code transfer, workload, skin effects and meaningful use.", "negative_findings": [ "No broad cross-device/code transfer, long delayed retention, daily communication benefit or universal skin/sensory tolerance has been shown." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Read any data through skin", "Learn a new language through vibration", "Universal haptic sense", "No visual or auditory support needed" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0228", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0397", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Vibration patterns can carry real information and people can learn a code. That does not create universal “skin reading”: the device, mapping and body site remain part of the ability.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Read data through your skin", "metric": "Device/code-specific recognition accuracy, confusion, retention, transfer and meaningful use", "boundary": "A learned vibration vocabulary is not a universal new sense or complete language." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-220", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Augmented-reality visual guidance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express augmented-reality visual guidance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "AR guidance can improve selected immediate task measures in simulation, but it has not been shown to create retained unaided competence or better patient outcomes.", "measurement_boundary": "Separate guidance-on performance from learning; measure registration/latency, errors, assistance, workload, delayed display-off performance, novel-case transfer, adverse events and meaningful outcome.", "negative_findings": [ "No delayed display-off retention, patient benefit, broad transfer or safe display-failure performance has been established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Download expert vision", "AR makes novices competent", "See through the body", "Safe procedure after one guided session" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0329", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "AR can guide a task in the moment. Titan separates that device-on boost from whether a person actually learned the skill and can work safely when the display disappears.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Download expert vision", "metric": "Errors, completion, workload and delayed display-off performance in a named task", "boundary": "Guided simulation speed cannot establish clinical competence, patient benefit or safe operation after display loss." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-221", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Physiological digital twin", "definition": "Capability to develop or express physiological digital twin in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A physiological digital twin is a context-specific computational model that may approximate selected patient responses; it is not a trainable human power or a complete digital copy of a person.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare clinical question, inputs, missingness, model/version, comparator, calibration/discrimination/error, subgroup performance, uncertainty, update policy and outcome; no wearable or model score alone diagnoses a person.", "negative_findings": [ "The sepsis model showed variable agreement and common coding, expert-rule and timing errors; patient benefit and cross-setting transport were not established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Your exact digital clone", "Predict your body perfectly", "Replace a clinician", "Simulate any treatment safely" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0215", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0450", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0451", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0454", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A digital twin is not a second you. It is a limited, versioned model of selected variables, useful only for the question and population in which it has been validated.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build a perfect digital copy of your body", "metric": "Context-specific prediction error, calibration, uncertainty, subgroup validity and clinical utility", "boundary": "A limited physiological model cannot reproduce a whole person or authorize diagnosis and treatment." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-222", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Cognitive offloading", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cognitive offloading in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "External reminders can improve performance while available, but offloading can reduce learning of the offloaded material; Titan measures both the configured benefit and the consequences of tool removal.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare goal as device-on function, learning, or both; measure setup/acknowledgement, omissions/false alerts, delayed device-on/off performance, generalization, burden, privacy and real consequence.", "negative_findings": [ "In controlled experiments, later memory for offloaded intentions fell below a no-offloading baseline; in multiple sclerosis, diary forgetting improved while a broader questionnaire did not." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Free your brain with no downside", "Outsource memory permanently", "Tools make memory weaker", "Real capability must be unaided" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0129", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0178", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0271", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Reminders really can help—and they can change what you learn unaided. Titan treats the person plus tool as a legitimate capability while making removal and failure visible.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Outsource memory with no cost", "metric": "Device-on task completion plus delayed device-off memory, errors, burden and fallback", "boundary": "A reminder can improve function without teaching the remembered content." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-223", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "External memory systems", "definition": "Capability to develop or express external memory systems in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Personalized external memory systems can improve selected everyday tasks for people with memory difficulties, provided the aid and support remain part of the declared capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure personally meaningful task completion, false/missed cues, setup burden, delayed device-on continuity, device-off consequence where relevant, support hours, privacy, outages and quality of life.", "negative_findings": [ "A broader everyday-memory questionnaire was unchanged in one active-controlled trial, and later unaided memory can be poorer for content previously offloaded." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Restore memory completely", "Replace carers or clinicians", "Never forget again", "Dependence on a tool is failure" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE_TO_HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0129", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0178", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0271", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "An external memory system can be a genuine part of someone’s capability. The right question is whether the whole person–tool–support system works reliably and safely.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Never forget again", "metric": "Chosen daily-task completion, cue reliability, support burden, outages and user-valued function", "boundary": "A reminder system neither restores all memory nor removes the need for people and fallback." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-224", "family_id": "FAM-28", "family": "Synthetic Senses, Digital Twins & Extended Cognition", "superdomain": "Technology & Augmentation", "power": "Predictive capability modelling", "definition": "Capability to develop or express predictive capability modelling in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A model can forecast a narrowly defined outcome in the context where it was validated; Titan does not support a universal score of a person’s potential or future capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare outcome, horizon, target population, missingness, comparator and consequence; report calibration, discrimination, uncertainty, subgroup errors, drift, human override and decision benefit/harm.", "negative_findings": [ "The prospective digital-twin study showed variable agreement and common implementation errors; no cross-context universal capability prediction or improved decision outcome was established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Predict anyone’s potential", "Know what you will become", "Objective life score", "AI decides who is capable" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0215", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0422", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0424", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0450", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0451", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0452", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0454", "source_alias_ids": [ "F28-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Models can predict narrow outcomes. They cannot reveal a person’s destiny. Every forecast belongs to a version, population, task, time horizon and governance system.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "AI can predict your human potential", "metric": "Out-of-sample calibration, error, subgroup performance, drift and decision consequence for one named outcome", "boundary": "A context-specific forecast cannot measure worth, destiny or total capability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-225", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Heat acclimation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express heat acclimation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can physiologically acclimatize to a defined heat exposure, but adaptation decays and never replaces environmental controls, rest, cooling, supervision or the right to stop.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare temperature, humidity, radiant load, clothing/PPE, workload and controls; track symptoms, core/skin temperature where professionally appropriate, heart rate, sweat/fluids, task function, delayed decay and adverse events.", "negative_findings": [ "Retention differed between studies and endpoints; several physiological measures did not change, and heat performance returned toward baseline in one two-week decay test." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become heatproof", "Train yourself not to need water or shade", "Sauna grants heat immunity", "Push through heat symptoms" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0191", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0388", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0439", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Heat acclimation is real—but it is temporary, variable and only one safety layer. No amount of training makes unsafe heat safe.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become heatproof", "metric": "Strain, symptoms, task function and adverse events under a defined heat/work/PPE configuration, plus decay", "boundary": "Physiological adaptation does not prevent heat illness or replace environmental controls." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-226", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Cold adaptation and protection", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cold adaptation and protection in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Repeated cold exposure can change selected laboratory responses, but effects are narrow and fragile; clothing, shelter, exposure limits, supervision and rescue remain the capability.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare air/water temperature, wind/wetness, clothing, immersion, workload and rescue context; measure cardiorespiratory response, dexterity, cognition, core/skin cooling, symptoms, function, delayed retention and adverse events.", "negative_findings": [ "Anxiety inhibited cold-shock habituation, and no study established survival benefit, general transfer or durable protection after training." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become immune to cold", "Train away cold shock", "Cold showers make open water safe", "Toughness prevents hypothermia" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0032", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0098", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0251", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0438", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Some cold responses can habituate. Anxiety and context can undo the benefit, and no training makes cold water, frostbite or hypothermia safe.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become immune to cold", "metric": "Cold-shock, cooling, dexterity, cognition and safe task function in one defined protected exposure", "boundary": "Narrow habituation cannot certify survival, open-water safety or immunity to tissue/core cooling." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-227", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Altitude adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express altitude adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People acclimatize to altitude over time, but fitness is not protection and shortcut pre-exposure can fail; safe capability includes ascent planning, symptom recognition and descent access.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare starting/sleeping altitude, ascent rate, prior exposure, health/medication, symptoms and evacuation access; measure oxygenation only as context, plus sleep, cognition, function, illness and descent/medical outcomes.", "negative_findings": [ "Seven one-hour passive hypoxia exposures did not prevent acute mountain sickness in susceptible people; prior success and fitness do not guarantee safety." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Train away altitude sickness", "Fitness makes altitude safe", "One hypoxia session pre-acclimatizes you", "Push upward through symptoms" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0339", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0442", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Altitude adaptation is real, but fitness is not immunity and quick pre-exposure can fail. The most important capability may be knowing when not to go higher.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train away mountain sickness", "metric": "Symptoms, sleep, oxygenation context and safe function at a declared altitude/ascent profile", "boundary": "Fitness, a pulse-ox number or brief hypoxia cannot guarantee protection from AMS, HACE or HAPE." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-228", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Water competence", "definition": "Capability to develop or express water competence in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Specific water skills can be taught, but water competence is always environment- and support-specific and never means drown-proof.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare pool/open water, temperature, current/waves, depth, clothing, flotation and supervision; measure entry, recovery, float/orientation, movement/exit, hazard decisions, distress signals, retention and adverse events.", "negative_findings": [ "The training study did not measure drowning; parental supervision judgments weakened as perceived child skill rose, and official guidance rejects skill-only safety." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Drown-proof yourself or a child", "Swimming makes open water safe", "Lesson completion removes supervision", "Cold-water survival skill" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0124", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0270", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0488", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Water skills are trainable. “Drown-proof” is not. Real competence includes the environment, supervision, flotation, judgment and rescue system.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Become drown-proof", "metric": "Environment-specific recovery, movement, exit, judgment and help-seeking with supervision/flotation declared", "boundary": "Pool performance cannot guarantee open-water or emergency survival." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; SUPERVISION_OR_NON_ATTEMPT_BOUNDARY; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-229", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Low-light operational capability", "definition": "Capability to develop or express low-light operational capability in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can manage a transient dark-adaptation state and learn task-specific scanning, lighting and instrument use; this is not trainable biological night vision.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare luminance, contrast, spectrum, adaptation history, vision/health, task and equipment; measure detection/localization, false alarms, time, collisions/near misses, instrument use, recovery after glare and fatigue.", "negative_findings": [ "Dark adaptation is quickly disrupted by bright light; color/detail degrade, illusions persist and no durable enhancement of retinal sensitivity was established." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "See in total darkness", "Train night vision permanently", "Operate safely without lights", "Red light preserves all vision" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0022", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0448", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Humans adapt to darkness temporarily and can learn better low-light procedures. That is not permanent night vision, and safe operation still depends on lights, instruments and training.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train permanent night vision", "metric": "Contrast/target detection, false alarms and safe task performance at a declared luminance with equipment visible", "boundary": "Dark adaptation is transient and cannot create vision in total darkness or override illusions." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-230", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Resource improvisation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express resource improvisation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Resource improvisation is the governed ability to preserve one essential function with safe available alternatives—not heroic survivalism or permission to improvise beyond competence.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare essential function, constraints, authority and prohibited domains; measure function restored, time, resource use, new hazards, coordination, accessibility, reversibility and after-action learning.", "negative_findings": [ "No selected evidence isolates durable, general improvisation skill or shows that an improvised solution transfers safely across hazards." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Survive anything with household objects", "Make medical or electrical substitutes", "Heroic lone-wolf improvisation", "Any workaround is better than stopping" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0455", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0480", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Real improvisation is not a survival hack. It is preserving one essential function safely, within competence and authority, when the expected resource is unavailable.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "MacGyver your way through any disaster", "metric": "Essential function restored, new hazards, authority, accessibility and reversibility under one declared constraint", "boundary": "Novelty cannot establish safety, legality, reliability or cross-hazard transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-231", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Disaster readiness", "definition": "Capability to develop or express disaster readiness in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Disaster readiness is a maintained household–community–institutional system of plans, alerts, supplies, roles and exercises; knowledge or owning a kit alone does not prove safety.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare hazard and jurisdiction; verify alerts, contacts, evacuation/shelter, accessible needs, supplies/expiry, roles, drill performance, communication failure, assistance and after-action correction—not a single readiness score.", "negative_findings": [ "A Superstorm Sandy study found that kits, plans and medication supplies did not reduce adverse outcomes; education evidence mainly measured knowledge rather than live execution." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Be ready for any disaster", "A go-bag guarantees survival", "Self-reliance replaces public services", "Prepared people do not need help" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0110", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0401", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0438", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0439", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0442", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0455", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0480", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Preparedness is more than a go-bag. It is a maintained network of alerts, plans, accessible support, supplies, roles, public services and practice that works under one real hazard.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A go-bag makes you disaster-proof", "metric": "Hazard-specific plan/drill execution, access, communication, dependencies, harms and recovery", "boundary": "Knowledge and supplies alone cannot prove live readiness or overcome infrastructure failure." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-232", "family_id": "FAM-29", "family": "Environmental Adaptation & Survival", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Environmental fallback", "definition": "Capability to develop or express environmental fallback in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Environmental fallback is the maintained ability of a household, team or institution to preserve an essential function through a safe tested alternative—not an individual promise to survive system collapse.", "measurement_boundary": "Name the essential function, duration, capacity and dependencies; test safe failover, access, communications, maintenance, fuel/power, data/records, responsible authority, cascading failure and recovery.", "negative_findings": [ "Household plans and supplies did not reduce adverse outcomes after Sandy in one retrospective study; continuity documents and stored equipment do not prove tested capacity." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Live indefinitely off-grid after any disaster", "Replace critical services yourself", "Solo self-sufficiency", "Any backup is adequate" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0110", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0438", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0439", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0442", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0455", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0480", "source_alias_ids": [ "F29-S015" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Fallback is not lone survivalism. It is keeping one essential function running through a safe, tested alternative—with maintenance, mutual aid and a point at which outside help takes over.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Survive total system collapse alone", "metric": "Safe essential-function continuity, duration, capacity, dependency and recovery under one disruption", "boundary": "A backup object or plan cannot guarantee resilience, safety or indefinite self-sufficiency." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-233", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Rapid response capacity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express rapid response capacity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Institutions can build faster escalation routes, but more alerts or team calls do not by themselves prove faster resolution or better outcomes.", "measurement_boundary": "Predeclare event, threshold and outcome; measure eligible-event coverage, detection-to-decision and decision-to-action latency, outcome, false activation, missed events, subgroup access, burden and harm.", "negative_findings": [ "Two independent cluster-randomized trials failed to show significant improvement in their tested patient outcomes; one also documented incomplete activation and the other lost half its intended hospitals and had low statistical power." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Instant institutional reflexes", "A response team prevents every crisis", "Call volume proves safety", "Automation may override clinical authority" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0100", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0105", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Fast response is a system capability: detect, authorize and act. More alerts alone do not prove that people were safer.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "An institution can install instant reflexes", "metric": "Eligible-event coverage, latency, outcome, misses, false activations and burden", "boundary": "Alert or call counts cannot establish safety or benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-234", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Organisational memory", "definition": "Capability to develop or express organisational memory in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Structured debriefs and durable records can preserve lessons, but organisational memory exists only when knowledge remains findable, contestable and usable after delay and turnover.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure retrieval and correct use after delay/turnover, action closure, contradictions retained, affected-person correction, repeat failure, access controls and privacy harm—not report count.", "negative_findings": [ "Small guided-debrief effects do not prove long-term memory; official review completion does not prove action closure or future performance." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "An archive remembers for the institution", "A debrief guarantees learning", "One official account is institutional truth", "Record everything forever" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0313", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0447", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0490", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Organisational memory is not a folder of reports. It is the ability to retrieve, challenge and use a lesson when people and conditions have changed.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Store everything and the institution will remember", "metric": "Delayed retrieval, correct reuse, action closure, repeat failure and correction rights", "boundary": "Report volume cannot prove retained or applied knowledge." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-235", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Redundancy and resilience", "definition": "Capability to develop or express redundancy and resilience in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Redundancy can preserve a named function through a tested alternative, but a plan, spare component or compliance label is not proof of resilience.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare function, disruption, duration and dependency; measure safe failover, capacity, recovery time/objective, data integrity, cascading failure, accessibility, maintenance and affected-person outcome.", "negative_findings": [ "Official standards specify practices rather than demonstrate outcomes; a written plan cannot establish capacity, recovery time or equitable continuity." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Failure-proof organisation", "A backup guarantees continuity", "Resilience means coping without public help", "Compliant means tested" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0425", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0457", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Resilience is demonstrated when a named function safely survives a named disruption—not when an institution owns a plan or spare part.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build a failure-proof organisation", "metric": "Safe failover capacity, recovery time, dependencies, access and affected-person outcomes", "boundary": "A plan or backup object cannot guarantee resilience." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-236", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Decision governance", "definition": "Capability to develop or express decision governance in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Decision governance makes authority, evidence, conflicts, dissent, reasons and appeal visible; it does not make a decision correct merely because a process was followed.", "measurement_boundary": "For a declared decision, measure authority clarity, evidence/uncertainty, conflicts, dissent treatment, affected-person influence, reason trace, timeliness, appeals, reversal and distributed outcome.", "negative_findings": [ "The selected sources specify governance conditions but do not causally establish improved decisions, durable culture or fair implementation." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Governance guarantees good decisions", "Leadership virtue score", "Consensus proves legitimacy", "A checklist replaces accountability" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0368", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0457", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Good governance does not promise perfect decisions. It makes power, evidence, disagreement, reasons and correction visible.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Install a process that always decides correctly", "metric": "Decision trace, dissent, conflicts, affected-person influence, appeal, distribution and outcome", "boundary": "Process compliance cannot prove correctness or legitimacy." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-237", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Resource allocation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express resource allocation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Resource allocation can be made more transparent and contestable, but no universal rule is fair across all scarcities, people and consequences.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare scarce resource and objective; report need, eligibility, access, wait, benefit/harm, distribution, excluded groups, uncertainty, appeal, revision, cost and opportunity cost.", "negative_findings": [ "Official ethics guidance does not show that any single rule was implemented fairly or improved outcomes; procedural compliance can coexist with distributive harm." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Optimize people", "Rank lives or human worth", "One fair formula", "Efficiency overrides rights" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0368", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0457", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0484", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Allocation is not just efficiency. A capable institution can explain who receives what, why, with what consequences—and how the decision can be challenged.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Find one formula that allocates perfectly", "metric": "Need, access, benefit, harm, distribution, exclusion, appeal and revision", "boundary": "Efficiency or consistency cannot establish fairness or justify ranking human worth." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-238", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Error reporting and learning", "definition": "Capability to develop or express error reporting and learning in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Institutions can increase error reporting, but learning is demonstrated only when reports are safely investigated, corrected and followed by fewer or less harmful repeat events.", "measurement_boundary": "Use eligible opportunities where possible; measure reporting access, severity/quality, time to triage, reporter feedback, action closure, recurrence, outcome, retaliation, false allegation, workload and subgroup reach.", "negative_findings": [ "Cluster trials found increased reporting without consistent safety-culture or clinical benefit, and one patient-feedback intervention had poor action-plan implementation." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "More reports prove a safer culture", "No reports means no errors", "Anonymous accusations determine guilt", "A dashboard learns" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0269", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0411", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0447", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0490", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Reporting an error is not the same as learning from it. Titan follows the chain from safe report to correction, feedback and reduced recurrence.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Install a form and become a learning organisation", "metric": "Safe access, investigation, feedback, action closure, recurrence, harm and retaliation", "boundary": "Report count cannot establish learning or safety." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-239", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Cross-institution coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express cross-institution coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Institutions can coordinate across boundaries when roles, information, consent and follow-up are explicit, but meetings or data exchange alone do not prove continuity.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure handoff completion, time, information accuracy/minimization, duplicate/missed work, no-wrong-door access, user burden, outcome, subgroup distribution, accountability and failure recovery.", "negative_findings": [ "A single configured clinical transition result cannot establish generalized coordination, and guidance adoption alone does not prove interoperability or equitable access." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Seamless integration", "Share all data to coordinate", "A partnership guarantees outcomes", "The user must coordinate the system" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0001", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0368", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0457", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Coordination is visible when a person or task crosses a boundary without being lost—not when institutions merely meet or exchange data.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Connect institutions and everything becomes seamless", "metric": "Handoff completion, accuracy, latency, outcome, user burden, privacy and recovery", "boundary": "Meetings, agreements or data volume cannot prove coordination." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-240", "family_id": "FAM-30", "family": "Institutional & Organisational Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Policy adaptation", "definition": "Capability to develop or express policy adaptation in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Policy adaptation is the governed ability to change, retain or stop a policy in response to valid evidence and affected-person outcomes—not simply publishing an evaluation.", "measurement_boundary": "Track version, evidence quality, uncertainty, affected groups, distribution, time to decision, implementation fidelity, outcome, unintended harm, appeal, reversal and retained contradiction.", "negative_findings": [ "Official evaluation and review frameworks do not establish that findings were valid, acted upon or beneficial; adaptation may be blocked by incentives and power." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Evidence automatically makes policy", "Continuous change is agility", "Consultation equals consent", "Quietly rewrite the record" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0457", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0459", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0490", "source_alias_ids": [ "F30-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "A policy is adaptive when evidence can genuinely change it—and the old version, reasons, disagreement and consequences remain visible.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Make policy automatically self-correcting", "metric": "Versioned evidence, decision latency, implementation, distribution, harm, appeal and reversal", "boundary": "An evaluation report cannot prove adaptation or benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-241", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Value clarity", "definition": "Capability to develop or express value clarity in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A structured exercise may help some people clarify trade-offs for one decision, but effects conflict across trials; it cannot discover a single true value system or prescribe the correct choice.", "measurement_boundary": "For one chosen decision, record option understanding, personally stated trade-offs, decisional conflict/preparation, choice congruence and later regret—with no ranking of the values themselves.", "negative_findings": [ "One trial found little immediate or three-month change and selected later benefit; an independent trial found no added improvement in decisional conflict, intent, perceived values concordance or self-efficacy." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Discover your true permanent values", "Value clarity score", "Correct values", "Uncertainty is failure" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0303", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0304", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Value clarity is not finding the “right” values. It is making one decision’s trade-offs more visible while keeping uncertainty and choice legitimate.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Reveal your one true value system", "metric": "Decision-specific understanding, stated trade-offs, congruence and later regret", "boundary": "The exercise cannot determine correct values or a permanent identity." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-242", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Long-term goal coherence", "definition": "Capability to develop or express long-term goal coherence in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can connect a chosen goal to obstacles and actions, but no planning method guarantees long-term coherence or overcomes structural barriers.", "measurement_boundary": "For one voluntarily chosen goal, measure understanding, conflict with other commitments, feasible action, progress, wellbeing/distress, structural barriers, revision and delayed persistence—not ambition or conformity.", "negative_findings": [ "A cluster-randomized workplace intervention did not improve average goal progress, increased anxiety and showed subgroup concerns." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Design your perfect life plan", "A coherent person never changes goals", "Goal score", "Failure means weak commitment" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0297", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0400", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Long-term direction is not rigid persistence. It is keeping goals connected to values, reality and wellbeing—and changing them when life changes.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Lock in one perfect life plan", "metric": "Chosen-goal progress, conflict, feasibility, wellbeing, barriers and revision over time", "boundary": "Planning cannot guarantee coherence or make goal change a failure." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-243", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Self-control", "definition": "Capability to develop or express self-control in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can configure supports that improve selected chosen behaviors, but “self-control” is not a single reservoir, moral trait or proof of independence from assistance.", "measurement_boundary": "Name the behavior, goal, context and supports; measure target behavior, wellbeing, deprivation, adverse events, burden, reversibility, delayed function and cross-task transfer separately.", "negative_findings": [ "Interventions produced mixed or conditional effects, did not show broad transfer, and some people declined commitment devices or needed clinical treatment." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Build unlimited willpower", "Weak people lack discipline", "Punitive lockout", "Control addiction yourself" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0231", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0287", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0297", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0400", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Self-control is often a well-designed support system, not heroic willpower. Titan measures the chosen outcome, assistance, cost and wellbeing together.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train unlimited willpower", "metric": "Specific chosen behavior, support configuration, retention, burden, reversibility and wellbeing", "boundary": "One behavior change cannot establish a general self-control trait." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-244", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Habit architecture", "definition": "Capability to develop or express habit architecture in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "A chosen routine can become more automatic through repeated action in a stable context, but timing varies widely and no fixed-day formula applies.", "measurement_boundary": "Declare behavior and cue; measure observed completion and automaticity trajectory, missed opportunities, burden, adverse displacement, context change, delayed persistence and choice to revise.", "negative_findings": [ "The foundational field study was observational, model fit varied, and estimated formation time ranged from 18 to 254 days without delayed post-practice retention." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Form any habit in 21/30/66 days", "Automatic means healthy", "Engineer other people’s habits", "Never miss twice guarantees success" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0012", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0287", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0297", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Habits are learned relationships between an action and context. They form at very different speeds, and automatic does not mean good.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build any habit on a fixed timetable", "metric": "Behavior and automaticity trajectory at a declared cue, plus burden and delayed persistence", "boundary": "A day count cannot guarantee formation, retention or benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-245", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Moral courage", "definition": "Capability to develop or express moral courage in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Speaking up is enabled or suppressed by authority and protection. Titan studies the complete challenge system, not a personal courage score.", "measurement_boundary": "For a declared concern, measure safe access, speaking-up opportunity, leader response, investigation, correction, retaliation, confidentiality, burden and outcome—not personality.", "negative_findings": [ "A discouraging authority condition suppressed challenge; no evidence shows durable transfer to real retaliation, and a policy alone does not guarantee protection." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Cowards stay silent", "Train fearless whistleblowers", "Public confrontation proves courage", "Loyalty test" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0083", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0460", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Moral courage is not fearlessness. People speak up more when authority invites challenge and the system protects them.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Train people to fearlessly confront power", "metric": "Safe challenge opportunity, response, correction, retaliation and outcome", "boundary": "Silence cannot diagnose cowardice, and simulation cannot guarantee real-world protection." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-246", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Responsible power use", "definition": "Capability to develop or express responsible power use in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Responsible power is demonstrated through bounded authority, transparent decisions, challenge and remedy—not through a leader’s self-description or moral score.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure role authority, conflict handling, evidence/reasons, dissent, participation, distribution, complaints, reversals, remedy and abuse—not claimed intention or personality.", "negative_findings": [ "The sources are normative/governance materials, not causal evidence that principles or policies change conduct or outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Ethical leader score", "Power reveals character", "Principles guarantee integrity", "Obedience is responsible use" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0458", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0460", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_SYSTEM_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Responsible power is not a personality. It is authority with limits, reasons, challenge and repair that affected people can actually use.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Identify inherently ethical leaders", "metric": "Authority limits, conflicts, dissent, distribution, complaints, reversals and remedy", "boundary": "Principle recitation and self-report cannot establish responsible conduct." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-247", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Identity flexibility", "definition": "Capability to develop or express identity flexibility in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People may describe themselves differently across contexts while remaining stable within a context, and cultures differ in how this is expressed; current evidence does not establish a trainable ideal called identity flexibility.", "measurement_boundary": "If studied, use person-defined context, agency, authenticity, belonging, distress, discrimination, function and cost; never reduce identity to one adaptability score.", "negative_findings": [ "The evidence shows cultural group differences and conditional within-context stability in framed measures—not trainability, deficit, individual diagnosis or functional benefit." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Become anyone at will", "Flexible identity is superior", "Rigid culture/personality", "Train masking or assimilation" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0117", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S014" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0296", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Identity can be stable, plural, contextual or changing. Titan does not rank these forms or train people to assimilate.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Learn to become anyone", "metric": "Person-defined agency, authenticity, belonging, function and cost across declared contexts", "boundary": "Contextual variation cannot establish superiority, trainability or an identity score." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-248", "family_id": "FAM-31", "family": "Ethical, Purposeful & Self-Governed Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Purpose and legacy transmission", "definition": "Capability to develop or express purpose and legacy transmission in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Optional supported legacy work can be meaningful for some people, but it does not create a universal purpose, erase distress or impose a duty to leave a record.", "measurement_boundary": "Use person-defined helpfulness, dignity, distress, burden, consent, privacy, family impact and later use/withdrawal; never score life worth, purpose or legacy size.", "negative_findings": [ "Two trials found no broad or primary distress benefit, and one found no improvement in several physical, social, emotional and functional outcomes." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Find your one life purpose", "Everyone needs a legacy", "Resolve end-of-life distress", "Your worth is what you leave" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0089", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0109", "source_alias_ids": [ "F31-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Legacy can be a chosen act of connection. It is not a duty, a cure for distress or a measure of whether a life mattered.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Discover a universal purpose and perfect legacy", "metric": "Person-defined helpfulness, dignity, burden, consent, privacy and recipient outcome", "boundary": "An artifact cannot measure life worth or guarantee distress relief or transmission." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-249", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Mutual aid", "definition": "Capability to develop or express mutual aid in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Mutual aid is community-organized reciprocal support. Selected group conditions are associated with continued volunteer participation, but current evidence does not show that every network is equitable, sustainable or an acceptable substitute for public services.", "measurement_boundary": "Community defines aims; measure request coverage, latency, dignity, reciprocity, unmet need, exclusion, helper burden, continuity, privacy, referrals and relationship to public entitlements.", "negative_findings": [ "One study documents meanings and practice rather than outcomes; the other is a short observational volunteer panel with 49.8% wave-two retention and does not establish unmet-need coverage, fair burden or causal effectiveness." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Mutual aid replaces the state", "Communities can always save themselves", "Volunteer hours prove impact", "Titan owns this model" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0192", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S001" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0244", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S017" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Mutual aid is reciprocal community care—not charity branding or a substitute for public duty. Its real test is who receives help, who carries the burden and what lasts.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A volunteer network makes a community self-sufficient", "metric": "Unmet-need coverage, latency, dignity, reciprocity, continuity, burden and exclusion", "boundary": "Stories or volunteer hours cannot prove equitable, sustainable impact." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-250", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Community sensing", "definition": "Capability to develop or express community sensing in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Community sensing can add timely local information, but every signal needs provenance, verification, representation and a safe accountable response route.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure sensitivity/specificity or agreement, latency, geographic/demographic coverage, contributor concentration, verification cost, response, false reports, privacy, burden and displaced harm.", "negative_findings": [ "Participation was highly concentrated in one study; community monitoring did not reduce overall forest use in another and displaced loss outside monitored areas." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "The crowd is ground truth", "More reports mean full coverage", "Surveil communities for their own good", "A map proves improvement" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0037", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S002" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0167", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0168", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Local people can add signals institutions miss. The capability is not the crowd alone—it is the governed chain from observation to verification and response.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Turn the crowd into a perfect sensor", "metric": "Verified accuracy, latency, coverage, concentration, response and displaced harm", "boundary": "Raw reports or map density cannot establish truth, representation or benefit." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-251", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Collective purchasing and resource pooling", "definition": "Capability to develop or express collective purchasing and resource pooling in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Pooling may reduce selected costs through scale and shared expertise, but hospital evidence conflicts and it is not automatically cheaper, fairer or better than individual choice.", "measurement_boundary": "Compare total price and transaction cost, quality, availability, choice, savings distribution, conflict, entry/exit, complaints, exclusion and counterfactual individual purchasing.", "negative_findings": [ "One hospital study found context-dependent savings associations; an independent contract analysis found no significant volume-related explanation of price variation and highlighted poor data and transparency. Neither establishes community benefit or fair distribution." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Bulk buying always saves", "One pool fits every member", "Savings prove fairness", "Lock members in for efficiency" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0090", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S005" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0320", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S018" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Pooling can buy scale and expertise, but more volume does not guarantee a lower price. Titan asks who actually saved, what quality changed, who lost choice and whether anyone could leave.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "A bigger buying group always wins", "metric": "Total cost, quality, access, choice, distribution, conflict and exit versus a counterfactual", "boundary": "Scale alone cannot establish value, fairness or suitability." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-252", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Ecological literacy", "definition": "Capability to develop or express ecological literacy in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "People can learn ecological systems and impacts, but current evidence does not show that information alone produces durable, effective environmental action.", "measurement_boundary": "Use objective place-specific system/decision tasks plus observed action, uncertainty calibration, collective outcome, anxiety, access constraints and delayed retention—not one virtue score.", "negative_findings": [ "The intervention paper reported no outcomes, and the observational study cannot establish causation, observed behavior, retention or ecological effect." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Eco-literacy makes people sustainable", "Carbon virtue score", "Information fixes climate behavior", "Extract local knowledge for a universal course" ], "risk_level": "MODERATE", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0327", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S007" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0352", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S006" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Ecological literacy is understanding relationships well enough to make a better situated decision—not passing a green quiz or carrying all responsibility alone.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Learn enough facts and become sustainable", "metric": "Place-specific decision accuracy, uncertainty, observed action, collective outcome and delayed retention", "boundary": "Knowledge or self-report cannot establish ecological impact or virtue." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY." }, { "power_id": "PWR-253", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Regenerative stewardship", "definition": "Capability to develop or express regenerative stewardship in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Stewardship can support ecological and livelihood outcomes when local rightsholders hold meaningful authority, but participation labels and short monitoring do not prove regeneration.", "measurement_boundary": "Rightsholders define outcomes; measure ecological baseline/change, spillover, livelihood, tenure/authority, distribution, burden, maintenance, uncertainty and multi-year persistence.", "negative_findings": [ "A randomized monitoring intervention displaced forest loss; observational commons data cannot prove causation and show no single governance feature improves every outcome." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Restore nature by mobilizing locals", "A participation checkbox proves justice", "Carbon gain outweighs rights", "Titan can publish traditional stewardship methods" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0135", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0167", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0168", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0402", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Regeneration is not a short project or a carbon number. It is ecological recovery with enduring local authority, livelihoods, maintenance and no displaced harm.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Copy one regenerative model anywhere", "metric": "Rightsholder-defined ecological recovery, livelihood, authority, spillover and multi-year maintenance", "boundary": "Participation or carbon gain cannot establish justice, causality or durable regeneration." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-254", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Civic coordination", "definition": "Capability to develop or express civic coordination in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Civic coordination can structure shared observation and decision-making, but participation, platform activity or majority support do not automatically create legitimacy or better outcomes.", "measurement_boundary": "Measure reach/representation, accessibility, deliberative quality, evidence use, dissent/minority protection, authority, implementation, distribution, appeals, trust and system outcome.", "negative_findings": [ "Support for assemblies was outcome-contingent; field effects varied and included displacement, while no evidence shows a universal civic-coordination method." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "The crowd decides correctly", "Digital participation is democracy", "Consensus is legitimacy", "Majority preference erases rights" ], "risk_level": "HIGH", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0135", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S008" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0167", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S004" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0168", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S003" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0230", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S009" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Civic coordination is not a comment box. People need real access, visible authority, protected disagreement and a trace from participation to decision and outcome.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Put everyone online and achieve democracy", "metric": "Representation, deliberation, authority, implementation, distribution and minority protection", "boundary": "Participation or majority support cannot establish legitimacy or good outcomes." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-255", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Intergenerational knowledge transfer", "definition": "Capability to develop or express intergenerational knowledge transfer in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Intergenerational knowledge transfer can sustain community continuity and stewardship, but only rightsholders decide what may be taught, recorded, restricted or shared.", "measurement_boundary": "Rightsholders define whether and how to measure continuity, use, language/land relationship, wellbeing, authority, access/restriction, recipient readiness and reciprocal benefit.", "negative_findings": [ "CARE and UNDRIP do not grant permission; one small community study cannot represent all Indigenous Peoples or validate extraction into a universal curriculum." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Build a universal Indigenous knowledge library", "Open all traditional knowledge", "Titan preserves knowledge for communities", "One culture’s method transfers everywhere" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0402", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S012" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0420", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S011" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0481", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S010" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "Living knowledge is not an open resource waiting to be collected. The people who hold it decide what continues, what stays restricted and who benefits.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Digitize every tradition to save it", "metric": "Community-defined continuity, authority, use, wellbeing, restriction and reciprocal benefit", "boundary": "Documentation cannot establish ownership, permission, appropriate transmission or universal transfer." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." }, { "power_id": "PWR-256", "family_id": "FAM-32", "family": "Community, Ecological & Hybrid Capability", "superdomain": "Environment & Systems", "power": "Human–animal–machine collaboration", "definition": "Capability to develop or express human–animal–machine collaboration in a declared context without inheriting broader claims.", "public_state_labels": [ "INTERNAL_EVIDENCE_COMPLETE", "PUBLIC_EXPLAINER_READY", "EXTERNAL_CONFIRMATION_REQUIRED" ], "authority_dimensions": { "internal_evidence_state": "COMPLETE_BOUNDED_INTERNAL", "public_explainer_permission": "READY_BOUNDED", "guide_permission": "NOT_READY", "external_confirmation_gate": "REQUIRED_BEFORE_HIGHER_AUTHORITY", "external_confirmation_triggers": [ "CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION", "CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED" ], "independent_validation_state": "NOT_CLAIMED", "promotion_permission": "NOT_GRANTED" }, "supportable_public_claim": "Animals, people and machines can contribute different functions in a configured system, but current evidence does not establish a general “super-team” or justify welfare costs.", "measurement_boundary": "Compare complete configuration with best standalone/paired alternatives on mission outcome, animal-based welfare and choice/avoidance, human workload/safety, machine failures, communication, aborts and recovery.", "negative_findings": [ "Conceptual frameworks and tiny pilots dominate; no durable net advantage, transfer or welfare benefit over simpler alternatives has been shown." ], "prohibited_wording": [ "Create an animal–AI superpower", "The animal consents like a human", "Automation replaces handlers/vets", "Performance outweighs welfare" ], "risk_level": "CRITICAL", "allowed_now": { "explain": true, "publish_bounded_evidence_summary": true, "publish_non_prescriptive_low_risk_guide": false, "stepwise_training_protocol": false, "clinical_or_diagnostic_instruction": false, "represent_community_or_cultural_authority": false, "claim_independent_validation": false, "promote_to_canonical_or_operational_standard": false }, "citation_bindings": [ { "citation_id": "CIT-0274", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S013" ], "binding_roles": [ "PRIMARY_EMPIRICAL_SUPPORT", "LIMITING_CONTRARY" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] }, { "citation_id": "CIT-0492", "source_alias_ids": [ "F32-S016" ], "binding_roles": [ "LIMITING_CONTRARY", "OFFICIAL_BOUNDARY_CONTEXT" ], "evidence_axes": [ "EXISTENCE", "FUNCTIONAL_VALUE", "LIMITING_FINDING", "RETENTION", "SAFETY_LEGITIMACY", "TRAINABILITY", "TRANSFER" ] } ], "bounded_guide_scope": [], "site_summary": "The frontier is not an animal with a gadget. It is a carefully governed animal–human–machine system whose performance never outranks animal welfare.", "myth_to_metric": { "myth": "Build a multispecies super-team", "metric": "Mission outcome, animal welfare/choice, human workload, machine reliability, communication and fallback", "boundary": "A demonstration cannot establish durable synergy, transfer or legitimate welfare trade-offs." }, "next_gate": "External confirmation is required before higher-authority use because: CLINICAL_HIGH_RISK_OR_REGULATED_CONFIGURATION; CULTURAL_COMMUNITY_RIGHTS_OR_AFFECTED_PERSON_AUTHORITY; SAFETY_LEGITIMACY_RESTRICTED." } ], "public_safety_rules": [ "Never sum the non-exclusive five-state counts.", "Internal evidence complete is not independently validated.", "Public explainer ready is not protocol permission.", "Non-prescriptive guide frame ready means bounded and informational; no source record permits a stepwise training protocol in this release.", "Clinical, high-risk, regulated, culturally governed, community-owned, disability/patient-led, labour, political, institutional and rights-affecting uses retain their explicit external gate.", "No promotion, clinical instruction, community representation or independent-validation claim is authorised." ], "provenance": { "machine_registry_sha256": "c2b3c0e7d0f3684a8635906329e2cda4a846db64f6c3c87f85c172d843695624", "source_master_sha256": "5984a26e9d52758396ef614645e7a8e900a49272a7b0df7fe649c51ac60b181f", "closure_register_sha256": "5338460a9176cc84ad4820697789be6c0235c7f532c9b4cac94d4c47bd7d7d9a" }, "authority_effects": { "canonical_kb_write": "NONE", "frozen_core_effect": "NONE", "operational_standard_effect": "NONE", "manuscript_effect": "NONE_BY_THIS_ARTIFACT", "cockpit_effect": "NONE", "site_source_effect": "NONE_BY_THIS_ARTIFACT", "deployment_effect": "NONE_BY_THIS_ARTIFACT", "promotion_effect": "NONE", "external_review_completion_effect": "NONE", "independent_validation_claim_effect": "NONE" } }